Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This is a perfectly acceptable reason to take the day off work?

316 replies

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:45

Dd (23) has an ongoing issue with her arm, she keeps getting horrendous pain (waiting for investigations but it’s likely to be due to hypermobility/ joint issues). The pain is severe and excruciating to the point she can’t talk eat move etc as it’s so bad.
standard painkillers don’t touch it. Codeine makes her uncontrollably vomit so can’t take that. She has called in sick to work today and been told that it’s not acceptable and they need to have a meeting as it’s the third time it’s happened this year. She literally can’t do her job safely (nursery) so surely they are BU?

OP posts:
MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 13:55

Mygreyhair · Yesterday 11:50

From a manager point of view, 3 absences within a 12-month period is high and a meeting should be called to find out if there is anything underlying.

If, as you say, there is an in-going medical issue, they should look at what adjustments they could make to her working day so she could attend. They may offer an occupational health assessment.

Ultimately though, she needs to be able to do her job. In the long term, is this job something she can realistically do?

It’s really not a big deal to be sick 3 times. In today’s age managers I have had prefer you don’t come in an infect the whole team when sick which impacts work a lot worse. In this case, it’s a health issue they should document but they’d never be able to sack her over capability for 3 absences in 12 months. Absolute nonsense.

MalateOxaloacetate · Yesterday 13:58

bababamama · Yesterday 13:05

To those saying this is ridiculous, would you as a parent appreciate being called to say your child cannot attend nursery because of staff sickness? How about fees increasing so they can employ additional staff in case someone rings in sick? Thought not. Usually the nursery manager is the cover, but if a second person calls in sick then some children cannot attend, it’s the law to have the correct ratios. Perhaps oddly, they would be legal if she was in work but assigned office duties because the law refers to people in the building to a certain extent, so that in emergency they can rush to help.

And yet if they are all sick… yeah that’s what has to happen as with literally every other business. If the staff are sick it has to close or hire additional staff and up the price. The cost of a service is stated up front and accepted by service users, if they cannot afford it they go elsewhere or they stop working. You cannot use the excuse of higher cost needs to treat human beings badly at work for being sick.

Lucytheloose · Yesterday 13:59

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:51

It’s the only job she can do so we will have to work something out

How can it possibly be the only job she can do? You don't seem to have a very high opinion of your daughter and her potential. If this is the kind of message she is getting at home, it is not surprising that she lacks confidence.

themarvelofmarvels · Yesterday 14:00

Ring ACAS and get some advice before you go to the meeting so that you know your facts. For those saying don't go with her, have they missed the bit where you say she is ASD and needs extra support?

I understand that it is annoying for the nursery, but when you are in A&E there is not much you can do about it, so they need to suck it up. They should have a backup plan for staff sickness, like casual cover etc.

Besidemyselfwithworry · Yesterday 14:02

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:54

The first time it happened I had to call
then from a and e as she was stressed not being there and they just kept asking would she be in later for their ratios and didn’t even ask how she was

They sound awful 😞
I’d be taking her to hospital and also phoning ACAS for some advice here
I’d also be looking for another job and staying off sick until I found more supportive employers!

Sladuf1 · Yesterday 14:03

I appreciate law is fast developing but for quite a few years now, the advice on allowing family members to attend formal workplace meetings as a reasonable adjustment where a person requires their family member’s support to help alleviate the individual’s difficulties (used as a shorthand term), has been to take care when denying these requests. So, actually the OP’s daughter’s employer should really consider a request for the OP to attend carefully. If need be, they should be getting an OH opinion about it.

In 2020 a tribunal found Royal Mail had breached the duty to make reasonable adjustments in not allowing an employee’s wife to attend a hearing. In that case, the employee was actually also represented by a TU rep at the hearing. However, the tribunal’s view was the TU rep didn’t understand the nature of the employee’s condition as well as his wife did, and that not allowing the employee’s wife to attend as well had prevented the employee from presenting his case.

There’s also been a more recent tribunal decision where a failure to make reasonable adjustments claim was upheld when an NHS trust hadn’t allowed the employee to be accompanied by his wife at sickness/absence management meetings - Mr I Lowe v Berkshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust.

Clarabell77 · Yesterday 14:03

JustFrustrated · Yesterday 12:12

At my place we wouldn’t allow a family member to attend

colleague/team member or union rep. That’s it

Not even colleague or union rep for an absence meeting. That would only he for a formal meeting.

OP you can’t go with her, it’s not school.

SockGene · Yesterday 14:06

I sympathise. I started having dreadful arm pain earlier this year. I suspect I might have a rotator cuff injury but it’s been quite hard getting a doctor’s interest in it, though I haven’t really pushed. Has she been checked for that? I also can’t take Codeine as it makes me feel really sick. Huge sympathies for her and I hope the meeting goes well. How stressful.

MsPrufrockk · Yesterday 14:13

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:51

It’s the only job she can do so we will have to work something out

Why is it the only job she can do?

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 14:13

Lucytheloose · Yesterday 13:59

How can it possibly be the only job she can do? You don't seem to have a very high opinion of your daughter and her potential. If this is the kind of message she is getting at home, it is not surprising that she lacks confidence.

She has a lot of difficulties and struggled a lot (got no GCSEs) and this has been the only job she can do, she’s only PT as well 3.5 days a week as couldn’t do full time. She loves the job but the way she has been treated (this is the third nursery she has worked at) at each employment has been difficult.

OP posts:
MsPrufrockk · Yesterday 14:15

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 14:13

She has a lot of difficulties and struggled a lot (got no GCSEs) and this has been the only job she can do, she’s only PT as well 3.5 days a week as couldn’t do full time. She loves the job but the way she has been treated (this is the third nursery she has worked at) at each employment has been difficult.

What happened at the first two nurseries? Is it you telling her this is the only job she can do?

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 14:16

MsPrufrockk · Yesterday 14:15

What happened at the first two nurseries? Is it you telling her this is the only job she can do?

No it was the only course we could get her onto/get her to do at college

OP posts:
TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 14:17

MsPrufrockk · Yesterday 14:15

What happened at the first two nurseries? Is it you telling her this is the only job she can do?

First was full time and she got really unwell from stress so decided to hand her notice in and look for another job nearer to home , the second she found was PT 4 days a week but the same thing so she got this one which was 3.5 days and fine till she developed this arm issue

OP posts:
Clarabell77 · Yesterday 14:18

Sladuf1 · Yesterday 14:03

I appreciate law is fast developing but for quite a few years now, the advice on allowing family members to attend formal workplace meetings as a reasonable adjustment where a person requires their family member’s support to help alleviate the individual’s difficulties (used as a shorthand term), has been to take care when denying these requests. So, actually the OP’s daughter’s employer should really consider a request for the OP to attend carefully. If need be, they should be getting an OH opinion about it.

In 2020 a tribunal found Royal Mail had breached the duty to make reasonable adjustments in not allowing an employee’s wife to attend a hearing. In that case, the employee was actually also represented by a TU rep at the hearing. However, the tribunal’s view was the TU rep didn’t understand the nature of the employee’s condition as well as his wife did, and that not allowing the employee’s wife to attend as well had prevented the employee from presenting his case.

There’s also been a more recent tribunal decision where a failure to make reasonable adjustments claim was upheld when an NHS trust hadn’t allowed the employee to be accompanied by his wife at sickness/absence management meetings - Mr I Lowe v Berkshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust.

Edited

That was a request made as part of a right to be accompanied though. The employer should be confirming in writing if this is a formal meeting with the right to be accompanied and only at that point might the daughter request a family member as the companion.

LIZS · Yesterday 14:20

Unfortunately there will be an absence policy which requires Back to Work interviews and potentially a disciplinary process if repeated. Maybe she is not cut out for the physicalities of nursery work. Is she at college the other 1.5 days as she can take English and Maths courses free which would improve her options.

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 14:25

She is so upset she is saying she is going to give notice as she wants to quit. I’m inclined to agree with her she needs a break and to sort her arm out. Perhaps we could after that think about some kind of training and get some advice as to what she could actually do that would suit her

OP posts:
TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 14:26

They’ve tried to call her multiple times today and she just won’t answer as is too stressed/in pain/upset

OP posts:
trossardmartinelli · Yesterday 14:28

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 14:26

They’ve tried to call her multiple times today and she just won’t answer as is too stressed/in pain/upset

This isn't good. She needs to be professional and answer the phone to them.

LIZS · Yesterday 14:30

If she has not been there long they might let her go anyway. Nurseries work on ratios and can’t easily have someone who has to take days off.

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 14:30

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 14:26

They’ve tried to call her multiple times today and she just won’t answer as is too stressed/in pain/upset

That's outrageous.
She has told them she is off sick.
She does need to follow the absence policy - and so do they!

AI suggest she send the following

I have reported my sickness absence in accordance with the nursery's absence policy and will continue to follow the required procedures.

I understand the staffing pressures, but I am currently unwell and not fit to attend work. I would appreciate it if this could be respected.

If there is any information you require from me regarding my absence, please contact me by message or email.

I will keep you updated in line with the sickness absence policy.

Thank you.

HangingOver · Yesterday 14:30

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:04

Referral to rheumatologist and a scan . I have a suspicion it may be nerve pain though, something that keeps getting trapped as it is always very sudden very severe but will last 24-72 hours then abruptly stop.
She did try naproxen it totally knocked her out so she can’t take that for work unfortunately

Really? It's not an opiate. I take it all the time, drive and everything. I had no idea Naproxen could do this!

bigboykitty · Yesterday 14:31

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:53

I think I will go with her as they have been really harsh each time and made her feel guilty on top of being in pain. She has ASD as well so is feeling incredibly stressed as she loves her job but as far as I can tell it’s not a very tolerant workplace. She is under so much pressure all the time

It's totally inappropriate to go with your DD. She's an adult and it's a meeting in her workplace.

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 14:31

trossardmartinelli · Yesterday 14:28

This isn't good. She needs to be professional and answer the phone to them.

She’s maintaining she spoke to them this morning and they said they’d speak to her tomorrow so she won’t answer now

OP posts:
Napsarelife · Yesterday 14:32

She's 23 she needs to answer the phone and deal with her employer like the adult she is. She can write notes and have written out what she wants to say.

spiderrider · Yesterday 14:33

I work for the nhs and this sounds the same as our sickness policy..3 absences in 12 months would definitely trigger a management and HR meeting.