Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents unfair with money, am I right to be resentful?

93 replies

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 21:45

Long story short: every time my brother has needed money to buy a house, my parents have helped him out financially.
The first time, they did it behind my back and had no plans to tell me. I only found out because they were staying with us and left an email open on the home computer.
Now it's happening again. They're giving him a large sum to buy a bigger house, and this time my dad told me himself because he wanted me to contribute too.

I should add that my husband and I lent my brother money for his first purchase (on top of my parents' gift), and they expected us to do the same again for the new purchase.
I told them we couldn't this time, as we have another project and need every penny. We also want to help our own children get on the property ladder. We left it there and everyone seemed fine with it, with my parents happy to top up. (To be clear my parents have more money than they will ever need but I’ve noticed my dad has become a bit careful/tight with age, which is why he asked me to help).

Since then I haven’t been able to shake the resentment. I don't even want to think about how much they've given him over the years. He relies on my parents for almost everything (money, babysitting, dog sitting, holidays), partly because of some poor life choices, and my dad can't bear that he doesn't have the lifestyle they do, so he tries to make up for it.
Meanwhile, they've never given me anything. They've always been loving and we get on well, but I suspect they assume I don't need help. That's partly true, but I work over 60 hours a week in a very demanding job I don't want to do forever, and I'd love to be able to help my kids buy a home too.
For the past week I've felt sad, disappointed and resentful. I haven't felt like calling them, and I've been short in my replies to their messages, which I feel bad about to some extent, but I can’t help.
I should also say that we are the exact opposite with our own children, perhaps as a reaction to all this. Whatever we give one, we give the others, or at least we're completely open about it and record everything officially so that no resentment or conflict builds up further down the line. That’s why I struggle even more with their behaviour.

Am I being unreasonable? Should I put it in perspective and let it go as life is too short, or talk to them? I’ve been thinking of finding the right moment to talk to my dad but I’d need to be very careful as money is taboo and conflicts do not exist in my family, so I'd need to be very diplomatic... Maybe worth adding I get on fairly well with my brother and his wife (without being overly close) and want to keep a good relationship. (Ironically, I think his situation is partly my dad's doing, since my parents have always spoiled him, killing any ambition and making him highly dependent on them).

Thanks in advance for your words of wisdom.

OP posts:
Lavenderwhite · Yesterday 22:43

My parents have given my DB more money than me and I also know their will favours him more than me. I am married with kids and work full time, on paper successful but stressful, DB is single and has never worked.

I chose not to discuss it with my parents as I was worried about causing a big fallout (we don’t communicate well as a family). I’m now realising over the years that I’ve become resentful, so I fear it will now ruin our relationship either way. If you have a decent relationship with them I would err towards speaking to them about it.

Isittimeformynapyet · Yesterday 22:44

My Dad gave my brother £1,200 because he'd given me that amount to get my front teeth capped nicely. He wanted to be "fair".

It was my brother who'd smashed my teeth out in the first place, with a torch when we were younger.

I'm still resentful. My brother essentially got paid for permanently injuring me.

PropertyD · Yesterday 22:45

Your brother is being given money- why is he wanting to move etc if he can’t afford it? I get that your parents are helping him
but why do they expect you to do so too?

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 22:47

@Thingcanonlygetbetter ”We do so much for them, they keep telling me I work to hard”.
Do we have the same parents??!! My mum keeps telling me I work way too much and should slow down to spend more time with my family. Well I’m not given free money and have to help everyone so I need to work!!
I wonder if they have an agenda here and want me to spend more time with them? I already help them with many aspects of their life, especially since they’ve moved closer, whereas my brother just takes.

OP posts:
Mary46 · Yesterday 22:49

Op its hard agree. Ours is really mean will get some grandkids nothing. Then give to others. I try and ignore it but no not nice. Parents can be weird lol

Namechangedoverandover · Yesterday 22:51

Thingcanonlygetbetter · Yesterday 22:34

And if you say anything you sound like an ungrateful greedy brat. I have made a few comments but they just go over their heads. I think the world is getting harder and I am actually not thinking of me at this stage but my kids. My brother will have over a million pounds of property and I am getting a 115k house. That is more of an inheritance than many will get and I understand that. But it is the inequality. We do so much for them, they keep telling me I work to hard 🤣 I have no choice as want to do the best for my kids. Telling me to slow down does my head in. They have even made comments that I will need to clear the house when their day is done but it is not going to be my house. Do you think it is because we as older women have just been hard working and get on with things while our brothers are just parented to death. I do be particularly disappointed in my mother as a woman to not recognise the unfairness. Tbh I will not be giving up my career to care for them.

"We do so much for them"

Isn't this part of the problem? That despite the rampant favouritism of your sibling by your parents and the resentfulness it causes you, you are still trying so hard to prove yourself worthy of their love? Why?

Why do so many women not only put up with it but also then run themselves ragged being their parents' carer while golden child provides minimal or no help but safe in the knowledge their parents will provide for them handsomely in their will?

You may love your parents but if they make such unreasonable requests of you so that they can continue to provide such largesse to a sibling, you need to start withdrawing from them to protect your sanity.

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 22:51

PropertyD · Yesterday 22:42

Are there cultural considerations here?

No, not at all!

OP posts:
seahorsessky · Yesterday 22:53

I get that some people say let them sink or swim, and if you stop making things easy, they'll sort themselves out. But a man who was always good at school. got a good job and then settled family etc had a sister who kept having issues-never did well at school, got involved in crime, never looked for work, got. The parents said they'd helped enough and they were going to be cruel to be kind. She kept going down hill and was dead at 30.
Not saying that always happens, but I can see what your parents are thinking, of they've seen similar happen.

lessglittermoremud · Yesterday 22:54

Personally I wouldn’t say anything because whatever you say it won’t make any difference to how differently you are treated.
If discussing money is taboo within your family and they can’t already see that their behaviour is wrong then raising it, when you want to keep good relationships with them all won’t give you the outcome you’re looking for.
I don’t understand why you gave your brother money alongside your parents for his first house?

PyongyangKipperbang · Yesterday 22:58

I think that you do need to talk to them (and actually saying to your mum, next time she says about you working too much, exactly what you said here) but dont do it on holiday.

I doubt it will go well and then you are all stuck there with a bad atmosphere and a ruined holiday. I would have the conversation now and get it over with.

Thingcanonlygetbetter · Yesterday 23:03

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 22:47

@Thingcanonlygetbetter ”We do so much for them, they keep telling me I work to hard”.
Do we have the same parents??!! My mum keeps telling me I work way too much and should slow down to spend more time with my family. Well I’m not given free money and have to help everyone so I need to work!!
I wonder if they have an agenda here and want me to spend more time with them? I already help them with many aspects of their life, especially since they’ve moved closer, whereas my brother just takes.

We must do! I think my parents would love if I quit work and run round after them all the time. They have an amazing social life but my mother is always bloody complaining. I do so much online for them and pay for things and when I tell them they owe me the money they act like they are giving me money. But it is money I spent for things for them. My SIL let slip what they have got them for Christmas and it is nice. My husband who is so good to them once got a bottle of wine they got free in a hotel. He doesn’t drink wine. I am nearly obsessive at treating mine equally. My daughter is my eldest and she is such a worker. She earned all the money for a school trip working for me. My son just couldn’t do the work to the standards required (I have tried to get him to do it, showed him and showed him but it was a nightmare and nearly cost me time). He now has a school trip and I don’t want him not to go as I know most kids would just get the money handed to them. So we are paying his trip. I am going to give my daughter the same amount of money as his trip is costing. I don’t want this pattern repeating just because someone is competent another person just gets given. My brother does say he feels for me but he is not going to rock the boat ( or should I say luxury liner)

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 23:10

PancakeCloud · Yesterday 22:39

Is there a reason your brother might need additional financial help. Why did you choose to give him money yourself? Surely there’s more to this.

No back story! It’s a pretty straightforward situation. He’s fit and healthy, just not naturally driven and has always favoured enjoying life and friends rather than aiming high and working hard when he was young. My dad enabled it by doing everything for him and spoiling him. I had the same upbringing but was naturally driven and met someone (my husband) like minded so ended up distancing myself from all that. My brother’s wife is genuinely lovely but more like my brother and they have made some poor choices in their lives. My dad struggles with the idea of his son not being as successful as he was so always tries and compensate with money, holidays, car etc

OP posts:
Peclet · Yesterday 23:12

dh is one of 3, and apart from a small contribution to our first home DH has had nothing. Compared to his siblings who have neeeded more and gotten more.

PILS recently had a family meeting where they showed all the comings and goings and basically there is ledger and what has been done now is balanced in the inheritance.

I had nothing to do with this but DH WAS STUNNED. Never asked for never expected but it was refreshing to know that in the end it was all accounted for.

could there be something similar happening with your family?

Mrsclaude · Yesterday 23:15

I think you have every right to have the conversation and explain how the inequitable treatment has made you feel…but I would encourage you to think realistically on what the actual result will be, you know them better than all of us.
In my family, there would be no point. They are elderly, set in their ways and favoring a sibling has been their lifelong habit that they weren’t going to change now. Me bringing it up would ultimately only hurt me, because they would carry on in their behavior and have the added storyline that I was creating drama/jealous/etc. I decided it wasn’t worth it.

Thingcanonlygetbetter · Yesterday 23:17

Isittimeformynapyet · Yesterday 22:44

My Dad gave my brother £1,200 because he'd given me that amount to get my front teeth capped nicely. He wanted to be "fair".

It was my brother who'd smashed my teeth out in the first place, with a torch when we were younger.

I'm still resentful. My brother essentially got paid for permanently injuring me.

OMG that is wild! I would have made him pay that never mind gift it to him.

Thingcanonlygetbetter · Yesterday 23:19

Peclet · Yesterday 23:12

dh is one of 3, and apart from a small contribution to our first home DH has had nothing. Compared to his siblings who have neeeded more and gotten more.

PILS recently had a family meeting where they showed all the comings and goings and basically there is ledger and what has been done now is balanced in the inheritance.

I had nothing to do with this but DH WAS STUNNED. Never asked for never expected but it was refreshing to know that in the end it was all accounted for.

could there be something similar happening with your family?

That is a fabulous way to operate! So fair

MidlifeMiseryGuts · Yesterday 23:20

Isittimeformynapyet · Yesterday 22:44

My Dad gave my brother £1,200 because he'd given me that amount to get my front teeth capped nicely. He wanted to be "fair".

It was my brother who'd smashed my teeth out in the first place, with a torch when we were younger.

I'm still resentful. My brother essentially got paid for permanently injuring me.

That is the most dreadful thing I’ve ever read. I don’t think I’d ever be able to let that go

Isittimeformynapyet · Yesterday 23:20

Thingcanonlygetbetter · Yesterday 23:17

OMG that is wild! I would have made him pay that never mind gift it to him.

In principle yes, but my brother has never had that kind of money available. He's one of life's losers.

Genevieva · Yesterday 23:25

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 21:58

That’s what I’ve been tempted to do and my husband is advising me to do. I’m taking them on holidays soon (been planned a while ago), which might be a good time to have the conversation. However I’ve been wondering if it’s worth it, hence this post.
My dad is old; he’s healthy but he won’t be with us forever, and I don’t want to come across like I’m obsessed with money. Also this type of discussion is pretty taboo in the family so it won’t be comfortable.
Yet this resentment keeps haunting me, and I can't stop feeling annoyed.

Yes it’s worth it. Fairness is important in families and unfairness can ruin relationships. Even if you don’t want a bigger house, you might invest the money for your children.

Updownaroundandaround · Yesterday 23:25

Totally unfair OP. I totally get your feeling of resentment and not wanting to talk to them. Even though my own parents are fair with giving money (they are very tight though) they travel to stay with me for up three months a year and to my brother for 4 days.

Something happened recently with their tightness after having provided for them 24/7 for 3 months that tipped me over the edge to the resentment so it sounds similar that the resentment has come to a head. I would bring it up although appreciate it's difficult.💐

Maybeitllneverhappen · Yesterday 23:25

Good luck having a conversation. My parents always prioritised my sister (not just financially). My dad died quite a while ago and my mum got even worse about it. I finally exploded 5 years ago and decades of unfairness shot out of my mouth. My mum was stunned and sort of apologized, but has since carried on exactly the same! She told my sister who was furious and now my relationship is seriously damaged with both of them. I hope your conversation goes better!

PivotPivotmakingmargaritas · Yesterday 23:28

I think you should say something- before the holiday to allow them to process everything before your holiday so it doesn’t spoil the holiday.

Especially as they are asking you to do more and more for them.

Watch the SNL skit “sister” - it’s a skit but so so accurate how daughters and sisters end up doing the caring while brothers take and take!

Maybe think of what you want to happen from your conversation- help with funds for your children so you can work less! Or more in the will for your children.

Don’t let a lazy brother cause you to be angry and upset as women we need to start calling out these practices of the sons being supported more.

Isittimeformynapyet · Yesterday 23:39

PivotPivotmakingmargaritas · Yesterday 23:28

I think you should say something- before the holiday to allow them to process everything before your holiday so it doesn’t spoil the holiday.

Especially as they are asking you to do more and more for them.

Watch the SNL skit “sister” - it’s a skit but so so accurate how daughters and sisters end up doing the caring while brothers take and take!

Maybe think of what you want to happen from your conversation- help with funds for your children so you can work less! Or more in the will for your children.

Don’t let a lazy brother cause you to be angry and upset as women we need to start calling out these practices of the sons being supported more.

as women we need to start calling out these practices of the sons being supported more.

I don't think this is a feminist issue - it's just what's happening in OP's particular family.

There are plenty of similar situations where the sexes of the offspring are reversed, and where they are both female or male.

Chilly80 · Yesterday 23:54

From another prospective you should feel sorry for them. They have lived a life being disappointed in their son. They can't just love him for who he is.
While they sound really proud of you.

I would still be really annoyed though. I don't have any siblings so can't compare. My inlaws are completely fair and equal, in a way too much as we all get matching Christmas presents of generic gifts rather than items we each individually would like.

DiplomaticImNot · Today 00:06

Seahorses26 · Yesterday 22:23

@Thingcanonlygetbetter @Namechangedasouting987 @LittleRedRidingBoots Thank you for sharing your experience. It sounds so similar to mine. I’m sorry but knowing I'm not the only one in this situation is a relief in itself, and it makes it easier to accept!

I had the chat, although mine was more general as it was also about attitude, time, effort, etc, rather than just monetary things.

If they're anything like my dps though, even if they see it, they won't admit it to you or themselves.

All I got back was:

"we treat you all exactly the same, and we don't know why you think/ feel otherwise."

It's not true, even objectively, but they can't or won't see it. I'm actually the middle child, though.

In a rare moment, shortly before my df passed away, my mum said I was always the independent one, and that I've never needed them, like my siblings do.

That's not true; I've just never had the choice/ chance to lean on them because it was never offered.

I'd have to say something (as I did), but just be prepared that it may not change anything.

Mine didn't really, but I am glad I said how I feel.

Although saying that, since my df died, I do feel that my DM tries to include me in more things than she would've previously done, eg, I'll now sometimes get an invite when her and my sister go out to lunch, etc. (And it's never that I can't go, they just don't normally ask).

A few years back when my df was still alive, all my siblings, parents and siblings' partners, and dc went on holiday together without me.

I wasn't even asked, and when I found out, all I got was that they didn't think I'd be able to go/want to go.

All I said was that it wouldn't have hurt to actually ask me rather than assume (and I would've gone, but it was too late by then).

Good luck 💐,

Swipe left for the next trending thread