Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

(Lack of) US Iran Peace Agreement Part 5

946 replies

OnePeppyFatball · 14/09/2026 10:37

Part 5

OP posts:
Thread gallery
131
rainingsnoring · 04/11/2026 05:43

BelleHathor · 04/11/2026 02:39

Looking like a 16+ point swing to Democrats, with some races having 30+ swings. Dems projected to win 240+ House seats and 52+ Senate seats. Absolute collapse in the under 45 male, Hispanic and Black vote.

Trump likely a lame duck president, he effectively regime changed himself. He even tried to say he'll stop funding Israel earlier https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/nov/03/donald-trump-usa-end-military-aid-to-israel-end-year-midterms

The only messaging the Trump admin offered was voters should suck up higher prices so that Iran doesn't get a nuke and the weird racist shouting about Islamo communists.

Late Senator Lindsey "never seen a war I didn't love" Grahams sister is projected to lose his seat in deep red South Carolina.
Texas is in play.

Ooh boy, we're in the fourth turning season, as this is not an endorsement of the Democrats but a wholesale rejection of Trump.

I guess Americans wanted to punish Trump for betraying his promises and prioritising foreign wars and putting helping Israel over the needs of ordinary Americans. That and his constant grifting while most of the population are getting steadily poorer.

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 06:34

As delighted as I am that Trump no longer holds any real power, we all know that he is a sore, sore looser. Which still renders him dangerous between now and January. I wonder what’s going to happen now.

I hope Bibi is worried.

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 04/11/2026 06:54

trumpredcard · 04/11/2026 02:08

When I wrote my post, I had already seen reports dd June relating to Russia's offer. My post was about Russia now inserting itself into the current round of negotiations, especially given it's current position in the Ukraine war.

It's not about believing whether the Russian offer is real, but whether it's being considered as part of a peace solution now.

The question was whether Russia are or are not "in the mix" re a potential peace solution, as reported by Axios (who I quoted) and other sources.

You said you would only believe that if there was a statement from Russia/Putin, which is not something normally expected when people quote from sources. I'm not sure why you would ask for a statement from the Kremlin if you were already aware that such a statement was made months ago.

Anyway, I'm glad we agree that Russia are in the mix. I did not say and my source did not say that it's a new development that Russia are "in the mix". The only things that were time stamped as recent were the phone call between Mohsen & Putin, described as taking place on "Monday" and a visit to Bejing by Rezaei's deputy, also described as taking place on Monday.

As a reminder, this was what I said in my post:

Russia does appear to be in the mix, yes.
The source is Axios, who say that Russia and China are taking an active role in the effort to reach a deal.

  • Russian President Vladimir Putin spoke by phone Monday with Iranian Secretary of the Supreme National Security Council Gen. Mohsen Rezaei. The two discussed the efforts to reach a diplomatic agreement.
  • Rezaei, who is very close to Khamenei, was also the recipient of a letter Vance sent recently proposing to resume negotiations.
  • Russia has also offered to be part of any nuclear agreement, including by receiving Iran's enriched uranium stockpile.
  • At the same time, Rezaei's deputy visited Beijing on Monday and met with the Chinese foreign minister. China is also urging the U.S. and Iran to resume direct negotiations to end the war.
www.axios.com/2026/11/02/trump-axios-interview-no-rush-resume-war
Twiglets1 · 04/11/2026 07:09

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 03:59

Hang on folks. Was I not gently "mocked" upthread for suggesting Trump might take out his anger at losses on Netanyahu ? I use the word "mocked" lightly. Cos we are a friendly bunch.

Trump’s Election Day bombshell on Israel points to historic shift | CNN Politics

"President Donald Trump is arguably the most pro-Israel president of modern times. So his Election Day announcement that the United States would end nearly $4 billion in annual aid to Israel was stunning."

For sure, could be an election ploy to try gain last minute votes. Then again, makes no sense bacuase dems tend to vote early, his base tend to vote on the day. So is he trying to turn his base away ?

Edited

You didn't just suggest that Trump might take out his anger at losses on Netanyahu.

You suggested he might "try to get his own back against him" by adopting a policy of "no bombing, because that would benefit Netanyahu"

That's what seems far fetched, that Trump would adopt a policy of no bombing, purely to spite Netanyahu. Trump will do what he thinks is best for Trump, as he always does. If he decides to stick with option 3 (maximum economic pain) rather than option 2 (renewed bombing) that will be done for strategic reasons and not, in my opinion anyway, simply to "try to get his own back" against Netanyahu.

rainingsnoring · 04/11/2026 07:15

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 06:34

As delighted as I am that Trump no longer holds any real power, we all know that he is a sore, sore looser. Which still renders him dangerous between now and January. I wonder what’s going to happen now.

I hope Bibi is worried.

Yes, he's a dangerous man for several reasons. He could well lash out.

Newbutoldfather · 04/11/2026 07:20

@Twiglets1 ,

‘That's what seems far fetched, that Trump would adopt a policy of no bombing, purely to spite Netanyahu. Trump will do what he thinks is best for Trump, as he always does. If he decides to stick with option 3 (maximum economic pain) rather than option 2 (renewed bombing) that will be done for strategic reasons and not, in my opinion anyway, simply to "try to get his own back" against Netanyahu.’

I am not sure about that! This whole war was about Israel really. Netanyahu told him he had a golden opportunity in Iran for a short and successful campaign, which he unwisely believed and got bogged down.

Of course, the U.S does not want Iran to get nuke, but I suspect that was done and dusted after the 5 day war. Now it is a matter of ego. Netanyahu’s campaign was run, in large part, on him being the Trump whisperer.

In a sense, of course, Israel is a part of U.S strategy. It is a way in which they can reliably project power. I don’t think the $4 bio is relevant here. It is 0.5% of Israel’s GDP, and Israel’s GDP/capita is greater than that of the UK. Of course, a decline in GDP of 0.5% does matter to Israel, but it’s not critical to the relationship.

I knew the mid terms would be bad, but not that bad.

I am not sure where we go from here. I was fairly sure that Trump would bomb, but I suspect he will be under huge Republican pressure not to, including from Vance. Of course, him and Bibi may decide to honour with a (literal) bang, but the risks just multiplied by several factors.

Newbutoldfather · 04/11/2026 07:26

@rainingsnoring ,

‘Yes, he's a dangerous man for several reasons. He could well lash out.’

He’s not sounding too dangerous right now. He has acknowledged the election result and admitted Iran was a factor. He sounds quite humbled.

He will have things he wants to get done before January, and settling Iran will be one of them. However, I am kind of suspecting that his party might have something to say about the squandering of more money and weapons, and even higher gasoline prices.

He will also now have to be thinking about his impeachment trial.

Twiglets1 · 04/11/2026 07:32

Newbutoldfather · 04/11/2026 07:20

@Twiglets1 ,

‘That's what seems far fetched, that Trump would adopt a policy of no bombing, purely to spite Netanyahu. Trump will do what he thinks is best for Trump, as he always does. If he decides to stick with option 3 (maximum economic pain) rather than option 2 (renewed bombing) that will be done for strategic reasons and not, in my opinion anyway, simply to "try to get his own back" against Netanyahu.’

I am not sure about that! This whole war was about Israel really. Netanyahu told him he had a golden opportunity in Iran for a short and successful campaign, which he unwisely believed and got bogged down.

Of course, the U.S does not want Iran to get nuke, but I suspect that was done and dusted after the 5 day war. Now it is a matter of ego. Netanyahu’s campaign was run, in large part, on him being the Trump whisperer.

In a sense, of course, Israel is a part of U.S strategy. It is a way in which they can reliably project power. I don’t think the $4 bio is relevant here. It is 0.5% of Israel’s GDP, and Israel’s GDP/capita is greater than that of the UK. Of course, a decline in GDP of 0.5% does matter to Israel, but it’s not critical to the relationship.

I knew the mid terms would be bad, but not that bad.

I am not sure where we go from here. I was fairly sure that Trump would bomb, but I suspect he will be under huge Republican pressure not to, including from Vance. Of course, him and Bibi may decide to honour with a (literal) bang, but the risks just multiplied by several factors.

The war was largely about protecting Israel I would say, but partly because of the fear that Israel would just be the beginning and that if they were destroyed, other enemies of Iran could follow.

Trump is adamant that Iran cannot be allowed to develop nuclear weapons and this is something that he is consistent about (many other countries agree with him on this). I disagree that it was "done and dusted" after the 5 day war.

Even before the midterms, I said that I could see it being appealing to Trump to use option 3 (maximum economic pain) to bring about a better outcome re option 1 (make a deal).

Seeing the outcome of the midterms, I believe that even more. I don't think it's got anything to do with spiting Netanyahu, though.

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 07:36

He might go for one more throw of the dice. Nothing to lose at this point.

Have also read in the press that his close advisors have told him he now needs to lawyer up.

I don’t feel sorry for him.

OP posts:
OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 07:39

A humbled Donny? It’s already not his fault. The man is an egoistical idiot.

OP posts:
Newbutoldfather · 04/11/2026 07:48

@Twiglets1 ,

‘The war was largely about protecting Israel I would say, but partly because of the fear that Israel would just be the beginning and that if they were destroyed, other enemies of Iran could follow.’

I don’t think Israel was ever under threat of destruction. The whole heroic ‘7 front war’ disguised the fact that a modern army with satellite imagery, a 5th generation airforce and the iron dome was fighting well armed guerilla armies. That is why thd casualties have been so asymmetric. Even Iran’s coordinated air defences were taken down in one night.

The nuclear threat is hard to guess, but there is no way that Iran was even close to getting a nuke on a warhead and firing it at Israel. Even then it would be odds on to be taken out mid air.

‘Even before the midterms, I said that I could see it being appealing to Trump to use option 3 (maximum economic pain) to bring about a better outcome re option 1 (make a deal).’

You did say that and having a credible military threat in situ does improve his bargaining position even further.

‘Seeing the outcome of the midterms, I believe that even more. I don't think it's got anything to do with spiting Netanyahu, though.’

I think there is a personality element here. Trump loves Netanyahu and sees him as a strong leader. There are also family ties through Kushner. Although Trump would never act solely to spite Netanyahu, the personal is political. I think he feels a bit conned by Netanyahu’s PowerPoint presentation and I do think Netanyahu is now pushing hard via claims of chemical weapons etc for another attack. I think Trump may not like this….

Twiglets1 · 04/11/2026 07:48

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 07:36

He might go for one more throw of the dice. Nothing to lose at this point.

Have also read in the press that his close advisors have told him he now needs to lawyer up.

I don’t feel sorry for him.

Not many people will feel sorry for him. He isn’t a likeable character, to put it mildly. Think US foreign policy is a bit more nuanced than Trump throwing “one more throw of the dice” though.

To what end? He will want to gain popularity before the end of his term, nor do something to make himself less popular, surely.

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 07:51

I don’t think he really cares what the American people think of him really. As has been evident throughout his presidency. Donny cares about Donny and his dollars.

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 04/11/2026 08:12

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 07:51

I don’t think he really cares what the American people think of him really. As has been evident throughout his presidency. Donny cares about Donny and his dollars.

We agree that he cares about No 1.

Won't do anything just for Netanyahu's sake - or just to spite him either - unless it aligns with his own interests.

Twiglets1 · 04/11/2026 08:24

Newbutoldfather · 04/11/2026 07:48

@Twiglets1 ,

‘The war was largely about protecting Israel I would say, but partly because of the fear that Israel would just be the beginning and that if they were destroyed, other enemies of Iran could follow.’

I don’t think Israel was ever under threat of destruction. The whole heroic ‘7 front war’ disguised the fact that a modern army with satellite imagery, a 5th generation airforce and the iron dome was fighting well armed guerilla armies. That is why thd casualties have been so asymmetric. Even Iran’s coordinated air defences were taken down in one night.

The nuclear threat is hard to guess, but there is no way that Iran was even close to getting a nuke on a warhead and firing it at Israel. Even then it would be odds on to be taken out mid air.

‘Even before the midterms, I said that I could see it being appealing to Trump to use option 3 (maximum economic pain) to bring about a better outcome re option 1 (make a deal).’

You did say that and having a credible military threat in situ does improve his bargaining position even further.

‘Seeing the outcome of the midterms, I believe that even more. I don't think it's got anything to do with spiting Netanyahu, though.’

I think there is a personality element here. Trump loves Netanyahu and sees him as a strong leader. There are also family ties through Kushner. Although Trump would never act solely to spite Netanyahu, the personal is political. I think he feels a bit conned by Netanyahu’s PowerPoint presentation and I do think Netanyahu is now pushing hard via claims of chemical weapons etc for another attack. I think Trump may not like this….

We agree at least that Trump would never act solely to spite Netanyahu.

Trump doesn't "love" Netanyahu though, he respects him as a strong leader.

Being a strong leader is important to Trump. He also respects Putin for the same reason.

Trump on Putin 2016 "If he says great things about me, I'm going to say great things about him. I've already said, he is really very much of a leader".

Trump on Putin 2022 “I knew Putin very well. I got along with him great. He liked me. I liked him. I mean, you know, he’s a tough cookie, got a lot of the great charm and a lot of pride... he loves his country".

As late as 2025, when asked by the BBC if he was done with Putin, Trump replied: "I'm disappointed in him, but I'm not done with him".

BelleHathor · 04/11/2026 08:25

rainingsnoring · 04/11/2026 05:43

I guess Americans wanted to punish Trump for betraying his promises and prioritising foreign wars and putting helping Israel over the needs of ordinary Americans. That and his constant grifting while most of the population are getting steadily poorer.

The cope is real out there "Trust the plan" "Trump is playing 5D chess" "this is a plot to expose election fraud". "Miriam Adelson" and "Panicans" is trending.

It started with failing to release the Epstein files and ended with the Iran war.

It was entirely easy to predict. It happened in 1920 [AI summary]
"The 1920 United States presidential election served as a massive, sweeping backlash against World War I and the progressive, interventionist policies of Democratic President Woodrow Wilson. 1, 2, 3]
Weary of war, global entanglements, and domestic upheaval, American voters delivered a historic landslide victory to Republican nominee Warren G. Harding. Harding capitalized on the national mood by running on a famous promise of a "return to normalcy."

Trump can't call people racists, low iq, say he doesn't want their vote, openly prioritise a foreign country, protect pedophiles, get Americans killed in foreign wars that you chose, allow masked ICE agents to kill Americans and facilitate War Crimes and say the American people support it.

Trump allowed his donors to run his policy and abandoned real America firsters. The 2024 new band of Trump supporters who only shifted their support to him due to his support of Israel never had the votes nor understood the base.

I hope Massie, MTG, Candace and Tucker are enjoying this, afterall schadenfreude is real nice with a morning coffee ☕️.

P.s. @RedTagAlan Trump has maybe a 2 week window to attack again. On the livestream Barnes and Baris said they've got marines in the region, ready to take the 2 islands. Trump seems sober and lucid right now, realising that his legacy is done and corruption trials await.

1920 United States presidential election - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1920_United_States_presidential_election

RedTagAlan · 04/11/2026 08:34

Newbutoldfather · 04/11/2026 07:48

@Twiglets1 ,

‘The war was largely about protecting Israel I would say, but partly because of the fear that Israel would just be the beginning and that if they were destroyed, other enemies of Iran could follow.’

I don’t think Israel was ever under threat of destruction. The whole heroic ‘7 front war’ disguised the fact that a modern army with satellite imagery, a 5th generation airforce and the iron dome was fighting well armed guerilla armies. That is why thd casualties have been so asymmetric. Even Iran’s coordinated air defences were taken down in one night.

The nuclear threat is hard to guess, but there is no way that Iran was even close to getting a nuke on a warhead and firing it at Israel. Even then it would be odds on to be taken out mid air.

‘Even before the midterms, I said that I could see it being appealing to Trump to use option 3 (maximum economic pain) to bring about a better outcome re option 1 (make a deal).’

You did say that and having a credible military threat in situ does improve his bargaining position even further.

‘Seeing the outcome of the midterms, I believe that even more. I don't think it's got anything to do with spiting Netanyahu, though.’

I think there is a personality element here. Trump loves Netanyahu and sees him as a strong leader. There are also family ties through Kushner. Although Trump would never act solely to spite Netanyahu, the personal is political. I think he feels a bit conned by Netanyahu’s PowerPoint presentation and I do think Netanyahu is now pushing hard via claims of chemical weapons etc for another attack. I think Trump may not like this….

Quote " There are also family ties through Kushner.".

But they are not related are they ? . The Kushner father, the one convicted of blackmail I think, was a doner, and Netanyahu stayed at his house.

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 08:35

This opinion piece is in the Telegraph:

“But Trump will not accept responsibility; he will point the finger at others for defeat. His most important international response could come in renewed attacks on Iran, likely again in cooperation with Israel, in the coming days, now that polls are closed. Whatever the strategic arguments for resuming strikes, and there are powerful reasons to do so, the triggering factor in Trump’s decision will be to show he is still “relevant”, as Bill Clinton once characterised his own wounded administration in 1994.
Beyond the possible immediate éclat of Iran, as Democrats take full control of the legislative branch, Washington’s next two years will be filled with stark partisanship. Democrats have planned how to wield their new control of Congress, using every committee, all of which they will soon control.”

Excerpt From
“Opinion: The Democrats will now take revenge on Trump and his ilk”
John Bolton
The Telegraph
https://apple.news/AhP0NNKH9RtO55AGHB0l7Pg
This material may be protected by copyright.

Opinion: America is about to discover how extreme the Democrat Left has become — The Telegraph

Self-described socialists won primaries across the nation and are now masking radical positions behind economic populism

https://apple.news/PgehRM4Gdj69OlSt_7f2URt

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 04/11/2026 08:40

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 08:35

This opinion piece is in the Telegraph:

“But Trump will not accept responsibility; he will point the finger at others for defeat. His most important international response could come in renewed attacks on Iran, likely again in cooperation with Israel, in the coming days, now that polls are closed. Whatever the strategic arguments for resuming strikes, and there are powerful reasons to do so, the triggering factor in Trump’s decision will be to show he is still “relevant”, as Bill Clinton once characterised his own wounded administration in 1994.
Beyond the possible immediate éclat of Iran, as Democrats take full control of the legislative branch, Washington’s next two years will be filled with stark partisanship. Democrats have planned how to wield their new control of Congress, using every committee, all of which they will soon control.”

Excerpt From
“Opinion: The Democrats will now take revenge on Trump and his ilk”
John Bolton
The Telegraph
https://apple.news/AhP0NNKH9RtO55AGHB0l7Pg
This material may be protected by copyright.

All these opinion pieces you post are just that - opinions.

For every opinion piece arguing one way, it would be possible to find one arguing the opposite.

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 08:45

Twiglets1 · 04/11/2026 08:40

All these opinion pieces you post are just that - opinions.

For every opinion piece arguing one way, it would be possible to find one arguing the opposite.

Edited

Which is why I stated it was an opinion piece. 🙄

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 04/11/2026 08:50

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 08:45

Which is why I stated it was an opinion piece. 🙄

What's the point of them though? They are literally a journalist's opinion, I would rather hear your opinion as expressed by you.

I'm not sure anyone even reads the longer ones. Obviously up to you what you want to post but your opinion is more relevant to a discussion forum.

BelleHathor · 04/11/2026 09:03

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 08:45

Which is why I stated it was an opinion piece. 🙄

Important opinion piece from John Bolton who served as the 26th United States National Security Advisor under President Donald Trump from April 2018 to September 2019.

Notorious War hawk and representative of the Military Industrial complex who lobbied extremely hard for the Iran conflict.

Twiglets1 · 04/11/2026 09:30

BelleHathor · 04/11/2026 09:03

Important opinion piece from John Bolton who served as the 26th United States National Security Advisor under President Donald Trump from April 2018 to September 2019.

Notorious War hawk and representative of the Military Industrial complex who lobbied extremely hard for the Iran conflict.

Yes he might have had some inside knowledge 6 years ago. He won't have insight into Trump's plans now and that is why it is called an opinion piece.

OnePeppyFatball · 04/11/2026 09:34

I would prefer to be well informed rather than not. Opinion pieces provide different perspectives. Up to you if you read them or not.

OP posts:
TopPocketFind · 04/11/2026 09:35

Trump didn't care about nuclear weapons when he tore up the JCPOA, what changed?

Swipe left for the next trending thread