Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

Violence against women and girls in Gaza.....

353 replies

mids2019 · 23/09/2026 23:01

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c94gm7dp40y0o

Even if you are in a war torn environment there is no excuse for alarming rates of sexual violence against women in Gaza. I think this highlights the fact that women suffer the most in Islamist governed territories like Gaza where women's rights have been historically removed. Hamas as a government aren't preventing this (weirdly enough) so what can be done. (Maybe a march?)

A file photo showing a Palestinian woman inspecting her damaged home after an Israeli strike on a nearby mosque, in Gaza City (29 July 2026)

Reports of violence against women in Gaza surge, UN agency finds

The UN Population Fund also says there has been a "severe escalation" in the number of early and forced marriages.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c94gm7dp40y0o

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
golosh · 09/11/2026 15:45

Emilesgran · 09/11/2026 12:30

People have expressed concern that the six-day truce to get Ukrainian civilians out of Oleshky would allow Russia to rearm, but you think Hamas refilling its coffers using stolen aid should be no concern of Israel? You know that participating in funding a terror organisation, even indirectly, is a crime?

Here are a few of the reasons why anyone who cared about Palestinians would not say what you just said - because they deliberately ensure that ordinary Palestinians have the worst lives possible so as to continue their war to destroy Israel.The first victims of Hamas are Palestinians.

https://x.com/Mr_Andrew_Fox/status/2119559729026306201?a=8hlhoQdhxIJs3IVitlY&s=20

https://x.com/afalkhatib/status/2119661443201040761?a=yP0prQXDSQkaKUvWq-U&s=20

No, let aid in.
The UN, red cross, WFP, Unicef all say that blocking humanitarian aid is ensuring unliveable conditions for Gazans. This is also a war crime.

Emilesgran · 10/11/2026 06:26

golosh · 09/11/2026 15:45

No, let aid in.
The UN, red cross, WFP, Unicef all say that blocking humanitarian aid is ensuring unliveable conditions for Gazans. This is also a war crime.

It’s crazy that people will accuse Israel of genocide while also apparently expecting them to provide aid for the people they are supposedly trying to kill.
Did anyone ever complain that the Hutus tried to stop aid getting through to the remaining Tutsis after the genocide? Or that the Turks didnt give aid to the Armenians they are massacring?

Only the Palestinians start a war by murdering and kidnapping innocent civilians, promptly lose that war, and then cry that they are being genocided - and find people ready to believe them.

It’s an excellent illustration of George Orwell's description of antisemitism.

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 06:36

Emilesgran · 10/11/2026 06:26

It’s crazy that people will accuse Israel of genocide while also apparently expecting them to provide aid for the people they are supposedly trying to kill.
Did anyone ever complain that the Hutus tried to stop aid getting through to the remaining Tutsis after the genocide? Or that the Turks didnt give aid to the Armenians they are massacring?

Only the Palestinians start a war by murdering and kidnapping innocent civilians, promptly lose that war, and then cry that they are being genocided - and find people ready to believe them.

It’s an excellent illustration of George Orwell's description of antisemitism.

It is a strange one.

If people genuinely think their aim is genocide, why expect humanitarian aid? Hardly a consistent position.

Though I do expect Israel to provide humanitarian aid and am disappointed when I hear it being limited, that’s because I don’t believe their aim is genocide.

golosh · 10/11/2026 07:32

Emilesgran · 10/11/2026 06:26

It’s crazy that people will accuse Israel of genocide while also apparently expecting them to provide aid for the people they are supposedly trying to kill.
Did anyone ever complain that the Hutus tried to stop aid getting through to the remaining Tutsis after the genocide? Or that the Turks didnt give aid to the Armenians they are massacring?

Only the Palestinians start a war by murdering and kidnapping innocent civilians, promptly lose that war, and then cry that they are being genocided - and find people ready to believe them.

It’s an excellent illustration of George Orwell's description of antisemitism.

Once again, no one is telling Israel to provide any aid.

We are simply asking that Israel allow already existing, waiting, aid, including medication, into Gaza, rather than blocking aid trucks from entering Gaza. Blocking aid is a war crime

If you want to read more about this you can do so: The UN, Red Cross, WFP, Unicef, WCK among many others have issued many statements and reports on this issue.

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 07:42

golosh · 10/11/2026 07:32

Once again, no one is telling Israel to provide any aid.

We are simply asking that Israel allow already existing, waiting, aid, including medication, into Gaza, rather than blocking aid trucks from entering Gaza. Blocking aid is a war crime

If you want to read more about this you can do so: The UN, Red Cross, WFP, Unicef, WCK among many others have issued many statements and reports on this issue.

Same point though - why would you expect them to allow it if you insist that they are genocidal maniacs? Isn't genocide inconsistent with allowing humanitarian aid into a country? Yet strangely there has been a lot that has entered Gaza (not enough, we can agree on that).

Emilesgran · 10/11/2026 12:36

golosh · 10/11/2026 07:32

Once again, no one is telling Israel to provide any aid.

We are simply asking that Israel allow already existing, waiting, aid, including medication, into Gaza, rather than blocking aid trucks from entering Gaza. Blocking aid is a war crime

If you want to read more about this you can do so: The UN, Red Cross, WFP, Unicef, WCK among many others have issued many statements and reports on this issue.

Same difference - if they were trying to commit genocide:

  1. they would have continued bombing from the air in October 2023 until there was nothing left instead of putting their own sons and daughters in danger from booby traps and so on,
  2. they would not have enabled the vaccination of thousands of children in Gaza in (I think 2024) after there’d been a polio outbreak
  3. as already said above: even allowing external aid in is not the act of a genocidal army.

If you can find an example from history of a generally accepted genocide where at least two of those three things were done by the “genociders” then fair enough.

But you won’t because it doesn’t happen. And that s why Israel won’t be found guilty of genocide because INTENT is clearly not there.

golosh · 10/11/2026 14:26

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 07:42

Same point though - why would you expect them to allow it if you insist that they are genocidal maniacs? Isn't genocide inconsistent with allowing humanitarian aid into a country? Yet strangely there has been a lot that has entered Gaza (not enough, we can agree on that).

I don’t expect them to allow it, intentional starvation as a method of warfare (a war crime) is one of the reasons for the arrest warrant on Netenyahu.

golosh · 10/11/2026 15:05

Emilesgran · 10/11/2026 12:36

Same difference - if they were trying to commit genocide:

  1. they would have continued bombing from the air in October 2023 until there was nothing left instead of putting their own sons and daughters in danger from booby traps and so on,
  2. they would not have enabled the vaccination of thousands of children in Gaza in (I think 2024) after there’d been a polio outbreak
  3. as already said above: even allowing external aid in is not the act of a genocidal army.

If you can find an example from history of a generally accepted genocide where at least two of those three things were done by the “genociders” then fair enough.

But you won’t because it doesn’t happen. And that s why Israel won’t be found guilty of genocide because INTENT is clearly not there.

None of these three points, although emotive, are legally what constitutes a genocide.

  1. Its quite well documented that they had a rush to bomb as much as possible using bunker bombs, 2000lb bombs. over 600 were used right at the beginning, and then netanyahu went to the US to beg for more.
  2. Polio is contagious, let me remind you of the proximity of Gaza to Israel; there was huge international pressure.
  3. Deliberately depriving civilians of essentials, and wilfully impeding relief supplies is a war crime. ICC judges found reasonable grounds to believe Netanyahu and Gallant bore responsibility for precisely that crime.

Intent: This is in the ICJ document, it goes on for 24 pages detailing intent. Netenyahu saying there are ‘no uninvolved civilians’; those invoking soldiers to ‘kill anything that moves’; Isaac Herzog not distinguishing between civilians and militants; Gallant saying ‘we will eliminate everything’, calling arabs ‘animals’; Ben Gvir - ‘they are all terrorists and should be destroyed’; Smotrich ‘we need to take gaza down in its entirety’; Eliyahu ‘the razed sections of gaza are beautiful. They will be given to those who fought in this war’.

As I said it goes on for 24 pages and that was just in the first few paragraphs.

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 15:13

golosh · 10/11/2026 15:05

None of these three points, although emotive, are legally what constitutes a genocide.

  1. Its quite well documented that they had a rush to bomb as much as possible using bunker bombs, 2000lb bombs. over 600 were used right at the beginning, and then netanyahu went to the US to beg for more.
  2. Polio is contagious, let me remind you of the proximity of Gaza to Israel; there was huge international pressure.
  3. Deliberately depriving civilians of essentials, and wilfully impeding relief supplies is a war crime. ICC judges found reasonable grounds to believe Netanyahu and Gallant bore responsibility for precisely that crime.

Intent: This is in the ICJ document, it goes on for 24 pages detailing intent. Netenyahu saying there are ‘no uninvolved civilians’; those invoking soldiers to ‘kill anything that moves’; Isaac Herzog not distinguishing between civilians and militants; Gallant saying ‘we will eliminate everything’, calling arabs ‘animals’; Ben Gvir - ‘they are all terrorists and should be destroyed’; Smotrich ‘we need to take gaza down in its entirety’; Eliyahu ‘the razed sections of gaza are beautiful. They will be given to those who fought in this war’.

As I said it goes on for 24 pages and that was just in the first few paragraphs.

If you think you know what legally constitutes a genocide, you will know that there hasn't as yet been a legal determination on the situation with Israel:

Much of the public conviction that Israel is committing genocide reflects a single confusion. UN commissions, special rapporteurs, and General Assembly resolutions have all used the language of genocide. Their institutional authority gives many people the impression that the legal question has already been decided. It has not. Under the Genocide Convention, only a competent court can make a binding legal determination of genocide. No court has found that Israel committed genocide. Everything else, however authoritative it may appear, is an allegation — not a legal determination.

combatantisemitism.org/special-features/legal-determination-of-genocide/

golosh · 10/11/2026 16:41

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 15:13

If you think you know what legally constitutes a genocide, you will know that there hasn't as yet been a legal determination on the situation with Israel:

Much of the public conviction that Israel is committing genocide reflects a single confusion. UN commissions, special rapporteurs, and General Assembly resolutions have all used the language of genocide. Their institutional authority gives many people the impression that the legal question has already been decided. It has not. Under the Genocide Convention, only a competent court can make a binding legal determination of genocide. No court has found that Israel committed genocide. Everything else, however authoritative it may appear, is an allegation — not a legal determination.

combatantisemitism.org/special-features/legal-determination-of-genocide/

Yes I know this.

This is because the ICJ have given South Africa 18 months to respond, then Israel have 18 months to respond to that. Then there will be a verdict in 2029. That’s how genocides are decided.

In the mean time, Israel has been told it must stop any forms of ethnic cleansing, punish incitement, allow humanitarian aid, submit compliance reports, prevent acts of genocide such as deliberately inflicting conditions that bring about mental and physical harm. It is being argued by the international community that Israel is not complying (eg not allowing in aid is non-compliance, incitement to violence aka settlers is non-compliance) and so the next step is UNSC and sanctions. One consequence is just diplomatic isolation as more and more countries become concerned about affiliating with a country that is committing war crimes.

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 17:14

Good @golosh I'm glad you acknowledge that there hasn't as yet been a legal determination.

Perhaps you should not talk about "acts of genocide" in that case.

Martymcfly24 · 10/11/2026 18:18

golosh · 09/11/2026 15:45

No, let aid in.
The UN, red cross, WFP, Unicef all say that blocking humanitarian aid is ensuring unliveable conditions for Gazans. This is also a war crime.

The winter storms have come to Gaza and at least 70,000 tents have been swept away. They were in such poor condition anyway after the past 3 years.
There are currently 150,000 tents outside Gaza waiting to get in that Israel have blocked.

Unliveable conditions is right.

ForRedPoet · 10/11/2026 20:38

Martymcfly24 · 10/11/2026 18:18

The winter storms have come to Gaza and at least 70,000 tents have been swept away. They were in such poor condition anyway after the past 3 years.
There are currently 150,000 tents outside Gaza waiting to get in that Israel have blocked.

Unliveable conditions is right.

You and golosh are derailing this thread. The title is VAGW in Gaza. You've criticised Israel enough on every other post in this topic.

We need to be honest about this violence without being called racist or else no proper debate (and hopefully change) can occur.

The problem is radical Islam.
It is not islamaphobic to mention how these countries with radical religions view women as dirt, allow them to be treated like this, indeed encourage the treatment and lose of women's rights.
That is the issue.
VAWG and utter misogeny is endemic in these countries, war or not. Any denial of this is a very poor show of our fellow women.

golosh · 11/11/2026 01:38

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 17:14

Good @golosh I'm glad you acknowledge that there hasn't as yet been a legal determination.

Perhaps you should not talk about "acts of genocide" in that case.

Acts of genocide is the legal term being used in the ICJ document: incitement is for example an act of genocide, Eliyahu saying ‘flatten the whole place and leave no one alive’ is an example that’s stated in the ICJ document.

Israel is now in the difficult position of trying to disprove these acts happened, when a lot of them were recorded and on live TV for everyone to see.

I get that that’s distressing for the every day liberal Israeli - but these are the facts - and there are many, particularly young people, who are protesting and have woken up to the harm their government is doing.

golosh · 11/11/2026 02:16

ForRedPoet · 10/11/2026 20:38

You and golosh are derailing this thread. The title is VAGW in Gaza. You've criticised Israel enough on every other post in this topic.

We need to be honest about this violence without being called racist or else no proper debate (and hopefully change) can occur.

The problem is radical Islam.
It is not islamaphobic to mention how these countries with radical religions view women as dirt, allow them to be treated like this, indeed encourage the treatment and lose of women's rights.
That is the issue.
VAWG and utter misogeny is endemic in these countries, war or not. Any denial of this is a very poor show of our fellow women.

If you read through the thread, I was addressing the issue of ‘misogyny in those backwards countries’ and I was repeatedly, weirdly, asked about aid.

Notwithstanding the racism in your post: “VAWG and utter misogeny is endemic in these countries” I have, many times, tried to address this in this thread.

Firstly, change will not come about from sentiments like yours. How many women in Gaza are saying “I hope ForRedPoet comes to save us, their views on our culture and land fill me with hope”. What is your solution for these countries as it happens?

Secondly, we must all look at our own dirty washing. In the week of Russell Brand, David Walliams, the country of Jimmy Saville, Wayne Couzens, VAWG stats around football time, misogynistic work cultures (I’m old enough to remember bum pinching as normal behaviour from sleazy men, even at work), the UK statistics on VAWG are nothing to be proud of and neither are we in any position to preach on this subject.

Thirdly, need I remind you, again, of Sde Teiman, the IDF whistleblowers who spoke of a culture of rape and sexual assault, and the fact that the rapist went on TV to standing ovations.

Twiglets1 · 11/11/2026 06:50

golosh · 11/11/2026 02:16

If you read through the thread, I was addressing the issue of ‘misogyny in those backwards countries’ and I was repeatedly, weirdly, asked about aid.

Notwithstanding the racism in your post: “VAWG and utter misogeny is endemic in these countries” I have, many times, tried to address this in this thread.

Firstly, change will not come about from sentiments like yours. How many women in Gaza are saying “I hope ForRedPoet comes to save us, their views on our culture and land fill me with hope”. What is your solution for these countries as it happens?

Secondly, we must all look at our own dirty washing. In the week of Russell Brand, David Walliams, the country of Jimmy Saville, Wayne Couzens, VAWG stats around football time, misogynistic work cultures (I’m old enough to remember bum pinching as normal behaviour from sleazy men, even at work), the UK statistics on VAWG are nothing to be proud of and neither are we in any position to preach on this subject.

Thirdly, need I remind you, again, of Sde Teiman, the IDF whistleblowers who spoke of a culture of rape and sexual assault, and the fact that the rapist went on TV to standing ovations.

Oh look an attempt to divert focus from what this thread is about - violence against women and girls in Gaza. Apparently we shouldn't talk about it until our own society is perfect and free of sleazy men. In other words, never.

As a reminder, this thread is about the sharp rise in reports of violence against women and girls in the Gaza Strip, including early and forced marriage.

Rape victims forced to marry their rapists to avoid shame and scandal.

Early or child marriage involving girls as young as 12.

Twiglets1 · 11/11/2026 06:53

There are multiple MN threads if you want to criticise Brand or Walliams, @golosh

Whatever their sins may be, they are not responsible for violence against women and girls in Gaza and neither is Jimmy Saville.

ForRedPoet · 11/11/2026 10:34

golosh · 11/11/2026 02:16

If you read through the thread, I was addressing the issue of ‘misogyny in those backwards countries’ and I was repeatedly, weirdly, asked about aid.

Notwithstanding the racism in your post: “VAWG and utter misogeny is endemic in these countries” I have, many times, tried to address this in this thread.

Firstly, change will not come about from sentiments like yours. How many women in Gaza are saying “I hope ForRedPoet comes to save us, their views on our culture and land fill me with hope”. What is your solution for these countries as it happens?

Secondly, we must all look at our own dirty washing. In the week of Russell Brand, David Walliams, the country of Jimmy Saville, Wayne Couzens, VAWG stats around football time, misogynistic work cultures (I’m old enough to remember bum pinching as normal behaviour from sleazy men, even at work), the UK statistics on VAWG are nothing to be proud of and neither are we in any position to preach on this subject.

Thirdly, need I remind you, again, of Sde Teiman, the IDF whistleblowers who spoke of a culture of rape and sexual assault, and the fact that the rapist went on TV to standing ovations.

Oh course I don't believe I am some kind of saviour! I do however believe open discussions about the harms Islamic fundamentalist leadership causes, including the disproportionate harm to women and girls is required before change.

You called my post racist. This is precisely what I am talking about. Trying to shut people who bring up the elephant in the room.

Or do you disagree that these regimes are misogynistic and harmful to women?

golosh · 11/11/2026 11:15

ForRedPoet · 11/11/2026 10:34

Oh course I don't believe I am some kind of saviour! I do however believe open discussions about the harms Islamic fundamentalist leadership causes, including the disproportionate harm to women and girls is required before change.

You called my post racist. This is precisely what I am talking about. Trying to shut people who bring up the elephant in the room.

Or do you disagree that these regimes are misogynistic and harmful to women?

Yes I disagree. For example, what do you mean by ‘these regimes’? does, for example, Lebanon or Egypt count as one of ‘these regimes’?

golosh · 11/11/2026 11:18

Twiglets1 · 11/11/2026 06:53

There are multiple MN threads if you want to criticise Brand or Walliams, @golosh

Whatever their sins may be, they are not responsible for violence against women and girls in Gaza and neither is Jimmy Saville.

No I don’t really care to do that Twiglet I’m just genuinely interested in the pro Israeli thought process. It’s fascinating.

ForRedPoet · 11/11/2026 11:32

golosh · 11/11/2026 11:15

Yes I disagree. For example, what do you mean by ‘these regimes’? does, for example, Lebanon or Egypt count as one of ‘these regimes’?

Are you being deliberately obtuse?
What do I mean by these regimes? Erm, precisely what I said.

You ask if Lebanon and Egypt count? Are they radical Islam run countries? No. They are Islamic, but not fundament governments, so they do not count.

Please share precisely what don't you understand about what I said and I will try and explain it in even more simpler terms.

Well as much as I can for some who admits these radical countries aren't misogynistic and harmful to women.

Twiglets1 · 11/11/2026 13:30

golosh · 11/11/2026 11:15

Yes I disagree. For example, what do you mean by ‘these regimes’? does, for example, Lebanon or Egypt count as one of ‘these regimes’?

You disagree that the Islamic fundamentalist regime of Hamas causes disproportionate harm to women and girls?

Despite all the evidence in the report that OP linked to, including early or child marriage involving girls as young as 12?

From the BBC report: One displaced woman in a school-turned-shelter in Gaza highlights how rape victims are often married to their rapists to avoid shame and scandal. "When rape cases are discovered in schools, you find weddings and celebrations at the school the next day," she says.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c94gm7dp40y0o

Emilesgran · 11/11/2026 13:51

golosh · 11/11/2026 11:18

No I don’t really care to do that Twiglet I’m just genuinely interested in the pro Israeli thought process. It’s fascinating.

Here is a girl who was not allowed into school because her dress was "insufficiently modest" and yet you're still insisting that it's Israel that is somehow at fault for this sort of oppression of women and girls. Presumably you have no problem with girls being refused education for not being sufficiently covered up?

https://x.com/afalkhatib/status/2120340950241206648?a=zi2iGFuAqbnNvFJOCEY&s=20

Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib (@afalkhatib) on X

The Failure to Protect Gaza's Children: 12-year-old Mennah, the daughter of my friend Na'ama, was denied entry today to a makeshift educational tent in Gaza's humanitarian zone because teachers deemed her clothing insufficiently "modest" and demanded s...

https://x.com/afalkhatib/status/2120340950241206648?a=zi2iGFuAqbnNvFJOCEY&s=20

golosh · 11/11/2026 14:13

ForRedPoet · 11/11/2026 11:32

Are you being deliberately obtuse?
What do I mean by these regimes? Erm, precisely what I said.

You ask if Lebanon and Egypt count? Are they radical Islam run countries? No. They are Islamic, but not fundament governments, so they do not count.

Please share precisely what don't you understand about what I said and I will try and explain it in even more simpler terms.

Well as much as I can for some who admits these radical countries aren't misogynistic and harmful to women.

I genuinely thought you were just conflating all muslim countries together in a group. It’s so common around here I just assumed you were doing the same.

Relevant to this conversation: Maslow’s hierarchy of needs: Human beings need the basics to survive before anything else. Even the BBC article OP posted says this:

“Aid agencies argue that the dangers for women in Gaza could be greatly eased by improving humanitarian conditions. There are calls for Israel to allow higher quality shelters into the territory as well as equipment to upgrade latrines and sanitation as well as lighting.”

I do agree with you, there are theocratic countries in the world that (apparently) have extremely conservative cultures and views. I can’t be sure: I have never been to Afghanistan, Iran, Syria. I have been to Jerusalem, with Arab friends, and while I was never under the impression Palestinians are fanatical or fundamentalist, I did get an eye opening look into the world of checkpoints, separate roads, vehicles, ID cards and the balance of power and humiliation my friends endured on a daily basis. It was just part of life, and humbling. I also remember there being a pretty cool art scene, Muslims and Christians hanging out together, clean nice streets, cute coffee shops and a lovely vibe. This was a few years ago now. Anyway all this to say that you might be under the impression they are living in some sort of fundamentalist state where you are whipped and stoned on the daily, but in reality it could be something completely different.

Anyway my opinion on this is this - and to be honest it’s the hill I probably will die on: Change does not come from middle class middle aged English women talking on a forum, at a dinner party, or among family after Christmas lunch, or whatever. These changes will only and should only ever come from the community itself, instigated by the community itself at its own choosing. When that community is dehumanised, marginalised, bombed to oblivion, ethnically cleansed, living in tents in the cold, etc, no one from that community is ever going to care about what the dehumanisers/ colonisers/ white saviours think.

Hence Maslow.