Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Existing PIP awards for under 25 should be honoured

502 replies

HonourExistingClaimants · Today 12:55

If changes have to be made there needs to be a clear date for changes for new claims from that point. Existing claims should be honoured till the review date and then changed.

Surely anything else would be really wrong?

OP posts:
Chiefunderling · Today 16:34

hoolaho · Today 14:56

Absolutely. I know several late teens/early 20s PIP claimants who have zero intention of getting a job because of their “anxiety”. They all helped each other with the forms after one girls mum paid for a copy of a strangers forms and an “answer guide” on Facebook.

This extreme anxiety didn’t stop them all going to a festival and taking a shitload of drugs. They didn’t “forget to eat” despite their ADHD, diagnosed by a fraud on Facebook obviously.

It’s disgusting. And other than the tax payer, the people who will suffer are genuine disabled people.

It’s not just completing a form though. You need to provide substantial legitimate evidence for everything you are claiming in the PIP form. This evidence is heavily scrutinised. You then get assessed, face to face or over the phone, by an assessor working for the DWP. This person is a healthcare professional employed by the DWP. This assessment will go over everything you put in the form & all the evidence you submitted. You can certainly lie in the form, but you won’t get PIP without a substantial amount of evidence to back up EVERYTHING you are claiming. Most of this evidence needs to come from professionals; Doctors, consultants, therapists, support workers, & Clinical Psychologists. You also need to give permission for the DWP to contact those treating you themselves.

There is a world of difference between applying for PIP & being successful in your application. In fact, many people who provide all of the above are still denied & end up in a tribunal (if they don’t take their owns lives first). Tribunals overturn approximately 60% of DWP PIP refusals. That tells us the DWP is not doing its job & is actually denying genuinely disabled people the money they need to survive. A tribunal panel is made up of multiple experts & a judge, & considers all the evidence provided in addition to your medical records. Scamming the system is incredibly hard to do. It’s so hard, genuine claimants are routinely denied PIP! This is the cold hard truth.

edited for typos.

Notonmyland · Today 16:34

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:27

Oh and disability assessments will be taken from the NHS and given to the job centre.

Job centres could be more like an agency.
All the jobs go there and the job centre staff look at your skills and assign you a jobs.
If you deliberately mess up an interview then what should be the penalty?

seahorsessky · Today 16:35

If another child has the exact same disability as a child getting it now, it is unfair that just because she was born earlier/became disabled earlier, she should get it and another child doesn't. That's as unfair as saying, for example, all children who get free dental care now will continue to do so, but any children born after 2027 won't. It needs to be the same for everyone.
That said, I think it's disgusting how many parents are paying for medical care/devices for their disabled children because they don't get it on the NHS, while others who have never paid a penny in get given money, even though they don't pay out for medical treatment. Every disabled person should be given whatever treatment they need free.

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:35

mummymeister · Today 16:28

but the scammers know which phrases to put in order to get the money. Basically, they lie. they lie excessively and they get the money.

they are conmen, they are thieves.

What is put on the form is meaningless without evidence.

mummymeister · Today 16:36

TravellingSpoon · Today 16:29

This!!

I wonder how many of the posters who begrudge a disabled person getting PIP would want to support their adult DCs for the rest of thier lives.

FFS I just give up. Read the whole thread. Literally no one is begrudging a disabled person getting PIP. they begrudge a scammer getting the money.

Shall I make this really simple then? you have 10p to give out as PIP. you have 10 people applying thats 1p each. if 8 of those applicants are scammers and you can stop giving them the money then that means you give 5p each to the those who need it. Thats how it works, its just not rocket science. How do you weed out the scammers? by offering the therapies and the one to one and all the other stuff that will enable most of the scammers to be weeded out. Not all, most. which leaves more money for those in genuine need of help and support.

I am in favour of supporting disabled people. I want them to get MORE than they get now. but we can only do this if we get rid of the cheats and the liars.

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:37

Notonmyland · Today 16:34

Job centres could be more like an agency.
All the jobs go there and the job centre staff look at your skills and assign you a jobs.
If you deliberately mess up an interview then what should be the penalty?

You can only get into the job centre to see someone if you are on benefits. If all the job vacancies go there, then how will people that are not claiming be able to find work?
How would you be able to tell if someone threw an interview deliberately?

hoolaho · Today 16:38

Chiefunderling · Today 16:34

It’s not just completing a form though. You need to provide substantial legitimate evidence for everything you are claiming in the PIP form. This evidence is heavily scrutinised. You then get assessed, face to face or over the phone, by an assessor working for the DWP. This person is a healthcare professional employed by the DWP. This assessment will go over everything you put in the form & all the evidence you submitted. You can certainly lie in the form, but you won’t get PIP without a substantial amount of evidence to back up EVERYTHING you are claiming. Most of this evidence needs to come from professionals; Doctors, consultants, therapists, support workers, & Clinical Psychologists. You also need to give permission for the DWP to contact those treating you themselves.

There is a world of difference between applying for PIP & being successful in your application. In fact, many people who provide all of the above are still denied & end up in a tribunal (if they don’t take their owns lives first). Tribunals overturn approximately 60% of DWP PIP refusals. That tells us the DWP is not doing its job & is actually denying genuinely disabled people the money they need to survive. A tribunal panel is made up of multiple experts & a judge, & considers all the evidence provided in addition to your medical records. Scamming the system is incredibly hard to do. It’s so hard, genuine claimants are routinely denied PIP! This is the cold hard truth.

edited for typos.

Edited

Maybe you should RTFT

It’s absolutely NOT incredibly hard to fraudulently claim PIP. In fact whole estates and even towns are doing it!

thatsgotit · Today 16:39

Ohmygiddygirl · Today 13:45

This news is great. It’s all about getting disabled people off benefits and into work, giving them a proper future to look forward to. What is the issue? Why the negativity? A life on benefits is surely the worst possible option for someone.

'Off benefits and into work'? Where are all these jobs going to magically spring from overnight, then, when there is already a shortage of jobs? And where are all these super-enlightened employers going to magically spring from who don't look at a disabled person and think 'On the reject pile with them, they'll be wanting accommodations/time off all the time'?

There will always be scroungers, but few people would choose a life on benefits. Most people want to pay their way in life, including most disabled people. And of course we need to assist disabled people who are able to work to be able to do so. But your sentiments here are both naive and overly simplistic.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:39

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:35

What is put on the form is meaningless without evidence.

I honestly think people think that you just tell the dwp I can't dress myself because I hurt my finger and the dwp say ok mate no probs heres £800

hoolaho · Today 16:39

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:35

What is put on the form is meaningless without evidence.

Jesus wept 😅

We have explained repeatedly how they get the “evidence” they need.

Charla69 · Today 16:39

The ableists are so gullible thinking that the government are going to help the disabled by helping them or getting them back in to work. They won't, they'll just pocket all the poors cash and gloat. Also employers will always pick the healthy over the disabled, so what jobs will they have for us?.

I'm audhd who suffers from severe anxiety and depression whilst also having several disabilities associated with these conditions. My children also have audhd and struggle but apparently they don't deserve help?.

I worked for 15 years before I couldn't do it anymore as I forced myself to work for other people. I won't do that anymore as it caused me harm in the long run. Before anyone jumps on me for "never working" or any of that ableist bullcrap.

hoolaho · Today 16:40

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:39

I honestly think people think that you just tell the dwp I can't dress myself because I hurt my finger and the dwp say ok mate no probs heres £800

Nobody thinks that.

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:40

hoolaho · Today 16:38

Maybe you should RTFT

It’s absolutely NOT incredibly hard to fraudulently claim PIP. In fact whole estates and even towns are doing it!

Whole towns? Which towns? If this is happening, then you can name them.

Gingerbreadlattetoppingsontheside · Today 16:40

Heatedblankettime · Today 13:56

If you read the detail more money will go to therapy instead and it sounds like they need therapy far more than benefits

Not everything can be resolved by therapy.

If you have no insight therapy does bugger all.

mummymeister · Today 16:41

Chiefunderling · Today 16:34

It’s not just completing a form though. You need to provide substantial legitimate evidence for everything you are claiming in the PIP form. This evidence is heavily scrutinised. You then get assessed, face to face or over the phone, by an assessor working for the DWP. This person is a healthcare professional employed by the DWP. This assessment will go over everything you put in the form & all the evidence you submitted. You can certainly lie in the form, but you won’t get PIP without a substantial amount of evidence to back up EVERYTHING you are claiming. Most of this evidence needs to come from professionals; Doctors, consultants, therapists, support workers, & Clinical Psychologists. You also need to give permission for the DWP to contact those treating you themselves.

There is a world of difference between applying for PIP & being successful in your application. In fact, many people who provide all of the above are still denied & end up in a tribunal (if they don’t take their owns lives first). Tribunals overturn approximately 60% of DWP PIP refusals. That tells us the DWP is not doing its job & is actually denying genuinely disabled people the money they need to survive. A tribunal panel is made up of multiple experts & a judge, & considers all the evidence provided in addition to your medical records. Scamming the system is incredibly hard to do. It’s so hard, genuine claimants are routinely denied PIP! This is the cold hard truth.

edited for typos.

Edited

Nope scamming the system is most definately not incredibly hard to do. private experts paid to do reports so its in their interests to over egg the symptoms. people are liars and cheats because if they do this the money they receive to sit on their arses all day and not work is considerable.

You need to get out more if you think this isnt going on on a huge wide scale across the country.

thatsgotit · Today 16:41

lifeturnsonadime · Today 15:09

How do you know the parents spend it appropriately. Maybe they use it to get their nails done?

Why is it always nails on these threads? 🙄

PollyPocket80 · Today 16:41

Happyindevon · Today 16:26

The PIP forms are impossible to satisfy unless you’re very severely disabled (paraplegic type thing), OR have a very broad and ‘spiky’ MH profile OR have a learning disability which makes you in need of 24/7 care

Because they require that you not be able to do basic things for yourself.

So somebody (like my friend - type 1 diabetes, neuropathy, half blind, kidney problems) like my friend wouldn’t qualify as she CAN dress herself and she CAN heat up some soup. But somebody ‘too anxious’ to do it or ‘too forgetful to leave something on the stove’ would qualify.

It’s mental

Sorry this is simply not true.
Hate to give anyone ideas but as another poster pointed out it's really not that difficult to score enough points with knowledge of the criteria and a devious mind. For example- a person complains to GP about how they can't leave the house, cook, dress etc without prompting, has suicidal ideation (that's the current favoured trigger phrase). Is prescribed anti anxiety/depression meds (no way to prove whether you actually take them). GP might refer you to a therapist or similar (to cover their arse)-bingo! not only is this now in your medical records but you need to see a specialist so it must be bad. Fast forward to PIP/UC assessment day, you repeat the same spiel, put on a sad voice, have someone in the background for 'support' and the outcome is very likely to go your way.
Again, am in no way saying this is all or even majority of claimants but it goes on a lot, people need to wake up to it.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:42

There are a few people on this thread who are going to get one hell of a harsh lesson one day when they get ill one day and just never get better or end up in an accident through no fault of there own. Or give birth to a disabled child. Some people really do think their above becoming disabled

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:43

thatsgotit · Today 16:41

Why is it always nails on these threads? 🙄

Tattoos too. Oh, and the latest iPhone.

Batsuke1 · Today 16:44

I’m definitely not in favour of pulling the rug out from underneath people that’s for sure. I suppose there would have to be a process of reassessing claimants, but that will take a lot of time as will putting the necessary support in place and job availability to help people get into work or training.

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:44

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:42

There are a few people on this thread who are going to get one hell of a harsh lesson one day when they get ill one day and just never get better or end up in an accident through no fault of there own. Or give birth to a disabled child. Some people really do think their above becoming disabled

Again , lots of people are disabled or battling chronic health conditions or dealing with some other adversity but they are just too honest to submit a scammy PIP application

It's simply not the case that everyone who doesn't get PIP is neurotypical and bouncing around running marathons in their spare time.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:44

PollyPocket80 · Today 16:41

Sorry this is simply not true.
Hate to give anyone ideas but as another poster pointed out it's really not that difficult to score enough points with knowledge of the criteria and a devious mind. For example- a person complains to GP about how they can't leave the house, cook, dress etc without prompting, has suicidal ideation (that's the current favoured trigger phrase). Is prescribed anti anxiety/depression meds (no way to prove whether you actually take them). GP might refer you to a therapist or similar (to cover their arse)-bingo! not only is this now in your medical records but you need to see a specialist so it must be bad. Fast forward to PIP/UC assessment day, you repeat the same spiel, put on a sad voice, have someone in the background for 'support' and the outcome is very likely to go your way.
Again, am in no way saying this is all or even majority of claimants but it goes on a lot, people need to wake up to it.

I've been sectioned twice been under the cmht for years have bpd, bipolar, anxiety disorder, multiple organ failure. And I got zero points first try getting pip. Stop believing the newspapers

hoolaho · Today 16:44

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 16:42

There are a few people on this thread who are going to get one hell of a harsh lesson one day when they get ill one day and just never get better or end up in an accident through no fault of there own. Or give birth to a disabled child. Some people really do think their above becoming disabled

Who are you referring to?

All I see is posters who want genuinely disabled people to get a higher amount of benefits and support than they do now. And for the scammers to be stopped.

mummymeister · Today 16:45

3DPrintedDragon · Today 16:40

Whole towns? Which towns? If this is happening, then you can name them.

This is an anonymous forum. no one is going to tell you where they live as you well know.

I have been on MN for years - since it started. I am not a liar. I see these posts every single fucking day on the facebook "gossip girls" type forums.

I drink coffee in spoons. I hear the conversations.

You choose not to believe me, thats fine, I can live with that. But it doesnt change the actual facts - the system is being scammed. The govt accept that that is why its being changed yet you dont?

Chiefunderling · Today 16:46

hoolaho · Today 16:38

Maybe you should RTFT

It’s absolutely NOT incredibly hard to fraudulently claim PIP. In fact whole estates and even towns are doing it!

That is a lie. Have you been through the PIP claims process yourself? Have you worked for an organisation assisting disabled people with PIP applications? Do you believe everything you read on social media? If you haven’t been through the process, how could you possibly know what it consists of?

I am sick & tired of people trying to smear sick & disabled people. Fact is, tribunals overturn 2/3rd of PIP claims. That likely doesn’t suit your uninformed opinion but that’s hard luck I’m afraid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread