Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to treat mum and MIL differently?

106 replies

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 14:23

I live with DH and 11 month old DD. Both our mums live about 45 mins away, fit and healthy, retired, early 60s.

When my MIL comes over to our house she takes us as she finds us and pitches in with family life - she’ll offer to pick up milk/bread on her way over, unload the dishwasher if it finishes whilst she’s here, get DD a snack etc. We obviously don’t expect her to do housework but she always offers and says she wants to be supportive and we really appreciate it! She loves playing with DD and is a great grandma.

My mum loves seeing DD but when she’s here makes a lot of comments about eg the oven not being clean enough or DD’s toys being messy - our house is definitely normal levels of clean and tidy but she is very house proud. She likes to be hosted and wants a formal sit down hot lunch and polite conversation. I find her coming over pretty stressful and hard work so prefer meeting her at a local children’s museum, nice park in the summer, National Trust place etc (all free, not costing her anything) so she can still play with DD.

Mum has started making comments about MIL coming over and is clearly annoyed I don’t invite her as often. I’ve tried talking to her in the past about her comments and she did not take it well AT ALL so now I just suggest the museum and ignore her hints (and don’t mention when MIL is coming!). I want to say ‘MIL doesn’t expect to be treated like the queen when she’s over, that’s the difference’ but won’t to avoid WW3.

We see them roughly as often as each other but AIBU to do different things with them?

OP posts:
Happyjoe · 17/11/2026 17:03

If your mum expects a hot sit down lunch and you give it then you're feeding the monster! Just tell her that you won't be able to do that anymore, M&S sandwiches going forward will be pushing the boat out! If she remarks on the houseproud stuff, buy a pair of fluffy washing up gloves and pass them to her with a cheerful "here you go mum, crack on".

I guess all you can do if you don't wish for WW3 to start by telling her the truth is stop doing the things she is demanding? She can either still enjoy her visit or.. well, not. That's up to her!

Yay for MIL :-)

TheSmallAssassin · 17/11/2026 17:05

I remember some advice Annalisa Barbieri gave in one of her columns that really struck me, if you ask someone to stop doing something because you don't like it and they don't either they purposely want to hurt you or don't care that it does.

If your mum brings it up again, I would say it one more time, 'I don't invite you to our house because I don't like it when you make "jokes" about how clean and tidy our house is, do you not care about that or are you trying to hurt me on purpose?'. If it comes up again "We've talked about this before, Mum".

My MiL did this kind of thing (and she was in our house once a week very kindly picking our kids up from school) and we eventually had a row about it and I put the kids in after school club instead. Things were a bit frosty for a bit but we are on good terms now (kids are grown up).

My mum would have reacted in the same way as yours too and I did have to pick her up on things, but it just has to be done, she owns her reaction to it, you are making a reasonable request, it's not your problem if she takes umbrage at it, she's a big girl, she will get over it! (Like she is expecting you to!)

Stayandfight · 17/11/2026 17:06

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 15:05

Thank you all, I really appreciate it!

MIL is a gem and I’m very lucky - I didn’t know her super well before DD but she’s been brilliant. I think it has also made me reflect on my relationship with my mum more and realise how hard I find her criticisms/defensiveness because I feel how much easier it is with MIL (and how she is with DH too). It does make me sad tbh.

Totally understand why people are saying to say something to my mum but honestly I feel like I’ve tried it all - if I say something in the moment she says ‘I’m just joking, you’re so sensitive!’. If I say beforehand ‘take us as you find us’ she says ‘of course, you know I like to make things easy’ and then makes the same comments?! I’ve tried having bigger picture conversations with her in the past when she’s been critical about other things and it descends into ‘I can’t say anything, you think I’m a terrible person etc etc’ so I’ve reached this point through a lot of trial and error! It doesn’t feel like she has the self awareness to either stop herself making comments or to hear me when I try to talk to her about them if that makes sense.

Writing all this out I’m realising how hard work I find all of this with her - especially when I have a baby who doesn’t sleep very well and could just do with some moral support - so I think I’m definitely going to stick with keeping it light and out of the house, I don’t have the energy for drama!

I could have written this about my DM. Over the years I’ve tried, jokes, serious conversations, asides, I’ve talked about ‘friends’ mothers - you name it I’ve tried it. It doesn’t work.

I give her what I can, but the open, honest relationship I want isn’t on offer. I restrict information when I know it will make her upset, I grey rock the negative comments and live me life. It’s a source of sadness to me but it is what it is and it’s her choice.

importantupdate · 17/11/2026 17:12

Tbh I’d just be honest about it. “MIL takes us as she finds us so I feel less pressure to have a perfect house and meal at the ready”. Maybe she will self reflect and realise she’s being a judgy cow.

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · 17/11/2026 17:16

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 16:16

Promise I’m not arguing but genuinely curious to know what it’s like for other people - for those who are saying they’d just be honest, if this was your mum how would she react to that? Because DH said he thinks if it were MIL she’d be hurt/offended for a minute then apologise and do things differently in future, and that’s just wild to me because I know my mum would have a HUGE reaction, saying she can’t believe I’m saying MIL is a better grandma than her, how devastating for her to have a daughter that says such awful things etc etc. And then maybe behave differently for 1 visit and then go back.

I know logically that that’s a really disproportionate reaction, but I think I’m realising that I’m so used to it that I can’t fully imagine being able to say something like this to my mum and it go down awkwardly but not terribly?

DH said he thinks if it were MIL she’d be hurt/offended for a minute then apologise and do things differently in future

Pretty much this. As that’s how people behave, as a general rule. And my parents are pretty normal people. We have conversations, listen to each others’ points of view and have a pleasant respectful relationship.

It sounds like there are broader issues with your mother.

Freshrain · 17/11/2026 17:22

for those who are saying they’d just be honest, if this was your mum how would she react to that? Because DH said he thinks if it were MIL she’d be hurt/offended for a minute then apologise and do things differently in future, and that’s just wild to me because I know my mum would have a HUGE reaction, saying she can’t believe I’m saying MIL is a better grandma than her, how devastating for her to have a daughter that says such awful things

It is difficult to know, I suppose, because my Mum wasn't like that.

I think, if possible, try to keep your MiL out of it, and not compare directly, but when she asks "Why can't I come round to your house like MiL does?", answer "Because you expect to be waited on hand and foot, and expect us to cook you a lovely meal and 'host you' as you would a guest" but without saying 'unlike MiL who chips in and doesn't create work for us.

I voted YANBU, but actually, you seem to be bending over backwards being more than generous to your mother, who should be a support to you, not work for you, when you have a baby. I speak here as a MiL to my dgc's Mum.

outerspacepotato · 17/11/2026 17:28

Your mother is demanding and critical. No wonder you dread her visits.

I'd be honest and let her explode. This is the reason why the difference in treatment. Let her do whatever she wants after that. She's probably not going to change, but she'll probably freeze you out for at least a time and you'll have some peace.

Or, the first critical remark, make her leave. Tell her she gets what she gets and if she can't be pleasant, you won't be hosting her and she gets consequences for criticism and demands. Stop catering to her, she's being a bitch.

Shufflebumnessie · 17/11/2026 17:30

YANBU. I can completely empathise. I'm very lucky in that my PiL are lovely people, and I feel awful saying it but I prefer spending time with them rather than my own parents. My in-laws will always ask what they can do to help in certain circumstances, they actively want to spend time with our DC, doing things that the DC will enjoy. They complement our parenting, tell me how lucky they are to have me as DiL etc.
On the other hand, my dad is completely disinterested in anything that he doesn't deem important or interesting, and just wants to do his own thing.
My mum thinks she's really laid back and flexible but if things aren't going the way she wants, or thinks they should be, then she gets all defensive and sulky. When they come to visit, my dad will just go out on endless walks and my mum will just sit reading her paper. She thinks she's a doting grandmother but actually has no interest in finding out anything about DC. They'll be telling her something they like eg Minecraft, but because she doesn't know anything about it she'll just cut them off and start talking Janet's new shed (who the hell is Janet?!).
I remember, hours after having our first baby we invited both sets of parents to visit. My in-laws bought sandwiches, cakes, snacks, drinks etc for us all to share so that we didn't need to think about food/drink. Plus, a balloon & flowers for me, and gifts for DS. My mum sent me message after message asking what time PiL were arriving, how she needed to arrive before them because she wanted to be the first to hold DS, and they turned up with nothing (not that I expected anything but the contrast was stark!).
Nothing ever seems quite good enough. I always feel like I'm a disappointment (only child).
To be honest, I've really reduced contact with them as I find it emotionally exhausting. If I try to raise anything I'm just met with denial, defence, sulking, tears, strained atmosphere etc. Oh, and throw in a bit of "well, I'll probably be dead soon" too.
Sorry, that turned into a bit of a cathartic rant but in short, I completely understand!

Pearlstillsinging · 17/11/2026 17:37

You could invite her for lunch "It'll just be soup and sandwiches, Mum" and have the oven cleaner at hand for when she comments on the state of your oven. "Here you go, Mum, feel free to get it up to your standard".

TheMimsy · 17/11/2026 17:37

@Sunshinetoday26 what are your mums relationships like with other people? Her parents/friends/family? Do you have your dad around or other siblings?

DiamondDandelion · 17/11/2026 18:25

My MIL was exactly the same, she passed away the start of this year leaving a huge gap in our lives. She was simply wonderful, I knew her 20 years and never once felt judged ever! My own Mum is very judgemental. We all had a much closer relationship with my MIL to my own Mum. Don't feel bad, you reep what you sew!

MrEdwardElizabethHitler · 17/11/2026 18:25

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 16:16

Promise I’m not arguing but genuinely curious to know what it’s like for other people - for those who are saying they’d just be honest, if this was your mum how would she react to that? Because DH said he thinks if it were MIL she’d be hurt/offended for a minute then apologise and do things differently in future, and that’s just wild to me because I know my mum would have a HUGE reaction, saying she can’t believe I’m saying MIL is a better grandma than her, how devastating for her to have a daughter that says such awful things etc etc. And then maybe behave differently for 1 visit and then go back.

I know logically that that’s a really disproportionate reaction, but I think I’m realising that I’m so used to it that I can’t fully imagine being able to say something like this to my mum and it go down awkwardly but not terribly?

I have a completely different relationship with my DPs, they're much more the muck in type. So freely admit it's me talking about something that would never happen to me.

However.... is your mum not a pain in the arse already? It doesn't sound like you have much to lose. If she kicks off, you do the same right back, and if she doesn't change her behaviour you haven't actually lost anything.

The less nuclear option might be perhaps to tell her you feel hurt when she slags off the state of the house, trowel it on if necessary. Do it incrementally. But this relies on her playing ball and you may just end up in the position where you have to either drop a truth bomb or keep putting up with it.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 17/11/2026 18:31

‘I’m sorry to have to say it, Mum, but MiL is helpful and uncritical, but I’m afraid I can’t say the same for you.’

comealongdobbeh · 17/11/2026 18:32

Right now, your DD is 11 months.

Soon, she’ll be old enough for your mother to start making comments at her, and she will be old enough to understand.

Whether WW3 erupts or not, put your foot down now and every time your mother reverts back, reset the boundary.

Chilly80 · 17/11/2026 18:32

I would stick as you are. It built up in me over years (Dad not mum) till I snapped one day and we didn't talk for nearly 2 years. He finally apologised sort of but another 2 years on we are still very low contact.

Holeymoley28 · 17/11/2026 18:35

Oh and my mum would likely strop off in a tantrum then come crawling back after a few days as if nothing happened but would then actually be behaving.

She wouldn’t mention it again because that would be her admitting she was wrong but she would take a breather and deal with it.

Iknewit · 17/11/2026 18:38

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 16:16

Promise I’m not arguing but genuinely curious to know what it’s like for other people - for those who are saying they’d just be honest, if this was your mum how would she react to that? Because DH said he thinks if it were MIL she’d be hurt/offended for a minute then apologise and do things differently in future, and that’s just wild to me because I know my mum would have a HUGE reaction, saying she can’t believe I’m saying MIL is a better grandma than her, how devastating for her to have a daughter that says such awful things etc etc. And then maybe behave differently for 1 visit and then go back.

I know logically that that’s a really disproportionate reaction, but I think I’m realising that I’m so used to it that I can’t fully imagine being able to say something like this to my mum and it go down awkwardly but not terribly?

My mum would also react like yours and I can understand being reluctant to challenge her but if you want to continue having a relationship with her it can’t all be on her terms.

I agree that making a direct comparison with your MIL will go down really badly.

I would challenge my mum in the moment and would respond if she made rude comments.
This isn’t everyone’s approach and some are much more conflict averse with their families but I have never been willing to let her behave that way in my home.

You have a choice.
Carry on as you are and find a way to accept it and cope with it which is hard.

You reduce contact further to protect yourself and your family.

You write to her, meet up with her and tell her what isn’t ok and you remind/challenge her in the moment. ‘Mum, I’m not listening to this’ etc Just shut it down and walk away.

Hatty65 · 17/11/2026 18:40

You won't change her, OP, My mother is like this and always has been. I avoided them apart from 'duty' visits because she was critical. Fairly recently she first of all said, 'We've not seen much of you lately' and then 5 minutes later said, 'You've put a lot of weight on. You really ought to watch what you eat a bit more'.

I responded with 'I've not been for a while because Dad always makes me feel unwelcome and you are so critical that I usually go away feeling shit about myself. It puts me off coming to be honest'. She was taken aback and said, 'Oh. We don't mean to'. I followed up by asking her if it was necessary to say unkind things every time I came and she was a bit shame faced and said, 'No. I suppose not'.

But it hasn't changed anything. Last time I saw her she said, 'Your hair looks dreadful'.

Iknewit · 17/11/2026 18:43

Hatty65 · 17/11/2026 18:40

You won't change her, OP, My mother is like this and always has been. I avoided them apart from 'duty' visits because she was critical. Fairly recently she first of all said, 'We've not seen much of you lately' and then 5 minutes later said, 'You've put a lot of weight on. You really ought to watch what you eat a bit more'.

I responded with 'I've not been for a while because Dad always makes me feel unwelcome and you are so critical that I usually go away feeling shit about myself. It puts me off coming to be honest'. She was taken aback and said, 'Oh. We don't mean to'. I followed up by asking her if it was necessary to say unkind things every time I came and she was a bit shame faced and said, 'No. I suppose not'.

But it hasn't changed anything. Last time I saw her she said, 'Your hair looks dreadful'.

I started getting up and leaving the room if my mum said stuff like this when challenging didn’t work. Sometimes I’d leave the house if I was at hers.

Ultimately it didn’t change so I stopped seeing her at all.

It’s soul destroying.

crochetandshit · 17/11/2026 19:13

"you know the answer mum, you just don't like it"

FreshAirandSunshine · 17/11/2026 19:22

Easy to say tell her straight if you don’t have a parent who is so totally focused on their own needs to the exclusion of all other rational perspectives! Like you OP I’ve learnt that these things need to be worked around rather than confronted because the weeping, wailing and gnashing of teeth that results from a gentle but honest conversation is simply not worth it. Apart from the aggro it causes it does not impact on the behaviour one bit, indeed sometimes the behaviour becomes more extreme seemingly just to make a point. As you’ve recognised, the key is in not providing information about when/how often you see MIL and in response to questions about it to be so vague as if to suggest that you barely register MIL’s existence. You’re definitely not being unreasonable, keep doing what you’re doing and remain bright and breezy about it.

ByPinkOP · 17/11/2026 19:47

I think the way you are currently handling it is spot on!
You can’t change who your mum is, so you are setting in place appropriate mechanisms that allows for that and still having a relationship.

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 20:07

Oh gosh stepped away for a bit to do the evening routine, thank you so so much to everyone who’s taken the time to reply!

I really didn’t mean for this to be a drip feed but of course you’re all absolutely right that this is part of a wider issue/pattern with my mum - I have done therapy about it in the past around my wedding and when I was pregnant but I guess things will keep popping up. I knew in the abstract that having my own DD would bring up feelings about my mum but there have definitely been times where I’ve been quite taken aback by it. A friend with a difficult relationship with her mum said to me when I was newly postpartum ‘sometimes you want A mum but not YOUR mum’ and that stuck with me - I think MIL being so supportive is really lovely and painful at the same time because it’s such a contrast.

One super helpful thing I’ve realised from this thread - thank you - is that I’m sometimes centring my mum even when I don’t realise. So if the starting point is ‘I know my mum wants to come to my house so what do I do?’ I get tied up in knots, but if the starting point is ‘what is the best way I can have a nice time with DD with as little stress as possible and my mum is there and gets to see DD’ then I know the answer to that is ‘not in my house’.

Something I’m starting to struggle with is the time and energy my relationship with my mum takes away from my time and energy for DD - whether that’s time having difficult conversations with mum, or me being sad afterwards or spending time debriefing with DH when we could be talking about DD. I don’t want to keep doing that (any tips?!) so my goal needs to be to engage with my mum more lightly and on a less emotional level rather than more.

OP posts:
SylvanMoon · 17/11/2026 20:07

Bigtrapeze · 17/11/2026 16:50

It is quite possible that your mum is not someone you can have this sort of conversation with and that she is not going to change. My parents, whilst lovely in many ways, like everything to be perfect and that's hard work generally but not tolerable on some occasions with a baby. I did spend time with them when DD was a baby but picked my activity/moment. They really wanted to be great grandparents but they expected her to be perfect too and I felt the pressure of their expectations. It is hard to articulate to anyone who hasn't felt like this and I just resolved not to do this to my daughter.

I think I was a bit responsible for trying to keep everyone happy too, and some of it was that I knew they would be thinking about how filthy my house was even if they didn't say it or being horrified if we were ten minutes late for something.

My PIL were much more laid back and had grandchildren already so knew what to expect. We holidayed with one set, not the other. I did two mini breaks with my parents and was utterly miserable by the end of both as they were completely inflexible and managing their expectations and the reality of a child felt impossible. I will happily go places with MIL. It is stress free.

You can't make these things completely equal.

Being a little mischievous, can you have them both round together? Might your mum watch MIL load the dishwasher and catch on?

Your mum sounds like managing the emotional fall out of having a word with her will be extremely time and energy consuming, so you might just need to work with what you've got. If you can change your reaction to not care about any house digs, you've probably kicked a goal. Play house dig bingo with DH, have a response ready that politely suggests it's not your prime focus or hand her the baby while you go and clean the sodding bath. Whatever gets you through with a smile.

I agree with @Bigtrapeze 100%. I think you either greyrock your mum, or agree with whatever thing she's picked out to complain about and hand her the baby as you deal with it, or invite both mums over at the same time and see what happens, or just carry on as you are now. Honestly, I can't see your DM really having an epiphany and changing her ways radically enough to be as chilled as your lovely MiL. Thank your stars that you've got her on your side.

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 20:09

Also it’s so helpful to see the contrast in responses from people with different kinds of parent relationships - love and solidarity to those who find this hard and I’m really pleased for those who have more straightforward families! I know I want to be a parent DD can talk to about hard things and I hope she says some of these things about me one day.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread