Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

Violence against women and girls in Gaza.....

353 replies

mids2019 · 23/09/2026 23:01

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c94gm7dp40y0o

Even if you are in a war torn environment there is no excuse for alarming rates of sexual violence against women in Gaza. I think this highlights the fact that women suffer the most in Islamist governed territories like Gaza where women's rights have been historically removed. Hamas as a government aren't preventing this (weirdly enough) so what can be done. (Maybe a march?)

A file photo showing a Palestinian woman inspecting her damaged home after an Israeli strike on a nearby mosque, in Gaza City (29 July 2026)

Reports of violence against women in Gaza surge, UN agency finds

The UN Population Fund also says there has been a "severe escalation" in the number of early and forced marriages.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c94gm7dp40y0o

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Twiglets1 · 11/11/2026 14:29

Tbh @golosh no one from the Gaza community is probably ever going to care about what any of us debate on Mumsnet - or the Israel community either.

We can't influence anything going on there. We have discussions on MN for our own reasons not because it helps them.

Emilesgran · 11/11/2026 15:55

golosh · 11/11/2026 14:13

I genuinely thought you were just conflating all muslim countries together in a group. It’s so common around here I just assumed you were doing the same.

Relevant to this conversation: Maslow’s hierarchy of needs: Human beings need the basics to survive before anything else. Even the BBC article OP posted says this:

“Aid agencies argue that the dangers for women in Gaza could be greatly eased by improving humanitarian conditions. There are calls for Israel to allow higher quality shelters into the territory as well as equipment to upgrade latrines and sanitation as well as lighting.”

I do agree with you, there are theocratic countries in the world that (apparently) have extremely conservative cultures and views. I can’t be sure: I have never been to Afghanistan, Iran, Syria. I have been to Jerusalem, with Arab friends, and while I was never under the impression Palestinians are fanatical or fundamentalist, I did get an eye opening look into the world of checkpoints, separate roads, vehicles, ID cards and the balance of power and humiliation my friends endured on a daily basis. It was just part of life, and humbling. I also remember there being a pretty cool art scene, Muslims and Christians hanging out together, clean nice streets, cute coffee shops and a lovely vibe. This was a few years ago now. Anyway all this to say that you might be under the impression they are living in some sort of fundamentalist state where you are whipped and stoned on the daily, but in reality it could be something completely different.

Anyway my opinion on this is this - and to be honest it’s the hill I probably will die on: Change does not come from middle class middle aged English women talking on a forum, at a dinner party, or among family after Christmas lunch, or whatever. These changes will only and should only ever come from the community itself, instigated by the community itself at its own choosing. When that community is dehumanised, marginalised, bombed to oblivion, ethnically cleansed, living in tents in the cold, etc, no one from that community is ever going to care about what the dehumanisers/ colonisers/ white saviours think.

Hence Maslow.

“Aid agencies argue that the dangers for women in Gaza could be greatly eased by improving humanitarian conditions. There are calls for Israel to allow higher quality shelters into the territory as well as equipment to upgrade latrines and sanitation as well as lighting.”

And the problem with this is that Hamas then takes these things and uses them for their own purposes, thus both enabling further attacks on Israeli citizens but also leaving people in Gaza without them. So unless you have a solution to prevent this from happening, what you are saying - and what you already have said - is that it's ok for Hamas to build up their armoury against Israel as long as crumbs of that aid reach ordinary Gazans. But Israelis (who are mostly not "middle class middle aged English women talking on a forum" etc are entitled to disagree with you. And aren't you far closer to that demographic (albeit possibly not English) than most Israelis?

I do agree with you, there are theocratic countries in the world that (apparently) have extremely conservative cultures and views. I can’t be sure: I have never been to Afghanistan, Iran, Syria.

So you think maybe Afghanistan is grand for women then? Seriously? I knew Syrians in Syria, decades ago, when it was a diverse society. That's no longer the case - the civil war and now the Islamist government (despite the desire of western governments to say it isn't Islamist, people there say it is) mean it is in the process of becoming another Iraq or Afghanistan.

"I have been to Jerusalem, with Arab friends, and while I was never under the impression Palestinians are fanatical or fundamentalist, I did get an eye opening look into the world of checkpoints, separate roads, vehicles, ID cards and the balance of power and humiliation my friends endured on a daily basis. It was just part of life, and humbling."

But those are only since terror attacks by Palestinians from those areas become a thing in Israel. Previous to that there was free movement into and out of Israel for Palestinians. Should Israel continue to allow anyone into Israel knowing that attacks are a real risk? Why?

"Anyway all this to say that you might be under the impression they are living in some sort of fundamentalist state where you are whipped and stoned on the daily, but in reality it could be something completely different."

And yet you've ignored evidence that anyone in Gaza who dares speak out against Hamas (ie "Islamic resistance") is arrrested, beaten, tortured and even killed - all because you hate Israel.

Emilesgran · 11/11/2026 19:32

Martymcfly24 · 10/11/2026 18:18

The winter storms have come to Gaza and at least 70,000 tents have been swept away. They were in such poor condition anyway after the past 3 years.
There are currently 150,000 tents outside Gaza waiting to get in that Israel have blocked.

Unliveable conditions is right.

And this is not unrelated to Hamas' actions:

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2026/11/10/hamas-seizes-tents-from-homeless-gazans-during-deadly-storm/

Last week, however, with torrential rain forecast, gunmen from Hamas’s internal security units summoned Palestinian civil servants who were trying to make the refugee camps safer from rain and forced them to sign pledges not to enter those areas.
The civil servants had been embarking on a joint project with the United Nations Development Programme to improve the quality of the tents in the camps. Hamas confiscated many of the tents that they had been distributing.
One engineer, Ahmed al-Tallouli, said he had been urgently replacing the current tents with more durable fibre-framed tents when he was summoned for questioning by Hamas. “Last Saturday, I carried out field work amid a depression and heavy rainfall, in response to clear instructions emphasising the necessity of urgent action to relieve the displaced and spare them risks as much as possible,” he said.
“I was surprised by a call yesterday from security in Gaza [Hamas] requesting my presence there today, followed by subsequent procedures, resulting in me being obligated to sign a pledge not to perform any tasks to the ministry in Gaza under the penalty of accountability.”

How is that Israel's fault? And what would be gained by bringing in more tents when Hamas are actively preventing improvements from being made? They are taking away the new tents that are being brought in.

That's because they are determined to ensure that Gazans suffer as much as possible, so as to give the useful idiots in the west "examples" of how terrible things are there. They've been doing this right from the start in October 2023, when they prevented people from leaving the areas that Israel warned it was going to attack. That was because Hamas wanted dead civilians, especially children.

And yet you are not capable of acknowledging this. Why not? Don't you care that Gazans are being made to suffer needlessly - by Hamas?

"Hamas’s internal security units have terrorised Gazan civilians since the war started on Oct 7, 2023. Numerous videos have emerged of gunmen savagely beating people suspected of dissent with iron bars."

Again, that doesn't seem to bother you. Why not?

golosh · 12/11/2026 01:29

Emilesgran · 11/11/2026 15:55

“Aid agencies argue that the dangers for women in Gaza could be greatly eased by improving humanitarian conditions. There are calls for Israel to allow higher quality shelters into the territory as well as equipment to upgrade latrines and sanitation as well as lighting.”

And the problem with this is that Hamas then takes these things and uses them for their own purposes, thus both enabling further attacks on Israeli citizens but also leaving people in Gaza without them. So unless you have a solution to prevent this from happening, what you are saying - and what you already have said - is that it's ok for Hamas to build up their armoury against Israel as long as crumbs of that aid reach ordinary Gazans. But Israelis (who are mostly not "middle class middle aged English women talking on a forum" etc are entitled to disagree with you. And aren't you far closer to that demographic (albeit possibly not English) than most Israelis?

I do agree with you, there are theocratic countries in the world that (apparently) have extremely conservative cultures and views. I can’t be sure: I have never been to Afghanistan, Iran, Syria.

So you think maybe Afghanistan is grand for women then? Seriously? I knew Syrians in Syria, decades ago, when it was a diverse society. That's no longer the case - the civil war and now the Islamist government (despite the desire of western governments to say it isn't Islamist, people there say it is) mean it is in the process of becoming another Iraq or Afghanistan.

"I have been to Jerusalem, with Arab friends, and while I was never under the impression Palestinians are fanatical or fundamentalist, I did get an eye opening look into the world of checkpoints, separate roads, vehicles, ID cards and the balance of power and humiliation my friends endured on a daily basis. It was just part of life, and humbling."

But those are only since terror attacks by Palestinians from those areas become a thing in Israel. Previous to that there was free movement into and out of Israel for Palestinians. Should Israel continue to allow anyone into Israel knowing that attacks are a real risk? Why?

"Anyway all this to say that you might be under the impression they are living in some sort of fundamentalist state where you are whipped and stoned on the daily, but in reality it could be something completely different."

And yet you've ignored evidence that anyone in Gaza who dares speak out against Hamas (ie "Islamic resistance") is arrrested, beaten, tortured and even killed - all because you hate Israel.

How am I ‘possibly not English’? I’d like your thought process on that because it’s interesting you think that.

I do not hate Israel. I do hate its government, Prime minister, president and policies and horrific actions towards its citizens and its occupied territories.

Fine then, don’t let in aid. Let them leave, starve or die. At least you will have fought for their feminist rights.

golosh · 12/11/2026 02:22

Twiglets1 · 11/11/2026 14:29

Tbh @golosh no one from the Gaza community is probably ever going to care about what any of us debate on Mumsnet - or the Israel community either.

We can't influence anything going on there. We have discussions on MN for our own reasons not because it helps them.

The Gaza community, if my instagram is anything to go by, is desperate for our help and attention. Every day I will see a video from a Gazan living in a tent asking for awareness, help, donations, or even just watching and clicking on share and like.

Similarly for the Israeli community, which appears to be genuinely confused as to why Israel is a pariah state, and thinks it's because we in the west are dumb and naive and have fallen for Hamas propaganda.

Emilesgran · 12/11/2026 06:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 06:45

golosh · 12/11/2026 02:22

The Gaza community, if my instagram is anything to go by, is desperate for our help and attention. Every day I will see a video from a Gazan living in a tent asking for awareness, help, donations, or even just watching and clicking on share and like.

Similarly for the Israeli community, which appears to be genuinely confused as to why Israel is a pariah state, and thinks it's because we in the west are dumb and naive and have fallen for Hamas propaganda.

Do you really think they care about our endless debates on Mumsnet?

Money yes - discussions on MN - No.

golosh · 12/11/2026 07:14

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 06:45

Do you really think they care about our endless debates on Mumsnet?

Money yes - discussions on MN - No.

Not literally mumsnet discussions. But that attention is bought to the cause, likewise in Ukraine where people are like ‘don’t forget about us’.

I have seen videos of Gazans saying their rent money is due for their tents - meaning yes Hamas (or local militia capitalising on the situation) is doing some sort of extortion, why are aid tents not free. I’m not under the impression there is a perfect victim. But that still doesn’t convince me about yours and @Emilesgranargument:

“Hamas are taking the aid. So no one gets aid” (This is a war crime and act of genocide, as it is depriving people of basic needs)

“Hamas are taking the aid in order to re-arm” (This doesn’t make sense to me, can you make it make sense? I don’t get this from a logical or monetary point of view).

Emilesgran · 12/11/2026 07:24

golosh · 12/11/2026 07:14

Not literally mumsnet discussions. But that attention is bought to the cause, likewise in Ukraine where people are like ‘don’t forget about us’.

I have seen videos of Gazans saying their rent money is due for their tents - meaning yes Hamas (or local militia capitalising on the situation) is doing some sort of extortion, why are aid tents not free. I’m not under the impression there is a perfect victim. But that still doesn’t convince me about yours and @Emilesgranargument:

“Hamas are taking the aid. So no one gets aid” (This is a war crime and act of genocide, as it is depriving people of basic needs)

“Hamas are taking the aid in order to re-arm” (This doesn’t make sense to me, can you make it make sense? I don’t get this from a logical or monetary point of view).

But “so nobody gets aid” is your description of Israel’s insistence on ensuring that aid is fully checked before being allowed through, and is inaccurate, since I linked to a civil engineer in Gaza who is being prevented from providing NEW tents by Hamas.

Which means that new tents are getting in to Gaza, albeit no doubt more slowly than they are arriving at the border.

So why isn’t Egypt letting them through the Egypt Gaza border if it’s as simple as you think?

And Hamas is stopping Gazans from getting new tents that have been allowed through.

Why do you have nothing to say about that? Just lies about it all being Israel’s fault?

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 07:26

golosh · 12/11/2026 07:14

Not literally mumsnet discussions. But that attention is bought to the cause, likewise in Ukraine where people are like ‘don’t forget about us’.

I have seen videos of Gazans saying their rent money is due for their tents - meaning yes Hamas (or local militia capitalising on the situation) is doing some sort of extortion, why are aid tents not free. I’m not under the impression there is a perfect victim. But that still doesn’t convince me about yours and @Emilesgranargument:

“Hamas are taking the aid. So no one gets aid” (This is a war crime and act of genocide, as it is depriving people of basic needs)

“Hamas are taking the aid in order to re-arm” (This doesn’t make sense to me, can you make it make sense? I don’t get this from a logical or monetary point of view).

You're quoting things at me another poster said, so suggest you raise it with them if you have comments on what they said.

Glad we agree Not literally mumsnet discussions.

These mumsnet discussions are for our own benefit, no one else's. It doesn't bring attention to the cause, we all know about the Gaza war and can read about it ourselves. If anything, arguing with people on MN has made me more sympathetic to Israel not less, because I see how unreasonable people are who blame them for everything while very rarely even mentioning Hamas.

Emilesgran · 12/11/2026 07:27

golosh · 12/11/2026 07:14

Not literally mumsnet discussions. But that attention is bought to the cause, likewise in Ukraine where people are like ‘don’t forget about us’.

I have seen videos of Gazans saying their rent money is due for their tents - meaning yes Hamas (or local militia capitalising on the situation) is doing some sort of extortion, why are aid tents not free. I’m not under the impression there is a perfect victim. But that still doesn’t convince me about yours and @Emilesgranargument:

“Hamas are taking the aid. So no one gets aid” (This is a war crime and act of genocide, as it is depriving people of basic needs)

“Hamas are taking the aid in order to re-arm” (This doesn’t make sense to me, can you make it make sense? I don’t get this from a logical or monetary point of view).

One thing we know has happened all through the war is that they then sell the aid which came in free, thus refilling their coffers to buy stuff that really matters to them like weapons.

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 07:30

Emilesgran · 12/11/2026 07:27

One thing we know has happened all through the war is that they then sell the aid which came in free, thus refilling their coffers to buy stuff that really matters to them like weapons.

Edited

We do all know that Hamas do that. The evidence is in the tunnels re how much aid and construction materials they stole in the past, and they haven't stopped.

A little honesty would make me respect those arguing against Israel so much more. I can be honest that Israel have been in the wrong many times too - why can't they be the same re blame on both sides.

inamarina · 12/11/2026 08:01

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 07:30

We do all know that Hamas do that. The evidence is in the tunnels re how much aid and construction materials they stole in the past, and they haven't stopped.

A little honesty would make me respect those arguing against Israel so much more. I can be honest that Israel have been in the wrong many times too - why can't they be the same re blame on both sides.

The evidence also was/is in the footage Gazans themselves uploaded onto social media where they talk about extortionate prices for goods that were donated, hence should be free.

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 08:08

inamarina · 12/11/2026 08:01

The evidence also was/is in the footage Gazans themselves uploaded onto social media where they talk about extortionate prices for goods that were donated, hence should be free.

Evidence all over the place for those that care to look.

golosh · 12/11/2026 12:13

Emilesgran · 12/11/2026 07:27

One thing we know has happened all through the war is that they then sell the aid which came in free, thus refilling their coffers to buy stuff that really matters to them like weapons.

Edited

So what’s the point of involving Iran? Surely the coffers from extortion are nothing in comparison to what’s being supplied by a superpower.

Also you can’t know for sure it’s Hamas. There was an interview with someone from the world food programme who said this is normal in wars, famine, natural disasters and the UN knows how to deal with it on the ground. They just are not being allowed to enter. Neither are journalists who can keep things in check.

Holding back aid is a war crime and act of genocide, as I’ve said many times.

FacetiousFace · 12/11/2026 12:17

Emilesgran · 12/11/2026 07:24

But “so nobody gets aid” is your description of Israel’s insistence on ensuring that aid is fully checked before being allowed through, and is inaccurate, since I linked to a civil engineer in Gaza who is being prevented from providing NEW tents by Hamas.

Which means that new tents are getting in to Gaza, albeit no doubt more slowly than they are arriving at the border.

So why isn’t Egypt letting them through the Egypt Gaza border if it’s as simple as you think?

And Hamas is stopping Gazans from getting new tents that have been allowed through.

Why do you have nothing to say about that? Just lies about it all being Israel’s fault?

So why isn’t Egypt letting them through the Egypt Gaza border if it’s as simple as you think?

Why do people keep saying this? How are Egypt supposed to 'let them through the Gaza border'? There is no border with Palestinians anymore, Israel have taken it, Israel have Palestinians penned into 30% of Gaza, there is no way for anything to reach Palestinians unless through Israeli controlled land. Egypt has exited the chat, you can no longer say 'but what about Egypt', get new lines.

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 12:33

golosh · 12/11/2026 12:13

So what’s the point of involving Iran? Surely the coffers from extortion are nothing in comparison to what’s being supplied by a superpower.

Also you can’t know for sure it’s Hamas. There was an interview with someone from the world food programme who said this is normal in wars, famine, natural disasters and the UN knows how to deal with it on the ground. They just are not being allowed to enter. Neither are journalists who can keep things in check.

Holding back aid is a war crime and act of genocide, as I’ve said many times.

Edited

Can't know for sure it's Hamas? Why try to defend them when they have been stealing & obstructing humanitarian aid for so long. We all know what they are doing. Denying it is not helpful to anyone.

Statement by the United Nations Deputy Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process, and Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator for the Occupied Palestinian Territory, Dr. Ramiz Alakbarov, on the Situation in Gaza (July 2026)

“I strongly condemn the recent obstruction of humanitarian operations in Gaza by the de facto authorities, which endangered humanitarian personnel, intimidated workers delivering lifesaving food assistance and disrupted life-saving humanitarian operations.

Yesterday, humanitarian workers were forced to halt food distributions after armed personnel affiliated with the de facto authorities forcibly entered the Abu Rashid food distribution point in Jabalia, North Gaza. The forces also entered a WFP warehouse and reportedly assaulted two truck drivers who were delivering humanitarian supplies.

These incidents are not isolated. They are completely unacceptable and reflect an increasingly dangerous pattern of intimidation, violence and obstruction, including smuggling attempts, targeting and abusing humanitarian operations. They are placing humanitarian workers at risk, disrupting the delivery of life-saving assistance, and further constraining the ability of humanitarian organizations to operate at a time when civilians across Gaza continue to face immense and pressing humanitarian conditions.

Direct threats to staff, interference with humanitarian supplies, and the shrinking humanitarian operating space continue to jeopardize operational continuity. At the same time, the expansion of areas under Israeli control is further reducing the space available to civilians, making it imperative that humanitarian assistance is able to move safely and reach people in need without interference.
Under international humanitarian law, all parties must respect and protect humanitarian personnel, facilities and relief supplies, and refrain from actions that obstruct humanitarian operations.

I call for an immediate end to all interference with humanitarian operations and to respect their independence, impartiality and neutrality. Civilians, including humanitarian personnel, must always be protected, and rapid, safe and unimpeded passage of impartial humanitarian relief must be facilitated.

The people of Gaza have already endured immense suffering. They cannot be subjected to further delays or disruptions in the delivery of life-saving assistance. I reiterate that humanitarian organizations must be able to carry out their work safely, independently, impartially and without fear of intimidation or violence.”

unsco.unmissions.org/en/news/statement-by-the-united-nations-deputy-special-coordinator-for-the-middle-east-peace

golosh · 12/11/2026 13:40

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 12:33

Can't know for sure it's Hamas? Why try to defend them when they have been stealing & obstructing humanitarian aid for so long. We all know what they are doing. Denying it is not helpful to anyone.

Statement by the United Nations Deputy Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process, and Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator for the Occupied Palestinian Territory, Dr. Ramiz Alakbarov, on the Situation in Gaza (July 2026)

“I strongly condemn the recent obstruction of humanitarian operations in Gaza by the de facto authorities, which endangered humanitarian personnel, intimidated workers delivering lifesaving food assistance and disrupted life-saving humanitarian operations.

Yesterday, humanitarian workers were forced to halt food distributions after armed personnel affiliated with the de facto authorities forcibly entered the Abu Rashid food distribution point in Jabalia, North Gaza. The forces also entered a WFP warehouse and reportedly assaulted two truck drivers who were delivering humanitarian supplies.

These incidents are not isolated. They are completely unacceptable and reflect an increasingly dangerous pattern of intimidation, violence and obstruction, including smuggling attempts, targeting and abusing humanitarian operations. They are placing humanitarian workers at risk, disrupting the delivery of life-saving assistance, and further constraining the ability of humanitarian organizations to operate at a time when civilians across Gaza continue to face immense and pressing humanitarian conditions.

Direct threats to staff, interference with humanitarian supplies, and the shrinking humanitarian operating space continue to jeopardize operational continuity. At the same time, the expansion of areas under Israeli control is further reducing the space available to civilians, making it imperative that humanitarian assistance is able to move safely and reach people in need without interference.
Under international humanitarian law, all parties must respect and protect humanitarian personnel, facilities and relief supplies, and refrain from actions that obstruct humanitarian operations.

I call for an immediate end to all interference with humanitarian operations and to respect their independence, impartiality and neutrality. Civilians, including humanitarian personnel, must always be protected, and rapid, safe and unimpeded passage of impartial humanitarian relief must be facilitated.

The people of Gaza have already endured immense suffering. They cannot be subjected to further delays or disruptions in the delivery of life-saving assistance. I reiterate that humanitarian organizations must be able to carry out their work safely, independently, impartially and without fear of intimidation or violence.”

unsco.unmissions.org/en/news/statement-by-the-united-nations-deputy-special-coordinator-for-the-middle-east-peace

So. Let. In. The. UN.
Let in journalists.
Let in the WFP - who know how to deal with militias in these situations. Like I just said, experts say these things are normal in famines, wars and natural disasters.
Let in aid.

Not👏doing👏so👏is👏a 👏war👏 crime👏

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 13:44

golosh · 12/11/2026 13:40

So. Let. In. The. UN.
Let in journalists.
Let in the WFP - who know how to deal with militias in these situations. Like I just said, experts say these things are normal in famines, wars and natural disasters.
Let in aid.

Not👏doing👏so👏is👏a 👏war👏 crime👏

Did you even read the statement from the UN Special Co-ordinator?

Can you read that and still say Can't know for sure it's Hamas.

Hamas have committed war crimes, why do you only ever focus on Israel?

It's dishonest to pretend only one side have committed war crimes.

golosh · 12/11/2026 14:53

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 13:44

Did you even read the statement from the UN Special Co-ordinator?

Can you read that and still say Can't know for sure it's Hamas.

Hamas have committed war crimes, why do you only ever focus on Israel?

It's dishonest to pretend only one side have committed war crimes.

Yes. De facto authority, it’s what the UN has been calling it for a while.

It means militia. As I just said, it is something that happens in situations of war, famine, natural disasters. Even the UN say that it’s not necessarily Hamas but just aggressive people trying to steal the food and hoard it. It may be Hamas, it may not, it may be both.

Nonetheless.

If you were able to let in food programmes and assistance, via the UN and WFP, they have protocol and know how to deal with these situations.

If you were to let in journalists to document it it could put international pressure and strengthen Israel’s case, if Israel is indeed telling the truth.

Not letting in aid is a war crime, it is a violation of international humanitarian law and it is against the Geneva convention. Not letting in aid is also giving the ICJ reason to rule genocide by starvation.

https://academic.oup.com/jicj/article/24/3/537/8735944

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 14:58

golosh · 12/11/2026 14:53

Yes. De facto authority, it’s what the UN has been calling it for a while.

It means militia. As I just said, it is something that happens in situations of war, famine, natural disasters. Even the UN say that it’s not necessarily Hamas but just aggressive people trying to steal the food and hoard it. It may be Hamas, it may not, it may be both.

Nonetheless.

If you were able to let in food programmes and assistance, via the UN and WFP, they have protocol and know how to deal with these situations.

If you were to let in journalists to document it it could put international pressure and strengthen Israel’s case, if Israel is indeed telling the truth.

Not letting in aid is a war crime, it is a violation of international humanitarian law and it is against the Geneva convention. Not letting in aid is also giving the ICJ reason to rule genocide by starvation.

https://academic.oup.com/jicj/article/24/3/537/8735944

In the context of Gaza, the "de facto authority" means Hamas.

Why are you ignoring Hamas stealing aid and building materials that they used to build their tunnel network - bigger than the London underground - as just what happens in war?

Why won't you condemn it?

Squeezingwildoranges · 12/11/2026 15:08

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 14:58

In the context of Gaza, the "de facto authority" means Hamas.

Why are you ignoring Hamas stealing aid and building materials that they used to build their tunnel network - bigger than the London underground - as just what happens in war?

Why won't you condemn it?

https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/hamas-aid-theft-no-evidence-analysis-1.7594805

golosh · 12/11/2026 15:11

“Hamas have committed war crimes, why do you only focus on Israel”

@Twiglets1

Because the Palestinians are living in tents, displaced, ethnically cleansed, forced to move out of their homes, killed disproportionately, starved, dying of medical issues that could easily be addressed if you just let aid in, and will very soon be out of Gaza which will likely turn into new settlements and Israel will build a riviera on the thousands of dead bodies buried under the rubble.

Because we bear witness to their suffering, which is far greater than the suffering of the Israelis. Far, far, far greater.

And if it were the other way round, I would be defending the Israelis to the hilt. On October 7th we were all on Israel’s side, what happened was horrific.
But nothing can justify this. 70,000 people. Many more thousands under the rubble.
Disgusting dehumanising things being said by Israeli politicians. Arabs are ‘cockroaches’, ‘vermin’, ‘cancer’.
And yes this can all be said about Hamas. But this is clearly a one sided war, Palestinians are being told they are vermin that need to be exterminated, their living conditions are dire in flooded cold tents, and their suffering is unimaginable.

And yes Hamas have committed war crimes - October 7th was a crime against humanity. But I don’t think equating Hamas with Israeli government is doing your argument any good. You’re basically saying ’treat both the same’

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 15:13

To be clear, are you trying to deny that Hamas steals humanitarian aid and building materials? Despite the testimony of Palestinians to the contrary.

And the statement I linked to earlier:

Statement by the United Nations Deputy Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process, and Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator for the Occupied Palestinian Territory, Dr. Ramiz Alakbarov, on the Situation in Gaza (July 2026)

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 15:16

golosh · 12/11/2026 15:11

“Hamas have committed war crimes, why do you only focus on Israel”

@Twiglets1

Because the Palestinians are living in tents, displaced, ethnically cleansed, forced to move out of their homes, killed disproportionately, starved, dying of medical issues that could easily be addressed if you just let aid in, and will very soon be out of Gaza which will likely turn into new settlements and Israel will build a riviera on the thousands of dead bodies buried under the rubble.

Because we bear witness to their suffering, which is far greater than the suffering of the Israelis. Far, far, far greater.

And if it were the other way round, I would be defending the Israelis to the hilt. On October 7th we were all on Israel’s side, what happened was horrific.
But nothing can justify this. 70,000 people. Many more thousands under the rubble.
Disgusting dehumanising things being said by Israeli politicians. Arabs are ‘cockroaches’, ‘vermin’, ‘cancer’.
And yes this can all be said about Hamas. But this is clearly a one sided war, Palestinians are being told they are vermin that need to be exterminated, their living conditions are dire in flooded cold tents, and their suffering is unimaginable.

And yes Hamas have committed war crimes - October 7th was a crime against humanity. But I don’t think equating Hamas with Israeli government is doing your argument any good. You’re basically saying ’treat both the same’

Because the Palestinians are living in tents is no answer to the question of why do you only focus on Israel.

I'm not saying "treat both the same" by the way. Hamas are worse, in my opinion. They are treating their own people brutally and stealing their aid. At least the Israel government values their own citizen's lives.