Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This is a perfectly acceptable reason to take the day off work?

323 replies

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:45

Dd (23) has an ongoing issue with her arm, she keeps getting horrendous pain (waiting for investigations but it’s likely to be due to hypermobility/ joint issues). The pain is severe and excruciating to the point she can’t talk eat move etc as it’s so bad.
standard painkillers don’t touch it. Codeine makes her uncontrollably vomit so can’t take that. She has called in sick to work today and been told that it’s not acceptable and they need to have a meeting as it’s the third time it’s happened this year. She literally can’t do her job safely (nursery) so surely they are BU?

OP posts:
IamtheDevilsAvocado · Yesterday 21:44

Skippythemagnificent · Yesterday 21:06

No, three separate instances of being sick is high. You could go off sick for two weeks then come back and carry on and that is fine. But taking three separate lots of sick leave is a lot. No healthy adult needs to miss work for sickness 3 times in fairly quick succession.

There is if it's flaring up nerve pain... And asd complicates it...

Of course, it would make the sickness metrics easier had she taken a month off all at once, but sadly, nerve pain doesn't behave like that.

SerenaCat93 · Yesterday 21:47

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 20:36

At the moment yes but if we work towards some goals and get the cause of the pain identified and treated she will likely be ok in the future ?

Nom she couldn't cope with even part time work before the arm pain. Sorting her arm out won't make her magically be able to cope with working. Neither is retraining in something else. If she can't physically work more than 3 days a week without burning out you need to look at disability benefits.

SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 21:55

Velumental · Yesterday 19:26

I work in the NHS and 3 in a year triggers contact with manager. 3 absences in a year is considered a lot

That aggressive level isn’t working well for the NHS is it?

Whatseatinggilbertsgrape · Yesterday 21:57

Octavia64 · Yesterday 11:50

Some workplaces have policies that you have to have a meeting after so many sickness absence.

one school I worked in you had to have a meeting after each absence which was total overkill.

i’d had an open ankle fracture and two operations, been in hospital a week and was in work on crutches and they still demanded a bloody meeting.

it was quite a short one - what could you do to avoid this absence? Well, I could try not to have a life changing accident?

in theory the meetings are to “support” you if you need any help at work but in practice they don’t usually work that way.

could your dd ask for non optiate painkillers? Codeine is notorious for nausea but she might be better on naproxen.

That happened at my mums school, a "back to work meeting" after a migraine 🙃

Keepingthingsinteresting · Yesterday 21:57

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 14:13

She has a lot of difficulties and struggled a lot (got no GCSEs) and this has been the only job she can do, she’s only PT as well 3.5 days a week as couldn’t do full time. She loves the job but the way she has been treated (this is the third nursery she has worked at) at each employment has been difficult.

I hear what you say @TrappedInaShituation , but gently it doesn’t sound like she can do the job. Nurseries need really reliable staff as they are screwed if staff don’t turn up, as are all the parents of the kids in the rooms that have to be closed in turn.

I understand why you feel protective but this is the third place she’s had problems and eventually one has to realise that sometimes it is us who is the problem, not everyone else.

I hope she gets sorted soon and finds more suitable employment.

jmh740 · Yesterday 21:59

Iloveeverycat · Yesterday 13:31

It is ridiculous in retail its the same if you have 3 single days off in a year you have a disaplinery. My DD had a disaplinery on a third absence as they had chicken pox do you really think they would want them to go to work with it when contagious and covered in scabs I don't think so but you still get a disaplinery for it.

Edited

Wouldnt be contagious if scabbed. I work as a TA was expected to work with scabies as long as not visible. A meeting after 3 absences would be standard where I am.

Changingnameagain · Yesterday 22:01

Unions won't help with existing issues but get her signed up with one now for any future stuff because her workplace sounds shit. ASD will be considered a disability and a reasonable adjustment for her anxiety would be to request she can take a support person in to meeting. Does she have a friend at work she could take? I agree witb PPs that taking you in won't project the most professional image but equally needs must and asking for advocate support due to ASD is totally reasonable.

SuddenDaredJelly · Yesterday 22:17

glogg · Yesterday 11:53

I find that crazy. How are people supposed to hold down a job if even 3 absences for justified sickness over one year is considered unacceptable.

Its not typical to be so ill you cant work all the time as an adult. I think i've maybe had two days off sick in 3.5 yrs in my current job. Some years I wouldnt have any days off.

SuddenDaredJelly · Yesterday 22:19

I understand why you feel protective but this is the third place she’s had problems and eventually one has to realise that sometimes it is us who is the problem, not everyone else.

This

RPRegionalPosh · Yesterday 22:19

glogg · Yesterday 11:53

I find that crazy. How are people supposed to hold down a job if even 3 absences for justified sickness over one year is considered unacceptable.

Underlying conditions aside are you really so ill 3 or more times a year you can't work?
I've not even had a heavy cold this year so far, I've not required time off, I do have underlying health issues and I'm not dragging myself in at deaths door. I wouldn't think it was common to need 3 periods of sickness absence in a year

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 22:23

They have to speak to people who have three absences in a set period of time to see if they can support or what can be done. it’s a standard procedure.

I get why you want to get involved but wanting to go down and speak to them is why some employers won’t employ young people - they have to deal with the parents as well.

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 22:28

Mygreyhair · Yesterday 11:50

From a manager point of view, 3 absences within a 12-month period is high and a meeting should be called to find out if there is anything underlying.

If, as you say, there is an in-going medical issue, they should look at what adjustments they could make to her working day so she could attend. They may offer an occupational health assessment.

Ultimately though, she needs to be able to do her job. In the long term, is this job something she can realistically do?

I'm sorry but 3 absences within a year is high? No it isn't!! That is once every four months.

mixedpeel · Yesterday 22:41

ilovepuppies2019 · Yesterday 17:02

I don’t understand how you all survive the sick leave approach in the UK. Three separate sicknesses is complete normal. You get a cold, get D and V, get a virus and have an accident in most years. I can’t think of many people who haven’t taken three separate incidents off work. Aus has a certain number of sick leave days and you use them with no questions asked beyond providing a doctors certificate after a certain number of days.

See @Putyhtgrf ’s post quoting you for an example of much more generous provision in certain professions. It’s a different world further down the pecking order.

The lower the pay for your role, the more punitive the working conditions are likely to be.

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 22:46

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 22:28

I'm sorry but 3 absences within a year is high? No it isn't!! That is once every four months.

It usually triggers a review in most companies.

JulietteRoche · Yesterday 22:56

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 22:46

It usually triggers a review in most companies.

Not in mine, thank the lord.

TheSnappyBluePoster · Yesterday 23:17

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 19:58

She seems to have needed to reduce her hours over the years from full time to 4 days to 3.5 . Her tolerance is decreasing and she’s now got this ?trapped nerve issue with her arm and she’s exhausted. I think it’s just not the career for her, she has said today she just can’t do it anymore and I feel that it’s not the end of the world she is young enough to go back into education.

What do you mean over the years?

She's 23 not 40.

How many years has she been working to reduce her days over the years?!

This is a really bad sign, and you enabling her isn't helping.

OneFunBrickNewt · Yesterday 23:47

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:09

She often needs support with this kind of thing as gets stressed and will potentially struggle to assert herself

Yes, but surely you going with her will undermine her in the eyes of her employer. Adults don't take their parents to work meetings.

ForPinkCrab · Yesterday 23:58

From my own experience I think I understand a bit about why you might want to step in and help your daughter ….

My daughter was late diagnosed with ADHD at 28 after years of anxiety, meltdowns and general chaos in her life.
She had various PT jobs after leaving school. Many of which, rightly or wrongly I found for her as she had very low confidence and couldn’t speak for herself without going into a panic and having a meltdown, due to the ADHD.
She didn't cope well with adults either, but turned out she didn’t like structure or being in a strict workplace with rules, she got RSD if someone even suggested she hadn’t done something correctly, which was why she didn’t like having ‘adults’ around telling her what to do.

I managed (in desperation) to get her in to a hairdressing apprenticeship when she was 23. At first she didn’t think she would get on as a hairdresser but as she’s arty she soon realised she could channel her artiness into hair, making crazy styles and wacky colours as well as the normal cut and blow dry .
Fast forward to now, she’s 30 rents a chair and self employed. No one tells her what to do or how to do it. She has clients that come from far and wide and a big instagram following. That little girl who was lost and didn’t think she’d be able to hold down a job is now a very confident, messy, and incredibly talented hair dresser . It took her a few years to find what suited her.
Maybe your daughter feels ‘safe’ working with young children because of her Autism, but the strict rules at where she works isn’t for her. I’d look at something that she would enjoy she can do independently. Could she cope with private child minding or going on a course to get the necessary qualifications .
I know her arm is also a problem, but could be made worse by the anxiety perhaps?

HollaHolla · Yesterday 23:59

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 20:32

We have done the physio self referral but the GP said they will likely want to have the results of the scan and a doctors opinion before doing anything

If you've got a bit of cash to support her, a good private physio can be about £40 per session, and do a lot to help with knowing what's going on, and rehabbing her. It might be something pretty simple, which can be resolved.
Maybe shorter days would be a solution for her, too.

TheCheekyCyanHelper · Today 00:29

Mygreyhair · Yesterday 11:50

From a manager point of view, 3 absences within a 12-month period is high and a meeting should be called to find out if there is anything underlying.

If, as you say, there is an in-going medical issue, they should look at what adjustments they could make to her working day so she could attend. They may offer an occupational health assessment.

Ultimately though, she needs to be able to do her job. In the long term, is this job something she can realistically do?

3 absences in 12 MONTHS is extreme???

TheSnappyBluePoster · Today 00:32

TheCheekyCyanHelper · Today 00:29

3 absences in 12 MONTHS is extreme???

For the same thing it is yes.

Genuinely, on average, how often are people really far too ill to be able to go to work during a year? I'm betting it's not three times.

People just don't fancy going when they're feeling a bit under the weather, but could actually work.

Anarchy99 · Today 00:41

TheCheekyCyanHelper · Today 00:29

3 absences in 12 MONTHS is extreme???

It warrants a review in many places. If someone works in such a place then they are agreeing for that to happen.

A review doesn’t necessarily mean disciplinary. It can mean putting reasonable adjustments and support in place to help the employee.

However if that doesn’t work then it becomes disciplinary

ilovepuppies2019 · Today 01:38

TheSnappyBluePoster · Today 00:32

For the same thing it is yes.

Genuinely, on average, how often are people really far too ill to be able to go to work during a year? I'm betting it's not three times.

People just don't fancy going when they're feeling a bit under the weather, but could actually work.

You’re incredibly lucky to be able to think that way. It’s also very untrue. Only three absences would be a good year for most people. The flue, D and V and an accident are pretty normal in a year.

maxslice · Today 01:57

IamtheDevilsAvocado · Yesterday 21:41

Wow... You're all heart.

I worked in a nursery in my 20s... And in a professional career from my 30s onwards ...

Nursery was much more stressful... The noise alone....

And ASD will amplify everything.

Thank you. Yes.

Scandalicious · Today 03:14

People may ask why your DD can ‘only’ work part time, but for some people with autism the strain of that is greater than most people experience in a full time role. The stress of it may lead to muscle guarding and spasms, but also there is a strong overlap between autism and joint hypermobility or Ehlers Danlos Syndrome, which could trigger subluxations in sleep. If the joint popped back in right away, the injury could still take days to recover pain wise. Also the extreme reactions to the medications are probably connected with sensory processing or metabolic sensitivities often experienced by people with autism. We are just starting to learn more about how much autism and adhd correlate with physical health issues. Has your DD generally had very flexible joints, or a tendency to experience sprains? You are doing the right thing OP not putting pressure on her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread