Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to treat mum and MIL differently?

106 replies

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 14:23

I live with DH and 11 month old DD. Both our mums live about 45 mins away, fit and healthy, retired, early 60s.

When my MIL comes over to our house she takes us as she finds us and pitches in with family life - she’ll offer to pick up milk/bread on her way over, unload the dishwasher if it finishes whilst she’s here, get DD a snack etc. We obviously don’t expect her to do housework but she always offers and says she wants to be supportive and we really appreciate it! She loves playing with DD and is a great grandma.

My mum loves seeing DD but when she’s here makes a lot of comments about eg the oven not being clean enough or DD’s toys being messy - our house is definitely normal levels of clean and tidy but she is very house proud. She likes to be hosted and wants a formal sit down hot lunch and polite conversation. I find her coming over pretty stressful and hard work so prefer meeting her at a local children’s museum, nice park in the summer, National Trust place etc (all free, not costing her anything) so she can still play with DD.

Mum has started making comments about MIL coming over and is clearly annoyed I don’t invite her as often. I’ve tried talking to her in the past about her comments and she did not take it well AT ALL so now I just suggest the museum and ignore her hints (and don’t mention when MIL is coming!). I want to say ‘MIL doesn’t expect to be treated like the queen when she’s over, that’s the difference’ but won’t to avoid WW3.

We see them roughly as often as each other but AIBU to do different things with them?

OP posts:
wordler · 17/11/2026 20:14

@Sunshinetoday26

As your Mum is prickly you may not be able to just have a simple conversation without fallout.

I think it feels like there are two problems, the type of visit she ‘demands’ and then the comments.

I think if you are more firm about making the visits suit you more then you might fee stronger about dealing with the comments in the moment.

Next time she complains that she is visiting you at home just say lightly ‘a lot of time
MIL visits we don’t really do a proper meal or anything - it’s much more casual, I didn’t think that was your thing. Of course I’d love you to come and hang out with us like that. Let me know when you want to come’

If she takes you up on that then give her stuff to do - hold the baby, give her a bath etc.

Anytime she complains about something give her the job of making it better. Pile of laundry - thanks Mum it really helps to have another pair of hands, cooker needs to be cleaner - what products and technique do you recommend, would love your help.

Mum can you put the kettle on while I change the baby? I’ll have a tea, thanks.

At the very least grey rock the comments - she points out it looks like the baseboards need a wipe. Blankly look at the baseboards and say ‘yes they probably do’ smile shrug move on.

Ihatelittlefriendsusan · 17/11/2026 20:20

I feel your pain.

I love my mum dearly but like yours she is super house proud, spends hours a day dusting/hoovering/bleaching things. She was a mum of the 80's so single income, plenty of free time when we were at school. When she dis work as we got older it was always part time, no more than 5 hours a day etc.

She trashes me about my house at every opportunity. For context i work full time in a very stressful industry. I was a single parent for a long time. Dd is a dancer and until recently a tennis player so most evenings are rehersals/classes/coaching etc. My house is clean, it's most tidy but it is very much lived in. I do not live on a show home.

Before dd was born my then mil would come up often, like yours she would clean/tidy/cook etc as I was incredibly ill during pregame with HG. She was very much like me in the belief that the dust will still be there tomorrow, it was more important that her kids then grandkids felt loved and had her attention rather than occupying themselves whilst she bleached everything in sight.

3 weeks before I gave birth she was "diagnosed" with terminal cancer, she had known for months if not years, i strongly suspect her diverticulitis was actually the cancer. She saw dd born and we spent every day for the last 9 weeks of her life with her. My mum was incensed that dd was spending her first weeks in a hospital. But mil was dying and I wanted her to have as much time with dd as possible.

Unfortunately it dos come to a head and my mum got told that if mil didn't see her then neither did she.

Find a way to have an honest calm conversation with your mum, if it comes out in a row it will be so much worse.

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 20:20

Final thing I’m realising (honestly thank you all so much for this thread!) is that I feel guilty about how much I like my MIL and there’s a childish part of me that feels like I’m betraying my mum (I know she’d feel like this). Again I know intellectually that that’s messed up - I’d be thrilled if DD as an adult had a supportive MIL! - but it’s lurking there.

So I’d like to embrace the good relationship I have with MIL as its own thing and not in comparison to my mum - it might bring up some complicated feelings but I really appreciate her and feel lucky to have her (and I tell her this!).

OP posts:
SplishSplash123 · 17/11/2026 20:20

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 16:16

Promise I’m not arguing but genuinely curious to know what it’s like for other people - for those who are saying they’d just be honest, if this was your mum how would she react to that? Because DH said he thinks if it were MIL she’d be hurt/offended for a minute then apologise and do things differently in future, and that’s just wild to me because I know my mum would have a HUGE reaction, saying she can’t believe I’m saying MIL is a better grandma than her, how devastating for her to have a daughter that says such awful things etc etc. And then maybe behave differently for 1 visit and then go back.

I know logically that that’s a really disproportionate reaction, but I think I’m realising that I’m so used to it that I can’t fully imagine being able to say something like this to my mum and it go down awkwardly but not terribly?

Lots of sympathy, OP, my mum sounds very similar to yours and I think it can be so unhelpful having people tell you that you just need to say something to her.

Communication is two way - it requires someone to hear what is being said, but it sounds like your mum is like mine and she doesn't really "hear" what is said. I can ask my mum not to do something or suggest she does something differently, and she may say yes but then carry on doing the thing I asked her not to do, or she may say why she has done things the other way. She won't necessarily outright refuse; it's just a sort of non-engagement, bulldozer approach. No matter what I say, she will never just say "okay fine I'll do that". I have lost my rag once or twice, as it really infuriates me, other times I just give up and - like you - just make decisions to limit the amount of times I have to put myself in situations which I know will end up causing me upset.

I don't really have any solutions, other than to say I do understand how annoying it is to have such a disrespectful mum! And YANBU - carry on doing what works for you. Maybe matching your mums energy and just brushing away her comments? She asks why MIL comes round and she doesnt - "oh, it works us meeting out and about. Anyway, back to what I was saying..."

BeWittyRobin · 17/11/2026 20:22

I think you want her to take you as she finds you like your MIL, sadly by sounds of it this isn’t the kind of women she is personality wise. Maybe you could adopt a take her as you find her attitude as well. What I mean by that is your mum is who she is and at 60 I can’t see her drastically changing even if you asked her or managed to get through to her. I also imagine this is how she’s always been but because you now have a loving relationship with your MIL and seen a different motherly figure at work you are actually noticing the differences more and more.

I am very jealous you have such a wonderful MIL, I went no contact with mine Jan 2025 after years of trying, then I realised no point trying, wasn’t gaining anything other than stress and it’s been and amazing 18months 🤣. But that’s a whole different story. I’m sure your mum offers many different traits than your MIL can maybe focus more on that and not compare. It’s hard not to compare.

As for her comments, I know you will have tried to ignore them but stand your ground if hosting, you host how you wish to host remember she is visiting you and you are an adult. Regardless what you know she would prefer tough shit really lol. Only way things will change for you is to change how you handle her and to hold your ground. Unlike my MIL I think there is hope for your relationship you just need to stand up for yourself by showing her what you wish to do, what you are prepared to do with regards to hosting etc. I would stop telling her so much about your MIL it’s kinda causing a competition that isn’t really there. As for her comments about housework and oven give her a sponge or Hoover so she can give it a clean or once over 🤷🏻‍♀️ my MIL stopped her comments quite quickly naturally when I did that a few times always with a smile x

OneNewEagle · 17/11/2026 20:22

How great to have a decent MIL.

as for mum/daughter tips I have none I’m afraid. I have had to do therapy due to my family and upbringing and currently LC or estranged from everyone.

Chilly80 · 17/11/2026 20:22

Does your mum ever invite you for lunch at her house? Would that be better for you? ⁷

HenriettaHippopotamus · 17/11/2026 20:28

I understand OP. I think some people are incapable of reflecting on how their own actions have led to how things are. No one likes to be criticised constantly.

You also don’t always make things better by confronting them. It seems you’ve tried in different ways, and I don’t think being more forceful will be fruitful.

SplishSplash123 · 17/11/2026 20:28

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 20:20

Final thing I’m realising (honestly thank you all so much for this thread!) is that I feel guilty about how much I like my MIL and there’s a childish part of me that feels like I’m betraying my mum (I know she’d feel like this). Again I know intellectually that that’s messed up - I’d be thrilled if DD as an adult had a supportive MIL! - but it’s lurking there.

So I’d like to embrace the good relationship I have with MIL as its own thing and not in comparison to my mum - it might bring up some complicated feelings but I really appreciate her and feel lucky to have her (and I tell her this!).

Just to add - Ive read your other posts and you sound very emotionally aware. Well done for doing the therapy and for recognising and unpicking some of the issues. It's tiring and exhausting and hard, but well done for doing it.

You mention about your mum being a drain on your energy. I found this too, and being on mat leave/having a child made me available after years of gently reducing contact. One thing I learned was that putting off a visit indefinitely stressed me out as then I felt at the mercy of her suggesting yet again that we do something. I then tried being more in control of the intervals between visits and setting a date that was suitably far apart. So for example, she wanted to visit weekly and I tried to push it to every 2 or 3 weeks, so I'd make a point of saying how busy I was when I saw her and then Id message afterwards saying "the next day that works for me is X, shall we meet at the park at 2pm then?"

suki1964 · 17/11/2026 20:29

My NIL was a pure darling

She didnt understand our world, - swear to god not once had she eaten a takeaway or bought a coffee , and her house - pristine

but she had manners, and never once challenged or called us out.

Mother however , it was always her way or the high way and had such great ecpectaions - as long as it wasnt her doing the graft.

MIL started her working life at 14 - in service. Met FIL. Married at 17 and became the housewife and mother

My Mother, , left school at 15, having been taught short hand and typing, stared off in the typing pool, working her way up to PA and retiring as deputy head of housing for a very successful London borough

I had more time of the day for MIL then I did my own mother tbh.

I dont think there is anything wrong in decided who you prefer, who makes you more comfortable in their company.

The saying you can pick. your friends but not your family is so ruddy true

Happyjoe · 17/11/2026 20:29

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · 17/11/2026 17:16

DH said he thinks if it were MIL she’d be hurt/offended for a minute then apologise and do things differently in future

Pretty much this. As that’s how people behave, as a general rule. And my parents are pretty normal people. We have conversations, listen to each others’ points of view and have a pleasant respectful relationship.

It sounds like there are broader issues with your mother.

It's fab to read you come from a normal, kind family. My partners family were like yours - mine not at all. I am finding reasonable people like you though are becoming a rarity, more is the pity. I hope you have children that you're passing on the kind, reasonable gene! 😁

AgileMentor · 17/11/2026 20:35

go over her house and make comments see how she likes it. My MIL would never my mum always makes comments about the dog which is unnecessary and has been going on 11 years now and it does me in I just tell her he does live here.

Iknewit · 17/11/2026 20:44

@Sunshinetoday26
I really relate to the realisation that you want a mum but your mum isn’t giving you what you need.

Enjoy your relationship with your MIL and don’t feel guilty.

bettyrubble99 · 17/11/2026 20:49

I'd tell her straight - she doesn't judge us.

Crowdedgrouse · 17/11/2026 20:58

My DM is like this and you make your own bed, she’s difficult to host so she is invited less.

Id like it to be different but she’s just too critical

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 20:58

SplishSplash123 · 17/11/2026 20:28

Just to add - Ive read your other posts and you sound very emotionally aware. Well done for doing the therapy and for recognising and unpicking some of the issues. It's tiring and exhausting and hard, but well done for doing it.

You mention about your mum being a drain on your energy. I found this too, and being on mat leave/having a child made me available after years of gently reducing contact. One thing I learned was that putting off a visit indefinitely stressed me out as then I felt at the mercy of her suggesting yet again that we do something. I then tried being more in control of the intervals between visits and setting a date that was suitably far apart. So for example, she wanted to visit weekly and I tried to push it to every 2 or 3 weeks, so I'd make a point of saying how busy I was when I saw her and then Id message afterwards saying "the next day that works for me is X, shall we meet at the park at 2pm then?"

This is so kind, thank you! I’m always hoping I’ve done ‘enough’ work whatever that means and then something else comes up… but that’s being a person I guess!

Such a good point about being more available on mat leave - I think before DD the formal Sunday lunch thing bothered me less because it was less often and I had more energy, but it’s not what I want to do on a random Tuesday after being up since 4am 😅

I think I also probably haven’t been vulnerable or emotionally needed my mum much for about 10 years - I’m pretty self sufficient, always had a stable job, DH and I have a very calm relationship etc - so when I gave birth and suddenly felt so vulnerable and emotional and in need of looking after it hit me HARD my mum not being very warm or supportive.

OP posts:
stillhiding1990 · 17/11/2026 21:02

Can you not sit down and just keep pottering and chatting

Summer98 · 17/11/2026 21:06

Why don't you invite both around at the same time and see what happens!

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 21:06

Chilly80 · 17/11/2026 20:22

Does your mum ever invite you for lunch at her house? Would that be better for you? ⁷

Oh gosh we have done this a few times but they’re even more formal and structured about timings at their house - got so many eye rolls when we were late for lunch when DD was a few months old and had a nappy explosion just as we were leaving! I think they’ve really forgotten what having a baby is like and think we’re just a bit useless which I don’t think is true.

Also it honestly feels like their whole house is just low coffee tables covered in glass ornaments 😬 and they do a lot of ‘DD that’s not for you!’ without moving a muscle as DH and I lunge to pull her away 😅

I do think when she’s older it could work well though because mum can be in charge of food and they’ve got a nice garden she can run around in (with fewer ornaments to smash).

OP posts:
Dandeloosha · 17/11/2026 21:07

Lean into it. Just relax and lean into it.

’Your oven is a mess.’
’Haha, yes. You’re right.’

’Your DD’s toys are all over the place.’
’You’re right! Yes they are.’

’Where’s my hot lunch?’
’I didn’t make one.’

And so on - bland agreement. She mildly annoyed but not able to do anything about it. You can’t change her, so let what she says just flow around you.

Ally886 · 17/11/2026 21:12

I think you sometimes need to take a step back from it being your mum. How would you feel if a friend explained your situation about their mum? You'd probably say "she needs to know that's unkind".

We have to travel about two hours to see my parents and fell into a pattern that my mum would sit there miserable about something or other half the time, or criticise me over and over for something. Then we would end up a bit cold with each other. I could tell it was frustrating for DH as he could be doing a lot more with his weekends than driving for hours to sit in a tense house.

Eventually he just had enough, told mum we wouldn't come down any more if she wasn't going to be nice. He went as far as telling my parents the entire relationship I have with them is facilitated by him, and he wasn't wrong. They have never come to see us or left their own town in 8 years. It made me thing "he's bang on" and they've been a lot better since. I can openly say "mum if you're going to be a child i'll just head home and do some crochet" 😂

CrazyMidget · 17/11/2026 21:14

Minasama · 17/11/2026 14:55

Of course. I have the opposite in that my own mum is supportive while MIL passed comments about the house. This upset my husband so he stopped inviting her. Your mum should listen to you and adapt her behaviour.

Why do so many older women do this? Both my mum and my MIL passed a ton of comments about our home, cooking, and possessions. I cleaned the place top to bottom before they arrived and cooked nice meals. Might as well not have bothered!

echt · 17/11/2026 21:14

Whatever you do, OP, don't compare your DM to your MIL if you bring this up with her. Your DM is a PITA in her own right, so focus on her behaviour. Referring to MIL's excellence will only give focus for deflection.

On the other hand, if your DM then says, well why do you have MIL around, give her both barrels.

NavyTurtle · 17/11/2026 21:24

Sunshinetoday26 · 17/11/2026 14:23

I live with DH and 11 month old DD. Both our mums live about 45 mins away, fit and healthy, retired, early 60s.

When my MIL comes over to our house she takes us as she finds us and pitches in with family life - she’ll offer to pick up milk/bread on her way over, unload the dishwasher if it finishes whilst she’s here, get DD a snack etc. We obviously don’t expect her to do housework but she always offers and says she wants to be supportive and we really appreciate it! She loves playing with DD and is a great grandma.

My mum loves seeing DD but when she’s here makes a lot of comments about eg the oven not being clean enough or DD’s toys being messy - our house is definitely normal levels of clean and tidy but she is very house proud. She likes to be hosted and wants a formal sit down hot lunch and polite conversation. I find her coming over pretty stressful and hard work so prefer meeting her at a local children’s museum, nice park in the summer, National Trust place etc (all free, not costing her anything) so she can still play with DD.

Mum has started making comments about MIL coming over and is clearly annoyed I don’t invite her as often. I’ve tried talking to her in the past about her comments and she did not take it well AT ALL so now I just suggest the museum and ignore her hints (and don’t mention when MIL is coming!). I want to say ‘MIL doesn’t expect to be treated like the queen when she’s over, that’s the difference’ but won’t to avoid WW3.

We see them roughly as often as each other but AIBU to do different things with them?

I voted that you are being unreasonable because you need to grow a pair and stand up to your mother. Stop being such a wet lettuce.

Elsvieta · 17/11/2026 21:28

CrazyMidget · 17/11/2026 21:14

Why do so many older women do this? Both my mum and my MIL passed a ton of comments about our home, cooking, and possessions. I cleaned the place top to bottom before they arrived and cooked nice meals. Might as well not have bothered!

Older women who didn't have careers, usually - their entire self-image and sense of self-worth is bound up with housework and cooking etc. They can't understand a woman for whom these things just aren't central to life or even very important. And sometimes they're jealous of her. But admitting that it didn't ever really matter much whether the oven was spotless would be admitting to a wasted life. Not many people can do that.