Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask my daughter’s teacher to check she’s dressed properly after PE?

257 replies

Gertrudethechicken · Yesterday 19:50

My daughter is five and came home from school today after PE wearing her trousers back to front, her shoes on the wrong feet and, bizarrely, with no T-shirt on at all (just her jumper).
It’s November!

I appreciate that children need to learn independence and I’m certainly not expecting someone to get her dressed from head to toe. However, she’s five, and she still needs a bit of help getting dressed. She needs help at home too, and we’re working on developing those skills.

I’ve politely messaged her teacher asking if someone could give her a little hand after PE and just check she’s properly dressed before sending her home.

I’m not asking for anything unreasonable, or am I? I have quite a lot of anxiety about her at school as we’ve had afew issues already and I don’t feel the school have been great at communication.

AIBU to expect a member of staff to make sure a five-year-old has actually got all her clothes on properly before leaving school? Or am I being silly?

OP posts:
Zanatdy · Yesterday 20:43

That brought back memories of DS2 always coming out with his trousers on back to front on PE day.

BreatheAndFocus · Yesterday 20:43

It’s also possible that the teacher or TA noticed and drew attention to it (Alice, you’ve forgotten to put your t shirt on. Take off your jumper, put your t shirt on and then put the jumper back on”) on her way to deal with another child or incident, but your DD didn’t do it. This is very common. Sometimes I’ll have to tell a child multiple times to get their coat from the cloakroom and put it on. Add crying, arguing, wee accidents, etc, etc, to that, and it’s no surprise that teachers can’t stand there until your DD sorts her clothes out.

Unless she was indecent or had clothes on in a somehow dangerous way, you are being unreasonable.

MajorProcrastination · Yesterday 20:43

There isn't time or capacity for the class teacher to be dressing all of the children after PE. That's a level of personal care that a 5 year old should be able to manage unless they have ALN.

You need to get her practicing this and I know it's tricky but it's something for her to work out. I do hear that you are trying to support her with this independence at home but you do need to keep up with this rather than expect the class teacher to do her shoes and make sure her trousers are on the right way etc.

At our primary, the children wear leggings or joggers and tshirts with jumpers and they can wear trainers so for PE and sports there's not so much of a fuss in getting changed.

Your expectation is unreasonable.

At our primary, in the nursery we have an increasing number of children coming to school without the basic skills that are expected at that age. I'm not talking about the children with ALN. There are many more children who aren't toilet trained, can't put their coat on, haven't developed their speech and language to expected levels, and other basic hygeine and social skills which have been the baseline for that age for a long, long, long time. It has impacted on the availability of adults, the environment, the activities and structure of the day for the children who are at the expected level. I don't think that's the case with your child, it sounds like a normal level of chaos and effort but hopefully you can use this as a learning moment for your daughter - which order does she put her clothes on, how does she tell which shoe goes on which foot etc.

CharlieEffie · Yesterday 20:43

MCF86 · Yesterday 20:36

I completely agree, but it isn't the teachers fault so it's still a valid point to make.

It is not a teachers job. There are fundamental that parents should be teaching their children before they go to school, like teaching them to get dressed. That is a parents job, teachers have 20/30 kids, parents have 1/2/3. No excuse. Also its not nursery, teachers arent there to provide childcare, there there to teach.

Sorry quoted wrong person

CywIarBach · Yesterday 20:44

augustuss · Yesterday 20:34

Am I the only one tired of the ‘there’s 20/30 children in a class’ argument… Let’s change that then! Are we saying it’s ok for our young children to not be adequately supervised…
I might be overreacting because I’m angry at my dc school today BUT when did it become ok to expect the bare minimum actual childcare from schools!

Maybe because school isn’t childcare. We are there to educate your children, not teach basic skills that parents should have already taught their child.

BobbleBear · Yesterday 20:46

Why are they getting changed for PE at that young age? Even my teenager doesn’t get changed at secondary school for PE.
They wear PE kit on the days they’re going PE.

peoniesandprosecco · Yesterday 20:47

This isn’t the teacher’s job. It’s things like this that made me leave the profession. Parents aren’t parenting and yet that’s the teachers fault. How?!

CharlieEffie · Yesterday 20:47

augustuss · Yesterday 20:34

Am I the only one tired of the ‘there’s 20/30 children in a class’ argument… Let’s change that then! Are we saying it’s ok for our young children to not be adequately supervised…
I might be overreacting because I’m angry at my dc school today BUT when did it become ok to expect the bare minimum actual childcare from schools!

It is not a teachers job. There are fundamental that parents should be teaching their children before they go to school, like teaching them to get dressed. That is a parents job, teachers have 20/30 kids, parents have 1/2/3. No excuse. Also its not nursery, teachers arent there to provide childcare, there there to teach.

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · Yesterday 20:47

These are skills to be taught at home, ideally before starting reception. Our school gave us a list of basics we should try and teach ahead of sept.

Explain to DC how shoes feel if on the wrong feet so they notice. Use PP tips about drawing/writing in them.

Trousers the wrong way not a big issue. Where is the t-shirt? I'm assuming they were trying to be quick.

I presume they can put their coat on/off and fasten it and undo it?

Finallyseenthelights · Yesterday 20:48

Ilovefoodandwine · Yesterday 19:55

Most schools go in to school on pe days in kitchen now. I'd be contacting the school to discuss this option

I think reception don’t bc it’s one of the boxes they need to tick in PSHE or the equivalent when they do assessments - self care and independence - can the child do this already, do they need support etc? Also, sadly (that it’s required), it’s an opportunity to look for signs of abuse - marks and possible malnutrition, etc. and to check overall whether the child looks under or over weight.

titchy · Yesterday 20:48

augustuss · Yesterday 20:34

Am I the only one tired of the ‘there’s 20/30 children in a class’ argument… Let’s change that then! Are we saying it’s ok for our young children to not be adequately supervised…
I might be overreacting because I’m angry at my dc school today BUT when did it become ok to expect the bare minimum actual childcare from schools!

Schools aren’t childcare…. They teach numbers and letters and paint and geography and science. Why are we so quick to think teachers should also be doing the parenting? Getting dressed, use the toilet, use cutlery etc. these aren’t tasks teachers should be teaching.

onlyoneoftheregimentinstep · Yesterday 20:51

Ligesani · Yesterday 19:56

Yanbu, she's still very little and this is part of a teacher's job.

It certainly isn’t. Can you imagine if all thirty children in the class needed this help? Children starting school should be able to dress themselves.

PinkCatCushion · Yesterday 20:52

You have absolutely no idea of the chaos involved in getting a Yr R class changed for PE. YABVVU.
it does your daughter no harm if an item of clothing is on backwards and to be honest getting changed independently is something you should have taught your child before starting school.

SandyCastles · Yesterday 20:54

I always know which days my DD5 has PE because she always comes out with at least one item of clothing on wrong.

Shoes on wrong feet, trousers back to front, cardigan inside out.. she knows how to fully dress herself at home, but it's like she can't be bothered, either that or they rush them and she just throws her clothes on.

I wouldn't worry, just practice at home a bit more.

Gofaster2023 · Yesterday 20:54

I wouldnt notice if someone had tshirt on or not. In fact today I didnt put a vest top under my jumper and I very nearly took off my jumper when I got too hot! And as for the trousers, you may be underestimating how dishevelled some children are by the end of the day! You immediately noticed but honestly the teacher probably just didnt. You could ask for help with the shoes tho. I dont know any infant teacher who wouldnt help with that. And as for why the one teacher in a small class couldn't help. Your child is one child needing help. Most of them probably could have looked better after pe, and in an ideal world they would sit quietly and look at a book while the teacher helped them all. But numbers 1 and 2 who were helped have got into the playdough and rubbed it into the carpet, 3 and 4 are tearing lumps out of each other and 5 is crying because its too loud while you're still helping numbers 19 and 20.

NCTDN · Yesterday 20:56

As a reception class teacher, I think it’s a shame that most schools have abandoned getting changed for pe since Covid. It’s a life skill. I think it’s tricky to notice trousers back to front but I would definitely notice shoes the wrong way round or no t-shirt.

RedDogWizz · Yesterday 20:56

Gertrudethechicken · Yesterday 20:05

She still needs help at home but We are trying to teach her to do it independently. I’m not asking them to teach her how to get dressed or to dress her. I mean, what am I to do… delay starting school until she can reliably put her shoes on the right feet and trousers the right way? All teacher would need to do is look at her and notice she has no T-shirt and shoes on the wrong feet, and just give her a verbal prompt to correct this. She wouldn’t even have to physically lift a finger.. is that really asking too much?

Why don’t you write ‘L’ and ‘R’ in her shoes or if they have buckles/particular pattern on one side that she needs to check that is on the outside?

Greenspaceskeepmecalm · Yesterday 20:56

Agree with you to a point but Reception is so busy, the teacher/TA may not have noticed (until they were leaving).

I would always get students to swap their shoes to the correct foot and if they were obviously missing a top- would mention this.

Mine often came home with uniform on incorrectly or things missing.

LeaveTheWorldBehind · Yesterday 20:58

Hadroncollideer · Yesterday 20:14

Well you can try asking them...

I remember when dd was in playgroup (so aged 3) another mum noticed her dd hadn't done her trousers up properly and mentioned it to the staff. The staff simply said to the little girl 'in a rather severe tone Alice, if you need help, you know to ask us'

What point are you trying to make? That school staff are horrible?

Gofaster2023 · Yesterday 20:59

When i have time, though, I always help them. I untuck dresses, re fasten buttons and re do hairstyles whenever I can. But sometimes you just have to go, are they dry and have most of their clothing, because there's only so much you can do at times.

Samysungy · Yesterday 21:12

Teach her strategies:

Laminate a visual steps and tie it to her PE bag so she can check she has done all the steps. Have the same visual at home so she is used to using it to dress in the morning.

Smiley face etc in shoes to get them on the correct way.

Strategies to check her pants are on backwards/jumper etc.

Let her make mistakes at home and talk about why it is wrong. So in a morning if the puts her jumper on backwards talk about how she is missing the logo on her chest or that the label is under her chin etc. Then she realises this is wrong. She cannot realise it is wrong if she has never got it wrong.

Let her do it herself in a morning and check her visual at home. Do not correct her before she does something wrong. Let her put something on the wrong feet and discuss the feeling etc. How could she solve this problem?

The best thing you can do it teach her strategies that overcome hurdles. Doing this each morning before school reinforces it so each week come PE she will improve.

If she comes out of school looking like she did do, go back in and instead of telling the teacher to do better, then get her PE bag and ask her if she did all the steps and what looks wrong etc. Then get her to correct it before you leave.

Hadroncollideer · Yesterday 21:17

LeaveTheWorldBehind · Yesterday 20:58

What point are you trying to make? That school staff are horrible?

No they weren't. They were definitely focused on independence though.

Chilly80 · Yesterday 21:18

Itwasthe90s · Yesterday 19:51

Your DD is still getting changed for PE?

I thought most schools abandoned the getting changed in school for PE thing since COVID, and that kids just wear their PE kit all day on PE days.

But to answer your question - Yes, YABU. The teacher has 30 kids to oversee, not just yours.

Edited

Not for reception as dressing themselves is in the curriculum

Bramblezz · Yesterday 21:18

Yanbu I think when children go to school as young as 4 then reception teachers need to accept the job will involve an element of ass wiping and helping the kids with their basic needs.

Thegirlwhowent · Yesterday 21:20

Ligesani · Yesterday 19:56

Yanbu, she's still very little and this is part of a teacher's job.

Is it? Making sure 30 children are dressed properly, as well as teaching them?

Swipe left for the next trending thread