Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

Violence against women and girls in Gaza.....

353 replies

mids2019 · 23/09/2026 23:01

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c94gm7dp40y0o

Even if you are in a war torn environment there is no excuse for alarming rates of sexual violence against women in Gaza. I think this highlights the fact that women suffer the most in Islamist governed territories like Gaza where women's rights have been historically removed. Hamas as a government aren't preventing this (weirdly enough) so what can be done. (Maybe a march?)

A file photo showing a Palestinian woman inspecting her damaged home after an Israeli strike on a nearby mosque, in Gaza City (29 July 2026)

Reports of violence against women in Gaza surge, UN agency finds

The UN Population Fund also says there has been a "severe escalation" in the number of early and forced marriages.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c94gm7dp40y0o

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Ellen2shoes · 15/11/2026 09:54

Have you watched NAZA? @Twiglets The film illustrates exactly why NGOs did not want to share their details with Israel.

Without binding legal assurances that this data would remain strictly administrative, aid workers feared their names, phone numbers, and identifying details would be fed directly into the exact intelligence and surveillance databases depicted in the film, making themselves, their families and neighbours vulnerable targets.

The label of "suspected operative" can be loosely applied through automated patterns and MSF and UNRWA for example were subjected to smear campaigns with countless unfounded accusations linking humanitarian workers to militant groups. NAZA exposes how submitting their personal histories and family connections would invite broad, unverified algorithmic flagging—turning routine medical coordination in Gaza into grounds for targeting. By July 2026, Israeli forces had killed more than 1,700 healthcare workers in Gaza.

Regardless, blocking aid is collective punishment, in contravention of international law. It should be non negotiable.

Twiglets1 · 15/11/2026 09:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Everexpanding made the link between Hamas & UNRWA on that thread so maybe take it up with them if you disagree - assuming you know their new username.

Twiglets1 · 15/11/2026 10:04

FacetiousFace · 15/11/2026 08:12

That's a lot of words to say that you agree with Israel blocking aid agencies entering Gaza. It would be better if Israel didn't block them but hey ho if they do. I mean what choice do they have?

It wasn't hard to find btw because I remembered you defending it. Literally Twiglets1 aid agencies blocked into advanced search and there it was 2nd result and you quite literally told me to - if you are going to accuse me of being "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine" then show some evidence.

I post a whole thread and am then accused of a personal attack and trying to discredit you? Did you want evidence or not because it seemed very much like you did. You say yourself I've said over and over again that I support more humanitarian aid coming into Gaza and have criticised Israel whenever they have blocked it. Apart from this one time when I said I could understand why Israel would block the NGOs who wouldn't comply with the new rules, on security grounds.

So you admit that 'this one time' you were actually 'understanding' of Israel blocking aid agencies from entering Gaza exactly what I said you did because I remembered your endless understanding on that thread. That's not a personal attack, that's not discrediting you, that not being uncivil. I didn't call you any names for your views, I havent made judgements on you for your views just simply repeated them back to you.

But I don’t agree with Israel blocking aid agencies. Only in the very specific case highlighted in that thread. Is it really surprising that Israel would have a problem with NGO employees who deny the Holocaust or the fact that Hamas attacked Israel on 7/10/23.

No it isn’t surprising. I can understand it. That does not mean that I agree with Israel blocking aid agencies generally, I don’t.

FacetiousFace · 15/11/2026 10:23

Twiglets1 · 15/11/2026 10:04

But I don’t agree with Israel blocking aid agencies. Only in the very specific case highlighted in that thread. Is it really surprising that Israel would have a problem with NGO employees who deny the Holocaust or the fact that Hamas attacked Israel on 7/10/23.

No it isn’t surprising. I can understand it. That does not mean that I agree with Israel blocking aid agencies generally, I don’t.

You asked for evidence that you were "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine" and seemed very offended that I remembered what you had said. I provided evidence and you agree that this one time I said I could understand why Israel would block the NGOs.

When you first denied doing it, I didn't push you further on the issue. You decided to push it further calling my post 'extremely offensive' and 'horribly insulting'. So I decided to defend myself, you asked for evidence, I provided it, then you agreed that in the case of the 35 NGOs being blocked you did indeed 'understand' Israel blocking them. That's it really, there isn't really anything else to say on the matter as far as I'm concerned.

golosh · 15/11/2026 10:48

Twiglets1 · 15/11/2026 09:58

Everexpanding made the link between Hamas & UNRWA on that thread so maybe take it up with them if you disagree - assuming you know their new username.

Twiglet what do you think you are implying when you say aid can’t enter because of ‘security reasons, including support for Hamas’.

Twiglets1 · 15/11/2026 11:10

FacetiousFace · 15/11/2026 10:23

You asked for evidence that you were "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine" and seemed very offended that I remembered what you had said. I provided evidence and you agree that this one time I said I could understand why Israel would block the NGOs.

When you first denied doing it, I didn't push you further on the issue. You decided to push it further calling my post 'extremely offensive' and 'horribly insulting'. So I decided to defend myself, you asked for evidence, I provided it, then you agreed that in the case of the 35 NGOs being blocked you did indeed 'understand' Israel blocking them. That's it really, there isn't really anything else to say on the matter as far as I'm concerned.

I do find your post extremely offensive yes as you "seemed to remember" that I am on board with Israel blocking aid, which I am not. Sorry to the person who had to trawl through dozens of posts of me saying I'm against the withholding of humanitarian aid in order to find the one thread where I was talking about specific NGOs - not all NGOs by any stretch of the imagination -and saying that I feel Israel had a point about blocking workers who have expressed such hatred towards them that they have denied the Holocaust for example.

In the very specific example of these particular NGOs, I find it reasonable that Israel wanted the basic staff details they were unwilling to provide. They made the choice not to provide the details and hence not to be able to carry on providing humanitarian aid. If they had complied (as all the other NGOs did) - the issue would not have arisen.

Agree there isn't anything else to say and if you feel you scored a point - yay for you. It doesn't help anyone in Gaza. Reading that old thread has just reminded me that while the usernames change, the emphasis on personal attacks rather than discussing the thread topic hasn't.

I'm all out of patience now so I'll leave you all to it. Try to remember what the thread is supposed to be about.

Emilesgran · 15/11/2026 11:38

FacetiousFace · 15/11/2026 10:23

You asked for evidence that you were "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine" and seemed very offended that I remembered what you had said. I provided evidence and you agree that this one time I said I could understand why Israel would block the NGOs.

When you first denied doing it, I didn't push you further on the issue. You decided to push it further calling my post 'extremely offensive' and 'horribly insulting'. So I decided to defend myself, you asked for evidence, I provided it, then you agreed that in the case of the 35 NGOs being blocked you did indeed 'understand' Israel blocking them. That's it really, there isn't really anything else to say on the matter as far as I'm concerned.

So you’re ignoring the fact that a number of NGOs were allowed to enter and of those that weren’t, it was because the Israelis said they have evidence that some of their aid was being given to/stolen by Hamas, potentially with complicity from employees of those NGOs?

IOW it’s absolutely not true that Israel is blocking aid so as to starve Palestinians but is instead trying to ensure that only NGOs which are capable of ensuring that their aid gets to civilians and NOT to Hamas get to bring stuff into Gaza.

And what exactly is wrong with that?

avd17 · 15/11/2026 12:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

That thread is from long before you started posting on Mumsnet. Do you usually spend your weekends combing though old threads hoping for a gotcha?

FacetiousFace · 15/11/2026 12:12

Emilesgran · 15/11/2026 11:38

So you’re ignoring the fact that a number of NGOs were allowed to enter and of those that weren’t, it was because the Israelis said they have evidence that some of their aid was being given to/stolen by Hamas, potentially with complicity from employees of those NGOs?

IOW it’s absolutely not true that Israel is blocking aid so as to starve Palestinians but is instead trying to ensure that only NGOs which are capable of ensuring that their aid gets to civilians and NOT to Hamas get to bring stuff into Gaza.

And what exactly is wrong with that?

Edited

Twiglets demanded evidence that she was on board with Israel blocking aid organisations from Palestine. I linked to a thread where she was on board with 35 aid agencies being blocked as she asked for and have been accused of point scoring and personal attacks for my trouble. I have passed no judgements about her being on board with it, I have called her no names for it, I didn't even say that there was anything 'wrong with it'. It was Twiglets who said it was horrendous and extremely offensive to say that someone was on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from entering Palestine so perhaps take it with her and ask her what's wrong with it. I'm over it.

Emilesgran · 15/11/2026 12:24

FacetiousFace · 15/11/2026 12:12

Twiglets demanded evidence that she was on board with Israel blocking aid organisations from Palestine. I linked to a thread where she was on board with 35 aid agencies being blocked as she asked for and have been accused of point scoring and personal attacks for my trouble. I have passed no judgements about her being on board with it, I have called her no names for it, I didn't even say that there was anything 'wrong with it'. It was Twiglets who said it was horrendous and extremely offensive to say that someone was on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from entering Palestine so perhaps take it with her and ask her what's wrong with it. I'm over it.

But she isn’t - not on the way you presented it. I mean it’s like saying someone who wants adults working with children to be properly vetted is “against adults working with children”.

No honest person would make such a sweeping claim.

So why is it ok to say it about aid when there is so much evidence that Hamas has been taking the aid, and that in some cases employees of some NGOs are complicit?

golosh · 15/11/2026 15:36

Emilesgran · 15/11/2026 12:24

But she isn’t - not on the way you presented it. I mean it’s like saying someone who wants adults working with children to be properly vetted is “against adults working with children”.

No honest person would make such a sweeping claim.

So why is it ok to say it about aid when there is so much evidence that Hamas has been taking the aid, and that in some cases employees of some NGOs are complicit?

she asked for evidence on something and was then given it. The minutiae of this whole conversation has been picked apart at the expense of actually discussing the issue at hand.

The impression this gives is that this is less about women in gaza and more about how Israel is ‘blamed for everything’ - such a disingenuous statement when Israel has acted in the way it has.

Twiglets1 · 16/11/2026 07:18

golosh · 15/11/2026 15:36

she asked for evidence on something and was then given it. The minutiae of this whole conversation has been picked apart at the expense of actually discussing the issue at hand.

The impression this gives is that this is less about women in gaza and more about how Israel is ‘blamed for everything’ - such a disingenuous statement when Israel has acted in the way it has.

The minutiae of this whole conversation has been picked apart at the expense of actually discussing the issue at hand.

Yes it has and for that you can blame the person who trawled through dozens of my posts to find the one exception where I could understand Israel blocking some NGOs, who were providing less than 1% of the aid.

Understanding why Israel would block staff WHO DENY THE HOLOCAUST! WHO DENY HAMAS ATTACKED ISRAEL! is NOT the same as providing evidence of me saying I'm ok with Israel blocking humanitarian aid WHICH I AM NOT, AND HAVE SAID I'M NOT ACROSS MULTIPLE THREADS.

Does it need spelling out any more? I'm against Israel blocking aid agencies apart from the ones who won't allow vetting of their employees to exclude antisemites who deny the Holocaust or that Hamas attacked Israel or other shit like that...

Move on for God's sake. If you want to discuss the issue at hand rather than piling in on me, discuss the issue at hand.

Emilesgran · 16/11/2026 10:35

golosh · 15/11/2026 15:36

she asked for evidence on something and was then given it. The minutiae of this whole conversation has been picked apart at the expense of actually discussing the issue at hand.

The impression this gives is that this is less about women in gaza and more about how Israel is ‘blamed for everything’ - such a disingenuous statement when Israel has acted in the way it has.

But as I said, the “evidence” was not evidence of the sweeping claim that had been made. It’s a misrepresentation to say it is.

golosh · 16/11/2026 10:38

Twiglets1 · 16/11/2026 07:18

The minutiae of this whole conversation has been picked apart at the expense of actually discussing the issue at hand.

Yes it has and for that you can blame the person who trawled through dozens of my posts to find the one exception where I could understand Israel blocking some NGOs, who were providing less than 1% of the aid.

Understanding why Israel would block staff WHO DENY THE HOLOCAUST! WHO DENY HAMAS ATTACKED ISRAEL! is NOT the same as providing evidence of me saying I'm ok with Israel blocking humanitarian aid WHICH I AM NOT, AND HAVE SAID I'M NOT ACROSS MULTIPLE THREADS.

Does it need spelling out any more? I'm against Israel blocking aid agencies apart from the ones who won't allow vetting of their employees to exclude antisemites who deny the Holocaust or that Hamas attacked Israel or other shit like that...

Move on for God's sake. If you want to discuss the issue at hand rather than piling in on me, discuss the issue at hand.

There are so many holes in your argument I don’t even know where to begin 🤦‍♀️

Twiglets1 · 16/11/2026 10:41

golosh · 16/11/2026 10:38

There are so many holes in your argument I don’t even know where to begin 🤦‍♀️

Then move on because you're the one complaining this argument is "at the expense of actually discussing the issue at hand."

golosh · 16/11/2026 15:27

Twiglets1 · 16/11/2026 10:41

Then move on because you're the one complaining this argument is "at the expense of actually discussing the issue at hand."

Yeh I’m spent. There’s only so much you can show people the facts. If they choose to deny the facts, listen to propaganda, and find themselves surprised they are in a minority opinion - where the majority of the countries of the world disagree - then there’s no helping them.

Twiglets1 · 16/11/2026 18:38

golosh · 16/11/2026 15:27

Yeh I’m spent. There’s only so much you can show people the facts. If they choose to deny the facts, listen to propaganda, and find themselves surprised they are in a minority opinion - where the majority of the countries of the world disagree - then there’s no helping them.

Probably just as well you're spent as you've had 5 posts deleted already on this thread.

Twiglets1 · Yesterday 14:53

FacetiousFace · 15/11/2026 08:12

That's a lot of words to say that you agree with Israel blocking aid agencies entering Gaza. It would be better if Israel didn't block them but hey ho if they do. I mean what choice do they have?

It wasn't hard to find btw because I remembered you defending it. Literally Twiglets1 aid agencies blocked into advanced search and there it was 2nd result and you quite literally told me to - if you are going to accuse me of being "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine" then show some evidence.

I post a whole thread and am then accused of a personal attack and trying to discredit you? Did you want evidence or not because it seemed very much like you did. You say yourself I've said over and over again that I support more humanitarian aid coming into Gaza and have criticised Israel whenever they have blocked it. Apart from this one time when I said I could understand why Israel would block the NGOs who wouldn't comply with the new rules, on security grounds.

So you admit that 'this one time' you were actually 'understanding' of Israel blocking aid agencies from entering Gaza exactly what I said you did because I remembered your endless understanding on that thread. That's not a personal attack, that's not discrediting you, that not being uncivil. I didn't call you any names for your views, I havent made judgements on you for your views just simply repeated them back to you.

That's a lot of words to say that you agree with Israel blocking aid agencies entering Gaza.

No that's a false representation of my opinion on humanitarian aid.

Even on this very thread (page 8), I said "I do expect Israel to provide humanitarian aid and am disappointed when I hear it being limited".

And in a conversation with Golosh I said "Isn't genocide inconsistent with allowing humanitarian aid into a country? Yet strangely there has been a lot that has entered Gaza (not enough, we can agree on that)" .

I said that I expect Israel to provide humanitarian aid, am disappointed when I hear it is being limited, and that not enough humanitarian aid is getting into Gaza. That is my position, said on this very thread, before your accusation.

FacetiousFace · Yesterday 16:26

Twiglets1 · Yesterday 14:53

That's a lot of words to say that you agree with Israel blocking aid agencies entering Gaza.

No that's a false representation of my opinion on humanitarian aid.

Even on this very thread (page 8), I said "I do expect Israel to provide humanitarian aid and am disappointed when I hear it being limited".

And in a conversation with Golosh I said "Isn't genocide inconsistent with allowing humanitarian aid into a country? Yet strangely there has been a lot that has entered Gaza (not enough, we can agree on that)" .

I said that I expect Israel to provide humanitarian aid, am disappointed when I hear it is being limited, and that not enough humanitarian aid is getting into Gaza. That is my position, said on this very thread, before your accusation.

I haven't posted on this thread in 3 days and someone got my post where I linked to the thread as you demanded me to do, where you were voraciously defending Israel blocking 35 aid agencies from entering Gaza deleted, like I said 3 days ago I'm over it so there is no need to continue tagging me.

Twiglets1 · Yesterday 16:40

FacetiousFace · Yesterday 16:26

I haven't posted on this thread in 3 days and someone got my post where I linked to the thread as you demanded me to do, where you were voraciously defending Israel blocking 35 aid agencies from entering Gaza deleted, like I said 3 days ago I'm over it so there is no need to continue tagging me.

Ok if you wish me to stop tagging you I will respect that going forward.

I just request in return that you stop implying on threads that I am against humanitarian aid getting into Gaza (unless you are going to reference the context of those particular NGOs on that one thread where I said I could understand Israel's position).

Because in fact I have been crystal clear on this thread (& multiple others) that I expect Israel to provide humanitarian aid, am disappointed when I hear it is being limited, and hold the opinion that not enough aid is getting into Gaza.

FacetiousFace · Yesterday 16:52

Twiglets1 · Yesterday 16:40

Ok if you wish me to stop tagging you I will respect that going forward.

I just request in return that you stop implying on threads that I am against humanitarian aid getting into Gaza (unless you are going to reference the context of those particular NGOs on that one thread where I said I could understand Israel's position).

Because in fact I have been crystal clear on this thread (& multiple others) that I expect Israel to provide humanitarian aid, am disappointed when I hear it is being limited, and hold the opinion that not enough aid is getting into Gaza.

I don't really see I just request in return that you stop implying on threads that I am against humanitarian aid getting into Gaza

Sigh. I didn't say this. My post said that you were on board with aid agencies being blocked from Gaza. You were in fact on board with 35 aid agencies being blocked from Gaza, we both agree with that. If you think that you were on board with aid agencies being blocked from Gaza means something other than what I clearly said then I can't help that but no lies were spoken.

Twiglets1 · Yesterday 17:00

FacetiousFace · Yesterday 16:52

I don't really see I just request in return that you stop implying on threads that I am against humanitarian aid getting into Gaza

Sigh. I didn't say this. My post said that you were on board with aid agencies being blocked from Gaza. You were in fact on board with 35 aid agencies being blocked from Gaza, we both agree with that. If you think that you were on board with aid agencies being blocked from Gaza means something other than what I clearly said then I can't help that but no lies were spoken.

How can I stop tagging you if you keep misrepresenting my views?

You said you "seemed to remember I was on board with aid agencies being blocked from Gaza" as if that was all aid agencies. You did not say I remember on that one thread you defended Israel blocking specific aid agencies that refused to supply basic details of staff, because they didn't want staff coming in who have antisemitic views about the Holocaust or the right of Israel to exist.

If you remembered a thread from ages ago, surely you also remembered what I said on this thread about wanting and expecting Israel to allow more humanitarian aid to get into Gaza?

FacetiousFace · Yesterday 17:50

Twiglets1 · Yesterday 17:00

How can I stop tagging you if you keep misrepresenting my views?

You said you "seemed to remember I was on board with aid agencies being blocked from Gaza" as if that was all aid agencies. You did not say I remember on that one thread you defended Israel blocking specific aid agencies that refused to supply basic details of staff, because they didn't want staff coming in who have antisemitic views about the Holocaust or the right of Israel to exist.

If you remembered a thread from ages ago, surely you also remembered what I said on this thread about wanting and expecting Israel to allow more humanitarian aid to get into Gaza?

I did remember and I linked to the thread as you demanded. That post was deleted. I'm not misrepresenting anything you were on board with 35 aid agencies being blocked from Gaza exactly as I said, I'm not sure why there is a need to go around in circles.

If you feel that you need to add caveats to that then go ahead but the accusations of misrepresentation, of point scoring, of me personally attacking you because I remembered you defending Isreal blocking aid agencies from entering Palestine are completely unnecessary. You can add your caveats without tagging me, without casting aspersions etc

I remember you being up for the GHFs food distribution hubs being created so I know that you aren't against all aid being delivered to Gaza but you did defend aid agencies being blocked from Gaza as I said.

Twiglets1 · Yesterday 18:01

FacetiousFace · Yesterday 17:50

I did remember and I linked to the thread as you demanded. That post was deleted. I'm not misrepresenting anything you were on board with 35 aid agencies being blocked from Gaza exactly as I said, I'm not sure why there is a need to go around in circles.

If you feel that you need to add caveats to that then go ahead but the accusations of misrepresentation, of point scoring, of me personally attacking you because I remembered you defending Isreal blocking aid agencies from entering Palestine are completely unnecessary. You can add your caveats without tagging me, without casting aspersions etc

I remember you being up for the GHFs food distribution hubs being created so I know that you aren't against all aid being delivered to Gaza but you did defend aid agencies being blocked from Gaza as I said.

I'm not against any aid being delivered to Gaza, I want the people living there to get all the aid they can.

Saying I can understand why Israel would ban certain aid agencies is not to say I am against aid being delivered at all. The aid could be delivered by other agencies as it largely was. Or some of the agencies who initially refused to comply with Israel's demands did comply eventually so they were able to work in Gaza again.