Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Hate Andy Burnham?

110 replies

Sausagenbacon · Today 17:51

He stands for Makerfield (a Leave seat) and makes a speech saying it wouldn't be a good idea to investigate returning to the EU.
Only a few months later starts doing the exact opposite.
And this isn't about Brexit, it's about a politician telling bare faced lies. Just to get into power.

OP posts:
Jc2001 · Today 18:55

Sausagenbacon · Today 18:02

That's not how it works. The EU won't accept a partial return

There are ways of negotiating a better deal for us without joining the EU

Other countries have done it but you need to make concessions. That's what he's trying to do.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:55

Alexisclarerose · Today 18:53

Yes - it really has made a huge dent in my weekly shop!

luckily I must be one of those pesky millionaires that Labour can’t stop obsessively hating a as I live in a band g house (it’s a 3 bed bungalow)

In that case you deserve everything you get!

Maybe in the next budget they should means test the Gerkin savings.

Glowingup · Today 18:59

No offence but the economy has pretty much been totally fucked since the wonderful idea of Brexit (who would ever have thought that would go to shit) so if he pushes for rejoining you can bet your arse I will be all for it. I am guessing Leave voters are still deluding themselves that the financial shite we are living through is due to something else. It was a nice experiment, it failed miserably so let's try to undo the damage.

Alexisclarerose · Today 18:59

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:55

In that case you deserve everything you get!

Maybe in the next budget they should means test the Gerkin savings.

I’ll get one step ahead and start stockpiling gherkins.

WestwardHo1 · Today 18:59

WarmHiker · Today 18:48

The buses minister, sorry the prime minister, is totally out of his depth. He had no clue how to fix the country or the economy. The highest energy prices in the world, out of control welfare, businesses going bust, crumbling infrastructure, sky high taxation all throttling the economy.

And the buses minister’s big win is something about subscriptions and letting a load of EU students in to pay lower fees so they can be subsidized by British taxpayer. Bravo.

Well you obviously think your phrase "buses minister" is hilarious. Well done 👏

DuncinToffee · Today 19:01

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 18:54

How does paying £2.5bn of tuition fees for European youngster reduce any damage?

Nothing has been agreed yet on fees. And you know it is a reciprocal agreement?

Trottersup · Today 19:03

Absolutely delighted about stronger links with the EU.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 19:06

DuncinToffee · Today 19:01

Nothing has been agreed yet on fees. And you know it is a reciprocal agreement?

Everything that has been announced is conditional on the UK agreeing to the fees.

Blueseaurchin · Today 19:06

Brexit was a terrible mistake that has had a disastrous impact on our economy.

Recent polls have shown that a majority of people are in favour of closer ties with the EU.

I have no idea why you 'hate' a PM who is doing what is best and sensible for the country.

Brexit was also the result of a bunch of lies by self-serving politicians Johnson and Farage. You should appreciate the fact that we now have someone in charge who is thinking about the country rather than his own self-interest.

Thankfully the young people who could not take part in the referendum can now make their voices heard and avoid voting for politicians who were stupid enough to cut us off from our biggest trading partners and curtail our freedom of movement while tanking the economy and our standards of living just because they did not like foreigners.

Happyjoe · Today 19:07

Alexisclarerose · Today 18:55

Well for one thing focus on anything apart from going on the live laugh love podcast!

Lol, well, yeah. Can't imagine Kier Starmer doing that.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Today 19:07

People are obviously entitled to hold different opinions about different politicians, but I do think it’s quite telling that so many of the criticisms of Andy Burnham on this thread seem to be couched in such sneering, sarcastic tones.

Andy Burnham has currently got a substantial lead on the polling around who people think would make the best Prime Minister, and so I do think some of his critics would do well to reflect on why a warm, engaging politician who communicates to a wide audience about the things that actually matter in their day to day lives (yes, including buses) and who chose not to waste a single minute of his conference speech mud slinging about his opponents is doing so much better than the other leaders: https://yougov.com/en-gb/articles/55919-who-would-make-the-best-prime-minister-november-2026

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 19:12

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Today 19:07

People are obviously entitled to hold different opinions about different politicians, but I do think it’s quite telling that so many of the criticisms of Andy Burnham on this thread seem to be couched in such sneering, sarcastic tones.

Andy Burnham has currently got a substantial lead on the polling around who people think would make the best Prime Minister, and so I do think some of his critics would do well to reflect on why a warm, engaging politician who communicates to a wide audience about the things that actually matter in their day to day lives (yes, including buses) and who chose not to waste a single minute of his conference speech mud slinging about his opponents is doing so much better than the other leaders: https://yougov.com/en-gb/articles/55919-who-would-make-the-best-prime-minister-november-2026

Edited

If you tell every audience what they want to hear, people will like you. It is no way to govern a country.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Today 19:17

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 19:12

If you tell every audience what they want to hear, people will like you. It is no way to govern a country.

I find that really interesting - in what do you think he’s telling the country what they want to hear? He’s been brave enough to say out loud Brexit is a failure - something that’s been almost completely taboo. He’s talked about ending the triple lock - something widely considered electoral suicide until he said it. He’s taking on the recommendations in the Milburn review, even though he’ll have to defend them staunchly to some of Labour’s base, and potentially some of his own backbenchers too.

I really don’t think he does just say what people want to hear - but I do think he’s an incredible communicator.

hobbledyhoy · Today 19:22

I think he’s done a decent job. He’s pragmatic and straightforward and isn’t afraid of telling the counter narrative that we’ve listened to from Farage et al for the last 10 plus years.
Brexit has made this country poorer and resulted in fewer opportunities for our children, quite frankly I’m glad he’s grasped the nettle and I suspect most people are.

Edited for typo

DuncinToffee · Today 19:30

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 19:06

Everything that has been announced is conditional on the UK agreeing to the fees.

There is a 6 month negotiation period

In exchange, UK students will be paying home fees as well, they can choose between 27 countries. Do you have an issue with that, other countries subsidising our young people?

boyleslaw · Today 19:39

Burnham is David Brent

Indigogogoing · Today 19:40

I’m a fan girl. ❤️

Goodgriefisthatrue · Today 19:40

He is trying to improve the current position- most people voted to move away from the EU as Boris went round telling people the NHS would 350 million extra!! Did that materialise no because it was a lie!! I know who I hate more!!

MandingoAteMyBaby · Today 19:47

With this deal implemented we are still outside the EU. It’s still “Brexit”. Don’t worry, you still won.

Uricon2 · Today 19:48

Sausagenbacon · Today 17:51

He stands for Makerfield (a Leave seat) and makes a speech saying it wouldn't be a good idea to investigate returning to the EU.
Only a few months later starts doing the exact opposite.
And this isn't about Brexit, it's about a politician telling bare faced lies. Just to get into power.

I do think there are better hate objects, some being in recent government pre AB. The simpering fool Liz Truss, for a start.

I'm old Bennite Left and have my caveats about Europe but the world has changed since 2016 and at least he has the wit to recognise that.

WarmHiker · Today 19:54

boyleslaw · Today 19:39

Burnham is David Brent

That’s offensive to David Brent.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 19:58

It is still a net cost to UK taxpayers of £2.5bn. The fact that there may or may not be a net cost to European taxpayers of the same is neither here nor there. We should be looking to save money not following the "Labour Way" of trying to find ever more ways to spend it.

It's not like our Universities are awash with money. I would have thought the money could be better invested at internally.

Clavinova · Today 19:59

DuncinToffee · Today 19:30

There is a 6 month negotiation period

In exchange, UK students will be paying home fees as well, they can choose between 27 countries. Do you have an issue with that, other countries subsidising our young people?

In exchange, UK students will be paying home fees as well, they can choose between 27 countries

How many undergraduate courses are there to choose from taught in English? For example, are there undergraduate degrees taught in English for maths or physics in Italy?

DuncinToffee · Today 20:07

Clavinova · Today 19:59

In exchange, UK students will be paying home fees as well, they can choose between 27 countries

How many undergraduate courses are there to choose from taught in English? For example, are there undergraduate degrees taught in English for maths or physics in Italy?

British people can speak foreign languages, do you think Italian students are coming to the UK for Italian spoken courses?

foxychox · Today 20:07

Those who are saying that it’s a good idea to get back to being closer to Europe, do you work in an industry that will be affected by a reunion with Europe? I do, and this is a catastrophic waste of time and money