Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Hate Andy Burnham?

110 replies

Sausagenbacon · Today 17:51

He stands for Makerfield (a Leave seat) and makes a speech saying it wouldn't be a good idea to investigate returning to the EU.
Only a few months later starts doing the exact opposite.
And this isn't about Brexit, it's about a politician telling bare faced lies. Just to get into power.

OP posts:
NewMonsteraLeaf · Today 20:09

Leaving Europe was a fucking stupid idea. I’m 100% behind him!

CandidLurker · Today 20:09

DuncinToffee · Today 19:30

There is a 6 month negotiation period

In exchange, UK students will be paying home fees as well, they can choose between 27 countries. Do you have an issue with that, other countries subsidising our young people?

Universities in other European countries will not be teaching courses in English. The number of students going overseas from here to do a full degree will be much smaller than those wanting to come here. French students have just been protesting en masse about the appalling state of their universities. British students would be horrified at the state of their university facilities and the teaching. Unless you are going to go private or somewhere elite there’s no comparison.

OakAndEmber47 · Today 20:13

Maddy70 · Today 17:58

He hasn't returned to the EU. He's just getting better deals than the botched previous deals

Better? Taking rules with no influence on making them, and paying for the privilege. I’d group them
with the Chagos deal - all a waste of time and unforced.

He is just warming us up for what will come next. A Labour manifesto that includes rejoining, with no referendum, just encase we pick the wrong answer again.

it’s funny how these “once in a generation” votes keep happening.

DuncinToffee · Today 20:13

CandidLurker · Today 20:09

Universities in other European countries will not be teaching courses in English. The number of students going overseas from here to do a full degree will be much smaller than those wanting to come here. French students have just been protesting en masse about the appalling state of their universities. British students would be horrified at the state of their university facilities and the teaching. Unless you are going to go private or somewhere elite there’s no comparison.

In all 27 countries?

needastrongone · Today 20:13

foxychox · Today 20:07

Those who are saying that it’s a good idea to get back to being closer to Europe, do you work in an industry that will be affected by a reunion with Europe? I do, and this is a catastrophic waste of time and money

No, but we did have a business whose customer base was approximately made up of 20% from EU countries and we lost ALL that trade due to the bureaucracy, tariff and general complexity arising from Brexit. When we sold, we had no EU customers at all. None.

Clavinova · Today 20:14

DuncinToffee · Today 20:07

British people can speak foreign languages, do you think Italian students are coming to the UK for Italian spoken courses?

British people can speak foreign languages

Apparently not that well. You said British people had the choice of 27 countries - now you are saying they have to speak multiple languages to have any sort of choice.

DuncinToffee · Today 20:18

Clavinova · Today 20:14

British people can speak foreign languages

Apparently not that well. You said British people had the choice of 27 countries - now you are saying they have to speak multiple languages to have any sort of choice.

Edited

Why do you think people go abroad if not for experiencing the local language, culture etc.

I studied in Germany, there were students from all over the EU incl many British. The common language was German, not everyone spoke English.

ginasevern · Today 20:19

@UnoriginalPoster "And this isn't about Brexit, it's about a politician telling bare faced lies. Just to get into power."

Christ on a bike. Not like Boris then who told enough lies to shame Pinocchio and switched to Leave as soon as he saw the glittering chance of being PM!

CandidLurker · Today 20:20

DuncinToffee · Today 20:13

In all 27 countries?

Yes I very much doubt many British students will have good enough language skills to study at degree level in a foreign language unless they have acquired fluency at a younger age. Acquiring English at a sufficiently decent level is easier as it’s taught almost everywhere and media etc easily available.

Anyway I guess we will see the numbers in due course.

DuncinToffee · Today 20:22

CandidLurker · Today 20:20

Yes I very much doubt many British students will have good enough language skills to study at degree level in a foreign language unless they have acquired fluency at a younger age. Acquiring English at a sufficiently decent level is easier as it’s taught almost everywhere and media etc easily available.

Anyway I guess we will see the numbers in due course.

You don't have a high opinion of British students it seems.

CandidLurker · Today 20:23

DuncinToffee · Today 20:18

Why do you think people go abroad if not for experiencing the local language, culture etc.

I studied in Germany, there were students from all over the EU incl many British. The common language was German, not everyone spoke English.

were you fluent in German before you arrived and were you doing a degree fully taught in German, all exams, coursework in German etc.

Clavinova · Today 20:23

DuncinToffee · Today 20:18

Why do you think people go abroad if not for experiencing the local language, culture etc.

I studied in Germany, there were students from all over the EU incl many British. The common language was German, not everyone spoke English.

I studied in Germany

Undergraduate degree? Also, you are a Dutch citizen.

CandidLurker · Today 20:28

DuncinToffee · Today 20:22

You don't have a high opinion of British students it seems.

I don’t have any opinion about them. I just thing it’s reality that fewer British students will go abroad than come here and British students will then be competing for jobs with European students for jobs. So I feel sorry for young British students who don’t realise it yet but those graduate jobs in the U.K will be going to European students who have studied with them at British universities but have the added advantage of another European language.

CurlewKate · Today 20:29

boyleslaw · Today 19:39

Burnham is David Brent

Could you say more about this? Or did you think it’s was a clever thing to say without explaining….

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · Today 20:31

He's doing what's best for the country. Brexit was a HUGE mistake, delivered in the worst possible way.

SevenYellowHammers · Today 20:33

@Meadowfinch If the good people of Makerfield still wanted Leave, they’d have voted Reform. They didn’t. Thank God.

Clearinguptheclutter · Today 20:34

There is renegotiating Boris’ shit deal with our closest trading partner by far, and rejoining. Surely you can understand they are totally different

AB has been quite clear there will not be a return to the EU without a proper vote. Most likely another referendum

JimBobsWife · Today 20:35

Blueseaurchin · Today 19:06

Brexit was a terrible mistake that has had a disastrous impact on our economy.

Recent polls have shown that a majority of people are in favour of closer ties with the EU.

I have no idea why you 'hate' a PM who is doing what is best and sensible for the country.

Brexit was also the result of a bunch of lies by self-serving politicians Johnson and Farage. You should appreciate the fact that we now have someone in charge who is thinking about the country rather than his own self-interest.

Thankfully the young people who could not take part in the referendum can now make their voices heard and avoid voting for politicians who were stupid enough to cut us off from our biggest trading partners and curtail our freedom of movement while tanking the economy and our standards of living just because they did not like foreigners.

I’m ambivalent about what he’s doing but if being in Europe were a guarantee of growth, France and Germany would not have lower growth than us.

The EU has not stood still in the last ten years, it is ever more regulated (unfortunately not in the area of live animal transport) and in areas where we have diverged eg AI, we have outperformed them.

CandidLurker · Today 20:37

Clavinova · Today 20:23

I studied in Germany

Undergraduate degree? Also, you are a Dutch citizen.

Oh that would be a huge advantage wouldn’t it? Just looked it up and Dutch and German share 84% lexical similarity. Apparently many common words look and sound alike

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 20:38

DuncinToffee · Today 20:22

You don't have a high opinion of British students it seems.

There are around 60,000 EU students in the UK and 20,000 UK students in the UK. I would expect the youth mobility scheme to broadly track what people do today. The fee discount can't just apply to those on the mobility scheme.

It is highly unbalanced which is presumably why "say yes Andy" could get commit to being "say yes later Andy".

It all gets agreed in 6 months without any fan fair and the Government hopes people won't notice.

Clavinova · Today 20:40

SevenYellowHammers · Today 20:33

@Meadowfinch If the good people of Makerfield still wanted Leave, they’d have voted Reform. They didn’t. Thank God.

Labour won Makerfield in 2017 and 2019 as well.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 20:40

Companies up and down the country are now going to implement red tape even fi their produce goes no where near the EU border.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 20:45

Clavinova · Today 20:40

Labour won Makerfield in 2017 and 2019 as well.

Burnham did promise them he wasn't going reopen the debate!

Clavinova · Today 20:46

Dandeloosha · Today 18:55

Every single manifesto for every single general election had a position on Europe. It was voted for repeatedly. Hardly anyone reads manifestos - that’s the trouble. Referendums are a spectacularly shit way of dealing with the problems faced by a country (especially tax evading billionaires), especially when dealing with extremely complex issues.

Every single manifesto for every single general election had a position on Europe. It was voted for repeatedly.

Labour's 2005 manifesto pledged to hold a referendum on what became the Lisbon Treaty - they didn't.

Clavinova · Today 20:48

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 20:45

Burnham did promise them he wasn't going reopen the debate!

Yes, that as well, but my point was that even being a very pro-leave seat they still voted Labour in 2017 and 2019.