Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to treat mum and MIL differently?

106 replies

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 14:23

I live with DH and 11 month old DD. Both our mums live about 45 mins away, fit and healthy, retired, early 60s.

When my MIL comes over to our house she takes us as she finds us and pitches in with family life - she’ll offer to pick up milk/bread on her way over, unload the dishwasher if it finishes whilst she’s here, get DD a snack etc. We obviously don’t expect her to do housework but she always offers and says she wants to be supportive and we really appreciate it! She loves playing with DD and is a great grandma.

My mum loves seeing DD but when she’s here makes a lot of comments about eg the oven not being clean enough or DD’s toys being messy - our house is definitely normal levels of clean and tidy but she is very house proud. She likes to be hosted and wants a formal sit down hot lunch and polite conversation. I find her coming over pretty stressful and hard work so prefer meeting her at a local children’s museum, nice park in the summer, National Trust place etc (all free, not costing her anything) so she can still play with DD.

Mum has started making comments about MIL coming over and is clearly annoyed I don’t invite her as often. I’ve tried talking to her in the past about her comments and she did not take it well AT ALL so now I just suggest the museum and ignore her hints (and don’t mention when MIL is coming!). I want to say ‘MIL doesn’t expect to be treated like the queen when she’s over, that’s the difference’ but won’t to avoid WW3.

We see them roughly as often as each other but AIBU to do different things with them?

OP posts:
Stayandfight · Yesterday 07:57

Loads of posters come up with dramatic, perfect solutions.

My experience is that it won’t happen. I genuinely wonder if having these frank, up front conversations actually work with some people - I’ve tried with my DM and it just causes more drama and sulking. Grey rock, ignoring not seeing her as much are my techniques. Not perfect but they work for me.

No contact is far too dramatic, an argument or challenging her is far too much hard work. And bottom line she is my mum, she is hard work but she is not a ‘nasty piece of work’. I love her, she comes from a far more challenging time and she’s not perfect.

I make the relationship work, it limps along sometimes but it’s there.

Stayandfight · Yesterday 07:58

MrsMcGarry · 17/11/2026 22:27

Totally get this. My stepmother (been in my life since I was toddler - my mum died) is very like this. And I now have my aunt (my mums sister who I only met as an adult) who is the lovely easy person in my life like your MIL who made me realise how lacking my relationship with my stepmother was.

My half sister has gone no contact with my stepmother (her mother). I frankly can't be arsed with that level of drama. I see her just a couple of times a year and grey rock throughout. Light, breezy, Mumsnet head tilt and pretend not to hear when she says anything critical. It works for me and means my now adult children can have a relationship of sorts with her - she doesn't pull the critical narcissistic shit with them because she has always known it would not work because I brought them up to be healthy people because I'd done the therapy work when they were toddlers.

People who don't have parents like this cannot comprehend that a sensible adult conversation would not produce results. But hopefully you've heard enough here to know there are plenty of us who do understand why you can't do that.

It's fine to manage complex relationships like this rather than resolve them. And believe me, the longer you practice the managing, the easier it gets and the less headspace it takes up. My stepmother and father visited 3 weeks ago. We went out for chi-chi dinner at the sort of place she likes, she mostly behaved, and dd and I rolled eyes at each other in a way she could not see when she started criticising the bread. I genuinely have not thought about her between then and reading this now.

It's really sad that you have a more comfortable relationship with your MIL than you do with your mother. But that's on her not you, because I bet you she has similarly difficult and dramatic relationships with other people...? So feel sad for what you didn't get from her, but rejoice you have someone else in your life that can fill that hole, and enjoy it.

I should have just said read this.

Credittocress · Yesterday 08:10

I much prefer my MIL to my mother. My mother seems to think being blood gives her license to criticise me in a way she would never to my SIL.

She crosses boundaries like crazy and it doesn’t even cross her mind they’re wrong. I was staying in hospital with my baby after they were born, they needed some extra care and we had a private room and my mum would just come walking in without knocking, didn’t even cross her mind to knock on the door that opened directly onto the corridor and I might have been getting changed, or feeding or catching up on sleep. The trend has carried on, the feeling she can come into my house and tell me what housework I need to do, what I should eat, how I should dress the kids…. Nothing is off limits

Goinggreymammy · Yesterday 08:17

Screamingabdabz · Yesterday 07:50

She is also learning that you’re only valuable and loveable if you toe the line, empty dishwashers and do grocery shopping.

If I brought milk and started emptying the dishwasher at my son and DIL’s house they’d think I’d gone mad. My DS would’ve already had lunch in and he'd tell me to sit down and relax.

I sense here that the op is fully responsible for domestics - hence why she’s grateful for MIL ‘pitching in’ and why criticisms from her DM of untidiness sting so much. Where is the DH in this? Why can’t he get the milk in when he knows visitors are coming? Can’t he unload the dishwasher?

What are you teaching dd about the roles of men and women?

Finally a voice of reason.
I would also think my PIL had lost the plot if they started doing housework and making food in my house.
We lived with them briefly a few years ago and even then I did all our own housework, cooking, ckeaning, etc. I used to be very annoyed with DH when he left unloading the dishwasher and putting out the bins till late and my FIL would have it done before him.

There's all this talk of boundaries nowadays but its very one sided, there are no boundaries on invoming benefit it seems.

Cosyblankets · Yesterday 08:26

Invite them at the same time see what happens

FridayPieday · Yesterday 19:04

Having gone through something similar but not the same with my Mum it might help you to think about why your Mum makes those comments. I found rationalising it helped me cope.

Is it that she feels usurped in her position as matriarch and desperately wants to keep you in line, and herself in charge?

Is it a slightly OCD/on the spectrum compulsion that she needs to see everything in order?

Is it that she actually sees all the things you are great at and so feels "lesser" as a result and so points out little things to feel better about herself?

Is it that she doesn't really see the clear difference between you and her and the criticism is actually more like negative self-talk?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page