Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This is a perfectly acceptable reason to take the day off work?

316 replies

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:45

Dd (23) has an ongoing issue with her arm, she keeps getting horrendous pain (waiting for investigations but it’s likely to be due to hypermobility/ joint issues). The pain is severe and excruciating to the point she can’t talk eat move etc as it’s so bad.
standard painkillers don’t touch it. Codeine makes her uncontrollably vomit so can’t take that. She has called in sick to work today and been told that it’s not acceptable and they need to have a meeting as it’s the third time it’s happened this year. She literally can’t do her job safely (nursery) so surely they are BU?

OP posts:
bababamama · Yesterday 12:59

3 absences in 12 months is standard for triggering a meeting if especially if the absences aren’t accompanied by a fit note (eg more than a week off for flu with a fit note, time off for a broken leg etc they accept easier than less time but not corroboration as to what it is. If the time off is for the same reason a good employer will be using the meeting to explore if there is anything they as a good employer can do reasonably to prevent future absences eg adaptations. If it’s down to the nature of the work she does, in the longer term it is wise to start to explore other careers

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · Yesterday 13:02

I think nurseries/ early years is a very difficult industry as they have to stick strictly to ratios and they can’t have extra staff just in case as their margins are so small.

No wonder they’re such germ factories with adults being leant on to turn up sick, as well as parents sending in sick kids to get to work.

However, the way they’re treating your daughter is not acceptable.

She might have been / might be better of having a longer continuous absence as once she comes back in, the next time she’s off is a new absence.

lifydiffy83 · Yesterday 13:03

She needs to go into the meeting ready to discuss a way forward. For example can she really not do anything when it flares up, could she agree to go in so ratio is hit but be hands off with the kids. Again I have no idea if this is viable but she needs to come up with a plan to present to them.

Upsetbetty · Yesterday 13:05

glogg · Yesterday 11:53

I find that crazy. How are people supposed to hold down a job if even 3 absences for justified sickness over one year is considered unacceptable.

Yeah this is ridiculous, I have worked in two very different career paths and in several corporate roles and I have never had this!!

bababamama · Yesterday 13:05

To those saying this is ridiculous, would you as a parent appreciate being called to say your child cannot attend nursery because of staff sickness? How about fees increasing so they can employ additional staff in case someone rings in sick? Thought not. Usually the nursery manager is the cover, but if a second person calls in sick then some children cannot attend, it’s the law to have the correct ratios. Perhaps oddly, they would be legal if she was in work but assigned office duties because the law refers to people in the building to a certain extent, so that in emergency they can rush to help.

Putyhtgrf · Yesterday 13:05

FrankieNeverRelax · Yesterday 12:19

For comparison this is my workplace sick policy
sick pay - 30 days a year full pay (unless you get something like cancer then it’s massively increased of course)
You get an informal meeting if you hit over 10 days sick in a year of 3 instances in 3 months
Then all the numbers reset and if you go over 10 days/3 instances you get a verbal warning
Then it all resets again if you do it again written warning

Occupational Health get involved at verbal warning stage and make adjustments for people e.g lower targets, more work from home days, more time off for appointments etc

Personally I’ve never hit a trigger but lots of people have and that’s way more often than your daughter so I think her workplace are exceptionally strict! They are also much more flexible if you were in hospital etc

Mine is three months on full pay, then three months half pay and then income protection insurance payouts after that.
Ive been off for years and I think they have forgotten I exist. Never have contact from HR or OH.

cymbalbread · Yesterday 13:09

It's nothing to do with it being an acceptable reason or not. They will simply be following their absence management policy. This doesn't mean she's in trouble - the purpose of the meeting is to review absense, consider whether there is any support that can be offered, consider an occuptational health referral etc. They have a duty to make reasonable adjustments where an employee has a potential disability so it would be a risk for them not to hold a meeting.

MissMoneyFairy · Yesterday 13:13

Nurseries are germ breeders but there's a difference between catching a cold or tummy bug that the employer should have a policy about than a chronic long term health issue, if she's signed off sick then she can't just go in and be hands off if that's her job role, she needs to go to the meeting, with a plan from her and her GP, maybe there is a different role there or reduced hours, as long as she is working within health and safety rules and has had the appropriate training I don't know what the nursery are supposed to do, they can't employ someone off sick a lot but she will be protected by law to ensure they follow the correct sickness and absence procedures for theirs and her benefit. Maybe she has to resign on ill health, acas will help her, could she manage a different job where there is no lifting like office or reception work.

herbetta · Yesterday 13:14

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:53

I think I will go with her as they have been really harsh each time and made her feel guilty on top of being in pain. She has ASD as well so is feeling incredibly stressed as she loves her job but as far as I can tell it’s not a very tolerant workplace. She is under so much pressure all the time

Do they know she has ASD and that it comes under the Equality Act? The hypermobility will be directly linked to this. Is she seeing a physio?

Somnambule · Yesterday 13:15

glogg · Yesterday 11:53

I find that crazy. How are people supposed to hold down a job if even 3 absences for justified sickness over one year is considered unacceptable.

I agree! I know nobody on Mumsnet is ever ill, but in the real world it's completely normal to be ill 3 times in a year.

allthemind · Yesterday 13:18

Has she tried wearing a elbow brace or wrist brace, wherever the pain is. I have hypermobility and suffer from tennis elbow a lot and it makes an enormous difference. I also sleep with my arm propped on a pillow so I dont overextend it overnight an bend it the wrong way, which was causing this issue. If im honest, even though I suffer with this, I dont think this really warrants a day off, as the pain is manageable with some accomodations and ibuprofen, or mine is anyway. Her job is quite manual though, perhaps she could work more in the office on those days when it is flaring up?

nolongeranutjob · Yesterday 13:19

MightyOles · Yesterday 12:51

What ideally should nurseries do when staff are off often if they have ratios they need to cover? Genuinely I wonder what people would suggest they do when 1 or 2 members of staff call in sick multiple times a year?

Sometimes they can get agency staff, especially if it's a longer term or known absence.

In this case a meeting sounds like a good idea, it's not necessarily a disciplinary, just a meeting to understand what's going on. If it's an ongoing issue the nursery needs to make plans to cover this. Also, since it's a physical issue not an illness they need to know if this employee is safe to pick up children while this condition is ongoing. A kid gets hurt because a staff member, who has a known problem with their arm, drops them is going to cause all kinds of problems.

TheAmberKoala · Yesterday 13:19

Upsetbetty · Yesterday 13:05

Yeah this is ridiculous, I have worked in two very different career paths and in several corporate roles and I have never had this!!

I dont get sick much, but I have 4 kids, there were a couple a periods over the years where I took quite a few days.

Mygreyhair · Yesterday 13:20

glogg · Yesterday 11:53

I find that crazy. How are people supposed to hold down a job if even 3 absences for justified sickness over one year is considered unacceptable.

I didn’t say unacceptable. I said ‘high’. In the vast majority of cases the absences are unavoidable and acceptable (like vomiting or flu). The point of the meeting is to pick up early those patterns of absences where people need support.

Hayley1256 · Yesterday 13:21

I would try and get her in with a Physiotherapist

owlpassport · Yesterday 13:28

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:54

The first time it happened I had to call
then from a and e as she was stressed not being there and they just kept asking would she be in later for their ratios and didn’t even ask how she was

From a management perspective, the point of the call to work is to inform them of an absence and expected duration of said absence so yes, they'd need to know when she was expected back for service delivery reasons. You sound upset that they 'didn't even ask how she was'. Okay it might have been polite and kind to ask, but ultimately they're her work, not her mum. Realistically they probably don't care, and are just stressing about who will cover. You are her mum, and can do the caring bit.

ETA - If your DD needs support in a meeting I really don't think you should provide it. Not only does it look bad (taking your mum in), you don't really sound like you have a good grasp of management requirements yourself and could make things worse.

Heatedblankettime · Yesterday 13:31

bababamama · Yesterday 13:05

To those saying this is ridiculous, would you as a parent appreciate being called to say your child cannot attend nursery because of staff sickness? How about fees increasing so they can employ additional staff in case someone rings in sick? Thought not. Usually the nursery manager is the cover, but if a second person calls in sick then some children cannot attend, it’s the law to have the correct ratios. Perhaps oddly, they would be legal if she was in work but assigned office duties because the law refers to people in the building to a certain extent, so that in emergency they can rush to help.

As a parent the last thing I want is someone caring for my child who is too ill to care for them safely.

Iloveeverycat · Yesterday 13:31

It is ridiculous in retail its the same if you have 3 single days off in a year you have a disaplinery. My DD had a disaplinery on a third absence as they had chicken pox do you really think they would want them to go to work with it when contagious and covered in scabs I don't think so but you still get a disaplinery for it.

Scandalicious · Yesterday 13:33

Whereabouts in the arm is it OP? I’m not a medic but have experience with joint issues. Did they take bloods at A and E or anywhere else? It is hot, swollen, red..? Does it just affect one joint?

ilovesooty · Yesterday 13:37

Iloveeverycat · Yesterday 13:31

It is ridiculous in retail its the same if you have 3 single days off in a year you have a disaplinery. My DD had a disaplinery on a third absence as they had chicken pox do you really think they would want them to go to work with it when contagious and covered in scabs I don't think so but you still get a disaplinery for it.

Edited

Was it a disciplinary or an absence management meeting?

Elsvieta · Yesterday 13:40

Has she got a diagnosis? You can't go to an adult's work meeting with them; if you want to support her, pay for her to see a private physiotherapist.

Iloveeverycat · Yesterday 13:45

ilovesooty · Yesterday 13:37

Was it a disciplinary or an absence management meeting?

A disaplinery as it was a third absence.

Moveoverdarlin · Yesterday 13:51

She’s 23. She categorically can not take her mother in to a work meeting. It’s not an embarrassing health problem nor is she in trouble. She needs to tell them her problem, tell them what the doctors have said, tell them the plan with regards to scans and appointments and go from there. She needs to be confident and upbeat. She needs to tell them how much she loves the job and how keen she is to get this matter resolved. She appreciates their patience while she undergoes goes treatment.

You getting involved makes it a mountain out of a molehill and completely undermines her. How can she look after children herself when she brings her Mum to a standard work meeting?

She’s had a few absences and her employers need to address it. That’s it. Stop fussing.

ItalianoSl · Yesterday 13:52

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:51

It’s the only job she can do so we will have to work something out

Why is that?

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · Yesterday 13:54

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:53

I think I will go with her as they have been really harsh each time and made her feel guilty on top of being in pain. She has ASD as well so is feeling incredibly stressed as she loves her job but as far as I can tell it’s not a very tolerant workplace. She is under so much pressure all the time

You really cannot expect to attend a workplace meeting.

Stop helicopter parenting your adult child.

She has a contract of employment to attend work. They will have processes due to the amount of time if she's had.

If she's unwell and unable to work them she just needs to explain that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread