Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to treat mum and MIL differently?

106 replies

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 14:23

I live with DH and 11 month old DD. Both our mums live about 45 mins away, fit and healthy, retired, early 60s.

When my MIL comes over to our house she takes us as she finds us and pitches in with family life - she’ll offer to pick up milk/bread on her way over, unload the dishwasher if it finishes whilst she’s here, get DD a snack etc. We obviously don’t expect her to do housework but she always offers and says she wants to be supportive and we really appreciate it! She loves playing with DD and is a great grandma.

My mum loves seeing DD but when she’s here makes a lot of comments about eg the oven not being clean enough or DD’s toys being messy - our house is definitely normal levels of clean and tidy but she is very house proud. She likes to be hosted and wants a formal sit down hot lunch and polite conversation. I find her coming over pretty stressful and hard work so prefer meeting her at a local children’s museum, nice park in the summer, National Trust place etc (all free, not costing her anything) so she can still play with DD.

Mum has started making comments about MIL coming over and is clearly annoyed I don’t invite her as often. I’ve tried talking to her in the past about her comments and she did not take it well AT ALL so now I just suggest the museum and ignore her hints (and don’t mention when MIL is coming!). I want to say ‘MIL doesn’t expect to be treated like the queen when she’s over, that’s the difference’ but won’t to avoid WW3.

We see them roughly as often as each other but AIBU to do different things with them?

OP posts:
ThatMintMember · 17/11/2026 21:31

This is such an interesting topic. I'm not sure the answer as I don't even speak to my MIL but what you say about your mum reminds me of my own mum.

When she comes for a visit she expects to have a peaceful cuppa and catch up whilst completely ignoring the DS that she supposedly wanted to see. I feel so guilty about the lack of attention he gets during the visit that I try to suggest we meet during nursery/school hours or at least have DH present to give our son some attention or take him out for a bit. Unfortunately I just accept her for how she is and feel bitter about it. I really don't think saying something would help as her mother was a very similar character.

There's also a huge contrast when my dad visits (they're divorced) as he will play with my son the whole visit, let me get some jobs done while he gives my son attention and will barely even accept a cuppa so as not to inconvenience me! He's difficult in other ways but my son definitely benefits more from his visits.

I guess it's not just an issue between a mother and MIL but also just grandparents in general.

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · 17/11/2026 21:32

Happyjoe · 17/11/2026 20:29

It's fab to read you come from a normal, kind family. My partners family were like yours - mine not at all. I am finding reasonable people like you though are becoming a rarity, more is the pity. I hope you have children that you're passing on the kind, reasonable gene! 😁

What a lovely kind comment! I do have DC, and I’m certainly trying. As I’m sure you are. 💗

5128gap · 17/11/2026 21:34

Id stay well away from comparisons with MiL, because thats the bit that going to smart. Don't get into a discussion about why they're treated differently, just try and and keep the focus on your mum.
I'd say, mum, I love to see you, but I struggle to have the house the way you expect it and to do a hot lunch for you, so it's nicer for both of us to meet elsewhere.
Don't add 'whereas MiL helps...' and if your mum presses just say something low key like 'MiL doesn't want lunch/isn't bothered about the house'.

CrazyMidget · 17/11/2026 21:47

DiamondDandelion · 17/11/2026 18:25

My MIL was exactly the same, she passed away the start of this year leaving a huge gap in our lives. She was simply wonderful, I knew her 20 years and never once felt judged ever! My own Mum is very judgemental. We all had a much closer relationship with my MIL to my own Mum. Don't feel bad, you reep what you sew!

Omg. I can't let this one slide. It's "You reap what you sow" not "You reep what you sew." Sow as in sowing seeds, not sewing with a needle. And then you reap the crop when it's grown.

user1492757084 · 17/11/2026 21:48

Remember to take a lovely outing to a park sometimes with MIL. She would enjoy it.

And every few months invite both over to your place at the same time. Education can occur in later life and your DM might learn a new skill.

DiamondDandelion · 17/11/2026 21:58

user1492757084 · 17/11/2026 21:48

Remember to take a lovely outing to a park sometimes with MIL. She would enjoy it.

And every few months invite both over to your place at the same time. Education can occur in later life and your DM might learn a new skill.

Omg, imagine correcting someone's grammar while they are talking about the death of a loved one!

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 22:01

user1492757084 · 17/11/2026 21:48

Remember to take a lovely outing to a park sometimes with MIL. She would enjoy it.

And every few months invite both over to your place at the same time. Education can occur in later life and your DM might learn a new skill.

Yes definitely aware of doing nice things with MIL too! We’ve had a couple of things planned recently and DD has been ill so we’ve ended up at home instead, so want to get something fun and festive booked in. Side note baby winter bugs are kicking my arse already and she’s not even at nursery yet 🫠

OP posts:
Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 22:04

Off to bed now but wanted to say another huge thank you to everyone has commented, and sorry I’ve not answered all the questions! Really appreciate all your kindness and it’s definitely given me a boost to stick to my guns and remember I’m the mum now and I’m setting the tone for DD’s family too.

OP posts:
JulietteRoche · 17/11/2026 22:09

YANBU, but you would also not be unreasonable if the situation was the other way around. I make no apology whatsoever for being much closer to my mother than I am to my MIL, and if I had had children my mother would have been the chief grandmother without a doubt. This site is far too fond of slagging off women who dare to be closer to their own mothers than their husband's mothers.

zanahoria · 17/11/2026 22:12

They are mothers not children

jgjgjgjgjg · 17/11/2026 22:17

Think very carefully about the messages your DD is absorbing. At the moment it sounds as if what she is learning is that it's okay to let people insult you, your house and your approach to life and trample over your boundaries. And that if those people make a good enough job of demonstrating that they are 'prickly then you just have to accept it forever.

HettyMeg · 17/11/2026 22:21

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 16:07

Definitely - I wasn’t telling her on purpose, just mentioning it in passing if we chatted about our days etc, but going to stop referencing her at all from now on!

I think this is the right approach. Information diet for your mum, she doesn't need to know everything. Sorry you're having this experience!

Havingitallnot · 17/11/2026 22:26

Gosh, I had to go back and read that again. I thought you’d been talking about your mum to start with! Lovely to read such great comments about your MIL.

MyLittleNest · 17/11/2026 22:26

I know the type of mother you have...

I would not make it about your mother vs mil. Yes, they are both grandmothers, but they are very different people and you have a very different relationship with them.

Because I know the kind of personality you are describing with your own mother, I think the best thing you can do is limit your time with her. I wouldn't mention your MIL at all, and if asked, be vague. The less information you provide, the less she can use it against you. She isn't going to take accountability, so I understand how talking openly will only frustrate you. For those who didn't grow up with difficult mothers, they don't understand that "just tell her how you feel" is not a realistic option or a path to a resolution.

Your mother can complain all she wants but her behavior is what will ultimately make you spend less time with her. I'd start worrying less about how your mother feels since she clearly doesn't care how she makes you feel. I'd also keep the visits brief and on your terms. Like you said - meeting in a neutral spot, and then have a hard stop for when you need to leave. Keep it pleasant but brief. And if she starts with the insults, I'd leave even sooner, You are no longer a child living under her roof, and if she treated a friend this way when seeing them, they'd limit their time too.

MrsMcGarry · 17/11/2026 22:27

Totally get this. My stepmother (been in my life since I was toddler - my mum died) is very like this. And I now have my aunt (my mums sister who I only met as an adult) who is the lovely easy person in my life like your MIL who made me realise how lacking my relationship with my stepmother was.

My half sister has gone no contact with my stepmother (her mother). I frankly can't be arsed with that level of drama. I see her just a couple of times a year and grey rock throughout. Light, breezy, Mumsnet head tilt and pretend not to hear when she says anything critical. It works for me and means my now adult children can have a relationship of sorts with her - she doesn't pull the critical narcissistic shit with them because she has always known it would not work because I brought them up to be healthy people because I'd done the therapy work when they were toddlers.

People who don't have parents like this cannot comprehend that a sensible adult conversation would not produce results. But hopefully you've heard enough here to know there are plenty of us who do understand why you can't do that.

It's fine to manage complex relationships like this rather than resolve them. And believe me, the longer you practice the managing, the easier it gets and the less headspace it takes up. My stepmother and father visited 3 weeks ago. We went out for chi-chi dinner at the sort of place she likes, she mostly behaved, and dd and I rolled eyes at each other in a way she could not see when she started criticising the bread. I genuinely have not thought about her between then and reading this now.

It's really sad that you have a more comfortable relationship with your MIL than you do with your mother. But that's on her not you, because I bet you she has similarly difficult and dramatic relationships with other people...? So feel sad for what you didn't get from her, but rejoice you have someone else in your life that can fill that hole, and enjoy it.

Woodfiresareamazing2 · 17/11/2026 22:28

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 14:23

I live with DH and 11 month old DD. Both our mums live about 45 mins away, fit and healthy, retired, early 60s.

When my MIL comes over to our house she takes us as she finds us and pitches in with family life - she’ll offer to pick up milk/bread on her way over, unload the dishwasher if it finishes whilst she’s here, get DD a snack etc. We obviously don’t expect her to do housework but she always offers and says she wants to be supportive and we really appreciate it! She loves playing with DD and is a great grandma.

My mum loves seeing DD but when she’s here makes a lot of comments about eg the oven not being clean enough or DD’s toys being messy - our house is definitely normal levels of clean and tidy but she is very house proud. She likes to be hosted and wants a formal sit down hot lunch and polite conversation. I find her coming over pretty stressful and hard work so prefer meeting her at a local children’s museum, nice park in the summer, National Trust place etc (all free, not costing her anything) so she can still play with DD.

Mum has started making comments about MIL coming over and is clearly annoyed I don’t invite her as often. I’ve tried talking to her in the past about her comments and she did not take it well AT ALL so now I just suggest the museum and ignore her hints (and don’t mention when MIL is coming!). I want to say ‘MIL doesn’t expect to be treated like the queen when she’s over, that’s the difference’ but won’t to avoid WW3.

We see them roughly as often as each other but AIBU to do different things with them?

Hi @Sunshinetoday26 .

I've read all your posts, but i want to respond to what you said here re your mum's expectations when she visits.

Just because she expects a hot sit down lunch doesn't mean that you have to provide one.
I would have something really easy, like soup and sandwiches. And get her to make them while you go and change the baby, or get a chore done. Or she can hold/entertain DD while you make them.

Just don't mould yourself to her agenda.
Set your own.

Also, if she makes a comment about , say, your oven not being clean - call her out.
'Why do you feel entitled to make a rude comment about my housekeeping? I don't appreciate it, please don't do it'.
Keep turning it back on her.

If she accuses you of being mean to her, say that you are responding to the energy she is putting out.

It will be awkward and uncomfortable, but eventually she will stop doing it. Or stop coming!

Good luck

morecakeneverstop · 17/11/2026 22:40

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 15:05

Thank you all, I really appreciate it!

MIL is a gem and I’m very lucky - I didn’t know her super well before DD but she’s been brilliant. I think it has also made me reflect on my relationship with my mum more and realise how hard I find her criticisms/defensiveness because I feel how much easier it is with MIL (and how she is with DH too). It does make me sad tbh.

Totally understand why people are saying to say something to my mum but honestly I feel like I’ve tried it all - if I say something in the moment she says ‘I’m just joking, you’re so sensitive!’. If I say beforehand ‘take us as you find us’ she says ‘of course, you know I like to make things easy’ and then makes the same comments?! I’ve tried having bigger picture conversations with her in the past when she’s been critical about other things and it descends into ‘I can’t say anything, you think I’m a terrible person etc etc’ so I’ve reached this point through a lot of trial and error! It doesn’t feel like she has the self awareness to either stop herself making comments or to hear me when I try to talk to her about them if that makes sense.

Writing all this out I’m realising how hard work I find all of this with her - especially when I have a baby who doesn’t sleep very well and could just do with some moral support - so I think I’m definitely going to stick with keeping it light and out of the house, I don’t have the energy for drama!

These are classic bullying tactics.

'I'm just joking' suggests you're overreacting and camouflages the insult.

'You're so sensitive' is a ways of deflecting accountability and shifting the blame onto you.

'Of course, you know I like to make things easy' and then doing the same old thing is gaslighting (making you doubt your own perception).

'I can't say anything, you think I'm a terrible person' - straw man logical fallacies recruited to pull the victim card.

I'm sorry, but your mother is a nasty piece of work, and she's unlikely to change. A PP suggested 'grey rock'. Another option is no contact, at least for a while. I know it's referred to as the nuclear option, but you have your own health (mental and physical) to consider, and the well-being of your family. These behaviours take their toll.

Take good care of yourself. Sending you a big hug 💓

Peclet · 17/11/2026 23:02

Best advice I can give you is to hold your boundary and be brave in doing so.

It doesn’t need to be a fight. Set your expectations- you can come here and take us as you find us- it will be sandwich’s for lunch. Or we can go out- up to you?

Then if a comment comes- bland agreement- be Teflon.

She will get the message. And you can be busy. Oh mum ill juts whizz the hoover aboht which you and dd read a story or whatever. Praise her for it. You’re good to her and I can get 20 mins back to straighten the house/get dinner started l/ etc etc

show her how to support you.

honeybeetheoneandonly · 17/11/2026 23:04

Embrace your love for your MIL. You won't be able to change your mum but you can make sure to minimise danger zones. If meeting your mum out and about works best for you, continue to do so. Your mum doesn't have to agree with it but she will have to accept it nonetheless.

SandyCastles · 17/11/2026 23:21

I'm so glad you have your MIL!

I really like the idea from @MrsMcGarry above to pretend not to listen if she says anything critical.. excellent advice.

Ironically my mum used to do this super annoying thing when she was not interested in the conversation you were having, in which she would just ignore what you were saying and start talking to the dog, it used to wind me up as it is so rude, but it worked to stop the conversation I suppose.. you could absolutely do the same thing with baby, 'are you hungry baby' 'Let's go and get you seen to' 'Did you want some toys to play with' it's an easy defelction without confrontation, your mum would have to be REALLY committed to keep bringing up the same thing repeatedly after you have ignored it, so maybe that would be enough to get the message across that you are choosing not to interact with her nonsense.

I find immediately changing the subject helps too, just need to have something up your sleeve for when it inevitably happens.

Apart from that, just keep her at arms length and try not to give it a second thought, the easy relationship with your MIL is how every mother daughter relationship should be IMO, unfortunately some people just aren't capable of it.

FridayPieday · 17/11/2026 23:56

Every time your Mother criticises something, agree with her and blame your husband. Maybe it can become a bit of a joke between you if you agree it in advance. She'll find it a lot more awkward to talk to him like she's talking to you.

Tiggywiggypiggy · Yesterday 06:36

I think this is a battle worth fighting, I wish I had.
Because at 60 with my mum at 90 I can tell you it doesn’t get any easier and if you don’t fight it now you, and possibly your children will be listening to this passive aggressive bullshit and adjusting your behaviour for her for years to come.
Draw a line.

Sillyoldgit62 · Yesterday 06:45

Why do you tell your mother ? Just don’t talk about her visits,simple

Goinggreymammy · Yesterday 07:33

Your mum sounds like hard work and i think you have come up with a good workaround. If she wants to visit at home and continues to make comments suggest that the visits arent enjoyable and you all go back to meeting out.
But .. why is your MIL unloading your dishwasher and buying groceries on her way to visit? Can your DH and yourself not manage even the most basic housework? You have one 11 month old, unless there is a severe drip feed of very high additional needs, its not like the first two to four weeks, surely there is sometimes sort of rhythm by now that allows for dishwashing to happen without bringing others into it? And unless yiu all are allergic to milk/dont drink it, surely there would be no need for a visitir yo bring milk if having a cup of tea?

Screamingabdabz · Yesterday 07:50

jgjgjgjgjg · 17/11/2026 22:17

Think very carefully about the messages your DD is absorbing. At the moment it sounds as if what she is learning is that it's okay to let people insult you, your house and your approach to life and trample over your boundaries. And that if those people make a good enough job of demonstrating that they are 'prickly then you just have to accept it forever.

She is also learning that you’re only valuable and loveable if you toe the line, empty dishwashers and do grocery shopping.

If I brought milk and started emptying the dishwasher at my son and DIL’s house they’d think I’d gone mad. My DS would’ve already had lunch in and he'd tell me to sit down and relax.

I sense here that the op is fully responsible for domestics - hence why she’s grateful for MIL ‘pitching in’ and why criticisms from her DM of untidiness sting so much. Where is the DH in this? Why can’t he get the milk in when he knows visitors are coming? Can’t he unload the dishwasher?

What are you teaching dd about the roles of men and women?