Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents unfair with money, am I right to be resentful?

94 replies

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 21:45

Long story short: every time my brother has needed money to buy a house, my parents have helped him out financially.
The first time, they did it behind my back and had no plans to tell me. I only found out because they were staying with us and left an email open on the home computer.
Now it's happening again. They're giving him a large sum to buy a bigger house, and this time my dad told me himself because he wanted me to contribute too.

I should add that my husband and I lent my brother money for his first purchase (on top of my parents' gift), and they expected us to do the same again for the new purchase.
I told them we couldn't this time, as we have another project and need every penny. We also want to help our own children get on the property ladder. We left it there and everyone seemed fine with it, with my parents happy to top up. (To be clear my parents have more money than they will ever need but I’ve noticed my dad has become a bit careful/tight with age, which is why he asked me to help).

Since then I haven’t been able to shake the resentment. I don't even want to think about how much they've given him over the years. He relies on my parents for almost everything (money, babysitting, dog sitting, holidays), partly because of some poor life choices, and my dad can't bear that he doesn't have the lifestyle they do, so he tries to make up for it.
Meanwhile, they've never given me anything. They've always been loving and we get on well, but I suspect they assume I don't need help. That's partly true, but I work over 60 hours a week in a very demanding job I don't want to do forever, and I'd love to be able to help my kids buy a home too.
For the past week I've felt sad, disappointed and resentful. I haven't felt like calling them, and I've been short in my replies to their messages, which I feel bad about to some extent, but I can’t help.
I should also say that we are the exact opposite with our own children, perhaps as a reaction to all this. Whatever we give one, we give the others, or at least we're completely open about it and record everything officially so that no resentment or conflict builds up further down the line. That’s why I struggle even more with their behaviour.

Am I being unreasonable? Should I put it in perspective and let it go as life is too short, or talk to them? I’ve been thinking of finding the right moment to talk to my dad but I’d need to be very careful as money is taboo and conflicts do not exist in my family, so I'd need to be very diplomatic... Maybe worth adding I get on fairly well with my brother and his wife (without being overly close) and want to keep a good relationship. (Ironically, I think his situation is partly my dad's doing, since my parents have always spoiled him, killing any ambition and making him highly dependent on them).

Thanks in advance for your words of wisdom.

OP posts:
MissingMeadow · Yesterday 21:47

I'd tell them how you feel. I'm not one for keeping things in though.

DanceMumTaxi · Yesterday 21:49

I would feel the same as you. It’s not fair at all.

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · Yesterday 21:50

As you have a good relationship with them I would talk to them about it. I would guess you are the coper who never asks for help so they think you don’t need it or want it. I do find it really odd theybexpect you to lend money to your brother though. Has he paid you back from the first time?

my parents are scrupulously fair and will always match the value of a gift to one with a gift to the other even though one of us is better off financially. It makes family relationships harmonious!

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · Yesterday 21:54

I think as a parent you always jump to save whoever’s in trouble/ can’t get to the standard you’d like them to reach. Not fair on the other sibling but I’d guess you see it as they got to where they needed to.

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · Yesterday 21:55

OP are you the oldest?

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 21:58

MissingMeadow · Yesterday 21:47

I'd tell them how you feel. I'm not one for keeping things in though.

That’s what I’ve been tempted to do and my husband is advising me to do. I’m taking them on holidays soon (been planned a while ago), which might be a good time to have the conversation. However I’ve been wondering if it’s worth it, hence this post.
My dad is old; he’s healthy but he won’t be with us forever, and I don’t want to come across like I’m obsessed with money. Also this type of discussion is pretty taboo in the family so it won’t be comfortable.
Yet this resentment keeps haunting me, and I can't stop feeling annoyed.

OP posts:
Coconutcreamz · Yesterday 21:58

Your father is an unfair CF.
Asking you whom works 60 hours to pay again for your brothers house.
Bloody hell OP.
How can you be so soft?

Completely unfair.
Also how controlling and messed up is your family?

They can impose on you for money but you cannot say anything?

How old are you?
You sound utterly controlled and trained to behave as they demand.

That is so messed up.

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 21:59

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · Yesterday 21:55

OP are you the oldest?

Yes

OP posts:
canklesmctacotits · Yesterday 22:01

I wouldn’t say anything. Nobody is in a position to judge another person’s parenting of their own child. “It’s not fair” doesn’t cut it in an adult - may not be fair, but what are you going to do about it? They obviously know it’s not fair, and they made the choice to continue anyway. You can only control your own behaviour.

But I wouldn’t give anything more. Definitely not.

LittleRedRidingBoots · Yesterday 22:03

I feel for you OP. It is similar in my family - my parents do and provide everything for my brother and minimal for me. I tried to have a conversation with my mum about it and it got me nowhere. So now I keep my mouth shut and my head down, but the resentment remains :(

Namechangedasouting987 · Yesterday 22:04

What they do with their money is up to them.
Asking you to contribute to your brother's house purchase is out of order (both times btw).
We helped DHs brother with several house moves. It annoys me but its DHs money.
My dad helps my brother more than me too.
But I dont need his money. So say nothing. It isnt worth the hassle to me.
Both DH and I are eldest kids and work v hard for our money. It is what it is.

Thingcanonlygetbetter · Yesterday 22:10

It’s tough OP, my parents are the same with my brother. I have worked so hard to achieve what I have and he just gets handed all the time. I know I will have the lions share of care to do in the future while he will reap the rewards in their will. I could never do it to my own kids. It actually hurts me and makes me sad.

LeafInTheSchnauzerBeard · Yesterday 22:11

The thing is it isn’t about the money - it’s about the attitude behind it. Maybe you should explain to them that there have been times you have really struggled with your long working hours and some help babysitting/dog walking/financial like they give your brother would have been really appreciated and that as your children have aged you’ve realised how it makes you feel like they care about you less. its not about the money but the fact they seem to care more for your brother by being so pivotal in his life whereas they are not in yours

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 22:13

@Coconutcreamz I’m in my late 40s. My husband says exactly the same (about the controlling aspect) as it was a lot worse when we were younger. I took a lot of distance since. It's a strange situation, as I've always got on well with my dad, better than with my mum. But it's true that he has always tried to control everything in our lives and do everything for us, which drives my husband mad. Looking back, I don't think he means any harm. He does it out of love, and he genuinely believes he’s helping. But it has clearly gone too far, and it's damaging our relationships. And completely screwed up my brother’s life as made him so dependent.

OP posts:
AbouttimeIhadanewusername · Yesterday 22:21

OP, Yes I grew up with my mother always treating my brother more generously than my sister and I. My husband and I always make sure we treat put children the same. I am fairly LC with my mother now.
You should speak to your parents about it and why on earth are you taking them on holiday or having them to stay when they don’t treat you well.

Nofeckingway · Yesterday 22:21

My parents gave us each according to our needs at the time . So paid for my wedding , paid for my brother's mature adult education, helped my sister with house deposit. Very generous with my kids too. This is while they were alive as they said they enjoyed seeing us benefit. None of us ever commented at the time as to whether anything was unequal. They thought they should leave house to my unmarried siblings but solicitor advised that it would be the most divisive thing to do , so left to all of us .
I don't really think you should comment on how they are choosing to give their money while they are still well able to be in charge of their own finances . It would be hard for them to see one child successful and the other struggle. Although like you , I am the oldest and the most financially OK . Ironically after my parents died I did continue to occasionally help my siblings out .

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 22:23

@Thingcanonlygetbetter @Namechangedasouting987 @LittleRedRidingBoots Thank you for sharing your experience. It sounds so similar to mine. I’m sorry but knowing I'm not the only one in this situation is a relief in itself, and it makes it easier to accept!

OP posts:
mysittingduck · Yesterday 22:26

What do you actually want your parents to do?

Holdinguphalfthesky · Yesterday 22:30

So many families where the boy is prioritised and advantaged over his sister, yet it’s the girl who makes a success of her survival. Why are boys so highly favoured, again?

NotAnotherScarf · Yesterday 22:33

MissingMeadow · Yesterday 21:47

I'd tell them how you feel. I'm not one for keeping things in though.

I'm with you my wife isn't. But mil is 97 and sil will find out that her selfishness has excluded her from her family once mil has gone

Thingcanonlygetbetter · Yesterday 22:34

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 22:23

@Thingcanonlygetbetter @Namechangedasouting987 @LittleRedRidingBoots Thank you for sharing your experience. It sounds so similar to mine. I’m sorry but knowing I'm not the only one in this situation is a relief in itself, and it makes it easier to accept!

And if you say anything you sound like an ungrateful greedy brat. I have made a few comments but they just go over their heads. I think the world is getting harder and I am actually not thinking of me at this stage but my kids. My brother will have over a million pounds of property and I am getting a 115k house. That is more of an inheritance than many will get and I understand that. But it is the inequality. We do so much for them, they keep telling me I work to hard 🤣 I have no choice as want to do the best for my kids. Telling me to slow down does my head in. They have even made comments that I will need to clear the house when their day is done but it is not going to be my house. Do you think it is because we as older women have just been hard working and get on with things while our brothers are just parented to death. I do be particularly disappointed in my mother as a woman to not recognise the unfairness. Tbh I will not be giving up my career to care for them.

AwksBut · Yesterday 22:38

I could have written most of that OP. I'm right here with you on these feelings.

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 22:38

mysittingduck · Yesterday 22:26

What do you actually want your parents to do?

That's a fair question, and honestly I'm not sure myself. I mentioned in my OP that the money could help with deposits for the kids' houses or another project, but in reality we don't need it. More is always welcome, but we've done very well for ourselves. Asking them for money would feel awkward, and I'd worry about coming across as money-obsessed.
Maybe it’s just letting my dad know about I feel and move on.

OP posts:
PancakeCloud · Yesterday 22:39

Is there a reason your brother might need additional financial help. Why did you choose to give him money yourself? Surely there’s more to this.

PropertyD · Yesterday 22:42

Are there cultural considerations here?