Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Hate Andy Burnham?

110 replies

Sausagenbacon · Today 17:51

He stands for Makerfield (a Leave seat) and makes a speech saying it wouldn't be a good idea to investigate returning to the EU.
Only a few months later starts doing the exact opposite.
And this isn't about Brexit, it's about a politician telling bare faced lies. Just to get into power.

OP posts:
HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:38

Alexisclarerose · Today 18:35

I hate that my mortgage is going up £400 a month while he went on a podcast with an Instagram influencer I guess to try and be relatable. I don’t want to relate to my prime minister. I want them to be a bad ass who stands up to trump and putin and makes tough decisions and sticks by them. Not this absolute waffle we’ve been getting.

Surely the 15p off gerkins has given you enough "breathing space" to cope with the interest rate raises?

Happyjoe · Today 18:38

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:36

Raising the idea of rejoining Europe is purely a distraction technique to keep the masses focus away from the fact his flagship Neets policy is already being sunk by his own backbenchers.

Sorry, but tosh.

Happyjoe · Today 18:40

Alexisclarerose · Today 18:35

I hate that my mortgage is going up £400 a month while he went on a podcast with an Instagram influencer I guess to try and be relatable. I don’t want to relate to my prime minister. I want them to be a bad ass who stands up to trump and putin and makes tough decisions and sticks by them. Not this absolute waffle we’ve been getting.

How do you think Burnham can stand up to them? In what way? They both insane egomaniacs who started wars. What can we do that not already doing (like help Ukraine)?

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:43

Happyjoe · Today 18:38

Sorry, but tosh.

To be honest if you disagree with me I take that as a massive positive.

Hoppity80 · Today 18:43

I think he’s brilliant

Meadowfinch · Today 18:44

The issue I have is that first time round, the U.K. voted for the common market, but consecutive govts took us closer to political union, and that created the anger, frustration and resentment that caused Brexit.
Now Burnham is doing it again, said he didn't want to readdress Brexit, and then does the complete opposite without a mandate. He's on the way to creating the same anger and resentment all over again. Will politicians never learn?

The EU is right to be cautious. If Reform wins in 2029, any new agreements will likely be torn up. Andy Burnham's actions might make that win more likely.

SevenYellowHammers · Today 18:44

UnoriginalPoster · Today 18:30

And this isn't about Brexit, it's about a politician telling bare faced lies. Just to get into power.

You conveniently ignore that the Leave campaign was basically politicians telling bare faced lies to get into power, or to stay in power.

Exactly that. It was a terrible campaign full of lies from Leave and lacklustre from Remain. The best thing to say is that it was a failed experiment and is best forgotten.

Happyjoe · Today 18:45

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:43

To be honest if you disagree with me I take that as a massive positive.

Yes, you do you.

TinaBeliever · Today 18:46

What he's doing is brilliant.

SevenYellowHammers · Today 18:46

@Meadowfinch I understand your point. I don’t think Farage will win an election though. Reform is dead in the water. All Farage’s parties collapse eventually.

SockGene · Today 18:47

It would be front page news if a politician wasn’t a liar. You can’t trust any of them.

Happyjoe · Today 18:48

Meadowfinch · Today 18:44

The issue I have is that first time round, the U.K. voted for the common market, but consecutive govts took us closer to political union, and that created the anger, frustration and resentment that caused Brexit.
Now Burnham is doing it again, said he didn't want to readdress Brexit, and then does the complete opposite without a mandate. He's on the way to creating the same anger and resentment all over again. Will politicians never learn?

The EU is right to be cautious. If Reform wins in 2029, any new agreements will likely be torn up. Andy Burnham's actions might make that win more likely.

I don't think so. I think people can see brexit is a failure. I don't think this will change anyone's minds whatever stance they may already have political wise.

WarmHiker · Today 18:48

The buses minister, sorry the prime minister, is totally out of his depth. He had no clue how to fix the country or the economy. The highest energy prices in the world, out of control welfare, businesses going bust, crumbling infrastructure, sky high taxation all throttling the economy.

And the buses minister’s big win is something about subscriptions and letting a load of EU students in to pay lower fees so they can be subsidized by British taxpayer. Bravo.

PinkCatCushion · Today 18:48

He’s reversing some of the damage done by the Tories (who were bare faced liars - Boris in particular).

Meadowfinch · Today 18:48

SevenYellowHammers · Today 18:46

@Meadowfinch I understand your point. I don’t think Farage will win an election though. Reform is dead in the water. All Farage’s parties collapse eventually.

Let's hope you are correct.

Dandeloosha · Today 18:49

Boris Johnson fucked up Brexit big style. He made the UK look like a clown. If Andy Burnham can unpick some of that mess I’m all for it - and good for him for saying it out loud. It’s about time someone called out that sex yeti.

needastrongone · Today 18:50

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:36

Raising the idea of rejoining Europe is purely a distraction technique to keep the masses focus away from the fact his flagship Neets policy is already being sunk by his own backbenchers.

No one can know until it passes, but the mood music is that this legislation will pass and I doubt they’d allow that to be the case in the media if it were not so. Two of the biggest architects of the revolt are now in cabinet.. notwithstanding the fact that the Labour government would be basically scuppered if it failed again.

Freysimo · Today 18:51

Maddy70 · Today 17:58

He hasn't returned to the EU. He's just getting better deals than the botched previous deals

It's not a great deal for animal welfare. Live exports back on the table.

Meadowfinch · Today 18:52

The other issue is that British universities are independent and I'm not sure the govt can agree that eu students will have lower fees. I can't see the govt subsidising 100,000 eu students' fees.

Kokonimater · Today 18:53

I think he’s doing a good job.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · Today 18:53

No YANBU because you can hate whomsoever you wish.
I for example hated that spineless cunt Cameron for pandering to the right wing morons in his party pushing for a Brexit referendum in the first place.
I hated the loathsome lying bastard Johnson for all the utter bullshit he spouted about Brexit and Covid (but making sure his wealthy mates were ok of course)
I also really hated the stupidly incompetent and unelected Truss who slashed the value of my pension pot in her 45 days of chaos. Don't remember that in the Tory manifesto of the time?
And no comment needs to be made about Farage...
So OP - hate Burham if you like, but at the moment opinion polls would suggest plenty of people have seen through all the damaging right wing shite and would quite like a change.

Alexisclarerose · Today 18:53

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:38

Surely the 15p off gerkins has given you enough "breathing space" to cope with the interest rate raises?

Yes - it really has made a huge dent in my weekly shop!

luckily I must be one of those pesky millionaires that Labour can’t stop obsessively hating a as I live in a band g house (it’s a 3 bed bungalow)

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:54

PinkCatCushion · Today 18:48

He’s reversing some of the damage done by the Tories (who were bare faced liars - Boris in particular).

How does paying £2.5bn of tuition fees for European youngster reduce any damage?

Dandeloosha · Today 18:55

Meadowfinch · Today 18:44

The issue I have is that first time round, the U.K. voted for the common market, but consecutive govts took us closer to political union, and that created the anger, frustration and resentment that caused Brexit.
Now Burnham is doing it again, said he didn't want to readdress Brexit, and then does the complete opposite without a mandate. He's on the way to creating the same anger and resentment all over again. Will politicians never learn?

The EU is right to be cautious. If Reform wins in 2029, any new agreements will likely be torn up. Andy Burnham's actions might make that win more likely.

Every single manifesto for every single general election had a position on Europe. It was voted for repeatedly. Hardly anyone reads manifestos - that’s the trouble. Referendums are a spectacularly shit way of dealing with the problems faced by a country (especially tax evading billionaires), especially when dealing with extremely complex issues.

Alexisclarerose · Today 18:55

Happyjoe · Today 18:40

How do you think Burnham can stand up to them? In what way? They both insane egomaniacs who started wars. What can we do that not already doing (like help Ukraine)?

Well for one thing focus on anything apart from going on the live laugh love podcast!