Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to treat mum and MIL differently?

96 replies

Sunshinetoday26 · Yesterday 14:23

I live with DH and 11 month old DD. Both our mums live about 45 mins away, fit and healthy, retired, early 60s.

When my MIL comes over to our house she takes us as she finds us and pitches in with family life - she’ll offer to pick up milk/bread on her way over, unload the dishwasher if it finishes whilst she’s here, get DD a snack etc. We obviously don’t expect her to do housework but she always offers and says she wants to be supportive and we really appreciate it! She loves playing with DD and is a great grandma.

My mum loves seeing DD but when she’s here makes a lot of comments about eg the oven not being clean enough or DD’s toys being messy - our house is definitely normal levels of clean and tidy but she is very house proud. She likes to be hosted and wants a formal sit down hot lunch and polite conversation. I find her coming over pretty stressful and hard work so prefer meeting her at a local children’s museum, nice park in the summer, National Trust place etc (all free, not costing her anything) so she can still play with DD.

Mum has started making comments about MIL coming over and is clearly annoyed I don’t invite her as often. I’ve tried talking to her in the past about her comments and she did not take it well AT ALL so now I just suggest the museum and ignore her hints (and don’t mention when MIL is coming!). I want to say ‘MIL doesn’t expect to be treated like the queen when she’s over, that’s the difference’ but won’t to avoid WW3.

We see them roughly as often as each other but AIBU to do different things with them?

OP posts:
Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · Yesterday 14:34

How refreshing to have a positive MiL situation. She sounds lovely.
You are not being unreasonable at all in your different approaches to your DM and your MiL.
I think you are showing great restraint in not telling your DM explicitly why you aren't comfortable with her coming to your home.

Iloveeverycat · Yesterday 14:37

Well done your MIL.
Why didn't she take it well thats tough tell her you only want her over if she doesn't make any comments and will have to leave if she does. Tell her you want her to come and play with your DD rather than having a formal meal. If she doesn't like it she doesn't have to come it's up to her. You don't have to put up with this it is all on her.

Absobeautely · Yesterday 14:39

Tell her she's welcome to come round but there won't be hosted lunch and she is not to make rude comments about your house.

If she chooses to not take it well thats completely fine.

OpalMoonflower · Yesterday 14:42

Your MIL sounds lovely !

I agree with others say she can come but she has to accept house won’t always be perfect.

Mischance · Yesterday 14:46

"It would be lovely to see you Mum, but you must take us as you find us and be prepared to muck in."

TVHedgehog · Yesterday 14:47

I think what you’re already doing has been thoughtful- rather than being so irritated by your mum’s comments and seeing her less, you’ve adjusted the location and she still gets to see you just as much as MIL.

Given she didn’t respond well to comments you’d previously made about it, it’s odd that she’s asking again - nothings changed so all she could realistically expect is the same or maybe more. Maybe you could say I did explain it to you before and you didn’t seem to like the answer. If you’d like me to explain again I’m happy to talk it through otherwise it’s best if we continue to meet up somewhere other than our home.

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Yesterday 14:52

Honestly, just tell her directly. Then she can’t claim she doesn’t know. There might be some initial unpleasantness, but then it’s done.

Minasama · Yesterday 14:55

Of course. I have the opposite in that my own mum is supportive while MIL passed comments about the house. This upset my husband so he stopped inviting her. Your mum should listen to you and adapt her behaviour.

Pumpkinsaregrowingnicely · Yesterday 15:00

Stop telling dm when you see mil.

Sunshinetoday26 · Yesterday 15:05

Thank you all, I really appreciate it!

MIL is a gem and I’m very lucky - I didn’t know her super well before DD but she’s been brilliant. I think it has also made me reflect on my relationship with my mum more and realise how hard I find her criticisms/defensiveness because I feel how much easier it is with MIL (and how she is with DH too). It does make me sad tbh.

Totally understand why people are saying to say something to my mum but honestly I feel like I’ve tried it all - if I say something in the moment she says ‘I’m just joking, you’re so sensitive!’. If I say beforehand ‘take us as you find us’ she says ‘of course, you know I like to make things easy’ and then makes the same comments?! I’ve tried having bigger picture conversations with her in the past when she’s been critical about other things and it descends into ‘I can’t say anything, you think I’m a terrible person etc etc’ so I’ve reached this point through a lot of trial and error! It doesn’t feel like she has the self awareness to either stop herself making comments or to hear me when I try to talk to her about them if that makes sense.

Writing all this out I’m realising how hard work I find all of this with her - especially when I have a baby who doesn’t sleep very well and could just do with some moral support - so I think I’m definitely going to stick with keeping it light and out of the house, I don’t have the energy for drama!

OP posts:
LaurieFairyCake · Yesterday 15:06

You don’t need to be quiet on this Flowers You are an adult and a mum.

I would literally tell my mum that MIL pitches in, empties dishwasher, makes no snarky comments and doesn’t expect to be treated like a queen and if she wants the same then get OFF HER ARSE and be a real Mum and grandma.

Sunshineheres · Yesterday 15:18

I'd be inclined to say MIL chips in while she's here and doesn't need cooking for, so it's much easier for me than when you come.

MrEdwardElizabethHitler · Yesterday 15:38

Agree with PPs, honesty is the best policy here. It's going to be awkward, but it already is. So you say MIL helps more when she's here, doesn't comment on the tidiness of the place and isn't expecting a sit down lunch. She's less work.

Sunshinetoday26 · Yesterday 16:07

Pumpkinsaregrowingnicely · Yesterday 15:00

Stop telling dm when you see mil.

Definitely - I wasn’t telling her on purpose, just mentioning it in passing if we chatted about our days etc, but going to stop referencing her at all from now on!

OP posts:
Sunshinetoday26 · Yesterday 16:16

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Yesterday 14:52

Honestly, just tell her directly. Then she can’t claim she doesn’t know. There might be some initial unpleasantness, but then it’s done.

Promise I’m not arguing but genuinely curious to know what it’s like for other people - for those who are saying they’d just be honest, if this was your mum how would she react to that? Because DH said he thinks if it were MIL she’d be hurt/offended for a minute then apologise and do things differently in future, and that’s just wild to me because I know my mum would have a HUGE reaction, saying she can’t believe I’m saying MIL is a better grandma than her, how devastating for her to have a daughter that says such awful things etc etc. And then maybe behave differently for 1 visit and then go back.

I know logically that that’s a really disproportionate reaction, but I think I’m realising that I’m so used to it that I can’t fully imagine being able to say something like this to my mum and it go down awkwardly but not terribly?

OP posts:
Absobeautely · Yesterday 16:25

My mother used to behave like that too, showing up, slagging off stuff about the house under the guise of 'being nice', then would relish playing the victim when I told her to stop, getting harsher each time.

Grey rock type techniques help, like if she's ranting and whingeing just cheerily say 'ok.' and don't console her or placate her. Bland, neutral, bored replies.
She is free to choose to behave better at any time if she wants, and to be enjoyable company.

Holeymoley28 · Yesterday 16:31

Just tell her straight.

It’s nice that your mil is so chilled as normally it ends up the other way around and too scared to tell mil to buck up.

But this is your mum so tell her you’d invite her more if she didn’t act like she needed to be hosted as if she was the queen and didn’t pass comments like she was Kim or Aggie? Form how clean if your home. If she actually made her visits to you enjoyable for you rather than a chore.

TheTortiePuffinNeedsHerBreakfast · Yesterday 16:32

Not at all unreasonable. I have similar with my siblings versus DH's. My siblings contribute to the meal, help clear up, and make an effort with the conversation. DH's siblings always turn up empty handed, expect to be waited on and expect us to make all the effort conversationally. I just crack on with invites for my siblings and avoid inviting DHs.

Rachelshair · Yesterday 16:38

It sounds like your mum is happy to dish out criticism but can't take it. Like mine!
Would she take more notice if your husband said something? Mine was really embarrassed when she realised my partner could hear her complaining at me.
Formal lunches and a spotless house are ridiculous expectations when you have a baby and it's your mum popping round.

dnamummy · Yesterday 16:41

Could you try inviting them at same time and see if your DM watches and adopts any of MILs behaviors - I ended up with a healthy completion over some housework and gardening tasks

DrinkFeckArseBrick · Yesterday 16:45

It's tricky OP as it sounds like you've already tried to raise it gently and been met with defensiveness and over reactions and then turning it back on you. So although a lot of people would raise it again directly, I'm not sure you will get the result you're looking for from your mum. Some people seem to be genuinely incapable of reflecting on their own behaviour and changing.

I think you have 3 options

  • Carry on doing what you're doing and maybe try and avoid telling her that your mil came over
  • Invite her over more and put up with the criticisms and comments
  • talk to her about your concerns but take the gamble that it might backfire and be more awkward

If you take the second option then I'd ask chatgpt how to deal with her comments in the moment in a way that she is least likely to take badly. Eg say 'I know you're joking and don't mean anything by it but I'd prefer if you could not make comments about how clean the kitchen is', or make a joke of it and ask if she is offering to clean it. I definitely wouldn't compare her to MIL in any way (eg say MIL does x but you do y), just focus on her (I'm not sure you have a great time when you visit us because I know I don't have time to host you as well as either of us would like, so I thought you'd prefer to meet out where you can get a proper meal' etc)

seahorsessky · Yesterday 16:46

As a general rule, treating both as equal grandmothers (they are!) and with equal respect is vital, and aiming to allow both the same time with you and the grandkids.
But people are individuals, which needs to be taken into account, for example, of one grandparent has severe health issues, she maybe can't babysit or change nappies. If one works FT, she can't babysit as much, maybe.
And in the case you say, if they have completely different personalities/needs/wants, that has to be accounted for, so in a case like yours, then it's inevitable there'll be some difference. As long as you are still polite and promoting as much contact as reasonably possible, it's fine.

Bigtrapeze · Yesterday 16:50

Sunshinetoday26 · Yesterday 16:16

Promise I’m not arguing but genuinely curious to know what it’s like for other people - for those who are saying they’d just be honest, if this was your mum how would she react to that? Because DH said he thinks if it were MIL she’d be hurt/offended for a minute then apologise and do things differently in future, and that’s just wild to me because I know my mum would have a HUGE reaction, saying she can’t believe I’m saying MIL is a better grandma than her, how devastating for her to have a daughter that says such awful things etc etc. And then maybe behave differently for 1 visit and then go back.

I know logically that that’s a really disproportionate reaction, but I think I’m realising that I’m so used to it that I can’t fully imagine being able to say something like this to my mum and it go down awkwardly but not terribly?

It is quite possible that your mum is not someone you can have this sort of conversation with and that she is not going to change. My parents, whilst lovely in many ways, like everything to be perfect and that's hard work generally but not tolerable on some occasions with a baby. I did spend time with them when DD was a baby but picked my activity/moment. They really wanted to be great grandparents but they expected her to be perfect too and I felt the pressure of their expectations. It is hard to articulate to anyone who hasn't felt like this and I just resolved not to do this to my daughter.

I think I was a bit responsible for trying to keep everyone happy too, and some of it was that I knew they would be thinking about how filthy my house was even if they didn't say it or being horrified if we were ten minutes late for something.

My PIL were much more laid back and had grandchildren already so knew what to expect. We holidayed with one set, not the other. I did two mini breaks with my parents and was utterly miserable by the end of both as they were completely inflexible and managing their expectations and the reality of a child felt impossible. I will happily go places with MIL. It is stress free.

You can't make these things completely equal.

Being a little mischievous, can you have them both round together? Might your mum watch MIL load the dishwasher and catch on?

Your mum sounds like managing the emotional fall out of having a word with her will be extremely time and energy consuming, so you might just need to work with what you've got. If you can change your reaction to not care about any house digs, you've probably kicked a goal. Play house dig bingo with DH, have a response ready that politely suggests it's not your prime focus or hand her the baby while you go and clean the sodding bath. Whatever gets you through with a smile.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · Yesterday 16:57

The main problem is that unreasonable people are unreasonable! Reasonable people would be very happy to take on board issues that are raised with them and adapt, but because they're reasonable, there aren't those issues in the first place!

I like PP's idea of inviting them over at the same time - even if MIL's thoughtfulness doesn't rub off on to her, you can point out the stark contrasts. You may even want to video 'the baby' and 'accidentally' capture evidence of the two grandmas' behaviour to make it clear later when the videos are watched back!

StencilCupChair · Yesterday 17:01

As she is prickly I wouldn't compare her to MIL. Explain to her that her coming over to your house makes you uncomfortable because of the comment she makes despite her promise to keep her mouth shut.

Tell her that she can think whatever she likes but she cannot say it aloud. Tell her that you think lots of thoughts about her, like these ones where you are pissed off at her constant criticism but you too keep your thoughts in your head. Tell her this is a two way street, she can't dish it out and then get pissy when you do it back to her.

Put is straight that if she wants a positive relationship with you and her grandchildren then she needs to amend her behaviour. If ww3 happens, let it. She clearly doesn't care if she upsets you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread