Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents unfair with money, am I right to be resentful?

93 replies

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 21:45

Long story short: every time my brother has needed money to buy a house, my parents have helped him out financially.
The first time, they did it behind my back and had no plans to tell me. I only found out because they were staying with us and left an email open on the home computer.
Now it's happening again. They're giving him a large sum to buy a bigger house, and this time my dad told me himself because he wanted me to contribute too.

I should add that my husband and I lent my brother money for his first purchase (on top of my parents' gift), and they expected us to do the same again for the new purchase.
I told them we couldn't this time, as we have another project and need every penny. We also want to help our own children get on the property ladder. We left it there and everyone seemed fine with it, with my parents happy to top up. (To be clear my parents have more money than they will ever need but I’ve noticed my dad has become a bit careful/tight with age, which is why he asked me to help).

Since then I haven’t been able to shake the resentment. I don't even want to think about how much they've given him over the years. He relies on my parents for almost everything (money, babysitting, dog sitting, holidays), partly because of some poor life choices, and my dad can't bear that he doesn't have the lifestyle they do, so he tries to make up for it.
Meanwhile, they've never given me anything. They've always been loving and we get on well, but I suspect they assume I don't need help. That's partly true, but I work over 60 hours a week in a very demanding job I don't want to do forever, and I'd love to be able to help my kids buy a home too.
For the past week I've felt sad, disappointed and resentful. I haven't felt like calling them, and I've been short in my replies to their messages, which I feel bad about to some extent, but I can’t help.
I should also say that we are the exact opposite with our own children, perhaps as a reaction to all this. Whatever we give one, we give the others, or at least we're completely open about it and record everything officially so that no resentment or conflict builds up further down the line. That’s why I struggle even more with their behaviour.

Am I being unreasonable? Should I put it in perspective and let it go as life is too short, or talk to them? I’ve been thinking of finding the right moment to talk to my dad but I’d need to be very careful as money is taboo and conflicts do not exist in my family, so I'd need to be very diplomatic... Maybe worth adding I get on fairly well with my brother and his wife (without being overly close) and want to keep a good relationship. (Ironically, I think his situation is partly my dad's doing, since my parents have always spoiled him, killing any ambition and making him highly dependent on them).

Thanks in advance for your words of wisdom.

OP posts:
MyPearlMentor · Today 03:40

“ Meanwhile, they've never given me anything. They've always been loving and we get on well, “

They have always been loving & you get on well. Really, they did give you everything. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Pipsquiggle · Today 03:41

What are the sums of money involved here?
How much have you given him before? How much has your parents?

Honestly from what you are saying, your parents sound sexist and are perpetuating poor choices. They hold you to different standards to your DB.

I know my parents have given my DSis money to fix her roof and buy furniture. She's single, works hard (nurse), doesn't earn a lot and has had cancer over the past few years. I have no issue with my mum and dad giving her this money. Neither does my DB.

rainingsnoring · Today 03:56

CamomileB · Today 00:30

I read it as a request for a loan that was declined and everyone moved on. I don’t think that helping one sibling more is treating children unequally, if one needs help and the other doesn’t. If she’d asked for help and they’d said no that would be a different matter. I don’t think we should feel we have a right to out parents’ money. I am one of seven children - my parents have helped some of us more than others over the years based on need. I don’t see it as any of my business and feel it has zero bearing on how much they love us all. Life is too short to get resentful about money, especially when you have enough of it to have a comfortable life.

They are literally treating their DC unequally. I think you mean inequitably!
I don't think the OP, nor anyone else has suggested that children have a right to their parent's money.

What is clear from @Seahorses26's post is that the parents have constantly given everything to the brother, lots of money but also their time and support. They have played favourites in a very obvious way. I wonder if there is sexism at play here, with the son being favoured. We are talking about a family with two siblings here, not seven, so the disparity is stark. Their actions, over decades, have turned the brother into a rather lazy and entitled person, who simply takes it for granted that he will be funded by his parents. The OP, on the other hand, is a hard working woman, who has done very well because of this and married someone with similar values. Instead of lauding her for her achievements and hard work, she is effectively punished by not being given support, financial or otherwise. In fact, she is expected to support her parents, while the favoured brother is not. Not only that, but she is also expected to give him her hard earned money. To top it off, she is even told off by her parents for working too hard and told that she should be spending more time with her family!

From my experience of seeing how these sort of situations play out, @Seahorses26, I suspect the conversation will not go well and your parents will fail to see things from your perspective. Most parents who make the choice to engage in such blatant favouritism do not like it when it is pointed out to them and become defensive and even start to lie about their past actions. This obviously says something about them and their characters, which was perhaps clear all along! I think you need to consider how much being honest and open with them will help you vs the potential fall out. An alternative would be to withdraw from the relationship a lot more in order to reduce the hurt caused by their behaviour.

Franjipanl8r · Today 04:15

This is the situation in my family, but my brother’s had health problems which has limited him working.

My parents have been very open about not trying to be “fair” they want equity rather than fairness and as a parent it’s not nice to see one child struggle and let the others flourish. Just have a conversation with them.

Remoter33 · Today 04:25

I’d feel resentful in your position but what your parents do with their money is up to them. They don’t have an obligation to treat you and your brother the same. However, asking you to help your brother financially again is out of order.

I’d make it absolutely clear that you have no intention of helping your brother out financially and that you will be using any extra money you have to support both of your children “equally” as they transition in to adulthood.

JoshLymanSwagger · Today 04:42

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 22:47

@Thingcanonlygetbetter ”We do so much for them, they keep telling me I work to hard”.
Do we have the same parents??!! My mum keeps telling me I work way too much and should slow down to spend more time with my family. Well I’m not given free money and have to help everyone so I need to work!!
I wonder if they have an agenda here and want me to spend more time with them? I already help them with many aspects of their life, especially since they’ve moved closer, whereas my brother just takes.

I think you do need to spend any extra time with your DH and kids...and let your parents get some help from your brother instead - I'll bet he doesn't do 60hr weeks.

veggie50 · Today 05:55

OP, imagine yourself in their shoes with one child doing much better financially than another...what would you do? If you genuinely feel you'd do things very differently from what they are doing then go and speak to them and explain what the issues were. Otherwise, stand back and give them your blessing.

Uniqueusername3 · Today 06:01

Don't ruin the holiday. Talk about it beforehand. Don't come at it from "you give them more money" but "I help you alot and I feel like you take that for granted and assume I don't need any help back. I feel like you offer DBro alot of support and expect me to support him as well but I would appreciate also receiving support from my parents. I know you see that I'm doing well financially, like yourselves, but that doesn't make me your equals, I am dbros equal and my financial security it coming at the expense of a massive workload and huge amount of stress and support from my parents, like DBro is getting, would massively benefit my life. I'm not asking you for money, but I need you to understand I'm hurt you asked me to support DBro with you and that you don't see that I also need support."

Support, help. Not money.

AgentKim · Today 06:04

I think your Dad has in some way brain washed you. I dont think its love. I think he is one of those old fashioned men who think men are more important than women.
I think you should do what your hubby says , he sounds as though he knows more about this than any of us on the outside.
I would distance myself from my parents after the holiday and tell them why you are doing so.
Don't help financially anymore, its your brother's choice what he dos and if he can't afford it he shouldn't rely on anyone to help him.
Your family is awful to be honest and the least you have to do with them the better.
Just worry about your own little family.

Janetwin · Today 06:27

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 21:58

That’s what I’ve been tempted to do and my husband is advising me to do. I’m taking them on holidays soon (been planned a while ago), which might be a good time to have the conversation. However I’ve been wondering if it’s worth it, hence this post.
My dad is old; he’s healthy but he won’t be with us forever, and I don’t want to come across like I’m obsessed with money. Also this type of discussion is pretty taboo in the family so it won’t be comfortable.
Yet this resentment keeps haunting me, and I can't stop feeling annoyed.

That resentment will only get worse and drive a wedge between you and your parents and brother if you don’t address it.

thepariscrimefiles · Today 06:28

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 22:38

That's a fair question, and honestly I'm not sure myself. I mentioned in my OP that the money could help with deposits for the kids' houses or another project, but in reality we don't need it. More is always welcome, but we've done very well for ourselves. Asking them for money would feel awkward, and I'd worry about coming across as money-obsessed.
Maybe it’s just letting my dad know about I feel and move on.

You should also absolutely stop subsidising your brother and your parents. Them exclusively helping your brother financially is one thing, expecting you to contribute is utterly ridiculous and unfair.

I would be cancelling the holiday with them. I wouldn't be able to hide my resentment.

Bobbykins · Today 06:29

I really empathize with your situation - there is a similar dynamic in my family and it is upsetting. I think you’re very wise to have realised you don’t need more money, you would just appreciate it and use it wisely. I think try and emotionally distance yourself from this by seeing it as an issue between your dad and brother which you thankfully are no longer involved in. Feel proud of how capable and independent you are, and the example you’re setting for your kids.
I personally wouldn’t bring this up with your family in a big way, but equally I wouldn’t make it a taboo subject. If it feels appropriate to call out the disparity sometimes then do it. It’s no bad thing to let people know how it makes you feel. Think about what help you might need from your parents - potentially they keen to help you too and just don’t know how.
And finally, prepare yourself that the disparity might flow through into your parents’ wills. This is their right as it’s their money. However you might want to try and make sure they aren’t thinking of leaving some provision which puts you in a difficult situation with your brother (ie shared property with legal provision that it provides an income to brother and can’t be sold). This does happen and I feel it’s really unfair.
hope that helps!

Mrsclaude · Today 06:37

veggie50 · Today 05:55

OP, imagine yourself in their shoes with one child doing much better financially than another...what would you do? If you genuinely feel you'd do things very differently from what they are doing then go and speak to them and explain what the issues were. Otherwise, stand back and give them your blessing.

Why are they doing better financially? I think that matters. If one had a disability that would limit earning potential, that’s different from someone choosing to work in a low income job in part time hours because they want a better work life balance but want a higher class lifestyle funded by someone else, which is different again from a sibling being helped temporarily whilst redundant - context matters. If both have the same upbringing, the same opportunities, etc and only one child is helped (and helped repeatedly), it becomes less about the money and more about what the money represents.
I still remember a different post where the OP found out her parents had been paying for her sister and family’s lifestyle and holidays while she worked in her passion job as a part time yoga instructor (from memory), whilst OP and her husband were working full time in fields they didn’t love but did to fund their own family, all the while not knowing money was freely flowing in her siblings direction. Things like this do real damage to relationships, and it’s rarely about the actual money involved.

thepariscrimefiles · Today 06:41

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 23:10

No back story! It’s a pretty straightforward situation. He’s fit and healthy, just not naturally driven and has always favoured enjoying life and friends rather than aiming high and working hard when he was young. My dad enabled it by doing everything for him and spoiling him. I had the same upbringing but was naturally driven and met someone (my husband) like minded so ended up distancing myself from all that. My brother’s wife is genuinely lovely but more like my brother and they have made some poor choices in their lives. My dad struggles with the idea of his son not being as successful as he was so always tries and compensate with money, holidays, car etc

I can see why your parents helped him financially to buy the house but I'm still not sure why you contributed as well. He's made decisions that mean he doesn't have as much money as you because he prioritises having fun over earning money but that is no reason for you to have to subsidise his property purchase.

Did your parents put pressure on you to contribute? How do they behave if you push back and refuse or have you never done this?

It's obvious that as well as you being a source of funds for your parents and brother, they are lining you up to provide them with hands-on care and support. You need to be very clear that you will not be doing this. They obviously have enough money to buy the best care. I'm also sure that they have no expectations of your brother being any sort of help and support in their old age.

thepariscrimefiles · Today 06:54

CamomileB · Today 00:10

I find this very strange. They surely can spend their money how they like? And you have said yourself that you don’t need their money. If you did they would probably help you. Why the resentment? Them helping your brother financially doesn’t mean they love him more. Forget about it and try to enjoy their company.

OP was expected to contribute financially to her brother's house purchase which she did. Her parents are now expecting her to subsidise him buying a bigger and better house. Thankfully, she has refused to do this. This isn't normal or kind behaviour from her parents towards OP.

Bringemout · Today 06:55

The bit that gets me is they asked you to contribute to getting him a bigger house. It shows such a lack of self awareness. Not only do they want to sub him they want you to sub him so he appears more successful than he is.

I think you should lay it out but also don’t expect much. They do this because they believe it’s absolutely fine.

3luckystars · Today 07:00

It sounds like they think you are the third parent in the family.

I would just say ‘I am your child too’

tripleginandtonic · Today 07:14

Thingcanonlygetbetter · Yesterday 23:17

OMG that is wild! I would have made him pay that never mind gift it to him.

I'm assuming it was an accident? If so I think OP is being unreasonable.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread