Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

492 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
mummymeister · Today 16:16

@Dimpkhimniaa spot on! Thats the problem.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:17

CatkinToadflax · Today 16:15

I would like to know how taking my son’s PIP and LCWRA off him is going to get him a job.

Didn't you hear making someone homeless and not being able to afford food suddenly gets rid off disability.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 16:18

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:17

Didn't you hear making someone homeless and not being able to afford food suddenly gets rid off disability.

That’s not a sensible response

mummymeister · Today 16:18

CatkinToadflax · Today 16:15

I would like to know how taking my son’s PIP and LCWRA off him is going to get him a job.

who is saying that your sons support is going to be taken off him? does he need it, can he not manage without it? then there will be the money in the pot to do this which there isnt at the moment because the scammers have it. does he want a job? is he capable of working? if he is then do you want some one to one help to get him into work to make a start? the country can only do this if it redistributes the pot away from the scammers and to the genuine.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · Today 16:19

Enhancing support for the profoundly disabled whilst making it possible for those with some disabilities to work sounds positive, as long as that’s what happens.

Helping young people who have some disabilities but who could work to do so is in their interests.

A life spent on benefits doesn’t sound a good one to me.

Now obviously some people cannot work and should be supported.

PollyPocket80 · Today 16:19

Chiefunderling · Today 16:14

What’s most worrying is there was barely any mention of the NHS. Access to treatment is one of the biggest issues here for young people struggling with mental ill health. Treatment is only accessible following diagnosis. Diagnosis is taking years in many cases. Then years more languishing on waiting lists for treatment. And treatment isn’t always a one & done. Many people with significant mental illness need treatment at various points in their lives. Where I live, the local health board had been in special measures for just shy of a decade. We have been completely failed by local & national government. I cannot see the necessary changes in accessing treatment & support happening here in the next decade. It is complete chaos & people of all ages are suffering terribly. This crisis cannot be solved until the NHS is brought up to scratch where mental health services are concerned.

You have a point but the bigger point is why there is an epidemic of mentally ill children/teens? if there was a 300% increase in children developing physical deformities it would quite rightly be a public health emergency but it's not.

hoolaho · Today 16:21

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 16:14

Yes, I think alot of the genuine claimants feel that it is a personal criticism of them when others acknowledge that there is rampant fraud in the system. The two things are not mutually exclusive and unfortunately it seems that honest, genuine claimants are more likely to be refused PIP than the frauds who know how to play the system.

Yes, because they haven’t walked in there already primed to play up, act and exaggerate.

PIP absolutely do accept GP reports. In fact, it’s advisable to have this evidence

mummymeister · Today 16:21

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:17

Didn't you hear making someone homeless and not being able to afford food suddenly gets rid off disability.

and yet again, literally no one on here is saying this! you are catastrophising. start actually reading the posts instead of doing this all the time. its not helpful and its not truthful either.

hoolaho · Today 16:21

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · Today 16:19

Enhancing support for the profoundly disabled whilst making it possible for those with some disabilities to work sounds positive, as long as that’s what happens.

Helping young people who have some disabilities but who could work to do so is in their interests.

A life spent on benefits doesn’t sound a good one to me.

Now obviously some people cannot work and should be supported.

A life on benefits is the dream in some areas, genuinely.

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:22

Itchthescratch · Today 14:44

If you reform the system then it should apply equally to everyone otherwise you end up with a two tier system where two people with exactly the same level for impairment are eligible for different levels of state benefit. That's obviously unfair and I don't see how anyone can support this

Why do a few posters keep saying that reassessing everyone on PIP would sort out the scammers from the genuine? This sounds like anyone coming out of this that has had their money stopped means they were scammers.
That is simply not true. The bar will be set higher, which means that many genuine disabled will lose their money. People who put the effort in to defraud the system would still get away with it, and still get paid.

@Itchthescratch ignore me quoting you. I can't edit that out.

mummymeister · Today 16:23

hoolaho · Today 16:21

A life on benefits is the dream in some areas, genuinely.

Yep. and not only the child but the parent too and the grandparents and the wider family. Its a badge of honour. they pass the crutches round between them and in our area they call them PIP sticks.

Shardonneigghhh · Today 16:25

If my son's disability benefits are removed, he will still be unable to work. As a result of not having disability benefits, he will be unable to ever live independently. Currently I am expecting to provide care and support to him for the rest of my life. But if his benefits go then he will also be financially dependent on me, and i am not a well off person. So in order to financially support him, i will be unable to retire and will work until I die. And what will happen after that is probably he will become homeless and also die.

Happyindevon · Today 16:26

The PIP forms are impossible to satisfy unless you’re very severely disabled (paraplegic type thing), OR have a very broad and ‘spiky’ MH profile OR have a learning disability which makes you in need of 24/7 care

Because they require that you not be able to do basic things for yourself.

So somebody (like my friend - type 1 diabetes, neuropathy, half blind, kidney problems) like my friend wouldn’t qualify as she CAN dress herself and she CAN heat up some soup. But somebody ‘too anxious’ to do it or ‘too forgetful to leave something on the stove’ would qualify.

It’s mental

mummymeister · Today 16:26

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:22

Why do a few posters keep saying that reassessing everyone on PIP would sort out the scammers from the genuine? This sounds like anyone coming out of this that has had their money stopped means they were scammers.
That is simply not true. The bar will be set higher, which means that many genuine disabled will lose their money. People who put the effort in to defraud the system would still get away with it, and still get paid.

@Itchthescratch ignore me quoting you. I can't edit that out.

Edited

Believe me when I say that the facebook forum where the scammers congregate are literally shitting themselves that they are going to be found out and lose their PIP. they know that with a proper robust reassessment they dont have a leg to stand on (no pun intended) They know that the minute they are expected to attend therapies etc the game will be up. they do not want this to come in because then its game over.

Blackcat2026 · Today 16:27

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 15:14

I don’t think anyone is suggesting that benefits should be cut for the genuinely disabled. The issue is the huge numbers who are playing the system to fraudulently get benefits for less serious issues.

And not forgetting that people in receipt of benefits they shouldn't really be entitled to are effectively stealing from those who are genuinely disabled and woefully neglected by the state and local authorities. While some are receiving too much, those really in need (including their carers) are not receiving enough!

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:28

mummymeister · Today 16:26

Believe me when I say that the facebook forum where the scammers congregate are literally shitting themselves that they are going to be found out and lose their PIP. they know that with a proper robust reassessment they dont have a leg to stand on (no pun intended) They know that the minute they are expected to attend therapies etc the game will be up. they do not want this to come in because then its game over.

Exactly. I don't know why people are so determined to believe this isn't going on. There's a huge industry around it.

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 16:28

mummymeister · Today 16:23

Yep. and not only the child but the parent too and the grandparents and the wider family. Its a badge of honour. they pass the crutches round between them and in our area they call them PIP sticks.

It’s so sad when the welfare system was originally intended to support those in genuine need and there was a sense of pride in working to support your family when at all possible.

mummymeister · Today 16:28

Happyindevon · Today 16:26

The PIP forms are impossible to satisfy unless you’re very severely disabled (paraplegic type thing), OR have a very broad and ‘spiky’ MH profile OR have a learning disability which makes you in need of 24/7 care

Because they require that you not be able to do basic things for yourself.

So somebody (like my friend - type 1 diabetes, neuropathy, half blind, kidney problems) like my friend wouldn’t qualify as she CAN dress herself and she CAN heat up some soup. But somebody ‘too anxious’ to do it or ‘too forgetful to leave something on the stove’ would qualify.

It’s mental

but the scammers know which phrases to put in order to get the money. Basically, they lie. they lie excessively and they get the money.

they are conmen, they are thieves.

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:28

Blackcat2026 · Today 16:27

And not forgetting that people in receipt of benefits they shouldn't really be entitled to are effectively stealing from those who are genuinely disabled and woefully neglected by the state and local authorities. While some are receiving too much, those really in need (including their carers) are not receiving enough!

Exactly! I would like to see the money spent on decent care and support for those who really need it. Not on extra spending money for people who have plenty.

TravellingSpoon · Today 16:29

Shardonneigghhh · Today 16:25

If my son's disability benefits are removed, he will still be unable to work. As a result of not having disability benefits, he will be unable to ever live independently. Currently I am expecting to provide care and support to him for the rest of my life. But if his benefits go then he will also be financially dependent on me, and i am not a well off person. So in order to financially support him, i will be unable to retire and will work until I die. And what will happen after that is probably he will become homeless and also die.

This!!

I wonder how many of the posters who begrudge a disabled person getting PIP would want to support their adult DCs for the rest of thier lives.

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:30

mummymeister · Today 16:28

but the scammers know which phrases to put in order to get the money. Basically, they lie. they lie excessively and they get the money.

they are conmen, they are thieves.

Yes and although it hasn't been mentioned in the press I know there have been some prosecutions

CatkinToadflax · Today 16:30

mummymeister · Today 16:18

who is saying that your sons support is going to be taken off him? does he need it, can he not manage without it? then there will be the money in the pot to do this which there isnt at the moment because the scammers have it. does he want a job? is he capable of working? if he is then do you want some one to one help to get him into work to make a start? the country can only do this if it redistributes the pot away from the scammers and to the genuine.

He has one-to-one supported employment help already, but that doesn’t mean it’s easy for a young person with multiple varied disabilities and very limited energy to even be offered a job, let alone maintain it.

As for “who is saying” my son’s PIP and LCWRA should be taken off him, this is precisely what the Milburn Report is recommending. How will they know that someone else is a scammer and he isn’t? He has oodles of evidence, but apparently so do scammers as well.

hoolaho · Today 16:31

TravellingSpoon · Today 16:29

This!!

I wonder how many of the posters who begrudge a disabled person getting PIP would want to support their adult DCs for the rest of thier lives.

Who here begrudges a disabled person getting PIP?

mummymeister · Today 16:31

CatkinToadflax · Today 16:30

He has one-to-one supported employment help already, but that doesn’t mean it’s easy for a young person with multiple varied disabilities and very limited energy to even be offered a job, let alone maintain it.

As for “who is saying” my son’s PIP and LCWRA should be taken off him, this is precisely what the Milburn Report is recommending. How will they know that someone else is a scammer and he isn’t? He has oodles of evidence, but apparently so do scammers as well.

if your son were offered one to one support, therapies etc he would say yes and snap up the chance I am sure.

the scammers wont. thats how they are going to be able to tell the difference.

Itchthescratch · Today 16:31

Dimpkhimniaa · Today 16:28

It’s so sad when the welfare system was originally intended to support those in genuine need and there was a sense of pride in working to support your family when at all possible.

Yes, it used to be shameful not to work. As a society we moved towards eradicating shame but unintentionally created a new generation that are completely shameless.