Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

Violence against women and girls in Gaza.....

353 replies

mids2019 · 23/09/2026 23:01

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c94gm7dp40y0o

Even if you are in a war torn environment there is no excuse for alarming rates of sexual violence against women in Gaza. I think this highlights the fact that women suffer the most in Islamist governed territories like Gaza where women's rights have been historically removed. Hamas as a government aren't preventing this (weirdly enough) so what can be done. (Maybe a march?)

A file photo showing a Palestinian woman inspecting her damaged home after an Israeli strike on a nearby mosque, in Gaza City (29 July 2026)

Reports of violence against women in Gaza surge, UN agency finds

The UN Population Fund also says there has been a "severe escalation" in the number of early and forced marriages.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c94gm7dp40y0o

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Ellen2shoes · 07/11/2026 21:30

This comment had more to it:
But the real problem there is sexual abuse by men in a “socially conservative society” - a euphemism for a misogynistic society.

If you didn’t ask for the rest to be deleted, I’m assuming mumsnet just took it out, which is odd. Perhaps MNHQ could clarify.

Emilesgran · 07/11/2026 21:47

Ellen2shoes · 07/11/2026 21:30

This comment had more to it:
But the real problem there is sexual abuse by men in a “socially conservative society” - a euphemism for a misogynistic society.

If you didn’t ask for the rest to be deleted, I’m assuming mumsnet just took it out, which is odd. Perhaps MNHQ could clarify.

I’ve just checked my emails and there’s nothing from Mumsnet about that so it seems not.

Anyway you haven’t said what you found so objectionable about it.

Ellen2shoes · 07/11/2026 21:53

I’ll take it up with MNHQ as it’s been removed.

Emilesgran · 07/11/2026 21:54

Ellen2shoes · 07/11/2026 20:28

I see that you must have asked Mumsnet to delete a part of a previous post before this last one, as the worst part embodied exactly what you are accusing other posters of doing and in a way which I believe breached guidelines. Interestingly, mods didn’t think it was a breach. I queried how such a comment should be allowed to stand, and the decision made me back away from the thread. There are no comments remotely like that from those who are sceptical about the sincerity of the motive behind expressions of concerns for women and children in Gaza while being spurious about the facilitation of humanitarian aid. I am glad you deleted it, but it’s a bit rich to then make false accusations against others. @Emilesgran

Edited

Although on your claim that it would be hypocritical of me to edit my post to remove something that was unfair/untrue, and then later on to object another poster who HADN’T edited their post to remove something that was unfair/untrue, I must say that your logic escapes me.

But in fact I don’t think I posted anything of the sort, so I didn’t make any such edits. So if you can’t find it, perhaps you misread/misinderstood?

Emilesgran · 07/11/2026 21:55

Ellen2shoes · 07/11/2026 21:53

I’ll take it up with MNHQ as it’s been removed.

I think MN always send a notification when they remove something, and I’ve received nothing about that post.

And anyway you already said that you complained and MN told you it didn’t break the rules. Do you think they changed their minds?

Ellen2shoes · 07/11/2026 21:56

it wasn’t an edit as was there the next day. As I said, I’ll raise it with mn.

Emilesgran · 07/11/2026 21:58

Ellen2shoes · 07/11/2026 21:56

it wasn’t an edit as was there the next day. As I said, I’ll raise it with mn.

Well if they did edit it, they didn’t tell me. I’ve just checked.

ETA It’s also a bit rich to be complaining about a post that MN told you didnt break any rules. Seems like you want your own rules.

golosh · 08/11/2026 01:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Bringemout · 08/11/2026 06:10

I think culture and the way religion is viewed obviously has an impact, many muslim majority countries have secularish laws but then it comes to personal law suddenly everyone goes full religion. The ja’fari laws which are being discussed in Iraq atm are horrific.

https://www.hrw.org/news/2025/10/15/iraq-new-personal-status-code-makes-women-second-class

You can’t pretend this has nothing to do with religion, countries will choose not to chop off a hand for stealing but will still be fully fine with polygamy or child marriage, or force a child to go with their father at the age of 7 regardless of whether thats a good thing or not. It’s pick and choose what you want as long as the beneficiary is a man.

In Gaza a grown man can marry a 14yr old girl or have a polygamous marriage. Anytime you allow that kind of thing you are making it clear what you think of women.

The translate button on x has been very revealing about what a lot of arab men think their rights are.

A woman holds a sign protesting women being deprived of their rights in marriage in Tahrir Square, Baghdad, Iraq, August 8, 2024.

Iraq: New Personal Status Code Makes Women Second Class

Iraq’s new Ja’afari Personal Status Code, passed by parliament on August 27, discriminates against women by favoring men in matters of marriage, divorce, inheritance, and children’s guardianship and care.

https://www.hrw.org/news/2025/10/15/iraq-new-personal-status-code-makes-women-second-class

Emilesgran · 08/11/2026 07:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

“Islamic or not” 😂
Another openly racist comment.

How on earth is that racist? Islam is not a race for one thing, and my post is all about the fact that male violence is NOT a limited to any one race religion or culture - that’s why it mentions football teams and work problems.

Twiglets1 · 08/11/2026 07:58

Emilesgran · 08/11/2026 07:48

“Islamic or not” 😂
Another openly racist comment.

How on earth is that racist? Islam is not a race for one thing, and my post is all about the fact that male violence is NOT a limited to any one race religion or culture - that’s why it mentions football teams and work problems.

Of course it isn’t.

And if it was racist I hardly think the comment would be met with a laughing emoji. Plus MN would have deleted it as no doubt someone reported it as they have been reporting your other posts disagreed with.

golosh · 08/11/2026 08:09

Twiglets1 · 08/11/2026 07:58

Of course it isn’t.

And if it was racist I hardly think the comment would be met with a laughing emoji. Plus MN would have deleted it as no doubt someone reported it as they have been reporting your other posts disagreed with.

Anything else? still waiting on your thoughts on the rest of what I said.

golosh · 08/11/2026 08:10

Twiglets1 · 08/11/2026 07:58

Of course it isn’t.

And if it was racist I hardly think the comment would be met with a laughing emoji. Plus MN would have deleted it as no doubt someone reported it as they have been reporting your other posts disagreed with.

Anything else? also waiting for you to say something about all the other things I mentioned.

Bringemout · 08/11/2026 08:27

I think the big problem is that when you let religion into laws it doesn’t compel anyone to be an utter bastard but utter bastards will take advantage of it.

Clearly much of the islamic world is still quite fond of the oppression of women bit. Right now on arab twitter saudi women are talking about how they are forced into the niqab whilst saudi men are calling them whores for complaining, Iraqi women are complaining about the ja’afri laws while Iraqi men are calling them whores for complaining, Kuwaiti women have started complaining about a new law which will require them to ask permission from their husbands to travel, no doubt they will soon be told they are whores too.

Women are well aware of the fact that men are taking the piss but when you place religion at the centre of everything all someone has to do is tell you you are going against god if you reject your own oppression. It is an extremely difficult line to tread because regardless of your religion or your religious beliefs you should not be subject to domestic violence or rape, it is impossible if the people above you won’t even recognise your most basic humanity.

There is a difference between someone committing a crime that society sees as criminal (say for example the rape of a prisoner) and institutionalising behaviour which should be considered criminal by any decent right thinking person and making it perfectly legal (like marital rape, also not recognised by many countries including ones that are not muslim majority).

So just to be extremely clear in Gaza you can marry a child and rape her completely legally and she has no recourse in law. Of course that is a cultural value which has its roots in religious rulings. I don’t care about anyones religious feelings btw, calling me names isn’t going to make me give a fuck either, look at the actual laws women are having to live under, lets not pretend that they aren’t oppressed first and foremost in their own homes by their own society.

the saddest thing I read was a girl talking about how she has to wear the niqab and she’s rarely allowed out the house. Her family decided she was allowed to go to “a place of entertainment” (not sure what) and she felt like she was all weird and wrong, like her body didn’t move right, she felt people were staring at her and she was jerky and out of place. This was a girl just going outside her home, fully covered in a country full of other covered women. The sheer psychological damage done to her was profoundly deeply sad and enraging. People are CHOOSING to do this to girls and women. Think she was from Saudi, I think about her all the damn time.

Twiglets1 · 08/11/2026 10:42

golosh · 08/11/2026 08:09

Anything else? still waiting on your thoughts on the rest of what I said.

Jeez I'm not answerable to you especially with that tone.

Emilesgran · 08/11/2026 12:24

Since your post has been removed, it wouldn’t be appropriate to reply to it.

I would point out though that the post to which you were replying has not been removed. It was about the causes of male violence against women, and the fact that terrible living conditions are in no way a justification for male violence. Violent men will always find a reason to take their anger out on women.

IOW while it would be a good thing if living conditions for everyone in Gaza can be improved, the idea that because Gazan men are violent to women, yet more aid should be given to Gaza, is the absolute worst reason possible.

Hamas already steals much of that aid to build up their forces so as to attack Israeli women and children. Why on earth would Israel let more in under those conditions?

Moreover, since Gazan women were often kept inside before the war, how much of the increase in violence is really just down to the fact that it can no longer be kept so well hidden when people are living in tents?

Emilesgran · 08/11/2026 12:25

golosh · 08/11/2026 08:10

Anything else? also waiting for you to say something about all the other things I mentioned.

Since your post has been removed, it wouldn’t be appropriate to reply to it.
I would point out though that the post to which you were replying has not been removed. It was about the causes of male violence against women, and the fact that terrible living conditions are in no way a justification for male violence. Violent men will always find a reason to take their anger out on women.
IOW while it would be a good thing if living conditions for everyone in Gaza can be improved, the idea that because Gazan men are violent to women, yet more aid should be given to Gaza, is the absolute worst reason possible.
Hamas already steals much of that aid to build up their forces so as to attack Israeli women and children. Why on earth would Israel let more in under those conditions?
Moreover, since Gazan women were often kept inside before the war, how much of the increase in violence is really just down to the fact that it can no longer be kept so well hidden when people are living in tents?

golosh · 08/11/2026 14:05

Right so I shall repeat, stating only facts:

Israeli soldiers have committed rape. There has a recorded increase in violent and sexual crimes inside the IDF since the war began. A whistleblower released a video of a gang rape of a Palestinian. One of the gang rapists at Sde Teiman, Meir Ben-Shetrit, appeared on two shows on channel 14 to standing ovations from the audience.

Whistleblowers at Sde Teiman and inside the IDF have spoken of a culture of sexual assault.

My question still stands: why is there no condemnation of this? Why, when this is pointed out on a mn thread, does the post get deleted? whilst blatantly racist comments about Islam and Muslim men get to stay?

golosh · 08/11/2026 14:17

Emilesgran · 08/11/2026 12:25

Since your post has been removed, it wouldn’t be appropriate to reply to it.
I would point out though that the post to which you were replying has not been removed. It was about the causes of male violence against women, and the fact that terrible living conditions are in no way a justification for male violence. Violent men will always find a reason to take their anger out on women.
IOW while it would be a good thing if living conditions for everyone in Gaza can be improved, the idea that because Gazan men are violent to women, yet more aid should be given to Gaza, is the absolute worst reason possible.
Hamas already steals much of that aid to build up their forces so as to attack Israeli women and children. Why on earth would Israel let more in under those conditions?
Moreover, since Gazan women were often kept inside before the war, how much of the increase in violence is really just down to the fact that it can no longer be kept so well hidden when people are living in tents?

No of course not, that’s far too convenient.
I’m sure the women of Palestine are overjoyed by your support.

golosh · 08/11/2026 14:20

Twiglets1 · 08/11/2026 10:42

Jeez I'm not answerable to you especially with that tone.

So no condemnation of rape by Israeli soldiers. Got it.

Twiglets1 · 08/11/2026 14:34

golosh · 08/11/2026 14:20

So no condemnation of rape by Israeli soldiers. Got it.

I’ve condemned rape by Israeli soldiers in the past, naturally I have no problem at all condemning rape whoever commits it.

Have you condemned rape & other violence committed by Palestinian men against Palestinian women & girls? I haven’t seen that from you.

I don’t know what blatantly racist comments you think have been made that aren’t being deleted? Perhaps explain that rather than keep raging about them.

Emilesgran · 08/11/2026 15:28

golosh · 08/11/2026 14:20

So no condemnation of rape by Israeli soldiers. Got it.

How is that relevant ON THIS THREAD?

It’s mere whataboutery.

I don’t think anyone here condones rape or other war crimes by Israeli soldiers, and speaking for myself I’ve said previously that any war crimes should absolutely be severely punished. And I’m sure that there have been such crimes, because I don’t know of a war where there have been no rapes or other crimes - by both sides.

None of that is relevant on here though.

Now, what would be relevant would be for you to explain how you think Israel should provide aid to Palestinian civilians without much of it being taken by Hamas?

Remember that at the height of various shortages during the war, one of the frequent complaints by Gazans was of food and tents etc being sold at prives many times above the pre war costs. That was nearly always stuff that was being given to Gaza in the form of aid - so why was it being sold at all - and who was making a profit from it?

And why did none of the reporters interviewing people who complained about the costs ever ask those questions? Was it too dangerous to ask when the answer was almost certainly “Hamas”?

golosh · 08/11/2026 16:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

golosh · 09/11/2026 12:17

Emilesgran · 08/11/2026 15:28

How is that relevant ON THIS THREAD?

It’s mere whataboutery.

I don’t think anyone here condones rape or other war crimes by Israeli soldiers, and speaking for myself I’ve said previously that any war crimes should absolutely be severely punished. And I’m sure that there have been such crimes, because I don’t know of a war where there have been no rapes or other crimes - by both sides.

None of that is relevant on here though.

Now, what would be relevant would be for you to explain how you think Israel should provide aid to Palestinian civilians without much of it being taken by Hamas?

Remember that at the height of various shortages during the war, one of the frequent complaints by Gazans was of food and tents etc being sold at prives many times above the pre war costs. That was nearly always stuff that was being given to Gaza in the form of aid - so why was it being sold at all - and who was making a profit from it?

And why did none of the reporters interviewing people who complained about the costs ever ask those questions? Was it too dangerous to ask when the answer was almost certainly “Hamas”?

A comment about sexual violence on a thread about sexual violence.

Really unsure about why the following is relevant, I think you have the wrong person. But Israel doesn’t need to provide aid to Palestine. It needs to stop blocking aid from entering. Once it is in, let them do what they want to it. Israel has no need to exert that level of control, its barbaric.

Emilesgran · 09/11/2026 12:30

golosh · 09/11/2026 12:17

A comment about sexual violence on a thread about sexual violence.

Really unsure about why the following is relevant, I think you have the wrong person. But Israel doesn’t need to provide aid to Palestine. It needs to stop blocking aid from entering. Once it is in, let them do what they want to it. Israel has no need to exert that level of control, its barbaric.

People have expressed concern that the six-day truce to get Ukrainian civilians out of Oleshky would allow Russia to rearm, but you think Hamas refilling its coffers using stolen aid should be no concern of Israel? You know that participating in funding a terror organisation, even indirectly, is a crime?

Here are a few of the reasons why anyone who cared about Palestinians would not say what you just said - because they deliberately ensure that ordinary Palestinians have the worst lives possible so as to continue their war to destroy Israel.The first victims of Hamas are Palestinians.

https://x.com/Mr_Andrew_Fox/status/2119559729026306201?a=8hlhoQdhxIJs3IVitlY&s=20

https://x.com/afalkhatib/status/2119661443201040761?a=yP0prQXDSQkaKUvWq-U&s=20

Andrew Fox (@Mr_Andrew_Fox) on X

The speaker is a Muslim cleric in Khan Younes who has broken with Hamas and offers a moment of clarity from a tent in Gaza. Thinking Gazans increasingly recognise that two generations of radicalisation destroyed their own territory, and the only way ou...

https://x.com/Mr_Andrew_Fox/status/2119559729026306201?a=8hlhoQdhxIJs3IVitlY&s=20