Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents unfair with money, am I right to be resentful?

93 replies

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 21:45

Long story short: every time my brother has needed money to buy a house, my parents have helped him out financially.
The first time, they did it behind my back and had no plans to tell me. I only found out because they were staying with us and left an email open on the home computer.
Now it's happening again. They're giving him a large sum to buy a bigger house, and this time my dad told me himself because he wanted me to contribute too.

I should add that my husband and I lent my brother money for his first purchase (on top of my parents' gift), and they expected us to do the same again for the new purchase.
I told them we couldn't this time, as we have another project and need every penny. We also want to help our own children get on the property ladder. We left it there and everyone seemed fine with it, with my parents happy to top up. (To be clear my parents have more money than they will ever need but I’ve noticed my dad has become a bit careful/tight with age, which is why he asked me to help).

Since then I haven’t been able to shake the resentment. I don't even want to think about how much they've given him over the years. He relies on my parents for almost everything (money, babysitting, dog sitting, holidays), partly because of some poor life choices, and my dad can't bear that he doesn't have the lifestyle they do, so he tries to make up for it.
Meanwhile, they've never given me anything. They've always been loving and we get on well, but I suspect they assume I don't need help. That's partly true, but I work over 60 hours a week in a very demanding job I don't want to do forever, and I'd love to be able to help my kids buy a home too.
For the past week I've felt sad, disappointed and resentful. I haven't felt like calling them, and I've been short in my replies to their messages, which I feel bad about to some extent, but I can’t help.
I should also say that we are the exact opposite with our own children, perhaps as a reaction to all this. Whatever we give one, we give the others, or at least we're completely open about it and record everything officially so that no resentment or conflict builds up further down the line. That’s why I struggle even more with their behaviour.

Am I being unreasonable? Should I put it in perspective and let it go as life is too short, or talk to them? I’ve been thinking of finding the right moment to talk to my dad but I’d need to be very careful as money is taboo and conflicts do not exist in my family, so I'd need to be very diplomatic... Maybe worth adding I get on fairly well with my brother and his wife (without being overly close) and want to keep a good relationship. (Ironically, I think his situation is partly my dad's doing, since my parents have always spoiled him, killing any ambition and making him highly dependent on them).

Thanks in advance for your words of wisdom.

OP posts:
Jacopo · Today 00:09

If you don't want to address the issue directly with them you should at least take every opportunity to let them know how you are dealing with your own children. “Oh Olivia is going to Spain with the school, it’s costing £600 so we’re taking Johnathan and Harry to London for a weekend of fun. We always make sure all of them get the same - that’s only fair after all.” Repeat with similar examples at frequent intervals.

They are convinced you will do everything when they’re old and frail. Time to unsettle their convictions. It doesn’t have to be a full-on argument.

CamomileB · Today 00:10

I find this very strange. They surely can spend their money how they like? And you have said yourself that you don’t need their money. If you did they would probably help you. Why the resentment? Them helping your brother financially doesn’t mean they love him more. Forget about it and try to enjoy their company.

71Alex · Today 00:14

If your family is poor at communication, I fear the conversation won’t go well. My experience in a similar situation is that trying to discuss it made it worse.

WatermelonSalad1 · Today 00:14

@Seahorses26 “They're giving him a large sum to buy a bigger house, and this time my dad told me himself because he wanted me to contribute too”

have you ever asked your father why? I mean you can’t ask him about what he wants to do with his own money, but you can definitely ask him why he expects you to contribute to the purchase of your brother‘s house, that would be a totally legitimate question…. Because none of this makes sense. I feel as if there must be something here that you don’t know about ?

WatermelonSalad1 · Today 00:15

CamomileB · Today 00:10

I find this very strange. They surely can spend their money how they like? And you have said yourself that you don’t need their money. If you did they would probably help you. Why the resentment? Them helping your brother financially doesn’t mean they love him more. Forget about it and try to enjoy their company.

Well, maybe it does. Maybe it doesn’t.

But why would you want to treat your children unequally?

And did you miss the bit where OP is expected to contribute to her brother’s new house?

DiplomaticImNot · Today 00:16

And it's not really about the money/time,etc, it's the feelings behind it: that I'm not loved or wanted as much as my siblings.

I could see their will being unequal between us and to me that would prove 100% that they never loved me as much as they love my siblings, and that is what hurts.

Anonanonay · Today 00:17

DiplomaticImNot · Today 00:06

I had the chat, although mine was more general as it was also about attitude, time, effort, etc, rather than just monetary things.

If they're anything like my dps though, even if they see it, they won't admit it to you or themselves.

All I got back was:

"we treat you all exactly the same, and we don't know why you think/ feel otherwise."

It's not true, even objectively, but they can't or won't see it. I'm actually the middle child, though.

In a rare moment, shortly before my df passed away, my mum said I was always the independent one, and that I've never needed them, like my siblings do.

That's not true; I've just never had the choice/ chance to lean on them because it was never offered.

I'd have to say something (as I did), but just be prepared that it may not change anything.

Mine didn't really, but I am glad I said how I feel.

Although saying that, since my df died, I do feel that my DM tries to include me in more things than she would've previously done, eg, I'll now sometimes get an invite when her and my sister go out to lunch, etc. (And it's never that I can't go, they just don't normally ask).

A few years back when my df was still alive, all my siblings, parents and siblings' partners, and dc went on holiday together without me.

I wasn't even asked, and when I found out, all I got was that they didn't think I'd be able to go/want to go.

All I said was that it wouldn't have hurt to actually ask me rather than assume (and I would've gone, but it was too late by then).

Good luck 💐,

Good grief, the holiday thing is appalling. I'm not sure I'd be able to speak to any of them again. What an absolutely c*ntish thing for them all to do.

WatermelonSalad1 · Today 00:18

Could it be something like

dad want to be able to tell people that son is doing really well and if he canpoint things like a big house that will help ? He can pretend his son is earning more and doing better or something.

Anonanonay · Today 00:18

I think you should tell them, OP, Their behaviour is awful.

JMSA · Today 00:22

Your brother is a total loser.

MitheredNotDead · Today 00:24

Presume the cash you’ve given your DB before with his earlier house purchase hasn’t been paid back?

I’d be asking your parents to refund it to you as they’re so fond of subbing the feckless fucker. I’d pay it on thick that you need the cash for the kids’ future.

CamomileB · Today 00:30

WatermelonSalad1 · Today 00:15

Well, maybe it does. Maybe it doesn’t.

But why would you want to treat your children unequally?

And did you miss the bit where OP is expected to contribute to her brother’s new house?

I read it as a request for a loan that was declined and everyone moved on. I don’t think that helping one sibling more is treating children unequally, if one needs help and the other doesn’t. If she’d asked for help and they’d said no that would be a different matter. I don’t think we should feel we have a right to out parents’ money. I am one of seven children - my parents have helped some of us more than others over the years based on need. I don’t see it as any of my business and feel it has zero bearing on how much they love us all. Life is too short to get resentful about money, especially when you have enough of it to have a comfortable life.

OneNewEagle · Today 00:38

The only bit that’s not ok was asking you to help your brother too.

but they are free to help their children as and when required.

OneNewEagle · Today 00:42

CamomileB · Today 00:30

I read it as a request for a loan that was declined and everyone moved on. I don’t think that helping one sibling more is treating children unequally, if one needs help and the other doesn’t. If she’d asked for help and they’d said no that would be a different matter. I don’t think we should feel we have a right to out parents’ money. I am one of seven children - my parents have helped some of us more than others over the years based on need. I don’t see it as any of my business and feel it has zero bearing on how much they love us all. Life is too short to get resentful about money, especially when you have enough of it to have a comfortable life.

I agree. I’m from a big family. People are helped as and when required if ever.

I have not had help and won’t be getting any but that’s a whole other story (I’m the eldest so deemed not to need any).

One of my sisters had her wedding paid for, help with deposit for first house, help with extension on the house, help with new windows. A brother had help with wedding, help with buying first house.

and as a parent I’ve been helping my DC recently. If I had more kids they’d get help when they urgently needed it not at any other time.

PivotPivotmakingmargaritas · Today 00:44

DiplomaticImNot · Today 00:06

I had the chat, although mine was more general as it was also about attitude, time, effort, etc, rather than just monetary things.

If they're anything like my dps though, even if they see it, they won't admit it to you or themselves.

All I got back was:

"we treat you all exactly the same, and we don't know why you think/ feel otherwise."

It's not true, even objectively, but they can't or won't see it. I'm actually the middle child, though.

In a rare moment, shortly before my df passed away, my mum said I was always the independent one, and that I've never needed them, like my siblings do.

That's not true; I've just never had the choice/ chance to lean on them because it was never offered.

I'd have to say something (as I did), but just be prepared that it may not change anything.

Mine didn't really, but I am glad I said how I feel.

Although saying that, since my df died, I do feel that my DM tries to include me in more things than she would've previously done, eg, I'll now sometimes get an invite when her and my sister go out to lunch, etc. (And it's never that I can't go, they just don't normally ask).

A few years back when my df was still alive, all my siblings, parents and siblings' partners, and dc went on holiday together without me.

I wasn't even asked, and when I found out, all I got was that they didn't think I'd be able to go/want to go.

All I said was that it wouldn't have hurt to actually ask me rather than assume (and I would've gone, but it was too late by then).

Good luck 💐,

Good grief… that’s horrible! Hope you are now very low contact - that’s so cruel

cornflakecrunchie · Today 00:50

I'm sorry, @Seahorses26 I'd drop the lot of them like a hot brick.
I can't BEAR unfairness or injustice. Especially from anyone who's supposed to love me.
I just couldn't live with it.

HRTtoHeart · Today 00:59

The first time, they did it behind my back and had no plans to tell me

This is where you're being unreasonable, OP. It's their money. It's their son. They don't have to run their spending plans past you.

notallthosewhotravelarelost · Today 01:23

Has your brother ever paid you back the money you gave for his first house?

I'd be unable to keep swallowing this and agree I'd want to ask why they would expect you to fund your brother's lifestyle. I'd probably end up doing this in response to a comment about working too many hours and it would get fraught and be unconstructive. Much better to tackle this when you are calmer and able to put across your perspective. You could use house deposits for your kids as a reason.

I think my family are very fair when it comes to money but by God do they favour my elder brother. I'm generally expected to put up and shut up and do what everyone else wants, whatever I want or have planned. I've discussed this with my brother in the last few years and he was a bit oblivious to it all - we get on better now. In my case it is good old fashioned sexismm and an expectation of a family hierarchy that I have just opted out of.

99bottlesofkombucha · Today 01:31

just as part of the answer, I would not fill the competence gap for them. I would work hard at making your brother do his share, and you do that by not doing it yourself. ‘We need to do x could you help?’ ‘Not that weekend but I’m sure John can, it would be his thing really. I’m pretty busy I’ll leave that one to John.’ Group message ‘John mum and dad need x, I’m busy at the moment and you’d be good at it, am leaving it to you.’

Mummyoflittledragon · Today 01:48

I would go with telling your parents you’re struggling to keep up with your demanding job, you’re getting older and ask for the equivalent to what they gave your brother both times to be distributed to your kids as house deposits.

BruFord · Today 01:49

Perhaps the easiest way to address this is to ask them for some financial help with your upcoming project. They think that you don't need their help, so why don't you ask them for some and see what happens.

If you're working over 60 hours a week and they tell you that you work too hard - perhaps helping you out too would enable you to cut down?

I'm assuming, of course, that they can afford to do this.

@Mummyoflittledragon Yes, she could also ask for something for her children.

JigsawPuzzler2 · Today 02:08

CamomileB · Today 00:10

I find this very strange. They surely can spend their money how they like? And you have said yourself that you don’t need their money. If you did they would probably help you. Why the resentment? Them helping your brother financially doesn’t mean they love him more. Forget about it and try to enjoy their company.

This.It is their money, not yours
Why do you think you have any right to a say in their spending decisions?

ImaginationDragon · Today 03:15

Its pretty wild. What did you say to him when he said he wanted you to contribute to your DB house upgrade? It makes it worse as it is a 2nd house and he is just wanting an upgrade. Didnt you tell him you are working 60 hours a week, exhausting yourself to try and keep up with what you have built and look out for your DC future and not prepared to do that work to just pass it on to DB?

My DD come with me to buy a new car. I was only just had it confirmed I would be getting a very generous car allowance from work and a payrise. I love cars and was very excited to go choose a brand new 1 (car allowance rules said it had to be less than 12 months old), selling my car was to be my deposit, but I needed a £500 down-payment that day. My dad said he would cover it and I pay him back when I sold my car when the new car was ready. When that time come my dad said he dont want the money back and would give £500 to my sibling to make it equal. My sibling is married and they outearned me and my parents by a substantial amount at that time, but this is how I would expect things to be. Just because you have done better in life, doesn't mean the extra support wouldn't be appreciated

user1492757084 · Today 03:20

I would leave it be. You don't need help.
Your brother is also secure.

Do you know what is in your parents' Wills?
If you are an executor, you might need to ask your parents to leave their financial details very clear.

Do they keep their gifts noted?
Do they want those gifts repaid, technically?

Your parents are at liberty to help any person or charity as they see fit.

AmnesiacDream · Today 03:28

I would work out what you want first. I don't think you can reasonably ask them to just not give your brother money. But if you want to get to the point where you can work less and spend more time with your family and an injection of cash in a similar amount to what they've given your DB would do that for you, you can perhaps broach that. Or if your DC are ready to get on the housing ladder, perhaps that would be the way to go.

I don't see how these conversations can be as entirely taboo as you seem to think, because they've clearly been having them with your brother.

Swipe left for the next trending thread