Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Milburn’s idea of prioritising NEETS for MH treatment and therapy over other YP more complex and ill who are managing to cling onto education will be catastrophic

139 replies

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 16:41

They’re already being left to get 100 times worse on hideously long wait lists which will now get even longer. Why should those with lesser need be prioritised simply because they’re not in education or work? Many seriously ill YP are battling to hold on to education by the skin of their teeth. Not being in education or work doesn’t mean you’re more ill or more deserving of treatment.They’ll be losing their PIP which many use for therapies and treatments so won’t be able to go private. Parents will have no choice but to pull them out of education if they want to get help,which will add to the NEET numbers!

OP posts:
Onlyontuesday · Yesterday 06:45

Kgti774 · Yesterday 06:41

It’s not about being livid.If you had a seriously mentally unwell child you’d do anything and I mean anything to get them help. Pulling them out of school would be my first point of action. Why put them through the added stress and strain if they’re going to be penalised for it?

Education is important for its own sake, not just accessing treatment.

Children with intense anxiety, depression, emotional regulation problems, EDs and trauma still need to have a sense of future and to engage in something meaningful.

GimmieABreakOr3 · Yesterday 06:46

Kgti774 · Yesterday 06:41

It’s not about being livid.If you had a seriously mentally unwell child you’d do anything and I mean anything to get them help. Pulling them out of school would be my first point of action. Why put them through the added stress and strain if they’re going to be penalised for it?

I am sorry but you do seem to be conflating two issues with one another. It seems you are angry that your children are without support and on lengthy waiting lists for therapy. That isn’t a reason to take them out of school. They’ll be benefitting from going to school. It’s not all about therapy!

Downalongandupalong · Yesterday 06:47

It doesn't say NEETs will be 'prioritised'. Again, read the report. From about .520 onwards it describes the changes in the MH system they think need to happen, which also- as well as the interventions through the YOS which is the suite of interventions I think you're talking about- looks at reform and funding of children's and adolescent mental health services.

'At risk of becoming NEET' is also an intervention category.

Kgti774 · Yesterday 06:51

GimmieABreakOr3 · Yesterday 06:46

I am sorry but you do seem to be conflating two issues with one another. It seems you are angry that your children are without support and on lengthy waiting lists for therapy. That isn’t a reason to take them out of school. They’ll be benefitting from going to school. It’s not all about therapy!

No they don’t benefit from going to school when serious mental illness goes untreated. More trauma and difficulties simply get added on top.There is decently no benefit if you are going to be shut out of therapy and counselling others not going through the additional stress and trauma are being prioritised for.

OP posts:
GimmieABreakOr3 · Yesterday 06:54

Kgti774 · Yesterday 06:51

No they don’t benefit from going to school when serious mental illness goes untreated. More trauma and difficulties simply get added on top.There is decently no benefit if you are going to be shut out of therapy and counselling others not going through the additional stress and trauma are being prioritised for.

Therapy isn’t everything! Mental health is holistic. And if it was that serious, they wouldn’t even be managing going to school. You don’t seem to want to see any other perspective but your own. It sounds like you just want someone to blame.

Kgti774 · Yesterday 06:56

Downalongandupalong · Yesterday 06:47

It doesn't say NEETs will be 'prioritised'. Again, read the report. From about .520 onwards it describes the changes in the MH system they think need to happen, which also- as well as the interventions through the YOS which is the suite of interventions I think you're talking about- looks at reform and funding of children's and adolescent mental health services.

'At risk of becoming NEET' is also an intervention category.

Parents are getting nothing for seriously unwell young people and haven’t for a very long time.They will grasp at anything and should. No parent is going to sit there waiting for the magic treatment fairy that will never arrive or is taking decades to arrive if counselling and therapy is to be had by coming off role.

As I said there are many many people who should know better who don’t know the reality of MH services and what families are battling with

OP posts:
Sartre · Yesterday 06:56

There’s an awful lot of holes in his review. I got 100 pages in yesterday so need to complete it today. I’m not sure where the additional counsellors are coming from. We already have an enormous backlog of young people and frankly adults awaiting NHS therapy, how is this going to be cleared? Massive epidemic of anxiety in YP and his solution is to wave a magic wand, it seems.

I also worry about the SEND YP who are going to lose their PIP but it’s ok because employers will adapt their training to them. Which employers exactly?

Sartre · Yesterday 06:57

GimmieABreakOr3 · Yesterday 06:54

Therapy isn’t everything! Mental health is holistic. And if it was that serious, they wouldn’t even be managing going to school. You don’t seem to want to see any other perspective but your own. It sounds like you just want someone to blame.

Many don’t go to school.

Kgti774 · Yesterday 06:59

GimmieABreakOr3 · Yesterday 06:54

Therapy isn’t everything! Mental health is holistic. And if it was that serious, they wouldn’t even be managing going to school. You don’t seem to want to see any other perspective but your own. It sounds like you just want someone to blame.

Wrong! Many do manage to keep on role by the skin of their teeth with periods off or attending 1 or 2 days a week.

Many families have tried everything and are doing everything and found that actually what is needed is the correct treatment in a timely fashion.

OP posts:
GimmieABreakOr3 · Yesterday 07:00

Sartre · Yesterday 06:57

Many don’t go to school.

But that’s what makes them NEET, and this is what the government are trying to focus on.

Kgti774 · Yesterday 07:02

GimmieABreakOr3 · Yesterday 07:00

But that’s what makes them NEET, and this is what the government are trying to focus on.

Many do go to school or are kept on role- by the skin of their teeth.Thats what makes them not NEET and shut out of support.

OP posts:
Sartre · Yesterday 07:04

GimmieABreakOr3 · Yesterday 07:00

But that’s what makes them NEET, and this is what the government are trying to focus on.

But you’re saying if their MH was so severe they wouldn’t go to school and that’s my point, they don’t go to school. He’s claiming we can wave a magic wand and find additional trained counsellors to fix the humongous anxiety epidemic but I don’t see how.

HonourExistingClaimants · Yesterday 07:04

He would be better off paying private therapists £3k per YP for 6 months of therapy than companies to hire and fire them within 6 months! NHS/camhs doesn’t have capacity to see everyone who needs seeing so until that’s sorted he should leave the benefits safety net in place and look at therapy and volunteer schemes to gain skills

Sartre · Yesterday 07:05

Where are the trained teachers coming from to teach the new technical skills too? Sorry, I just found a million holes in it. He’s tried but I worry about the material reality.

Kgti774 · Yesterday 07:10

HonourExistingClaimants · Yesterday 07:04

He would be better off paying private therapists £3k per YP for 6 months of therapy than companies to hire and fire them within 6 months! NHS/camhs doesn’t have capacity to see everyone who needs seeing so until that’s sorted he should leave the benefits safety net in place and look at therapy and volunteer schemes to gain skills

The removal of PIP is an additional disaster waiting to happen that will compound it. Many parents pay for private psychiatry, treatments, transport and therapies via PIP that will be keeping them on school role by the skin of their teeth . They will now no longer be able to do so. CAMHs and adult MH services are going to be at a huge amount of additional pressure because of this thus making the crumbs left for those with kids not NEET even less.

OP posts:
Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Yesterday 07:19

EasternStandard · 17/11/2026 23:16

Tax breaks? Labour just lumbered small businesses with higher taxes. Their approach is not a strength it’s poor policy to get it that wrong.

I don’t think this is - or should be - party political. If the political debate about the Milburn report descends into Labour did this, the Conservatives did that, then the problem won’t get solved, and young people will miss out. The NEET numbers have been rising for over two decades, so, clearly no one government or political party is to blame. Regardless of whoever made whatever mistakes in the past, I think it’s good this government is tackling it now.

The Milburn report recommends tax breaks (including lower N.I contributions) and hiring grants for businesses employing young people. I think that’s a good thing. If you think the main problem is it’s too expensive for SMEs to hire young people, then I’m surprised you don’t too.

Kgti774 · Yesterday 07:22

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Yesterday 07:19

I don’t think this is - or should be - party political. If the political debate about the Milburn report descends into Labour did this, the Conservatives did that, then the problem won’t get solved, and young people will miss out. The NEET numbers have been rising for over two decades, so, clearly no one government or political party is to blame. Regardless of whoever made whatever mistakes in the past, I think it’s good this government is tackling it now.

The Milburn report recommends tax breaks (including lower N.I contributions) and hiring grants for businesses employing young people. I think that’s a good thing. If you think the main problem is it’s too expensive for SMEs to hire young people, then I’m surprised you don’t too.

Edited

I don’t blame Labour for this. Most of the NEET problem has stemmed from Tory policies.

I will however highlight holes, issues and clear ignorance in Milburn’s report when it will be the basis for future Labour policy.

OP posts:
EasternStandard · Yesterday 07:32

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Yesterday 07:19

I don’t think this is - or should be - party political. If the political debate about the Milburn report descends into Labour did this, the Conservatives did that, then the problem won’t get solved, and young people will miss out. The NEET numbers have been rising for over two decades, so, clearly no one government or political party is to blame. Regardless of whoever made whatever mistakes in the past, I think it’s good this government is tackling it now.

The Milburn report recommends tax breaks (including lower N.I contributions) and hiring grants for businesses employing young people. I think that’s a good thing. If you think the main problem is it’s too expensive for SMEs to hire young people, then I’m surprised you don’t too.

Edited

I’m sure Labour don’t want the tax hikes mentioned. Labour could not understand a jobs tax hits jobs, and yet they couldn’t hear anything from SMEs or anyone saying what would happen. So we had the NI hike.

Of course any young person who faced a long period of rejection could develop anxiety, stress, depression; anything that would trigger the need for talking services or other support.

That’s bad for them and a cost to fund.

Downalongandupalong · Yesterday 07:36

Kgti774 · Yesterday 07:10

The removal of PIP is an additional disaster waiting to happen that will compound it. Many parents pay for private psychiatry, treatments, transport and therapies via PIP that will be keeping them on school role by the skin of their teeth . They will now no longer be able to do so. CAMHs and adult MH services are going to be at a huge amount of additional pressure because of this thus making the crumbs left for those with kids not NEET even less.

Edited

The proposal is that DLA is extended to 18 though (which seems right). I do think the financial support package for over 18s needs a lot more thought - the localised approach rings a lot of alarm bells without clear guardrails. My DC gets DLA- I would obviously prefer a more sustainable option of correctly supported work with targeted support rather than what would be quite precarious PIP at 16, which I've always thought is an inappropriate transition point anyway.

But I think we're going to have to look at this in coordination with the devolution white paper which should give a clearer idea on what some of those guardrails are.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Yesterday 07:38

Kgti774 · Yesterday 07:22

I don’t blame Labour for this. Most of the NEET problem has stemmed from Tory policies.

I will however highlight holes, issues and clear ignorance in Milburn’s report when it will be the basis for future Labour policy.

Yes, I can tell you’re not being party political - I was specifically answering a PP who quoted me. My personal POV is that this is a long term, deeply complex problem, and I do think it’s going to take a multi pronged approach.

On balance, I do think Milburn’s proposals are a really strong package of interventions, but reading your posts, I can understand your concern that even though it is not the intention, when counselling and talking therapies are so scarce, it might inadvertently incentivise families to take kids out of school.

I think there’ll be a consultation phase before anything is implemented though so hopefully parents and mental health practitioners will work the government to address those concerns before anything is put into place.

EasternStandard · Yesterday 07:39

5128gap · Yesterday 06:14

Because the government is trying to run the country on a shoe string, with an electorate who don't seem to think anyone can be asked to pay more tax, and detractors constantly yapping on about cutting welfare to fund defence and stirring the public into panic. They think prioritising support to adults who could work will cut welfare and bring in more money.

The tax burden is higher now, what do you mean ‘shoestring’?

Ik some are keen to pay more but usually they’re asking for others to. And we’re £3trn in debt because voters keep demanding more.

Kgti774 · Yesterday 07:45

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · Yesterday 07:38

Yes, I can tell you’re not being party political - I was specifically answering a PP who quoted me. My personal POV is that this is a long term, deeply complex problem, and I do think it’s going to take a multi pronged approach.

On balance, I do think Milburn’s proposals are a really strong package of interventions, but reading your posts, I can understand your concern that even though it is not the intention, when counselling and talking therapies are so scarce, it might inadvertently incentivise families to take kids out of school.

I think there’ll be a consultation phase before anything is implemented though so hopefully parents and mental health practitioners will work the government to address those concerns before anything is put into place.

Yes, let’s hope.

OP posts:
Haggishenri · Yesterday 08:39

I’m Scottish and have an autistic child. What was most effective in helping was getting occupational therapy. Someone who gave my child practical solutions to coping with things like friendships / bitchiness / screeching kids in school / coping with classroom violence / corridor attacks just really coping with the unmitigated violence of a modern day Scottish state secondary. Strategies also for things like wearing clothes with textures that were hard to cope with (school uniform), the stress of talking to people you didn’t know etc etc. this was on CAMHS and I got shoved up the list via an effective Labour MSP. Don’t waste your time with the sNP / Green MSPs they’re utterly useless.

We did 6 x 45 min sessions and then school was bearable. We need to treat these things early before they get bigger. If the violence in Scottish schools are actually addressed too that would be massively helpful. Random
assaults and screaming kids are totally overwhelming. Help is there, you just need an effective MSP to kick up a huge fuss.

And these changes are mainly to do with England. Any NI changes would affect Scotland, and the cuts to PIP would filter through to the Scottish budget, but will Scotland cut their vast benefits bill? Who knows.

Hoardasurass · Yesterday 09:15

Downalongandupalong · Yesterday 06:34

The strategy is about NEETs. Why would it mention other groups? It's focused on a particular cohort and a particular type of help. Have you read the paper?

There are also SEND reforms coming, there's also a new mental health strategy white paper coming just before Christmas. Why don't you look at all of those things together?

It might be that they are inadequate, but the NEETs work can't be a theory of everything.

What we need is a complete shake up at camhs. More staff, money and resources and a legal requirement to treat asd children for the co-morbidities that often comes with it.
We need actual individually targeted talking therapy for those who need it at the point in time that its needed.
We should never be in a position where children who have attempted suicide are being sent home and told that its a year+ wait for any help or that crippling anxiety and/or debilitating phobias will not be treated as the child is autistic.
None of the measures that you have talked about will do anything to provide what is really needed when it comes to camhs or sen provisions at schools because we dont have the money or trained councillors, psychologists, psychiatrists and sen teachers

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 13:08

Kgti774 · Yesterday 06:29

I didn’t say that. As I said it was stated quite clearly that young people who are already Neet should have guaranteed access to fast-track services like talking therapies and counselling within three months. There is next to no talking therapy or counselling anywhere. You can have tried to take your life several times and not get anything. When people are fast tracked others are pushed down the queue. That is a fact.The numbers of NEETs are supposed to be huge so that's a significant push down. As a parent I absolutely wouldn't be pushing through with school now. Getting support and treatment for mental health trumps everything. When the treatable is left it gets massively worse and harder to treat which impacts life and costs the tax payer significantly more

Milburn clearly doesn’t have a clue re what is going on in MH services and how widespread struggles through a complete lack of services are. I find that ignorance hugely concerning. There are many many families struggling with work and education that are battling to get support and help for very unwell young people who are not documented as NEET. Being NEET absolutely does not make you more needy by default,

Edited

His remit is to report on Neets, not to resolve mental health care.

Swipe left for the next trending thread