Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Milburn’s idea of prioritising NEETS for MH treatment and therapy over other YP more complex and ill who are managing to cling onto education will be catastrophic

139 replies

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 16:41

They’re already being left to get 100 times worse on hideously long wait lists which will now get even longer. Why should those with lesser need be prioritised simply because they’re not in education or work? Many seriously ill YP are battling to hold on to education by the skin of their teeth. Not being in education or work doesn’t mean you’re more ill or more deserving of treatment.They’ll be losing their PIP which many use for therapies and treatments so won’t be able to go private. Parents will have no choice but to pull them out of education if they want to get help,which will add to the NEET numbers!

OP posts:
HonourExistingClaimants · Yesterday 13:11

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 09:15

What we need is a complete shake up at camhs. More staff, money and resources and a legal requirement to treat asd children for the co-morbidities that often comes with it.
We need actual individually targeted talking therapy for those who need it at the point in time that its needed.
We should never be in a position where children who have attempted suicide are being sent home and told that its a year+ wait for any help or that crippling anxiety and/or debilitating phobias will not be treated as the child is autistic.
None of the measures that you have talked about will do anything to provide what is really needed when it comes to camhs or sen provisions at schools because we dont have the money or trained councillors, psychologists, psychiatrists and sen teachers

Yes rather than paying boots and Lidl etc up to 5k per temp employee and however many millions to set this all up they should be leaving PIP etc alone and pushing money and resources into early diagnosis, early interventions, supportive therapies and CAMHS. That’s the only logical way to resolve this situation.

Kgti774 · Yesterday 16:10

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 13:08

His remit is to report on Neets, not to resolve mental health care.

Who told him to resolve MH care?Not me. I simply pointed out that these measures will put need second(dangerous),raise wait lists for non NEETs and will thus raise NEET numbers.

OP posts:
NightHeron · Yesterday 17:11

Oliveoy · 17/11/2026 21:12

It is, it's a disgrace. When DD was diagnosed I was prepared for a wait for treatment, but I couldn't have imagined we'd just be sent away to manage it ourselves. Every referral that's been made (child psychology team, CAMHS, out of area services) has been rejected. Further to that I made a complaint to the trust nearly 6 months ago about the lack of care and that still hasn't been answered. On her worst days she's had more than 10 seizures, full loss of consciousness. Nobody cares.

Haven’t you taken the seizures up with a neurologist?

Oliveoy · Yesterday 17:20

NightHeron · Yesterday 17:11

Haven’t you taken the seizures up with a neurologist?

Yes, of course. It was a consultant neurologist who diagnosed following EEGs. The seizures are non epileptic so they can't be medicated. Under the NICE guidelines she should be under the care of a multi disciplinary team and receiving psychotherapy etc, but the services haven't been commissioned to treat paediatric FND.

NightHeron · Yesterday 17:31

Oliveoy · Yesterday 17:20

Yes, of course. It was a consultant neurologist who diagnosed following EEGs. The seizures are non epileptic so they can't be medicated. Under the NICE guidelines she should be under the care of a multi disciplinary team and receiving psychotherapy etc, but the services haven't been commissioned to treat paediatric FND.

Even in adult MH services, the wait for psychotherapy can be 2 - 3 years.

Oliveoy · Yesterday 17:37

NightHeron · Yesterday 17:31

Even in adult MH services, the wait for psychotherapy can be 2 - 3 years.

So? We can't even go on a waiting list!

BoredZelda · Yesterday 17:46

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 16:56

No they leave them until they repeatedly try to take their own life and now they’re going to be penalised for trying to hold on to school and college. I can’t believe the youngsters who have clung on to education now get penalised for their efforts. Some are seriously ill. My dd has been on tier 3 treatment and the dynamic support register rated red. She is hugely complex and missed hours of school seriously unwell but clung on. She’s now in between services but needs more treatment, we’ll need to pull her out of education!!

I honestly think these people are clueless re how dire things are and what actually happens in MH services.

I mentor a young person who’s mental health is so poor she has been talking of suicide. CAHMS did an urgent initial assessment and passed her to someone for a meeting. They refused to consider medication and asked her to keep a sleep diary. 🤦🏻‍♀️

NightHeron · Today 10:00

Oliveoy · Yesterday 17:37

So? We can't even go on a waiting list!

The Nice guidelines imo are theoretical at times in the NHS these days. It’s all about cutting waiting lists.

We’ve been in A & E with DD2, being assessed by a mental health HCP, for being suicidal (and she’s been there at least 50 times for that); and they commented to us, that they are off to assess a suicidal child next - not that they’d get any help! If suicidal children don’t get help, then a child with non epileptic seizures isn’t likely to get any, are they?

DD2, after 50 plus incidents of suicidal behaviour can’t get on the waiting list for EMDR, for her CPTSD, caused by bullying at work, as she has ADHD and most likely undiagnosed autism.

Oliveoy · Today 10:42

NightHeron · Today 10:00

The Nice guidelines imo are theoretical at times in the NHS these days. It’s all about cutting waiting lists.

We’ve been in A & E with DD2, being assessed by a mental health HCP, for being suicidal (and she’s been there at least 50 times for that); and they commented to us, that they are off to assess a suicidal child next - not that they’d get any help! If suicidal children don’t get help, then a child with non epileptic seizures isn’t likely to get any, are they?

DD2, after 50 plus incidents of suicidal behaviour can’t get on the waiting list for EMDR, for her CPTSD, caused by bullying at work, as she has ADHD and most likely undiagnosed autism.

Edited

Would you say that about any other neurological condition?
"If suicidal children don't get help, then a child with epilepsy/a brain tumour isn't likely to get any, are they?"

NightHeron · Today 11:44

Oliveoy · Today 10:42

Would you say that about any other neurological condition?
"If suicidal children don't get help, then a child with epilepsy/a brain tumour isn't likely to get any, are they?"

Yes, DD1 has among the most severe epilepsy in the country. She has been under the top epilepsy units in the UK. It’s a severe epileptic encephalopathy, which causes cognitive deterioration and behaviour problems. Its very like dementia. They say she’s at the interface between neurology and psychiatry. I can’t get NHS mental health input for her. Her professor of neurology said three neurology appointments a year aren’t enough for her - she gets one now.

It’s probably a de novo genetic mutation, which interacts with another ultra rare genetic metabolic disorder, she has, which DH and I both carry. It causes malnutrition, which in turn causes psychiatric problems, cognitive deterioration and dementia.

She is supposed to be seen by a multi disciplinary metabolic team, every 6 months, to talk about her diet, which includes blood tests on the ammonia in her blood (a neurotoxin). She wouldn’t have had an appointment in two years, because they gave her an appointment and cancelled it a few days before repeatedly.

The GP in our family says middle management in hospitals, who aren’t even clinicians cancel appointments to keep down waiting lists. He told me, he increasingly has to tell his patients to make a complaint to get a hospital appointment. He told me to complain about DD1. I had to complain twice to get a face to face appointment for her, and probably only got an appointment eventually, because it was in their own reports, she needs close surveillance; and their own website said they can’t give safe care, unless they see their patients face to face at least once a year.

I myself have a neurological disorder and am under a professor of neurology at Queen Sq. I am supposed to get a treatment every three months. It will have been five months, by the time of my next appointment. He himself complained last time, it had been four months and I definitely need it after three months. I don’t have time to complain about that, because I have enough to do, caring for members of my family (which is why I need the treatment to enable me to be a carer).

I also have two benign tumours. The Nice guidelines say I meet the criteria to have one removed, as it will cause kidney damage and osteoporosis. I can’t get the surgery on the NHS from my consultant endocrinologist. The other tumour could kill me, if it starts bleeding. I am supposed to have a MRI scan every year to check it’s growth, as the bigger it gets, the more likely it is to bleed. I had to wait two years for the next MRI scan - and I’ve not had the results in a month.

hibernatinghedgehog · Today 12:34

@Oliveoy have you thought about request an EHCNA? Therapies can be part of EHCPs even where the NHS can’t/won’t ordinarily provide it.

Personally, I don’t think others have significant needs that are unmet excuses not providing support.

Chiefunderling · Today 13:25

Hi Op, I have the same concerns as you do. I am in my mid-40’s now, but 25/30 years ago I was a young person with significant mental illness. The system was very different back then. I was fortunate to get the intensive support & treatment I needed from the NHS mental health services for a decade. However, around 15 years ago I noticed a huge shift in adult & adolescent mental health provision. Approximately a decade ago, a GP at my surgery told me; “the mental health services, as you knew them, no longer exist”. She was right.

If I were a young person today, with the same untreated significant mental illness, I’m not sure I’d survive. That is no exaggeration. I have needed ongoing support with my life-long mental illness but this dried up a decade ago. I am reliant on heavy duty psychotropic medications, which should be regularly reviewed. My last review was 6 years ago. I struggle to cope & I’m an adult. I have no idea how they expect young people & their care givers to manage?

There is existing research that indicates people with moderate to severe mental illness do not receive the treatment & support they need. This is because we are harder to treat (cannot be cured), require ongoing care (expensive & resource intensive) & these factors negatively impact NHS & Gov. statistics on treatment & NHS budgets. In a nutshell, the NHS mental health service wants quick wins that come with milder or circumstance-specific mental health problems. 8 weeks of talking therapy may help these people, but it doesn’t touch the sides where significant mental illness is concerned. The NHS & Gov. view significant mental illness as a burden.

What we need is a NHS mental health service that is fit for purpose, for children, adolescents & adults AND wider, community based mental health support hubs for young people across the board. We need both, operating simultaneously, to ensure everyone gets the support they need. But I just don’t see this happening. And I agree that Milburn is purposely conflating NEET’s & young people with significant mental illness. This is dangerous & we know it will be those young people with significant mental illness who lose out.

Almost without fail, greater awareness of an illness or condition is met with a positive reaction from Government & the public. Think Cancer’s, Diabetes etc. Yet with mental illness it has been the exact opposite! More awareness has led to claim’s of over-diagnosis & suspicion. I am not aware of this happening with any other medical conditions. And sadly, this has, once again, increased the stigma surrounding mental illness. Milburn is part of the problem, not the solution. Interestingly, Prof. Peter Fonagy’s report into young people’s mental health didn’t get anywhere near this level of attention because it found young people’s mental health is far worse now.

PocketSand · Today 16:08

@Kgti774it’s even more worrying to assume that Milburn is not ignorant about autism and mental health and the dire state of services but simply cares more about cutting essential benefits and pandering to the ignorant who they hope will vote for them if they look tough. It’s easy to look tough to reduce the income of families with disabled DC by more than 50% in some cases.

But the DC are still disabled so the cost shifts to another state budget at greater expense and increased distress.

On the plus side we, the government, helped x amount of NEETs get early MH support but this only reduced the number of NEETs by a small amount because it turned out most don’t have severe mental health conditions that are a barrier to work and half of them don’t claim benefits anyway. Unfortunately this meant that young people with severe conditions had to wait longer and sadly some of them fell out of education or work so it turned out our policy actually increased NEETs. Who knew?

Plus our added policy of removing access to health element of UC and PIP for disabled 18-25 year olds had a tangential connection to NEETs and was morally ‘contentious’ and financially disastrous as claimants were no longer able to fund being in work or education and family carers were no longer able to claim CA and even though this was a pittance it proved the final straw and the state was legally obliged to provide care at great cost. Who knew? Your 16 year old is transferred to PIP and then loses it from 18-24. And then qualifies again at 25. What’s wrong with that?

wisbech · Today 16:37

Ignasta · 17/11/2026 16:49

Precisely this. I can’t understand how, in a developed country, we can accept talk of “prioritising” healthcare.

A lot of the young people out of work will have experienced MH issues and would be suitable candidates to help others - ie as paid training and work.

And often poor MH is the result of not being able to find a job. So it’s kinda ironic. The govt wanting to treat young people for poor mh, originally caused by lack of jobs - which resulted from govt policy

Of course it needs to be prioritised. There is more demand for MH professional time than the NHS has available. It takes well over a decade to train up a new MH professional (leave school at 18, 5 year med school, 2 years foundation, 3 years core training, 3 years speciality training). If you want to increase the numbers in training, you then reduce the availability of current professionals (because more of them need to be diverted to teaching/ training)

How to become a psychiatrist

So, for at least 15 years, you don't have enough MH professionals, and current capacity needs to be prioritised

How to become a psychiatrist

Find out more information on how to become a psychiatrist.

https://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/become-a-psychiatrist/choose-psychiatry/how-to-become-a-psychiatrist

New posts on this thread. Refresh page