Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

(Lack of) US Iran Peace Agreement Part 5

946 replies

OnePeppyFatball · 14/09/2026 10:37

Part 5

OP posts:
Thread gallery
131
RedTagAlan · 09/11/2026 06:04

trumpredcard · 09/11/2026 05:24

Maintain the war against Iran to eliminate a nuclear capacity that Iran may or may not have vs endanger the world's food by making it impossible for Iran to produce fertiliser that the world needs.
Why is no one talking about fertiliser and next year's crop yield?

Is it Iran that make the fertilizer ? I thought it was the other gulf states?

RedTagAlan · 09/11/2026 06:06

trumpredcard · 09/11/2026 05:37

A demonstration of the beneficial power of democracy

The Mid-term results are no guarantee that Trump, Kegsbreath and Miller won't decide to use the US military capability to resume the war as a last throw of the dice.
Affordability was the number one reason for voting blue.
(The war in Iran is vastly unpopular too.)

I think it does show the power of the vote against policy.

OnePeppyFatball · 09/11/2026 08:11

Torygraph:

“Israel has said it is “not done with Iran”, as a fragile truce between the two countries hangs in the balance.
Speaking at a ceremony for Israeli troops on Sunday, Israel Katz, the Israeli defence minister, said: “With regard to Iran, the mission is still not complete.
“Iran is trying to renew its efforts to obtain nuclear weapons, alongside other grave efforts that place the state of Israel in real danger.”
Tehran has repeatedly denied that it is developing nuclear weapons, despite accusations by the US and Israel.
Donald Trump claimed Iran’s nuclear facilities were “completely and totally obliterated” in June after the US-Israeli bombing campaign, and has repeatedly said that “Iran will never have a nuclear weapon”.
However, he has hinted that he is considering another attack on an Iranian nuclear facility, amid reports that Iran is bracing for strikes.”

Excerpt From
“‘We’re not done with Iran’, warns Israel”
Emily Smith
The Telegraph
https://apple.news/ATzeNUmTBRVunP7cl9idAMg
This material may be protected by copyright.

Pickaxe Mountain nuclear strike and Trump’s other Iran war options — The Telegraph

Analysts believe the risk of nuclear Armageddon may be a step too far, even for this US administration

https://apple.news/Pg5Px8jdjQpTCxQRp-xPSBG

OP posts:
trumpredcard · 09/11/2026 12:10

RedTagAlan · 09/11/2026 06:04

Is it Iran that make the fertilizer ? I thought it was the other gulf states?

https://iran-exp.com/the-role-of-iranian-urea-and-ammonia-in-global-fertilizer-supply/

Natural gas is the primary feedstock for ammonia production, which is then converted into urea. Iran holds the second-largest natural gas reserves in the world, giving it a significant cost advantage in producing nitrogen-based fertilizers.

The Role of Iranian Urea and Ammonia in Global Fertilizer Supply

Iran’s Role in the Global Supply of Urea and Ammonia Fertilizers Explore Iran’s role in global urea and ammonia supply, its advantages, markets, and future outlook in the international fertilizer industry.IntroductionAs the global population continues...

https://iran-exp.com/the-role-of-iranian-urea-and-ammonia-in-global-fertilizer-supply

Newbutoldfather · 09/11/2026 12:23

Pickaxe mountain is the big deal here.

Has Iran moved enough people and equipment and Uranium to start making a bomb? If so, how close are they?

And, if the above is true, it does seem that the only way of penetrating it is with a bunker-busting nuke. Or a temporary invasion, where Pickaxe mountain is held until the tunnel network is destroyed and/or the uranium removed.

It becomes a tough choice. Let Iran become a nuclear power, the U.S uses a nuke (or invades) or Israel uses a nuke (no one knows whether they have bunker-busting nukes) or invades.

None of the above are appetising to anyone bar Netanyahu and power is fast seeping away from him.

I think the outcome is very foggy indeed.

RedTagAlan · 09/11/2026 13:30

Newbutoldfather · 09/11/2026 12:23

Pickaxe mountain is the big deal here.

Has Iran moved enough people and equipment and Uranium to start making a bomb? If so, how close are they?

And, if the above is true, it does seem that the only way of penetrating it is with a bunker-busting nuke. Or a temporary invasion, where Pickaxe mountain is held until the tunnel network is destroyed and/or the uranium removed.

It becomes a tough choice. Let Iran become a nuclear power, the U.S uses a nuke (or invades) or Israel uses a nuke (no one knows whether they have bunker-busting nukes) or invades.

None of the above are appetising to anyone bar Netanyahu and power is fast seeping away from him.

I think the outcome is very foggy indeed.

Lets not forget Iran is the size of Western Europe and has 90 million people. It has industry, engineers and scientists.

If they really want a nuke, they could make one. Same as DPRK done. And I just looked something up, they have Uranium mines. Low grade ore it seems, but they can do the whole thing.

I also just looked up if they smelt Aluminium. Yup. Half million tonnes a year. They have all they need. No need to import the materials to make the machines to make the bombs. They are in the worlds top ten steel producers in the world. They are an industrial nation.

Eventually they need to talk to each other.

Edit to add. Just been looking up what Iran make. They make it all, thanks to decades of sanctions. Want a CNC lathe or mill, or a multi axis machining center? They make them.

They claimed their first jet engine in 2018. If true, then it's worth remembering not many nations can do that.

trumpredcard · 09/11/2026 14:14

Let Iran become a nuclear power

How convenient, promoting this argument has become for Trump.

RedTagAlan · 09/11/2026 15:41

trumpredcard · 09/11/2026 14:14

Let Iran become a nuclear power

How convenient, promoting this argument has become for Trump.

Keep saying something often enough, and all that.

It keeps coming back to the JCPOA. That was done and dusted, and working. And really, that is all that needs to be done, and indeed can be done. Don't comply, then snapback on sactions relief. No escallation needed till a device is tested, if ever. Because that can't be hidden.

trumpredcard · 09/11/2026 16:45

It must be my age, because when I think of the entire Iran war debacle what comes to mind is the suffering, waste of human life and resources. And for what?

RedTagAlan · 09/11/2026 17:11

trumpredcard · 09/11/2026 16:45

It must be my age, because when I think of the entire Iran war debacle what comes to mind is the suffering, waste of human life and resources. And for what?

It's a brutal authoritarian theocratic regime that kills protestors.

And no, I am not going to reverse that and say that is Trump.That would insult the dead Iranians. But I do think if he had stuck to maximum pressure over that instead of going to nukes, he could have gotten more genuine support. But it was never about the dead protestors. He dumped that. And I suspect that was because of the CIA, and the part it played in the protests.

Opereration Iran Liberation.

trumpredcard · 09/11/2026 17:57

It's a brutal authoritarian theocratic regime that kills protestors.

This is not disputed. Even the wrong sort of sm post, or making a podcast while not wearing a head covering has resulted in brutal repercussions.
But the hard underlying question is still:
What authority does the US have to dictate another country's religious/political system?
I would listen to a podcast where experts debate this.

trumpredcard · 10/11/2026 06:28

Trump now says an attack on Iran is highly unlikely.
On Monday, Mr Trump told reporters he believes the war "militarily is effectively over" after meeting with Qatar's prime minister earlier in the day, where the two leaders discussed the US naval blockade in the Strait of Hormuz.
"Iran militarily is effectively over," Mr Trump said. "We're just keeping it the status quo."
https://news.sky.com/story/positive-momentum-towards-end-to-iran-war-trump-says-13610128

All US bombers moved after an alleged Iranian threat to RAF Base in Fairford hosting US airforce
Whitehall officials have confirmed that in relation to the threats they are currently dealing with "there is an ongoing high tempo of threat from Iran to the UK, and it's logical that US airbases would be pretty high on any targeting list".
They have also not disputed the decision from Washington was in response to the incident at the airbase in Gloucestershire.
The BBC has also been told it was a military rather than a political decision - taken at an operational level - and communicated from the US military to its British counterparts.
BBC

Newbutoldfather · 10/11/2026 08:04

Trump always talks out of both sides of his mouth, depending on the audience, depending on the day….

If the U.S has lost the will to attack, which is possible, given the election results, where does that leave Israel? Netanyahu recently stated that Israel had not finished with Iran.

RedTagAlan · 10/11/2026 12:24

Newbutoldfather · 10/11/2026 08:04

Trump always talks out of both sides of his mouth, depending on the audience, depending on the day….

If the U.S has lost the will to attack, which is possible, given the election results, where does that leave Israel? Netanyahu recently stated that Israel had not finished with Iran.

It leaves them on it's own ?

And Netanyahu is in trouble too with elections there.

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 13:16

Eisenkot has been given the first opportunity to try to build a new coalition government in Israel so - if he is successful - that could change Israel's position re the Iran war.

Eisenkot could form a coalition that includes the United Arab List (Ra'am), which has indicated it is willing to form part of an Eisenkot-led coalition.

United Arab List (Ra’am) leader Mansour Abbas said Tuesday that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s bloc will soon move into the opposition, expressing a desire to join a government coalition led by Gadi Eisenkot, according to Israeli media.

Speaking during a Ra’am faction meeting ahead of the swearing-in of Israel’s 26th Knesset, Abbas said his party will continue working to replace Netanyahu’s government and “aspires to be part of the coalition and the next government,” the daily Israel Hayom said.

https://www.aa.com.tr/en/middle-east/united-arab-list-leader-says-netanyahu-bloc-heading-to-opposition-seeks-role-in-eisenkot-led-coalition/4118902

United Arab List leader says Netanyahu bloc heading to opposition, seeks role in Eisenkot-led coalition

United Arab List leader says Netanyahu bloc heading to opposition, seeks role in Eisenkot-led coalition

Mansour Abbas says participation in government is ‘fundamental civil right’ | Anadolu

https://www.aa.com.tr/en/middle-east/united-arab-list-leader-says-netanyahu-bloc-heading-to-opposition-seeks-role-in-eisenkot-led-coalition/4118902

trumpredcard · 10/11/2026 15:16

out of date/link in pp.

Scotland??

Several US military aircraft were evacuated from RAF Mildenhall in Suffolk on Monday, after the US Air Force concluded they could be at risk from a possible Iranian threat if they remained at the British base.
Ten air tankers were relocated to bases in Germany, Spain and Scotland, while Osprey transport aircraft were sent to nearby RAF Lakenheath. It is the second time the US has undertaken a hasty redeployment in the UK with some of its bombers pulled from RAF Fairford in October.
The latest incident was said to be in response to a threat from Iran, according to the Wall Street Journal, although British sources emphasised there was no immediate or direct danger to the base or the area nearby.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/nov/10/us-reportedly-evacuated-aircraft-from-raf-mildenhall-over-iran-threat

RedTagAlan · 10/11/2026 15:43

trumpredcard · 10/11/2026 15:16

out of date/link in pp.

Scotland??

Several US military aircraft were evacuated from RAF Mildenhall in Suffolk on Monday, after the US Air Force concluded they could be at risk from a possible Iranian threat if they remained at the British base.
Ten air tankers were relocated to bases in Germany, Spain and Scotland, while Osprey transport aircraft were sent to nearby RAF Lakenheath. It is the second time the US has undertaken a hasty redeployment in the UK with some of its bombers pulled from RAF Fairford in October.
The latest incident was said to be in response to a threat from Iran, according to the Wall Street Journal, although British sources emphasised there was no immediate or direct danger to the base or the area nearby.

www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/nov/10/us-reportedly-evacuated-aircraft-from-raf-mildenhall-over-iran-threat

Prestwick. The RAF have something there. And close to a Trump golf course. Remember the scandal in his first term when he redirected flight military flights there and said the crew should use his course Hotel ?

AMC Review Finds No Wrongdoing in Stays at Trump Resort, Scotland Stops | Air & Space Forces Magazine (airandspaceforces.com)

The US military use Prestwick a lot.

I thought it was only the bad guys who done this duel use thing.

AMC Review Finds No Wrongdoing in Stays at Trump Resort, Scotland Stops | Air & Space Forces Magazine

Audio of this article is brought to you by the Air & Space Forces Association, honoring and supporting our Airmen, Guardians, and their families. Find out more at afa.orgThe House Committee on Oversight and Reform is investigating the Air Force...

https://www.airandspaceforces.com/amc-review-finds-no-wrongdoing-in-stays-at-trump-resort-scotland-stops/

trumpredcard · 10/11/2026 19:37

Where's the baby Trump in his diapers blimp when you need it? I'm waiting for the protests to begin.

A US Airforce refuelling tanker has landed in South Ayrshireafter it was moved from RAF Mildenhall following an unspecified threat.
An RAF Voyager was also seen landing at Prestwick Airport shortly after the USAF plane touched down on Tuesday afternoon
AOL

TopPocketFind · 10/11/2026 19:48

A senior US soldier arrested by UK counter-terror police.

The 41-year-old man was arrested near Gloucester on Tuesday, on suspicion of offences under the National Security Act, the Metropolitan Police said.

The force said the allegations related to Russia. The FBI said the arrest involves allegations of espionage.

RedTagAlan · 10/11/2026 19:50

trumpredcard · 10/11/2026 19:37

Where's the baby Trump in his diapers blimp when you need it? I'm waiting for the protests to begin.

A US Airforce refuelling tanker has landed in South Ayrshireafter it was moved from RAF Mildenhall following an unspecified threat.
An RAF Voyager was also seen landing at Prestwick Airport shortly after the USAF plane touched down on Tuesday afternoon
AOL

There is a famous protest photo from Turnberry.

"Trump is a c**t". But banned for me, so can't link it.

Also this:

'Trump is a c*' sprayed on his beloved £200,000,000 Trump Turnberry Golf Club | News UK | Metro News

Trump's prized £200,000,000 UK golf club wrecked by protestors

'F*** Trump' and 'Free Gaza' was also sprayed on the luxury estate

https://metro.co.uk/2025/03/08/trump-a-c-sprayed-beloved-200-000-000-uk-golf-club-22693323/

Twiglets1 · 11/11/2026 07:24

Washington backs economic pressure

Following a meeting with Qatar’s prime minister on Monday, President Donald Trump said several Arab governments favored keeping the present arrangements in place.

“Qatar, Saudi Arabia, UAE, Bahrain, Kuwait, and others, would prefer the status quo,” Trump wrote on Truth Social, describing that arrangement as the continuation of the US naval blockade and Operation Iron Gate, an initiative targeting weapons shipments and other illicit flows across Iran’s land borders and the Caspian Sea.

Secretary of State Marco Rubio made the economic argument more explicitly on Tuesday.

“The economic pain that is being inflicted on Iran right now is extraordinary, and it compounds. It’s growing every day,” Rubio told reporters in Paris.

“We don’t need to conduct military strikes if we’re achieving the same objective through economic means and economic pressure,” he added.

The economic campaign combines the naval blockade with sanctions against Iranian financial institutions, oil exports and businesses involved in sanctions evasion.

https://www.iranintl.com/en/202611102352

An Iranian man looks at a butcher shop window in Tehran, Iran, October 27, 2026.

Iran faces economic attrition under US blockade, economist warns

A prolonged confrontation with Washington risks eroding Iran’s economy and impoverishing its people even without a sudden collapse, an Iranian economist warned, as Washington appears intent on maintaining economic pressure without renewed major combat...

https://www.iranintl.com/en/202611102352

trumpredcard · 11/11/2026 08:48

After Tuesday's hit on a tanker, UKMTO reported another today.

UKMTO has received a report of an incident involving a tanker in the Strait of Hormuz. The status of crew, damage assessment, and environmental impact are unknown at the time of this report. Vessels are advised to transit with caution and report any suspicious activity to UKMTO, whilst authorities investigate.

A few other incidents were reported yesterday. An Emirati ship was attacked and damaged in UAE territorial waters. Separately, an attack on a Liberia-flagged oil tanker in the Gulf injured four crew members, including an Indian national, India's Ports and Shipping Minister said. Another tanker reported being struck by an unknown projectile about 35km north-east of Lima in Oman, UKMTO said. The Bigger picture:Iran has claimed a series of attacks on vessels in the Strait of Hormuzand off the coasts of Oman and the UAE, often blaming operators for hitting sea mines.*

Meanwhile Rubio told G7 allies that their naval blockade are working “so well” ...

but Oil prices rose on Wednesday from the previous session's two-month lows, as the market swung between hopes for a de-escalation in the Iran war and concerns about attacks on shipping in the Strait of Hormuz. Brent futures climbed $1.04, or 1.1 per cent, to $92.53 a barrel at 8:20am UAE time. US West Texas Intermediate crude rose 67 cents, or 0.8 per cent, to $86.71
(ME Today)

*handy Sea mines - which may, or may not exist...

Twiglets1 · 11/11/2026 09:05

Feels like stalemate.

Both sides enduring some economic pain (Iran more so) but both sides can withstand it, for now anyway.

Surely a peace deal is on the cards before too much longer?

Newbutoldfather · 11/11/2026 09:21

@Twiglets1 ,

If the UK or Europe enjoyed a 3.4% GDP growth (admittedly only over the last quarter), I am not sure we would describe it as pain.

The U.S isn’t really enduring pain, but the inflation due to high gas hits the poorest hardest. Net/net, high oil is actually a positive for U.S GDP.

The pain on the U.S side is the breaking of promises by Trump (no ‘forever’ wars and bringing down inflation) and the loss of electoral support.

Twiglets1 · 11/11/2026 09:40

Newbutoldfather · 11/11/2026 09:21

@Twiglets1 ,

If the UK or Europe enjoyed a 3.4% GDP growth (admittedly only over the last quarter), I am not sure we would describe it as pain.

The U.S isn’t really enduring pain, but the inflation due to high gas hits the poorest hardest. Net/net, high oil is actually a positive for U.S GDP.

The pain on the U.S side is the breaking of promises by Trump (no ‘forever’ wars and bringing down inflation) and the loss of electoral support.

Ok maybe “some economic pain” was overstating it. The American public getting upset about it costing more to fill up their gas guzzlers is probably more accurate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread