Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Milburn’s idea of prioritising NEETS for MH treatment and therapy over other YP more complex and ill who are managing to cling onto education will be catastrophic

139 replies

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 16:41

They’re already being left to get 100 times worse on hideously long wait lists which will now get even longer. Why should those with lesser need be prioritised simply because they’re not in education or work? Many seriously ill YP are battling to hold on to education by the skin of their teeth. Not being in education or work doesn’t mean you’re more ill or more deserving of treatment.They’ll be losing their PIP which many use for therapies and treatments so won’t be able to go private. Parents will have no choice but to pull them out of education if they want to get help,which will add to the NEET numbers!

OP posts:
Neverendingstory111 · 17/11/2026 19:51

Velumental · 17/11/2026 19:36

Ridiculous isn't it?!

Here they do but it is dismal, my child has not been able to accsess school for 3 years.
We have begged and pleaded for help before it got to that.
He did get some CBT (not by CAMHS) but because of being behind cognitively found it really difficult to engage with.
His paediatrician asked for CAMHS and deemed him to need higher support (tertiary management) but CAMHS seem to know my child better then me and his paediatrician of 4 years and yet again they have given him a service he will not be able to manage.
The reason for this is that he was on the waiting list for nearly a year and I was told it was to get him of that waiting list.sonit basically looks good.

BluebellBeth · 17/11/2026 19:54

LoremIpsumCici · 17/11/2026 17:05

How odd, they certainly treated me and my DD (I am AuDHD and she is ASD).

What did they do? We just get the 'it's just part of asd nothing we can do' lines too.

UnbeatenMum · 17/11/2026 19:56

I don't know about adult mental health services, but in my area even if you're a priority at CAMHS it's still a multiple year wait for any meaningful help. I was told DD1 was a priority for an appointment for prescribing anti depressants at one point and a year later we still hadn't heard back. The crisis team are actually good but access to that wouldn't be based on NEET status anyway. So I can't see the policy change making a meaningful difference without more funding and more clinicians.

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 19:58

GimmieABreakOr3 · 17/11/2026 19:46

It’s not my job to define that I’m afraid.

Also you are making so many assumptions. This plan the government have started to consider isn’t even in place yet! If you read the report, significant funding needs to go into it for 9 out of the 10 years, it was in the billions (the proposal) which would suggest they’d be plugging more into staff and resources. I don’t think that necessarily means support will be taken away from your child. Feel like you’re jumping the gun a bit and maybe catastrophising…

I’m really not. It was stated quite clearly that young people who are already Neet should have guaranteed access to fast-track services like talking therapies and counselling within three months.There is next to no talking therapy or counselling anywhere. You can have tried to take your life several times and not get anything. When people are fast tracked others are pushed down the queue. The numbers of NEETs are supposed to be huge so that’s a significant push down. As a parent I absolutely wouldn’t be pushing through with school now. Treatment and therapy is far more important. Allocation of the precious little there is should be allocated by need not whether somebody is in school or not. It’s a ridiculous idea.

OP posts:
likelysuspect · 17/11/2026 20:00

Hoardasurass · 17/11/2026 16:49

The thing that everyone is ignoring is the fact that there is no treatment for asd or the anxiety that goes hand in hand with it and adhd is treated with drugs not therapy so saying that they will be prioritised for mental health treatment is a joke because camhs doesn't treat them anyway

Yes I was coming on this thread to say exactly this

Most of the YP who are NEET or who are also just about clinging on to education dont have a formal MH diagnosis from anyone, let alone CAMHS because they are so reluctant to formally diagnose a MH disorder

Then on top of that I found it almost impossible that young people with ND of any flavour, are diagnosed with MH conditions. They might be in much later life but as children its called dysregulation or instability or behavioural responses or any such other woolly term designed to hold back any actual MH treatment.

Whichever group they fall into anyway, they'll be fobbed off with some CBT group work, which is great for anxious kids who have no ability to engage with groups.

likelysuspect · 17/11/2026 20:10

hibernatinghedgehog · 17/11/2026 19:23

If your DD has an EHCP, therapies can be, and should be if they are reasonably required, included in F of the EHCP and therefore the normal referral processes and waiting lists don’t apply. If the LA has refused to amend to include these, she/you can appeal.

They'll be expected to be met via universal services though.

Seaitoverthere · 17/11/2026 20:10

It’s all very depressing. My DC is a NEET. Hasn’t been able to do anything for 4 years since left school.

We have paid for counselling every week, they have tried 4 or 5 antidepressants and had no success with any, we’ve paid for an autism assessment and they now have a diagnosis. Paid for one psychiatrist who said he couldn’t help and after a number of months of trying to find another they finally have an appointment with a 2nd psychiatrist next month.

So far they have had one year of universal credit and we have spent the best part of 10k on trying to help to no avail.

Chikenpotpoe · 17/11/2026 20:13

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 16:48

There are many in school/ college roll on reduced hours. They’ll just need to leave completely. There is zero incentive to stay in education if you’re further down the list for treatment that will get you well. It’s utter madness!

I agree, it's very poorly thought out and I feel it's just been done so they can say they have a strategy to address the NEET situation.

hibernatinghedgehog · 17/11/2026 20:13

likelysuspect · 17/11/2026 20:10

They'll be expected to be met via universal services though.

Not necessarily. And even if that is what the LA expects, if the provision is detailed, specified and quantified in F, it can be enforced.

likelysuspect · 17/11/2026 20:17

LoremIpsumCici · 17/11/2026 17:05

How odd, they certainly treated me and my DD (I am AuDHD and she is ASD).

Treated you and your daughter in what way?

Are you talking about when you were a child or are you talking about adult MH services for you as an adult?

Do you and your daughter have diagnosed MH disorders?

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 20:18

Seaitoverthere · 17/11/2026 20:10

It’s all very depressing. My DC is a NEET. Hasn’t been able to do anything for 4 years since left school.

We have paid for counselling every week, they have tried 4 or 5 antidepressants and had no success with any, we’ve paid for an autism assessment and they now have a diagnosis. Paid for one psychiatrist who said he couldn’t help and after a number of months of trying to find another they finally have an appointment with a 2nd psychiatrist next month.

So far they have had one year of universal credit and we have spent the best part of 10k on trying to help to no avail.

Paying for a private psychiatrist is £600 to £700, med reviews half that, therapy is £500 a month, autism diagnoses £3k….Families don’t have that kind of money when they’re battling to keep jobs because of care needs. Sorry but if my kid is going to be pushed down the queue that will avoid these bills when you’re losing PIP too trying to keep in education is hugely counter productive particularly when it’s a mountain to climb anyway.

OP posts:
Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 20:20

Chikenpotpoe · 17/11/2026 20:13

I agree, it's very poorly thought out and I feel it's just been done so they can say they have a strategy to address the NEET situation.

I honestly get the strong impression that Milburn is actually very ignorant about autism, mental health, the dire state of mental health services in this country and what battling families are living with. It’s hugely worrying.

OP posts:
likelysuspect · 17/11/2026 20:28

Having said that Im now going to contradict myself slightly in that I also work with a large number of children (and their parents) who will say they or their child has bad MH, poor MH, cant do x or y or z due to 'MH', when what they mean is, they dont manage to do things which make them feel uncomfortable

There is no tolerance for feeling uncomfortable.

However, having said that, anyone who struggles with that, still needs some sort of intervention, still needs to understand how to manage in life and accept feeling distressed, stressed, panicky, bored, unsure, unlikeable, uncomfortable, worried, all the normal human emotions we all have with realms of normality

This isnt what experiences on this particular thread are about, but that is also what forms much of the NEET cohort.

Seaitoverthere · 17/11/2026 20:32

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 20:18

Paying for a private psychiatrist is £600 to £700, med reviews half that, therapy is £500 a month, autism diagnoses £3k….Families don’t have that kind of money when they’re battling to keep jobs because of care needs. Sorry but if my kid is going to be pushed down the queue that will avoid these bills when you’re losing PIP too trying to keep in education is hugely counter productive particularly when it’s a mountain to climb anyway.

It is very shit and I hear you. I was just venting about what we have had to do and pay somehow, not sure how we have managed but you do what you have to do . I have been really ill and was unable to walk at one point and DH has a chronic health condition and is somehow just managing to keep us a float.

The shit hit the fan for us when DC tried going to university. They don’t get PIP and didn’t claim UC for 3 years as we kept hoping they would improve and make it to university or something. All we can do is hope that psychiatrist number 2 doesn’t bankrupt us and can help.

Oliveoy · 17/11/2026 20:34

LoremIpsumCici · 17/11/2026 16:53

While there is no treatment for ASD, there absolutely is treatment for all comorbid conditions that an autistic person is at higher risk for

  • Anxiety
  • Depression
  • PTSD
  • Burnout
  • OCD
  • ADHD
I agree it is a bit of a joke as most MHTs cannot or do not want to help complex patients as it takes specialist input to provide treatment for the above that is tailored to the autistic mind.

Not all comorbid conditions unfortunately. My DD is autistic and also has FND (much higher prevalence of FND amongst autistic people).

In our area (and around most of the country) there are no commissioned services to treat paediatric FND. DD has been left to get on with seizures with zero support or treatment.

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 20:35

likelysuspect · 17/11/2026 20:28

Having said that Im now going to contradict myself slightly in that I also work with a large number of children (and their parents) who will say they or their child has bad MH, poor MH, cant do x or y or z due to 'MH', when what they mean is, they dont manage to do things which make them feel uncomfortable

There is no tolerance for feeling uncomfortable.

However, having said that, anyone who struggles with that, still needs some sort of intervention, still needs to understand how to manage in life and accept feeling distressed, stressed, panicky, bored, unsure, unlikeable, uncomfortable, worried, all the normal human emotions we all have with realms of normality

This isnt what experiences on this particular thread are about, but that is also what forms much of the NEET cohort.

But those just saying their have mental health and who are NEET are now going to be prioritised over those more complex and ill who battle into school even for a few hours. It’s nuts!

OP posts:
likelysuspect · 17/11/2026 20:38

Oliveoy · 17/11/2026 20:34

Not all comorbid conditions unfortunately. My DD is autistic and also has FND (much higher prevalence of FND amongst autistic people).

In our area (and around most of the country) there are no commissioned services to treat paediatric FND. DD has been left to get on with seizures with zero support or treatment.

You wouldnt think we're a first world country would you. Its a disgrace.

likelysuspect · 17/11/2026 20:38

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 20:35

But those just saying their have mental health and who are NEET are now going to be prioritised over those more complex and ill who battle into school even for a few hours. It’s nuts!

Yes good point.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 17/11/2026 20:43

I think there are definitely legitimate concerns about some young people falling through the cracks, but my understanding is a central plank of the Milburn Review is designed around early intervention and additional mental health support in schools. They aren’t just going to be shuffling NEETS to the front of existing NHS waiting lists, are they? My understanding was the proposals also call for billions of pounds investment to expand capacity. I think they’re also talking about introducing national maximum waiting times for all young people's mental health care. I think lots of the measures look concerning in isolation, but it’s a whole package, isn’t it?

stichguru · 17/11/2026 20:49

In theory it's a good idea. Someone who is too unwell to be in education, employment or training, is going to need mental health services more than someone who is well enough to be in education, employment or training,

However we all know this is totally not actually true:

  1. there are many people not in education, employment or training, without mental health needs, and therefore a proportion of those with mental health needs are going to be ones that just wouldn't be in education anyway and their mental health needs won't be the problem.
  2. Education establishments vary so widely in their ability to support people with mental health needs that one person whose really quite sick might live near a College that supported them well, while someone else with less needs might not get proper help at another College.
  3. Same as 2 for employers/apprenticeships etc
  4. When people's mental health needs stem from poor experiences in the education system, education maybe an especially difficult place for them, so they may be out of it, even without serious needs.
Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 20:50

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 17/11/2026 20:43

I think there are definitely legitimate concerns about some young people falling through the cracks, but my understanding is a central plank of the Milburn Review is designed around early intervention and additional mental health support in schools. They aren’t just going to be shuffling NEETS to the front of existing NHS waiting lists, are they? My understanding was the proposals also call for billions of pounds investment to expand capacity. I think they’re also talking about introducing national maximum waiting times for all young people's mental health care. I think lots of the measures look concerning in isolation, but it’s a whole package, isn’t it?

Edited

Families with very unwell complex children don’t want gimmicks and hubs they want therapies and treatments, the very things NEETS are going to be prioritised for and getting quicker. Waiting makes conditions harder to treat. Sorry but dragging unwell children into school only to be pushed further down the list for treatment they need is ludicrous. Desperate parents aren’t daft and will pull their kids out of school.

OP posts:
Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 20:58

stichguru · 17/11/2026 20:49

In theory it's a good idea. Someone who is too unwell to be in education, employment or training, is going to need mental health services more than someone who is well enough to be in education, employment or training,

However we all know this is totally not actually true:

  1. there are many people not in education, employment or training, without mental health needs, and therefore a proportion of those with mental health needs are going to be ones that just wouldn't be in education anyway and their mental health needs won't be the problem.
  2. Education establishments vary so widely in their ability to support people with mental health needs that one person whose really quite sick might live near a College that supported them well, while someone else with less needs might not get proper help at another College.
  3. Same as 2 for employers/apprenticeships etc
  4. When people's mental health needs stem from poor experiences in the education system, education maybe an especially difficult place for them, so they may be out of it, even without serious needs.

“Someone who is too unwell to be in education, employment or training, is going to need mental health services more than someone who is well enough to be in education, employment or training”

This absolutely isn’t true. I have had 2 kids under tier 3 services, on the dynamic support register rated red and and a CETR. They’ve never been NEET. One was very part time and had periods in hospital but were still on role and would return.Part of the reason they got so unwell was from having to wait for treatment. I know many NEETs with very minor MH difficulties. If I knew my kids were waiting because they were in school and others with less difficulties were getting the treatment they needed because they weren’t in school I’d pull mine out in a flash.

OP posts:
GimmieABreakOr3 · 17/11/2026 21:03

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 19:58

I’m really not. It was stated quite clearly that young people who are already Neet should have guaranteed access to fast-track services like talking therapies and counselling within three months.There is next to no talking therapy or counselling anywhere. You can have tried to take your life several times and not get anything. When people are fast tracked others are pushed down the queue. The numbers of NEETs are supposed to be huge so that’s a significant push down. As a parent I absolutely wouldn’t be pushing through with school now. Treatment and therapy is far more important. Allocation of the precious little there is should be allocated by need not whether somebody is in school or not. It’s a ridiculous idea.

Well don’t prioritise education then, don’t bother encouraging your kids to go to school 🙄

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 21:05

GimmieABreakOr3 · 17/11/2026 21:03

Well don’t prioritise education then, don’t bother encouraging your kids to go to school 🙄

Desperate parents won’t! But this is
ludicrous as it will increase the numbers of NEETS. I don’t think many realise how many desperate families shut out of treatment there are.

OP posts:
Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 17/11/2026 21:09

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 20:50

Families with very unwell complex children don’t want gimmicks and hubs they want therapies and treatments, the very things NEETS are going to be prioritised for and getting quicker. Waiting makes conditions harder to treat. Sorry but dragging unwell children into school only to be pushed further down the list for treatment they need is ludicrous. Desperate parents aren’t daft and will pull their kids out of school.

I understand that that is what families with very unwell complex children want and need, but I think there is potential that the proposals in the Milburn report, if properly implemented, will actually improve mental health provision for all children. My understanding is that the aim is that by giving NEET young people with lower-level anxiety or depression immediate community support without needing a formal diagnosis, you’re actually stopping those young people from clogging up the specialist clinicians needed by children with more severe, complex conditions.

As I understand it, the fast track for NEET young people only applies to basic counselling services and talking therapies. As far as I’m aware, they are not talking about fast tracking access to specialist paediatricians, occupational therapists, speech and language therapists, or acute services. So, I don’t think putting an unemployed 19-year-old into a 3-month talking therapy course will in reality take a slot away from a school child needing complex clinical treatment.