Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Hate Andy Burnham?

105 replies

Sausagenbacon · Today 17:51

He stands for Makerfield (a Leave seat) and makes a speech saying it wouldn't be a good idea to investigate returning to the EU.
Only a few months later starts doing the exact opposite.
And this isn't about Brexit, it's about a politician telling bare faced lies. Just to get into power.

OP posts:
Hatty65 · Today 17:56

He's a politician. Aren't they (mostly) all liars? I'm not defending him particularly, just wondering how you can feel so bitter about it.

They've all lied to get into power!

Sausagenbacon · Today 17:57

I hear what you say, but it was just so transparent.

OP posts:
Maddy70 · Today 17:58

He hasn't returned to the EU. He's just getting better deals than the botched previous deals

Sausagenbacon · Today 18:02

That's not how it works. The EU won't accept a partial return

OP posts:
Woollyguru · Today 18:03

Now he's PM he has to consider the whole country not just his constituency

Winewolfhywls · Today 18:04

I'm glad he's taking us closer to Europe. Political and economic reasons make us safer and with potentially higher standards of living long term. Many people who voted leave them would not vote leave now.

needastrongone · Today 18:04

He’s improving the deals that were originally agreed….

GoodkneeBadKnee · Today 18:07

I think he's doing the right thing re closer ties to Europe.

AmberSpy · Today 18:08

He isn't taking us back into the EU. A second referendum may well be a Labour manifesto pledge at the next election but we are not going to just sneak back in with nobody noticing.

whateventoputhere · Today 18:15

Don’t be silly it’s not a ‘leave seat’ - that vote was 10 years ago, due to population changes (e.g the more pro leave voters being older and younger people becoming able to vote) basically everywhere is Remain now.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Today 18:16

What he said in Makerfield was that even though he’s always said he’d like to re-join in his lifetime (I mean, he literally wrote that in a book, so there’s no pretending people didn’t understand his feelings on the E.U), he would not be pushing for a rejoin or another referendum this parliament. And he isn’t doing that.

But as a PP has said, he doesn’t just represent Makerfield - he represents the whole of the country, and it’s increasingly clear that a majority of the country think Brexit was a failure and want a closer relationship with the EU. I think the deal he has negotiated is much better than what we had.

Timeforabiscuit · Today 18:22

I think hate is a strong position, especially when compared with Boris Johnsons illegal prorogation of parliament to get his way on Brexit.

Burnham's being thoroughly transparent (and legal!).

Pinkflamingo10 · Today 18:24

But he’s got such pretty eyelashes !

Hiredgun · Today 18:26

He’s doing what Burnham does best and looking after his own interests with the hopes of getting in with the EU once the electorate kick him out.

Sometimessmiling · Today 18:26

Sausagenbacon · Today 18:02

That's not how it works. The EU won't accept a partial return

They are though. We need this

SevenYellowHammers · Today 18:28

I am uncomfortable with the lack of democracy around returning to EU (in some shape or form). It doesn’t sit well.

BUT I think it’s the correct thing to do. There’s a lot of duality in my thinking there, I grant you.

Without getting into why I think Brexit is an unmitigated disaster (to respect OP’s wishes), it was a terrible mistake and can’t be put right comfortably and easily.

I have much sympathy for people who live in deindustrialised areas who may feel that immigration is to blame but I think that putting employment at the top of the agenda is vital for the whole country but particularly for the areas that Thatcher attacked.

I think Burnham is doing a good job for the country in desperate circumstances. It’s dreadful that this country no longer has a proper car industry and that we’re buying EVs from China, that is but one area that could help build employment in deindustrialised areas and consumption of products across the country.

Don’t hate OP. I’m really annoyed with Farage, Johnson, Cameron and - yes - Corbyn for getting us into this mess but I don’t hate. We’ve lost two politicians and one retired politician to hate, we don’t need more hate.

UnoriginalPoster · Today 18:30

And this isn't about Brexit, it's about a politician telling bare faced lies. Just to get into power.

You conveniently ignore that the Leave campaign was basically politicians telling bare faced lies to get into power, or to stay in power.

Thedogscollar · Today 18:31

His deal will bring billions into the UK economy.
I think he's doing a great job for this country and young people.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:33

It's not healthy to hate someone. It is frustrating how easily people fall for vibes rather than substance.

Subsidising EU students is going to cost us £2.5bn alone.

CurlewKate · Today 18:33

Seems entirely sensible to explore our current absolutely shit relationship wth Europe. No idea why you would make you hate him.

WestwardHo1 · Today 18:33

FGS even Farage has said Brexit hasn't been great.

Happyjoe · Today 18:35

Sausagenbacon · Today 18:02

That's not how it works. The EU won't accept a partial return

They will accept a deal that is fine for them too, that's how business works is it not?
Can't see the issue. He's trying to make things better. We lost a hell of a lot of money after brexit, how can anyone have an issue that he's trying to make it better?

CurlewKate · Today 18:35

Sausagenbacon · Today 17:57

I hear what you say, but it was just so transparent.

You do seem to fail to understand how politics works.

Alexisclarerose · Today 18:35

I hate that my mortgage is going up £400 a month while he went on a podcast with an Instagram influencer I guess to try and be relatable. I don’t want to relate to my prime minister. I want them to be a bad ass who stands up to trump and putin and makes tough decisions and sticks by them. Not this absolute waffle we’ve been getting.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:36

Raising the idea of rejoining Europe is purely a distraction technique to keep the masses focus away from the fact his flagship Neets policy is already being sunk by his own backbenchers.