Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

England's good PISA results: how much credit does Gove's GCSE reform truly deserve?

167 replies

ParentOfOne · 14/10/2026 18:25

England did reasonably well in the latest PISA results, much better than Scotland and Wales
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgy6n0l4rdo

I'd be interested in comparing opinions on how much credit Gove's GCSE reform of 2013 deserves for this.

I don't like Gove (a Brexiter who famously said that all schools should be above average...) but I am open to admitting that I can disagree with someone on a topic but still agree on another.

It's not clear to me what the main difference between Gove's GCSE and the previous system was: did coursework use to count in the previous system, whereas he made the GCSE reliant only on the final examination? Has this made the results fairer and more reliable, to the extent that the test and the marking are the same across the country?

It's also not clear to me how the Welsh system differs. I remember many comments from Welsh politicians against teaching to the test and in favour of a more comprehensive approach, but I do not understand what it means in practice.

What was most striking for me was that the results were not driven by socio-economic factors, and that English students in deprived areas still did better than Welsh students in less deprived areas (based on the press - I haven't analysed the reports myself), so it's not a matter of London being richer and skewing the results.

Thoughts?

Students in green school uniforms sit at desks reading books during a classroom lesson. Pencil pots and study materials are visible on the tables, with a noticeboard and classroom displays in the background.

England up in reading, maths and science rankings as Scotland and Wales dip

The latest Pisa report also warned of a global decline in teenagers' reading skills.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cvgy6n0l4rdo

OP posts:
SmallDFartyCarNRG · 15/10/2026 13:18

I mean, most of our kids are depressed or anxious and have zero job offers even when they get a degree, so do PISA scores (particularly when our high rankings come because other countries plummeted spectacularly) really matter when thinking of our children? Gove didn't care about their mental health enough to help with MH care or keeping any youth initiatives or centres open.

napody · 15/10/2026 13:19

ParentOfOne · 15/10/2026 10:00

@napody You said that teaching, because it's a 'heavily unionised profession', resists all accountability.

Apologies if I was unclear. Not everywhere. I made examples of other countries where teachers are heavily unionised, resist change and accountability, and advocate measures which are ultimately worse for students and schools.

In England, teachers are not unfireable like in some other countries, and are much more accountable.

Teachers in England aren't resisting all accountability. They're resisting the excessive amounts in the current system. Which has probably improved PISA results as children are so used to being tested they're likely to perform well. But at what cost?

What was this cost? Is there any indication that other countries, with less focus on testing (from Wales to Italy to France) have better behaviour, better results, better mental health?

And what alternative would you suggest?

I think one of the great flaws in Gove's reform is that the 16 year olds who fail their GCSEs are practically abandoned, forced to resit them (many of them continue to fail), and kind of stuck in a limbo. I'll confess I don't know what a better approach to that would be. But the solution cannot be to get rid of rigorous, centralised testing.

I don't think anyone is advocating that. Is there an upper limit on the amount that is acceptable, do you think?

noblegiraffe · 15/10/2026 13:39

Fifthtimelucky · 15/10/2026 12:10

Glad to see some schools are still doing this!

Really not many at all, that school is an outlier.

England's good PISA results: how much credit does Gove's GCSE reform truly deserve?
prh47bridge · 15/10/2026 14:08

Araminta1004 · 15/10/2026 12:44

https://www.theguardian.com/education/2026/sep/08/england-teenagers-outperform-peers-in-most-countries-in-maths-reading-and-science

@prh47bridge - it is only Science that has gone up. If you look at the graphs.

I don’t think we should sit here and kid ourselves that Literacy and Reading etc is improving much. Lots of stuff has been published that Reading for pleasure has gone down significantly amongst teens over time. Slight improvement again recently, but disadvantage gap is significant. literacytrust.org.uk/news/our-latest-research-shows-modest-rise-in-childrens-reading-engagement-but-levels-remain-low/

The reading score has also gone up, albeit not by anything like as much as science. But I agree with your point that this needs to improve further.

Fifthtimelucky · 15/10/2026 14:46

Araminta1004 · 15/10/2026 13:04

@ParentOfOne - my opinion is that primary reforms did unlock greater reading ability and potential in the later years. I also actually believe it is good for all children to be able to engage with eg Shakespeare. But the relentless hammering of certain GCSE texts ad nauseam and prescriptive way of answering to get a top grade - enough to put plenty off students off!

Reading for pleasure is fundamental to democracy I think. So I would really be making that a priority.

On the point about prescriptive ways of answering exam questions in order to get good marks, this approach does worry me a bit. However, when I compare it with how things were when I took my O and A levels, it does have its advantages.

My daughter’s boyfriend teaches history and politics - two subjects I did for A level. I recently showed him my A level papers (from 1979) and he was very surprised by the format. We had to answer 4 equally weighted essay questions in each 3 hour exam (two 3 hour exams for each subject). He asked how the exams were marked/what the learning objectives were. I told him we had no idea. We were taught content, but not how to use it.

With one exception, the advice we were given on taking O and A level exams was limited to:

  1. Read the rubric (this included turning over/reading to the bottom of the exam paper to make sure you didn’t miss any questions or instructions); and

  2. Answer the question!

That was it. We had absolutely no idea what the examiners were looking for.

The exception was our French teacher who advised us (for O level) to use a number of what she called “phrases to impress examiners”. These were not required, and were not learned by rote. They were grammatical constructions that we could tailor to whatever we were writing about and weave in as appropriate.

Today’s prescription may be off-putting
to some, but I bet it is part of the reason why pupils get much better results than we did in the 1970s!

Nomura · 15/10/2026 15:25

noblegiraffe · 15/10/2026 13:39

Really not many at all, that school is an outlier.

Those are AS level entries though. Schools offering 4 subjects in yr12 do not enter them as AS Levels as those have been scrapped. My point was they are still ensuring students get the benefit of getting more breadth of study by starting off with 4 subjects.

Papyrophile · 15/10/2026 16:08

@Fifthtimelucky O and A level courses were aimed at the academically able. I'm a little older than you, and as you say, learning objectives and exemplars did not really exist. I never saw a "model" essay. The definition of success was the time-honoured, Posit, Prove via evidence, and conclude. You could argue anything you wanted as long as your points were solidly backed up.

My A level history teacher was inspired: of a class of 14, we scored 8 As and 6 B grades, with one Distinction in the S paper.

user149799568 · 15/10/2026 16:22

wafflesmgee · 14/10/2026 20:04

I also agree that there is a direct correlation with the change in curriculum and children’s mental health suffering. I’m a primary school teacher and think we now teach to the test and are overly formal from too young an age at the cost of developing children’s ability to gain the skills they need to be independent learners eg collaboration, perseverance, independence, creativity, hands on practical learning.

the results also fail to show the vastly narrowing secondary school curriculum as a result of the teacher retention crisis and lack of funding, eg the numbers of children doing a level music or languages are at an all time low. Some would argue this narrowing is necessary to ensure the basics are taught well but I think it’s an absolute disgrace compared to countries where children have to take nine subjects to a level standard- these may score lower but in my view create more well rounded people with a higher overall skill set.

I think it’s an absolute disgrace compared to countries where children have to take nine subjects to a level standard

Which countries require all students to take nine subjects to A Level standard?

Fifthtimelucky · 15/10/2026 16:35

@Papyrophile those are very impressive results, especially for the 1970s (or earlier). I don’t think anyone in my year got more than a C for history and mainly it was Ds and Es!

SoftIce · 15/10/2026 16:53

Positives:

  • Phonics
  • Rigorous academic GCSEs
  • Some rigorous practical GCSEs (food, DT, engineering)
  • Progress 8

Negatives:

  • They should have gone further and done the same for construction, child development, etc. as they did for food and DT GCSEs. That would have gone some way towards achieving parity of vocational qualifications.
  • Narrowing of the curriculum - many schools now only allow pupils to take 8 subjects, and because of EBAC (when it was still a thing), the choices are often quite restricted with maybe one completely free option. Which means that the good work done on food and DT was actually in vain, since pupils can't take the qualifications anymore.
  • They should not have abolished GCSE IT. Computer science may be more respected but IT is actually much more useful for many pupils than computer science.
Papyrophile · 15/10/2026 16:57

@Fifthtimelucky , inspired teacher. Easily distracted, she could be derailed at the drop of a pencil, but her subject knowledge was so deep and wide that she was never dull. It was mostly talk (no chalk: she never wrote anything on the board) but somehow we ended up with a great appreciation of multiple aspects of history and research into the early modern period in Britain and Europe.

metellaestinatrio · 17/10/2026 07:51

napody · 14/10/2026 22:35

The sad truth is that heavily unionised and ideological groups will always oppose any kind of change and of external testing, because they hate accountability.

Wow, that's a big shift from your first few wide eyed posts.
There's a big difference between standardised testing at say 16, and making it so frequent and high stakes from age 5/6 that 15 year olds (the ones who take PISA) are so drilled at test taking it makes it difficult to make meaningful comparisons with other countries.

There is not “frequent and high stakes” testing from age 5/6 - that’s absolute rubbish. There is a phonics check in Y1, a times tables check in Y4 and then SATs at the end of Y6. That’s it for primary school. The phonics and times tables checks are (intentionally, by schools) administered so gently the child should not (or barely in the case of Y4) even be aware they are taking a test. They practise in class but learning sounds / times tables is part of the curriculum anyway. By the time you get to SATs children are ten or eleven and perfectly ready to sit a few tests in their usual classroom with their teacher - they don’t need to be “high stakes” for the children as they are actually used to measure the school not the child.

Arguably, having SATs and then presumably various tests at secondary school gets them used to sitting exams so it’s not a big deal when they come to GCSEs.

cityliving99 · 17/10/2026 08:08

prh47bridge · 15/10/2026 14:08

The reading score has also gone up, albeit not by anything like as much as science. But I agree with your point that this needs to improve further.

Parents need to read to their children. Secondary schools try to do extra reading with pupils who are in year 7 and have low ability reading.
My friend is a school librarian and this is part of her job. After a few weeks of daily reading the results are amazing. But why are secondary schools having to do this? And these pupils come from a variety of backgrounds.

User454545454546565 · 17/10/2026 10:58

I think PISA is incomplete. If England was ranked on MFL performance it would come bottom of every league table going.

The government wanted a STEM focus so it has got a lot of high performing Maths and Science students. This is penalising children who aren't interested in sciences but who have linguistic ability who never get the chance to shine.

Russian, Arabic and Chinese (among others) should be mainstream GCSE options, in the same way that basically every country in the world requires English as a compulsory school subject. We just look ignorant overseas.

So zero credit to Gove from me.

ParentOfOne · 17/10/2026 13:34

@User454545454546565 Reading in your own language is part of the PISA test.

Foreign languages are NOT more important than basic reading and maths skills.

Struggling to comprehend a text or struggling with basic calculations means functional illiteracy.
Not being able to speak foreign languages does not.

And, for the record, I say this as someone who has lived abroad and happens to speak, read and write in 2 foreign languages.

You are welcome to think that Gove should have done more for foreign languages.
But implying that foreign languages are more important than reading and maths is... questionable at best.

There is also the rather objective and undeniable fact that foreign languages are less important for English speakers. Yes, they broaden the mind, it's great to learn them. they expose you to a whole new world etc etc etc. Not denying any of that. But English is the lingua franca of the world. There's no denying it.

OP posts:
noblegiraffe · 17/10/2026 14:13

User454545454546565 · 17/10/2026 10:58

I think PISA is incomplete. If England was ranked on MFL performance it would come bottom of every league table going.

The government wanted a STEM focus so it has got a lot of high performing Maths and Science students. This is penalising children who aren't interested in sciences but who have linguistic ability who never get the chance to shine.

Russian, Arabic and Chinese (among others) should be mainstream GCSE options, in the same way that basically every country in the world requires English as a compulsory school subject. We just look ignorant overseas.

So zero credit to Gove from me.

I mean, this is factually incorrect.

Gove deliberately made MFL part of the Ebacc and had the aim to get 75% of pupils taking it by 2022 and 90% by 2025. He wanted pupils to study MFL.

The problem was Labour dropped compulsory MFL at GCSE in 2004, at which point huge swathes of MFL teachers lost their jobs. The country was not in a good place to replace them in 2010 and have struggled to recruit since (and there has then been a vicious circle of fewer kids having language qualifications as a pool to recruit new teachers from), There is also huge resistance from both children and parents when it comes to trying to encourage them to take it at GCSE. Schools implement various measures, like blocking French with BTEC travel and tourism or whatever so parents who want their kids to avoid vocational qualifications have to put up with them taking French and omg the MN threads moaning about this....

Piglet89 · 17/10/2026 14:19

Gove imagined the kind of curriculum that would’ve suited him as a child and implemented that. There is absolutely no reason children of 5/6 should need to take ages to understand what an adverb is when they could learn it in seconds when they’re older.

I also cannot respect a man who sat on a bed reading while his wife and mother in law did the hard work settling in after a house move (Sarah Vine’s book). Pathetic.

Bloau · 17/10/2026 14:28

Piglet89 · 17/10/2026 14:19

Gove imagined the kind of curriculum that would’ve suited him as a child and implemented that. There is absolutely no reason children of 5/6 should need to take ages to understand what an adverb is when they could learn it in seconds when they’re older.

I also cannot respect a man who sat on a bed reading while his wife and mother in law did the hard work settling in after a house move (Sarah Vine’s book). Pathetic.

Agree, the spelling, punctuation and grammar requirements at primary are crazy (and I have a linguistics degree and love talking about words!). Could many adults recognise the past perfect tense in English? That's what I'm having to teach 8 year olds.

Bloau · 17/10/2026 14:30

cityliving99 · 17/10/2026 08:08

Parents need to read to their children. Secondary schools try to do extra reading with pupils who are in year 7 and have low ability reading.
My friend is a school librarian and this is part of her job. After a few weeks of daily reading the results are amazing. But why are secondary schools having to do this? And these pupils come from a variety of backgrounds.

Those children have probably read several times a week at primary for 7 years. They are coming to secondary unable to read in spite of this. I think secondaries massively underestimate how much time teachers put into children who simply aren't developmentally ready to meet curriculum requirements.

ParentOfOne · 17/10/2026 14:35

@Piglet89 I also cannot respect a man who sat on a bed reading while his wife and mother in law did the hard work settling in after a house move (Sarah Vine’s book). Pathetic.

But that's a separate point. If you want to judge Gove the man in his entirety, you're welcome to create a thread for that. I am no fan of his - I did point out he's a Brexiter who said all schools should be above average!

The point of my thread was to discuss the legacy of his education reform, what he got right, what he got wrong, etc.

@Bloau Agree, the spelling, punctuation and grammar requirements at primary are crazy (and I have a linguistics degree and love talking about words!).

Is it fair to say there is too much complex grammar in primary and maybe not enough in secondary? Would a different balance have made more sense? Genuine question - I am not too sure about the grammar syllabus at GCSE

OP posts:
Piglet89 · 17/10/2026 14:53

ParentOfOne · 17/10/2026 14:35

@Piglet89 I also cannot respect a man who sat on a bed reading while his wife and mother in law did the hard work settling in after a house move (Sarah Vine’s book). Pathetic.

But that's a separate point. If you want to judge Gove the man in his entirety, you're welcome to create a thread for that. I am no fan of his - I did point out he's a Brexiter who said all schools should be above average!

The point of my thread was to discuss the legacy of his education reform, what he got right, what he got wrong, etc.

@Bloau Agree, the spelling, punctuation and grammar requirements at primary are crazy (and I have a linguistics degree and love talking about words!).

Is it fair to say there is too much complex grammar in primary and maybe not enough in secondary? Would a different balance have made more sense? Genuine question - I am not too sure about the grammar syllabus at GCSE

I see it’s a separate point. However, it speaks to his character as more of a thinker than a doer. More theoretical than practical/realist. Less concerned with mucking in than continuing to pontificate and navel gaze.

That is relevant as I think one needs to be practical with an awareness of the real world in order to implement a curriculum that can help everyone achieve their potential.

Araminta1004 · 17/10/2026 14:56

Society and the “system” is increasingly complex so there is no getting away from the fact that Maths and English GCSEs need to reflect that complexity and understanding to access modern life. The law does not allow ignorance of it nor does the financial system, practically speaking. It permeates every part of life.
A significant proportion of the prison population are illiterate and innumerate to a “functional” level.
So on that aspect Gove was right, it needed to become harder.

As for the decline of reading, in an ideal world parents should be reading to their DC regularly and discussing texts. However, again modern life is so busy plenty don’t have the time when they all get back at 6pm onwards shattered. I think the second best is age appropriate recommended audio books for the whole family to listen to and share. I would like to see more of that with easy access for all, rather than TV/screens time as the default for children. Also more listening to a variety of music across the ages.

Owlbookend · 17/10/2026 14:58

It is somewhat depressing that a thread about the UK doing relatively well in international educational comparisons seems to result in digs at teaching unions and very little appreciation of the role of teaching professionals in achieving this. Im trying to imagine what type of news story would result in appreciative posts about teachers.
The maintenance of standards in core subjects is most likely associated with increased use of evidence based practice that @noblegiraffe highlights, This includes greater direct teaching, modifying input based on formative assessment and phonics emphasised in the early years & key stage 1. This direction of travel predated Gove, but he certainly kept with it. I think it is these broad principles rather than his more esoteric ideas about curriculum content and reduction/devaluing of 14-16 practical options that has had an impact.

Owlbookend · 17/10/2026 15:03

& i think increasing use of screens (by us all not just kids) is likely strongly linked to decreased reading for pleasure.
As a child in the 80s we had 1 TV with limited child friendly offerings on limited channels at limited times. There just wasnt the same variety of alternative entertainment to reading.

I dont know how we change that. I am as guilty? as anyone at constantly engaging in screen based entertainment.

User454545454546565 · 17/10/2026 15:11

@noblegiraffeI'm more than happy to blame Labour as well, no problem.

The obsession with French is outdated. MFL is far more than French and Spanish but that's all you get in my region, and usually not even both at the sane school.