Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Milburn’s idea of prioritising NEETS for MH treatment and therapy over other YP more complex and ill who are managing to cling onto education will be catastrophic

139 replies

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 16:41

They’re already being left to get 100 times worse on hideously long wait lists which will now get even longer. Why should those with lesser need be prioritised simply because they’re not in education or work? Many seriously ill YP are battling to hold on to education by the skin of their teeth. Not being in education or work doesn’t mean you’re more ill or more deserving of treatment.They’ll be losing their PIP which many use for therapies and treatments so won’t be able to go private. Parents will have no choice but to pull them out of education if they want to get help,which will add to the NEET numbers!

OP posts:
GimmieABreakOr3 · 17/11/2026 21:10

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 21:05

Desperate parents won’t! But this is
ludicrous as it will increase the numbers of NEETS. I don’t think many realise how many desperate families shut out of treatment there are.

Are you really saying that your children will NOT benefit from some of the proposals on this list:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq074grvdpz2o

Mental health and emotional wellbeing is holistic. It’s not just about therapy and medication. Having access to good education, training and job opportunities, having an optimistic outlook for the future, something that helps your self esteem and gives you purpose in life ALL contribute to good mental health… this is what the government is trying to support!

A young woman working machinery and wearing protective earphones

Neets review at a glance: Key proposals from Alan Milburn's report

A major review proposes widespread changes to help get young people into work across the UK.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq074grvdpz2o

Oliveoy · 17/11/2026 21:12

likelysuspect · 17/11/2026 20:38

You wouldnt think we're a first world country would you. Its a disgrace.

It is, it's a disgrace. When DD was diagnosed I was prepared for a wait for treatment, but I couldn't have imagined we'd just be sent away to manage it ourselves. Every referral that's been made (child psychology team, CAMHS, out of area services) has been rejected. Further to that I made a complaint to the trust nearly 6 months ago about the lack of care and that still hasn't been answered. On her worst days she's had more than 10 seizures, full loss of consciousness. Nobody cares.

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 21:16

GimmieABreakOr3 · 17/11/2026 21:10

Are you really saying that your children will NOT benefit from some of the proposals on this list:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cq074grvdpz2o

Mental health and emotional wellbeing is holistic. It’s not just about therapy and medication. Having access to good education, training and job opportunities, having an optimistic outlook for the future, something that helps your self esteem and gives you purpose in life ALL contribute to good mental health… this is what the government is trying to support!

I’m talking about the prioritising of NEETs for MH treatment not the entire list. That said the most important thing is access to the right early MH treatment delivered by those with expertise. The rest is meaningless as if very unwell you can’t access the rest.

OP posts:
Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 21:21

Oliveoy · 17/11/2026 21:12

It is, it's a disgrace. When DD was diagnosed I was prepared for a wait for treatment, but I couldn't have imagined we'd just be sent away to manage it ourselves. Every referral that's been made (child psychology team, CAMHS, out of area services) has been rejected. Further to that I made a complaint to the trust nearly 6 months ago about the lack of care and that still hasn't been answered. On her worst days she's had more than 10 seizures, full loss of consciousness. Nobody cares.

What families are going through is a national disgrace, people don’t realise how dire mental health services are until they are in this hideous situation. The victimising of those with MH, autism
and ADHD is also appalling as is the ignorance form those who should know better. Can’t help feeling further down the line there will be another report highlighting this.

OP posts:
GimmieABreakOr3 · 17/11/2026 21:22

Kgti774 · 17/11/2026 21:16

I’m talking about the prioritising of NEETs for MH treatment not the entire list. That said the most important thing is access to the right early MH treatment delivered by those with expertise. The rest is meaningless as if very unwell you can’t access the rest.

OK, I hear you. So there is potentially a gap in these proposals.

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 17/11/2026 21:30

When my now 18 year old was 12 he took an overdose and nearly died. Camhs did an assessment and said they wouldn't be able to help him because it was obvious he had asd. Except he wasn't diagnosed with asd because his needs weren't considered severe enough to go on the waiting list. He was finally given a diagnosis of autism aged 17. He now gets the highest amount of PIP.

I think the hardest part is with my 20 year old. Because my younger children don't know whether they have PIP/DLA or not. My 18 year old knows but doesn't really care about it. But my 20 year old knows and understands. He was getting PIP and then it was taken away. He spent his entire childhood trusting professionals in health, education, social care and government. He now thinks there are people who don't believe he is disabled. He works and is at uni which he is fully expecting to do. He works hard for not much money and he doesn't think that because he has autism he gets out of doing things. He knows he is capable of working so he does. He is limited as to what kind of work he can do but he has managed to get 2 part time jobs and we are really proud of him. For my son PIP isn't just about the money, it's about the recognition that he has a disability and he has to work harder than other people to do the same thing. He is always being told he doesn't have "proper autism " because he doesn't have learning disabilities. The PIP was like a certificate of recognition and now it's gone.

seahorsessky · 17/11/2026 21:30

I didn't think the PIP being removed for all under 25s had been finalised? Fair enough, if I'm wrong then ok.
Something does have to change though. Very few of my friends at school/college tried to access MH (if you want to say maybe there was a stigma so they didn't say, or that maybe more of them should have done, fine), yet family with teenagers say massive numbers of them do nowadays, yet there's not many more services provided than in 2000, it seems.
We need support for all young people, not just some, although there are already cases where help is prioritised to certain groups in the NHS. A midwife says younger mums and those with drug or other problems get more support in maternity than most mums, for example.

Hoardasurass · 17/11/2026 21:33

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 17/11/2026 21:09

I understand that that is what families with very unwell complex children want and need, but I think there is potential that the proposals in the Milburn report, if properly implemented, will actually improve mental health provision for all children. My understanding is that the aim is that by giving NEET young people with lower-level anxiety or depression immediate community support without needing a formal diagnosis, you’re actually stopping those young people from clogging up the specialist clinicians needed by children with more severe, complex conditions.

As I understand it, the fast track for NEET young people only applies to basic counselling services and talking therapies. As far as I’m aware, they are not talking about fast tracking access to specialist paediatricians, occupational therapists, speech and language therapists, or acute services. So, I don’t think putting an unemployed 19-year-old into a 3-month talking therapy course will in reality take a slot away from a school child needing complex clinical treatment.

Do you honestly think that this or any other government are actually going to put the money, staff (wherever they'll come from) and resources into this that ots going to need to work the way you describe and not take money staff and scant resources from the already underfunded camhs service?

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 17/11/2026 22:08

Hoardasurass · 17/11/2026 21:33

Do you honestly think that this or any other government are actually going to put the money, staff (wherever they'll come from) and resources into this that ots going to need to work the way you describe and not take money staff and scant resources from the already underfunded camhs service?

That’s a good question, and I’m genuinely sceptical about how well these recommendations will be implemented. But currently, both NEET young people and young people with complex mental health needs are being failed by the system, and I haven’t seen any better suggestions than these for changing that.

EasternStandard · 17/11/2026 22:25

Hoardasurass · 17/11/2026 21:33

Do you honestly think that this or any other government are actually going to put the money, staff (wherever they'll come from) and resources into this that ots going to need to work the way you describe and not take money staff and scant resources from the already underfunded camhs service?

Milburn says most young he talked to want to work. He cited a young woman who sent 2000 applications. In that instance perhaps she needs a job rather than talking therapies.

I agree it’ll just be money taken from elsewhere in any case.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/11/2026 22:31

You sound like people who complain about doctors treating minor / liveable illnesses when people with major ones are waiting. The reality is that both need dealing with and if we only ever treat the most severe needs far more people will end up very ill. Getting NEETS into support and meaningful work means less money out on benefits and more money in from taxes. This supports the growth we need to fund services for all.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/11/2026 22:36

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 17/11/2026 21:30

When my now 18 year old was 12 he took an overdose and nearly died. Camhs did an assessment and said they wouldn't be able to help him because it was obvious he had asd. Except he wasn't diagnosed with asd because his needs weren't considered severe enough to go on the waiting list. He was finally given a diagnosis of autism aged 17. He now gets the highest amount of PIP.

I think the hardest part is with my 20 year old. Because my younger children don't know whether they have PIP/DLA or not. My 18 year old knows but doesn't really care about it. But my 20 year old knows and understands. He was getting PIP and then it was taken away. He spent his entire childhood trusting professionals in health, education, social care and government. He now thinks there are people who don't believe he is disabled. He works and is at uni which he is fully expecting to do. He works hard for not much money and he doesn't think that because he has autism he gets out of doing things. He knows he is capable of working so he does. He is limited as to what kind of work he can do but he has managed to get 2 part time jobs and we are really proud of him. For my son PIP isn't just about the money, it's about the recognition that he has a disability and he has to work harder than other people to do the same thing. He is always being told he doesn't have "proper autism " because he doesn't have learning disabilities. The PIP was like a certificate of recognition and now it's gone.

Ffs. PIP was never intended to be a certificate of recognition! I’m against the proposals to change it, but what you’re saying is an absolute pisstake. It sounds like something GB News would pretend in order to rile up their viewers.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 17/11/2026 22:40

EasternStandard · 17/11/2026 22:25

Milburn says most young he talked to want to work. He cited a young woman who sent 2000 applications. In that instance perhaps she needs a job rather than talking therapies.

I agree it’ll just be money taken from elsewhere in any case.

Edited

But isn’t the strength of the Milburn report - that it recognises that NEET young people have differing needs and will therefore need differing solutions?

If that young woman doesn’t have mental health barriers, she wouldn’t be offered talking therapy - but she presumably would benefit from the tax breaks and hiring grants he’s proposing for employers.

BluebellBeth · 17/11/2026 23:04

seahorsessky · 17/11/2026 21:30

I didn't think the PIP being removed for all under 25s had been finalised? Fair enough, if I'm wrong then ok.
Something does have to change though. Very few of my friends at school/college tried to access MH (if you want to say maybe there was a stigma so they didn't say, or that maybe more of them should have done, fine), yet family with teenagers say massive numbers of them do nowadays, yet there's not many more services provided than in 2000, it seems.
We need support for all young people, not just some, although there are already cases where help is prioritised to certain groups in the NHS. A midwife says younger mums and those with drug or other problems get more support in maternity than most mums, for example.

It hasn't, it's just a recommendation at the moment. Any changes will have to get through the House of Commons and House of Lords first.

EasternStandard · 17/11/2026 23:16

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 17/11/2026 22:40

But isn’t the strength of the Milburn report - that it recognises that NEET young people have differing needs and will therefore need differing solutions?

If that young woman doesn’t have mental health barriers, she wouldn’t be offered talking therapy - but she presumably would benefit from the tax breaks and hiring grants he’s proposing for employers.

Tax breaks? Labour just lumbered small businesses with higher taxes. Their approach is not a strength it’s poor policy to get it that wrong.

bumblingbovine49 · 17/11/2026 23:56

JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/11/2026 22:36

Ffs. PIP was never intended to be a certificate of recognition! I’m against the proposals to change it, but what you’re saying is an absolute pisstake. It sounds like something GB News would pretend in order to rile up their viewers.

She is just using the "certificate of recognition" as a metaphor to describe a feeling and not a fact. If PIP is taken away, that comes with an implied message that he does not have additional needs, so has lost some external recognition of his difficulties, which will have an impact both emotional and practical. This doesn't man that pip is a literal certificate of recognition Obviously too complex an idea for

My understanding is that PIP is supposed to be used to help someone who has difficulty living a normal life to achieve as close to that as they can. Surely using it to help with accessing employment makes sense and is exactly what it is for. Since her son can work but only with difficulty, maybe the payments allow him to work part time so he can take rest more often and therefore not burn out so he can continue in emplyment long term. What about that is unreasonable?

Kgti774 · Yesterday 05:54

JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/11/2026 22:31

You sound like people who complain about doctors treating minor / liveable illnesses when people with major ones are waiting. The reality is that both need dealing with and if we only ever treat the most severe needs far more people will end up very ill. Getting NEETS into support and meaningful work means less money out on benefits and more money in from taxes. This supports the growth we need to fund services for all.

That is ridiculous. Pushing YP who are more complex and severe down a list simply because they are not NEET means they are far more likely to become NEET and harder to treat thus costing more. And yes the resources for this will be taken from the very few resources we already have those impacting those not NEET even more. To be NEET you just have to not enrolled in education. There are many enrolled but very unwell and only managing a couple of days in school in danger of being NEET who will be under far more difficulty in many cases than those not enrolled at all. Then we have those in part time SEND courses who will also be pushed down the list. If parents are losing PIP on top they will have no choice but to pull their children out of education particularly those whose kids are clinging on by a thread and likely to become NEET anyway.

OP posts:
5128gap · Yesterday 06:14

Because the government is trying to run the country on a shoe string, with an electorate who don't seem to think anyone can be asked to pay more tax, and detractors constantly yapping on about cutting welfare to fund defence and stirring the public into panic. They think prioritising support to adults who could work will cut welfare and bring in more money.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 06:18

I tell you what will be catastrophic.

Fucking up the education system from 2010 to 2024 leading to the shitshow we have today.

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 06:21

JemimaTiggywinkles · 17/11/2026 22:31

You sound like people who complain about doctors treating minor / liveable illnesses when people with major ones are waiting. The reality is that both need dealing with and if we only ever treat the most severe needs far more people will end up very ill. Getting NEETS into support and meaningful work means less money out on benefits and more money in from taxes. This supports the growth we need to fund services for all.

This. They aren't stopping helping everyone in favour of Neets. There is a media focus on them as the findings of the report are coming out.

Kgti774 · Yesterday 06:29

DeftGoldHedgehog · Yesterday 06:21

This. They aren't stopping helping everyone in favour of Neets. There is a media focus on them as the findings of the report are coming out.

I didn’t say that. As I said it was stated quite clearly that young people who are already Neet should have guaranteed access to fast-track services like talking therapies and counselling within three months. There is next to no talking therapy or counselling anywhere. You can have tried to take your life several times and not get anything. When people are fast tracked others are pushed down the queue. That is a fact.The numbers of NEETs are supposed to be huge so that's a significant push down. As a parent I absolutely wouldn't be pushing through with school now. Getting support and treatment for mental health trumps everything. When the treatable is left it gets massively worse and harder to treat which impacts life and costs the tax payer significantly more

Milburn clearly doesn’t have a clue re what is going on in MH services and how widespread struggles through a complete lack of services are. I find that ignorance hugely concerning. There are many many families struggling with work and education that are battling to get support and help for very unwell young people who are not documented as NEET. Being NEET absolutely does not make you more needy by default,

OP posts:
Downalongandupalong · Yesterday 06:34

The strategy is about NEETs. Why would it mention other groups? It's focused on a particular cohort and a particular type of help. Have you read the paper?

There are also SEND reforms coming, there's also a new mental health strategy white paper coming just before Christmas. Why don't you look at all of those things together?

It might be that they are inadequate, but the NEETs work can't be a theory of everything.

Onlyontuesday · Yesterday 06:36

Yes, it is unfair to not base treatment on clinical need. But to have NHS treatment we need a functioning society.

If the government increase taxes they will be out in 2028 by a party that will promise reduced taxes and stark cuts to welfare without the help of prioritised treatment. I doubt the conservatives or reform will be investing in MH either.

If we let these young people stay NEET many of them are very unlikely to enter the workforce. So that's a shitty life for them, and less tax income across a generation to support the NHS.

If I was on a waiting list I would indeed be livid but that doesn't mean it's not the right thing to do.

Kgti774 · Yesterday 06:38

Downalongandupalong · Yesterday 06:34

The strategy is about NEETs. Why would it mention other groups? It's focused on a particular cohort and a particular type of help. Have you read the paper?

There are also SEND reforms coming, there's also a new mental health strategy white paper coming just before Christmas. Why don't you look at all of those things together?

It might be that they are inadequate, but the NEETs work can't be a theory of everything.

Of course it involves other groups. There are next to no resources available. You can’t magic therapists and counsellors out of thin air even if there was more money. If NEETs are going to be prioritised and fast tracked others will be pushed down. There is zero incentive to battle against your child becoming NEET. Priority for treatment should be based on need not whether you’re registered st a school or not. Desperate parents who would do anything to get their kids seen will move them from school. I would in a heartbeat if I knew keeping them on role pushed them further down the queue for help and treatment.

OP posts:
Kgti774 · Yesterday 06:41

Onlyontuesday · Yesterday 06:36

Yes, it is unfair to not base treatment on clinical need. But to have NHS treatment we need a functioning society.

If the government increase taxes they will be out in 2028 by a party that will promise reduced taxes and stark cuts to welfare without the help of prioritised treatment. I doubt the conservatives or reform will be investing in MH either.

If we let these young people stay NEET many of them are very unlikely to enter the workforce. So that's a shitty life for them, and less tax income across a generation to support the NHS.

If I was on a waiting list I would indeed be livid but that doesn't mean it's not the right thing to do.

It’s not about being livid.If you had a seriously mentally unwell child you’d do anything and I mean anything to get them help. Pulling them out of school would be my first point of action. Why put them through the added stress and strain if they’re going to be penalised for it?

OP posts: