Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

(Lack of) US Iran Peace Agreement Part 5

946 replies

OnePeppyFatball · 14/09/2026 10:37

Part 5

OP posts:
Thread gallery
131
trumpredcard · 05/11/2026 08:34

According to Zhou, laser energy must be transmitted and amplified through specialty optical fibers. These fibers are doped with special rare-earth elements

Next question. Which special earth elements?

RedTagAlan · 05/11/2026 08:48

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 08:22

@RedTagAlan ,

I am amazed by that, to be honest.

I know everyone is working on this. However, it seems the Chinese have beaten the U.S.

I imagine if the U.S had them, they would be in theatre now. I guess it also depends on cost, size etc, but that is definitely the future of anti drone warfare, and maybe even anti missile warfare at some point.

After all, if you are firing at light speed, you don’t need to make too many ballistic adjustments for position!

Goes without saying, pinch of salt needed re PRC State media. Shall we go into the physics ? Could be an interesting side.

I think of it in terms of hypersonics. Very difficult. The US do not have them ready, yet other nations claim to have thousands, with no evidence presented.

As you say, I would expect the US to have these too.

And anyway, just send the drones out when it is raining ? Or foggy ? The Gobi is very dry. Not much humidity.

As an accecdote. I remember a project I worked on. We could not get a product to pass a temperature dependent safety test. The boss said we will do that later. A few months later a fellow engineer came up to me and said, with no tears in his eyes, " it passes the test now. The boss is really clever, he said to do the test now because he has changed things, and now it passes"

I said yeah. It's winter now. Ambient temperature is 25 degrees lower than when we done the test before.

Aye, I won't say what the product is, but be aware. Some things are not as safe in a heatwave as they are in winter :-)

But that product was scrapped eventually. But they did sell a few million.

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 09:06

@RedTagAlan ,

‘And anyway, just send the drones out when it is raining ? Or foggy ? The Gobi is very dry. Not much humidity.’

I did not even think about that! Shows how impractical I am. However, when I looked it up, that is a soluble problem. They use a very high powered laser pulse for a very short time (femtosecond, apparently!) to vaporise the cloud,
and then a second laser fires through the hole.

I assume targeting is much easier with a light speed weapon. The time of travel of the light beam would be hundredths of a second at most, so you could probably aim at the target, rather than having to calculate its trajectory.

I don’t know much about lasers. I did study them briefly as part of my degree but that was a LONG time ago. I don’t know how big a laser would have to be or how much it would cost. I am guessing it is a very soluble problem though.

RedTagAlan · 05/11/2026 09:43

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 09:06

@RedTagAlan ,

‘And anyway, just send the drones out when it is raining ? Or foggy ? The Gobi is very dry. Not much humidity.’

I did not even think about that! Shows how impractical I am. However, when I looked it up, that is a soluble problem. They use a very high powered laser pulse for a very short time (femtosecond, apparently!) to vaporise the cloud,
and then a second laser fires through the hole.

I assume targeting is much easier with a light speed weapon. The time of travel of the light beam would be hundredths of a second at most, so you could probably aim at the target, rather than having to calculate its trajectory.

I don’t know much about lasers. I did study them briefly as part of my degree but that was a LONG time ago. I don’t know how big a laser would have to be or how much it would cost. I am guessing it is a very soluble problem though.

Personally, I think of energy in terms of tea kettles. It is one of the highest energy appliances in the house. A 3KW kettle is pulling the max number of amps that a 13 amp plug can handle at 230V. And as per UK regs, 13 amps needs a 2.5mm cross section wire. And that is pretty thick.

And although cable size to amps is not linear, I find thinking in “kettles” is a good starting point to visualise electrical power.

The Global times article does not mention what power, but if they said it was 300 KW that to me is 100 kettles. That is a lot of energy. That is a small village worth of kettles. Try putting that into the back of a Jeep.

If fact, quickly popping 300KW at 230V into a cable size website, super quick, it says 113 mm^2 CSA minimum copper cable size over 1 metre with 1 % voltage drop.

That is a mighty thick cable to carry that energy.

An interesting side for sure while we wait for war news.

RedTagAlan · 05/11/2026 10:24

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 09:06

@RedTagAlan ,

‘And anyway, just send the drones out when it is raining ? Or foggy ? The Gobi is very dry. Not much humidity.’

I did not even think about that! Shows how impractical I am. However, when I looked it up, that is a soluble problem. They use a very high powered laser pulse for a very short time (femtosecond, apparently!) to vaporise the cloud,
and then a second laser fires through the hole.

I assume targeting is much easier with a light speed weapon. The time of travel of the light beam would be hundredths of a second at most, so you could probably aim at the target, rather than having to calculate its trajectory.

I don’t know much about lasers. I did study them briefly as part of my degree but that was a LONG time ago. I don’t know how big a laser would have to be or how much it would cost. I am guessing it is a very soluble problem though.

Quote “They use a very high powered laser pulse for a very short time (femtosecond, apparently!) to vaporise the cloud,and then a second laser fires through the hole. “

Goodness me. Now you have sent me off on one. Because that sounds very elegant, and we can work it out. The energy needed to do that. But easier with rain I think.

Average size of raindrop is 0,05 ml. Lets say there are 2000 raindrops between you and the drone, that’s 100 Ml. I picked 2000 cos I already know it takes 259 K Joules to boil that much water from 20 C. One watt is one joule per second. So for a 1 second laser burst, it’s a strait equal. A 259 KW laser. 86 kettles ( putting the speed of rain fall aside).

But that is just boiling the water to steam. We have to vaporize the steam ( that takes 2260 J/g ). But maybe not, because now the laser is hitting the drone. So anything above the 259 KW is mostly getting through?

It’s interesting. And far from easy. I think that is why it is to be on ships first, because they have the power generation, and the space.

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 10:26

@RedTagAlan ,

I think you gave to make a distinction between power and energy, and also energy per unit area. It doesn’t take a lot of energy to bring down a drone if the area is small enough (think of the analogic photon pressure).

The kettle analogy only really has relevance with cheap (impure) copper conductors. Military lasers will have very specialist conductors.

RedTagAlan · 05/11/2026 10:35

Newbutoldfather · 05/11/2026 10:26

@RedTagAlan ,

I think you gave to make a distinction between power and energy, and also energy per unit area. It doesn’t take a lot of energy to bring down a drone if the area is small enough (think of the analogic photon pressure).

The kettle analogy only really has relevance with cheap (impure) copper conductors. Military lasers will have very specialist conductors.

For sure. But power is the rate of doing work. So if it takes 1000 Joules of energy to break a drone, the power is the rate of that energy being being applied.

And yes, we are into superconductor territory. And for that we are talking liquid helium cooling.

And a lot of the helium is stuck in the Gulf, because of the war. But then again, I am sure they can send that by plane.

So it is back to the Iran war.

trumpredcard · 05/11/2026 11:19

I'm useless at Maths and Physics, but as per previous link, didn't the Brits install the laser on an armoured vehicle?

RedTagAlan · 05/11/2026 11:43

trumpredcard · 05/11/2026 11:19

I'm useless at Maths and Physics, but as per previous link, didn't the Brits install the laser on an armoured vehicle?

Yes, but it is not deployed. In development.

RedTagAlan · 07/11/2026 02:40

Interesting TRUTH from POTUS.

"Friday, November 6, 2026 6:09 PM

Israel and, in fact, the entire Middle East, WOULD NOT EXIST TODAY if I did not stop Iran from having a Nuclear Weapon. Nobody wants to say that, but everybody knows it's true! President DONALD J. TRUMP"

Strange one. Because his mantra is that "Iran can't get a Nuke", but here there seems to be a mix of tense ? That he has already stopped them in the past ? Because if he had not already stopped them, how would the Mid East have stopped existing ? And if he has already stopped them, then what is this war about?

His TRUTH is an odd mix of past, present and future, that I can't work out.

Oh, and price of oil dropped.

RedTagAlan · 07/11/2026 03:09

On my post above, I think that TRUTH is a demonstration of his thinking process. Something we have talked about here.

Because it looks to me like he uses language as a brain dump rather than as a precise transfer of information. Maybe it is an insight into his thinking method?

That is, this TRUTH shows a total lack of scientific thought process to it. If he was trying to communicate something precisely, then scientific method should really be used.

So he either thinks he is right no matter what, without being able to explain it, or he does not really care what other people think, and puts no effort into communicating it ?

Or he has no concept of the scientific method. That would also explain why so much of what he says seems like a conspiracy. I am sure, by the way, that he is a flat earther.

Ironically, I am not very good at explaining this at all. Not my field :-)

Twiglets1 · 07/11/2026 06:01

@RedTagAlan I believe Trump’s point is that he has stopped Iran from developing the capability for nuclear weapons and continues to do so. So the tenses are correct to be both in the past and the present.

Does Trump believe the earth is flat? Never heard him say so. I wouldn’t be that surprised as he is not scientific but equally- it’s a big accusation to make if there’s no evidence of him actually saying it?

trumpredcard · 07/11/2026 06:03

RedTagAlan · 07/11/2026 03:09

On my post above, I think that TRUTH is a demonstration of his thinking process. Something we have talked about here.

Because it looks to me like he uses language as a brain dump rather than as a precise transfer of information. Maybe it is an insight into his thinking method?

That is, this TRUTH shows a total lack of scientific thought process to it. If he was trying to communicate something precisely, then scientific method should really be used.

So he either thinks he is right no matter what, without being able to explain it, or he does not really care what other people think, and puts no effort into communicating it ?

Or he has no concept of the scientific method. That would also explain why so much of what he says seems like a conspiracy. I am sure, by the way, that he is a flat earther.

Ironically, I am not very good at explaining this at all. Not my field :-)

The term you're looking for is stream of consciousness.

Stream of consciousness is a narrative technique that mimics the natural, often disjointed flow of a character's thoughts and perceptions, using irregular syntax and minimal punctuation to replicate the mind's associative leaps.

And Trump's reveals how illogical his thoughts are. Probably only thinks in dollars, not words.

OnePeppyFatball · 07/11/2026 06:17

Telegraph:

“The US military launched fresh but limited strikes in Iran late on Friday, targeting an air defence system, according to president Donald Trump.
Iranian media reported that two explosions were heard around the Suza area of Qeshm, a critical island along the main international shipping corridor for oil.
Speaking to reporters shortly after arriving in West Palm Beach, Florida, on Friday evening, Mr Trump characterised the military engagement as minor.
"They built a little bit of an anti-aircraft device and we knocked it out in about 15 minutes, maybe five," he said. Mr Trump offered no further details regarding the target. ”

Excerpt From
“US launches new strikes on key Iranian island as Tehran weighs proposals to end war”
Aamer Madhani, Samy Magdy, Michelle L. Price
The Independent
https://apple.news/A1Ruz_OvHSdqKYXnz9iUN_A
This material may be protected by copyright.

Iran | The Independent

The latest breaking news, comment and features from The Independent.

https://www.independent.co.uk/topic/iran

OP posts:
OnePeppyFatball · 07/11/2026 06:18

Soz, Independent.

OP posts:
RedTagAlan · 07/11/2026 06:33

OnePeppyFatball · 07/11/2026 06:17

Telegraph:

“The US military launched fresh but limited strikes in Iran late on Friday, targeting an air defence system, according to president Donald Trump.
Iranian media reported that two explosions were heard around the Suza area of Qeshm, a critical island along the main international shipping corridor for oil.
Speaking to reporters shortly after arriving in West Palm Beach, Florida, on Friday evening, Mr Trump characterised the military engagement as minor.
"They built a little bit of an anti-aircraft device and we knocked it out in about 15 minutes, maybe five," he said. Mr Trump offered no further details regarding the target. ”

Excerpt From
“US launches new strikes on key Iranian island as Tehran weighs proposals to end war”
Aamer Madhani, Samy Magdy, Michelle L. Price
The Independent
https://apple.news/A1Ruz_OvHSdqKYXnz9iUN_A
This material may be protected by copyright.

Quote " "They built a little bit of an anti-aircraft device and we knocked it out in about 15 minutes, maybe five," "

An example of something Trump does A LOT. State a number, then instantly reduce it if he thinks the reduction benefits him.

Can see his thinking there. He says 15 mins, then instantly it's as if a wee voice in his head says " make it 5, sounds better". Truth does not matter at all to this fella.

We know this of course. Just pointing it out.

trumpredcard · 07/11/2026 10:06

Trump's on a roll...or thinks he is. And NATO might need to have. word.

Donald Trump is planning to bypass Ukraine to make a double deal with Vladimir Putin to end the war and reopen the Strait of Hormuz, European officials fear.
The grand bargain was seen as the US president’s best opportunity to end the Ukraine and Iran conflicts in quick succession, sources close to the talks told The Telegraph.

The sources said that if Mr Trump handed a favourable deal to Putin, the Russian leader could then use his close ties with Iran to unblock the strait.
Gulf mediators are understood to be confident that the US and Iran are close to reaching a nuclear deal that would end the fighting and open the shipping lane. However, they believe Tehran would still need to be convinced by their Russian allies to finalise the agreement.
Separately, Iran and Russia are in talks over a deal to send advanced air defence systems to Tehran, contradicting Mr Trump’s claim that Moscow is not helping the Islamic Republic “at all”.
A secret Iranian planning memo reviewed by this newspaper revealed that Tehran would lean on the Kremlin for support in any further conflict with the US.

Speaking in the Oval Office on Thursday, Mr Trump said he was discussing a deal with Putin to end the war in Ukraine and redraw the security architecture of Europe.
His comments raised fresh fears that he would attempt to squeeze Kyiv and other European capitals into a deal favourable to Moscow. Two top officials told The Telegraph that Continental leaders would push back against any such arrangement.
A third source said that they were braced for a potential American offer to convince Europe to “sacrifice” Ukraine.
On Friday, European officials were wargaming their potential responses to the US-Russia plan before a fresh round of trilateral peace talks in the Middle East next week.
One of the driving factors behind their concerns is Mr Trump’s decision to meet a Russian negotiator at the White House, after Melania Trump hosted representatives from Kyiv and Moscow.
...
“It might involve all of Europe ... It’s going to be a big, beautiful agreement, and everyone is going to be thrilled.”
Mr Trump’s remarks were followed by a statement from Jared Kushner, his son-in-law and senior envoy, teasing a deal to “create a more stable and predictable security environment” for all of Europe.
Mr Kushner said: “President Trump today advanced an important discussion with several European leaders about the need for a broader European security architecture that can help establish the conditions for lasting peace.”

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/67da36c5cc3e233a

Trump ‘planning double deal with Putin to end two wars’

US president aims to use talks with Moscow to end conflicts in Ukraine and Iran and reopen Strait of Hormuz

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/67da36c5cc3e233a

trumpredcard · 07/11/2026 10:09

And then there's this:

Russia in talks to supply advanced missiles to Iran
Kremlin visit by Tehran’s security chief casts doubt on Trump claim that Moscow is not helping Islamic Republic

Iran and Russia are in talks over a deal to send advanced air defence systems to Tehran, The Telegraph can reveal.
The Islamic Republic was “optimistic” that Vladimir Putin would finally deliver the long-awaited S-400 air defence systems it had sought for years, a senior Iranian official said.
Mojtaba Khamenei, Iran’s supreme leader, sent Mohsen Rezaei, his security chief, to the Kremlin on Thursday with a personal letter whose central demand, according to the official, was the supply of the weapon. The negotiations over a deal contradict claims by Donald Trump that Russia is not helping Iran “at all”.

TopPocketFind · 07/11/2026 10:14

Miller is his new Chief of Staff, that is not good news.

BelleHathor · 07/11/2026 10:33

A secret Iranian planning memo reviewed by this newspaper revealed that Tehran would lean on the Kremlin

Lol 😁😉😂 I wonder who found this secret memo!.

Similar to Iran there's a battle between the oligarch class who want to deals for business reasons and the general public who want a full and final settlement not just a frozen war.

Trump would also need to reign in his own CIA who are the ones who've been assisting Zelensky to continue to bomb Russian energy infrastructure.

Take it with a grain of salt as the Pakistan is in the American camp, however Pepe Escobar claims to have a source that was in the meeting between Rezaei and Putin, and the discussion was about Gas pipelines.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7vLM3i0SfcY

trumpredcard · 07/11/2026 10:57

And the Qatari option from the Guardian.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/nov/07/strait-of-hormuz-qatar-plan-iran-nuclear-inspections

Qatar, the lead mediator in the US-Iran conflict, is seeking to persuade Tehran to allow UN nuclear weapons inspectors to visit Iran’s bombed nuclear sites, including those housing the country’s stockpile of highly enriched uranium.
Iran would not be required to make any commitment that the stockpile would be removed from the country, with other options on the table, including reducing the uranium content by down-blending it.
...
Under the Qatar proposal, the US would immediately lift the naval blockade on Iran in the strait of Hormuz and release a portion of the $8bn (£6bn) of its frozen assets. In return, Iran would agree to visits by International Atomic Energy Agency inspectors to its bombed nuclear facilities, based on a previous abandoned agreement that had been reached in Cairo in September 2025.

Strait of Hormuz could reopen as part of Qatari plan for Iran nuclear inspections

Trump still considering new assault on Iran nuclear sites – though threats less credible after Vance remarks

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2026/nov/07/strait-of-hormuz-qatar-plan-iran-nuclear-inspections

Twiglets1 · 08/11/2026 06:34

The US has announced a reward of up to $20 million for information about Iran's nuclear programme.

The State Department's Rewards for Justice is also offering to potentially relocate the person who provides such details.

Meanwhile, the US military says it is setting up a task force to enhance Washington's efforts to restrict Iran's movement of weapons and sanctioned material across its borders.

As well as the movement of weapons, it will also focus on dual-use and illegal revenue streams.

Centcom estimates that its naval blockade of Iran's ports has prevented the country from exporting more than $25bn in crude oil.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6d091ev3p0jo

An Iranian woman walks past a wall painting of Iranian revolutionary soldiers in Tehran, Iran, 25 February 2026

US offers $20m reward for information about Iran's nuclear programme

Donald Trump has repeatedly raised the prospect of renewing strikes against Iran's nuclear facilities.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6d091ev3p0jo

trumpredcard · 09/11/2026 05:24

Maintain the war against Iran to eliminate a nuclear capacity that Iran may or may not have vs endanger the world's food by making it impossible for Iran to produce fertiliser that the world needs.
Why is no one talking about fertiliser and next year's crop yield?

trumpredcard · 09/11/2026 05:37

A demonstration of the beneficial power of democracy

The Mid-term results are no guarantee that Trump, Kegsbreath and Miller won't decide to use the US military capability to resume the war as a last throw of the dice.
Affordability was the number one reason for voting blue.
(The war in Iran is vastly unpopular too.)