Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This is a perfectly acceptable reason to take the day off work?

323 replies

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:45

Dd (23) has an ongoing issue with her arm, she keeps getting horrendous pain (waiting for investigations but it’s likely to be due to hypermobility/ joint issues). The pain is severe and excruciating to the point she can’t talk eat move etc as it’s so bad.
standard painkillers don’t touch it. Codeine makes her uncontrollably vomit so can’t take that. She has called in sick to work today and been told that it’s not acceptable and they need to have a meeting as it’s the third time it’s happened this year. She literally can’t do her job safely (nursery) so surely they are BU?

OP posts:
Dontevenlookatme · Today 04:28

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 12:04

Referral to rheumatologist and a scan . I have a suspicion it may be nerve pain though, something that keeps getting trapped as it is always very sudden very severe but will last 24-72 hours then abruptly stop.
She did try naproxen it totally knocked her out so she can’t take that for work unfortunately

Not the point of your thread but I have something similar which I’m sure started with a badly administered flu vaccination that I suspect hit a nerve. The jab was very painful and my arm suddenly went dead, very uncomfortable and had trouble driving home but disappeared as quickly as it came on.

A couple of time now I’ve felt the pain suddenly come on and I really can’t use that arm while it lasts, (last time was very inconveniently in the middle of preparing Christmas dinner) but it equally suddenly goes away.

I’ve found if I can catch it and sort of roll my arm and shoulder I can stop it.

Has she had any injections in that arm?

Natsku · Today 05:07

Skippythemagnificent · Yesterday 21:06

No, three separate instances of being sick is high. You could go off sick for two weeks then come back and carry on and that is fine. But taking three separate lots of sick leave is a lot. No healthy adult needs to miss work for sickness 3 times in fairly quick succession.

I just checked my absences for this year, 11 separate instances (mostly 1 day, some 2 or 3 days) plus one absence to look after my child for several days. Most of those were for heavy colds or stomach bugs, which of course even as a healthy adult I pick up because I have children who bring home all the bugs, once for extreme toothache, and once when my shoulder was injured so I couldn't do my job. My manager has not raised any concerns about this at all.

Stopsnowing · Today 05:16

Perhaps she should consider working in after school clubs/children’s activities or babysitting as it sounds like she can’t cope with the demands of a workplace
and needs something a lot more fleixible.

Pippa12 · Today 05:45

Natsku · Today 05:07

I just checked my absences for this year, 11 separate instances (mostly 1 day, some 2 or 3 days) plus one absence to look after my child for several days. Most of those were for heavy colds or stomach bugs, which of course even as a healthy adult I pick up because I have children who bring home all the bugs, once for extreme toothache, and once when my shoulder was injured so I couldn't do my job. My manager has not raised any concerns about this at all.

11 absences!!! Almost once a month??!!

Absences are managed hard in the NHS, but employees receive sick pay and the bill is astronomical. Each absence is followed by a ‘return to work’ which gives the both employers and employee to express needs/concerns. Perhaps if your daughter had a meeting earlier she would have been able to talk about her issues and make a plan. Sickness meetings are scoffed at but they are great way of weeding out the piss takers who take sick days every month and supporting those who are generally struggling to stay in work.

3 absences is alot unfortunately. It’s disrupting service need and safety-,they need to consider if your daughter is fit for the role, sadly it doesn’t sound like she is.

Taking some time out is a good idea. Exhaustion isn’t unusual for her conditions. It does sound like a career change is necessary. Perhaps a large organisation (like the nhs) who have strong policies for disabilities and the facilities to make reasonable adjustments would suit. Although strict sickness policies will be enforced.

Try naproxen again? It can’t wipe her out, it’s an anti inflammatory with no sedative properties. Perhaps, she was just tired when she took it?

HollaHolla · Today 06:02

Natsku · Today 05:07

I just checked my absences for this year, 11 separate instances (mostly 1 day, some 2 or 3 days) plus one absence to look after my child for several days. Most of those were for heavy colds or stomach bugs, which of course even as a healthy adult I pick up because I have children who bring home all the bugs, once for extreme toothache, and once when my shoulder was injured so I couldn't do my job. My manager has not raised any concerns about this at all.

Crikey - I've had 5 this year, which I thought was a lot. It's certainly more than I've ever had previously.
I've had a couple of bad migraines, some minor surgery, and a dose of what I think was norovirus.
My boss has a chat when I return each time - which is the same as what I do when it's any of my team. I've got a lovely line manager now (which wasn't the case previously), who is keen to make sure I'm properly well again, etc. They have asked if I'd find different screens, etc., helpful for the migraines, but I think they're menopause migraines, as I also suffered terribly with them as a teenager.

Nylonflares · Today 06:10

Gently, I think you need to take a step back and let her deal with whatever is going on herself

It’s kinder to her to let her function as an adult, which she is, and navigate her way through life’s difficulties herself.

mysittingduck · Today 06:45

Your DD has done really well to get and hold down this job. Unfortunately I wonder if the repetitive movements and lifting that go with nursery work are exacerbating her arm problem. What a shame.
The nursery must have limits as to how far they can cover unplanned absences and will be getting worried after 3 instances in one year. . Hopefully they are not suggesting that she's making an unreasonable fuss. But perhaps a different childcare job would work better for DD. Nerve problems are not always easily fixed.

Natsku · Today 06:47

HollaHolla · Today 06:02

Crikey - I've had 5 this year, which I thought was a lot. It's certainly more than I've ever had previously.
I've had a couple of bad migraines, some minor surgery, and a dose of what I think was norovirus.
My boss has a chat when I return each time - which is the same as what I do when it's any of my team. I've got a lovely line manager now (which wasn't the case previously), who is keen to make sure I'm properly well again, etc. They have asked if I'd find different screens, etc., helpful for the migraines, but I think they're menopause migraines, as I also suffered terribly with them as a teenager.

Hope you find something that helps with the migraines, must be awful 😞 chats for that kind of thing makes sense, as variations at work can potentially help with migraines but there's nothing to help with heavy colds* so a chat about those would be a waste of everyone's time!

*by which I mean affecting my lungs and triggering my asthma or unable to think straight which is a very expensive risk for my work as I operate an extremely expensive piece of machinery which can permanently damage my eyes if I make a mistake when I can't think straight, or break expensive panels or the machine itself - sick pay is definitely cheaper that that!

TheLemonLemur · Today 06:59

Natsku · Today 05:07

I just checked my absences for this year, 11 separate instances (mostly 1 day, some 2 or 3 days) plus one absence to look after my child for several days. Most of those were for heavy colds or stomach bugs, which of course even as a healthy adult I pick up because I have children who bring home all the bugs, once for extreme toothache, and once when my shoulder was injured so I couldn't do my job. My manager has not raised any concerns about this at all.

11 absences almost 1 a month?? You don't have a typical employer that this hasn't been an issue. Public sector absences are scrutinised because of the generous sick pay I have had 1 sick day this year.
3 absences would trigger an absence meeting in most places op so try to stay calm it is not targeting just likely policy

TicTac80 · Today 07:21

Sounds really painful - I hope your DD gets to see someone quickly and get to the bottom of what's happening. I understand why the nursery are worrying about ratios - of course they have to. Your idea of getting some more qualifications in place isn't a bad one at all.

One thought though...she'll have an enhanced DBS, won't she? If you guys haven't done this, I think it would be worth doing now for the future - get her registered/whatever on the online DBS service. That would mean other employers could easily check her DBS status. You do pay a small annual fee. I'm a nurse so this is handy for me - I work FT in the NHS but just joined an events medical team as well (just for ad hoc work). It might mean that she could join an agency and do a bit of ad hoc work.

Dreamingofsnowymornings · Today 07:30

TrappedInaShituation · Yesterday 11:54

The first time it happened I had to call
then from a and e as she was stressed not being there and they just kept asking would she be in later for their ratios and didn’t even ask how she was

Horrible behaviour from them.

Karma2023 · Today 07:53

Please don't suggest she gets a sick note until they can sack her, if she intends on not returning. Its really unfair on everyone to deal with the uncertainity.

dippy567 · Today 08:01

Think about it from employers point if view. They do have ratios and if people always calling in sick they don't have those ratios so presumably it puts pressure on everyone else and/or they need to get agency staff in?

Has she really bern unable to work each time? I do wonder if you're enabling and need to help her skill up and build resilience do she can 'do life" - sometimes just sucking it up is what you need to do in life.

TinnedBeans · Today 08:27

I really feel you are being given a hard time here, OP.

I've worked in some wonderful nurseries where the staff are genuinely valued and appreciated. I've also worked in nurseries and childcare where the staff are seen as another x amount of children through the door and of very little more value.

Whilst I've also had jobs in hospitality and other areas, the childcare jobs are the only jobs I've ever known whereby you are expected to work all hours, for little more than minimum wage, bring or source resources for the children in your care and work overtime whilst not being paid for the overtime but also chastised for doing the overtime.

You can ring in the morning and explain you're ill but be expected to ring by 12 noon to confirm you're still ill. In one employment I had, I was expected to write observations whilst bed-bound after an emergency operation and to also ring every morning and afternoon to say I was still in hospital and couldn't attend- despite family dropping off a medical note on my behalf. In that particular case I fell asleep one day and woke up to lots of missed calls- rang back and was treated awfully.

You need incredibly thick skin to work in some of these settings and I certainly hadn't developed that by 23 years old. It's better to move on.

There are wonderful nurseries out there with genuinely caring and understanding management and it sounds to me like your daughter is absolutely wonderful with children - and should be supported.

I feel that if she finds the right childcare post and setting, she's likely to excel; but sadly, it sounds she would be better off coming out of her current employment (she doesnt need the stress and constant mithering).

Is there another role she can do with her qualifications?

I wish her all the best. I hope she finds the cause of her arm pain and is able to get it sorted. 🥰

GreaterCassowary · Today 11:24

You mention potential hypermobility, has she ever been assessed for hypermobile EDS? It's worth checking out as it would explain both the pain (nerve being trapped when the shoulder subluxates) and exhaustion/fatigue. I was in a similar position, in terms of symptoms, at her age and it would have saved me a great deal of pain and disability had I been diagnosed back then. There's a huge overlap of hEDS with ASD too. IF it is this then physiotherapy, with a physio who understands hypermobility, and learning to pace to manage her energy levels will set her up very well for the future.

This is not medical advice btw, she should obviously have any other investigations as recommended by her doctor(s).

Nospringchix · Today 12:02

HangingOver · Yesterday 14:30

Really? It's not an opiate. I take it all the time, drive and everything. I had no idea Naproxen could do this!

It made me feel very dizzy and sick when I tried it. I wonder whether neurodivergence also makes people react differently to things?

TheSnappyBluePoster · Today 12:43

ilovepuppies2019 · Today 01:38

You’re incredibly lucky to be able to think that way. It’s also very untrue. Only three absences would be a good year for most people. The flue, D and V and an accident are pretty normal in a year.

Contrary to popular belief, people don't get the flu every year. They get a heavy cold.

The flu is actually pretty rare to catch, and i've only had it once.

You've all got colds, and you should be going to work. If you're getting it every year, it's not flu.

The flu will also put you on the floor for a couple of weeks and take a long time to recover from. It won't just be a day or two off work.If that's all it is, it's a cold

I haven't had a stomach bug since I can't even remember when.

An accident every year?! Wtf! How unfortunate are you and everyone you know to have an accident every year thslat involves injury.

TunnocksOrDeath · Today 13:36

localnotail · Yesterday 19:22

3 days sick in a year is a lot??? What?... Are you a manager at some sort of a sweatshop?

I work in a bog standard office and people are generally sick 1-2 days a month on average, plus time off for appointments.

Each person is sick one or two days a MONTH?? That's insane. Is it a particularly unhealthy working environment? Are people warm enough, or working shift patterns that prevent proper sleep? Are they underpaying folk, so they can't afford to look after themselves?
I was at my last place over 20 years and I think, with the exception of the pandemic, most people averaged less than 5 days a year. It was also a very supportive environment, it wasn't like "come in or you'll be fired", people just didn't really get ill that much.

localnotail · Today 13:41

TunnocksOrDeath · Today 13:36

Each person is sick one or two days a MONTH?? That's insane. Is it a particularly unhealthy working environment? Are people warm enough, or working shift patterns that prevent proper sleep? Are they underpaying folk, so they can't afford to look after themselves?
I was at my last place over 20 years and I think, with the exception of the pandemic, most people averaged less than 5 days a year. It was also a very supportive environment, it wasn't like "come in or you'll be fired", people just didn't really get ill that much.

This includes things like dentist, appointments, etc. Why is it so weird?

ItalianoSl · Today 13:46

localnotail · Today 13:41

This includes things like dentist, appointments, etc. Why is it so weird?

I have been working for over 30 years. I have never worked anywhere where people have taken 1 or 2 days off sick a month on top of appointment.
Are they actually unwell that often, or just taking sick days?

TunnocksOrDeath · Today 13:57

localnotail · Today 13:41

This includes things like dentist, appointments, etc. Why is it so weird?

It's really unusual. The ONS says the average for a UK worker is 4.4 per annum. At you workplace they are averaging up to 24 per annum.
If I was a manager at your workplace I'd be trying to understand why my workforce is unhealthy to such a statistically anomalous degree - it could be indicative of an environmental or procedural issue that could get them sued if anyone ever finds out what it is and decides they deserve compensation.

ilovepuppies2019 · Today 14:08

TheSnappyBluePoster · Today 12:43

Contrary to popular belief, people don't get the flu every year. They get a heavy cold.

The flu is actually pretty rare to catch, and i've only had it once.

You've all got colds, and you should be going to work. If you're getting it every year, it's not flu.

The flu will also put you on the floor for a couple of weeks and take a long time to recover from. It won't just be a day or two off work.If that's all it is, it's a cold

I haven't had a stomach bug since I can't even remember when.

An accident every year?! Wtf! How unfortunate are you and everyone you know to have an accident every year thslat involves injury.

Edited

I actually test and confirm positive for the flu in many years. Perhaps I’m particularly unlucky. I’d you’ve never tested then you might want to as the flu can sometimes feel like a heavy cold and isn’t guaranteed to floor you although it often does. Don’t forget that Rsv, Covid and any every other air rod bug is flying around. Accidents is a broad term but this year I had an emergency root canal, a procedure to check for acid reflux and hemmaroids that could only be done on a work day and I fell down a ravine (oops). Life happens and 3 separate periods of leave off work is completely normal. We see sick leave so differently in Aus.

Orangwipe · Today 14:33

Just tell them GTA 6 is out at midnight.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page