Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think that this man's family member/carer shouldn't have been allowing him to hug children at the park?

110 replies

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 17:44

Name changed for this, but I am a regular user, not a disability hate troll.

At the park with my 2 year old dd yesterday and there was a young man, who was very clearly mentally disabled, playing on the equipment. He was with his family, rather than a paid carer. I'm assuming this as the people he was with looked like they were having a birthday gathering at one of picnic tables.

Anyway, he came over and chatted with me, while I was helping my dd on the slide. Told me his name and that he was 20, and then gave me a hug. I was uncomfortable with this because I don't like hugging strangers but I let it happen because I didn't want to upset him.

He then tried to hug my dd, who ran away. I said something like "sorry, she doesn't want to hug right now. She's busy playing". He climbed up on the little climbing frame she was on and tried to hug her again. I quickly lifted her down because she was looking frightened at him coming towards her again.

He walked away after this, but tried to hug a couple more of the kids on the playground. They also looked uncomfortable with it.

Aibu to think that his family/carer should have been watching him a bit better?

OP posts:
KissMyArt · 15/11/2026 17:47

YANBU

But I would've had a polite friendly word with his family as you said he continued to do it to other children.

Chunkybabythighs · 15/11/2026 17:47

You shouldn't have let him hug you either? You can say no for yourself and your child

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 17:50

Chunkybabythighs · 15/11/2026 17:47

You shouldn't have let him hug you either? You can say no for yourself and your child

No, I shouldn't of. But there was no warning before he tried to hug me so I couldn't have stopped him without pushing him away which I didn't want to do.

OP posts:
Besidemyselfwithworry · 15/11/2026 17:53

I’d have said something myself! They should have been watching him.

JustAMiddleAgedDirtBagBaby · 15/11/2026 17:55

They absolutely should have been stopping him - for his sake as much as for the children who were there.

WearyAuldWumman · 15/11/2026 17:59

YANBU.

At hospital some time ago, I got chatting to a family group in the waiting room. The little girl was seeing about a tonsilectomy, so I told her about my experiences having one when I was her age.

On the way out, I bumped into the family and asked the parents' permission to give the little girl money for a treat for being so brave. (She'd been a bit worried about going to hospital.) The parents said that was fine and both the wee girl and her parents thanked me.

Later, I was waiting for my bus home when the mum and little girl came up to me. The mum asked if it was okay for the wee one to give me a hug. I was impressed that the mum was teaching the little girl about consent.

The carers of the man in the OP should be doing the same.

Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 15/11/2026 18:10

I am very familiar with this sort of thing, I have a close friend with a child whose mental age in some scenarios is about 7 or 8, when chronologically, they are 25. Like the young man mentioned here, he is very friendly and doesn't understand boundaries with adults and children. I think you need to be clear with him and state straight away that you don't like hugs and your child doesn't either.

I do think if 'adult children' need to use the park, their carers should be changing their activities, such as going to the shops etc when actual children arrive at the park. It is definitely an issue for his carers to deal with and it is rotten that his family are left to deal with it all. Proper carers should be facilitating outings and supporting him, rather than putting so much stress on his family who are possibly too connected with him to be able to challenge him or disappoint him.

You shouldn't have to put up with that, but I am really pleased that you aren't blaming the young man. They definitely need carers for outings though, it's too much for a family to cope with.

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 18:27

Thank you for the replies. Yes, I definitely don't blame him and I do understand how hard it must be for his family.

Just an awkward situation to deal with all round.

OP posts:
Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 15/11/2026 18:39

It might be worth ringing Adult Social Care about it. Perhaps they could set up certain times when 'adult children' can use the facilities without the risk to young children. It's not good for them (or you) to be hugged unexpectedly by a stranger, especially one who can't understand social norms.
Well done though, you were very kind.

likelysuspect · 15/11/2026 18:42

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 17:44

Name changed for this, but I am a regular user, not a disability hate troll.

At the park with my 2 year old dd yesterday and there was a young man, who was very clearly mentally disabled, playing on the equipment. He was with his family, rather than a paid carer. I'm assuming this as the people he was with looked like they were having a birthday gathering at one of picnic tables.

Anyway, he came over and chatted with me, while I was helping my dd on the slide. Told me his name and that he was 20, and then gave me a hug. I was uncomfortable with this because I don't like hugging strangers but I let it happen because I didn't want to upset him.

He then tried to hug my dd, who ran away. I said something like "sorry, she doesn't want to hug right now. She's busy playing". He climbed up on the little climbing frame she was on and tried to hug her again. I quickly lifted her down because she was looking frightened at him coming towards her again.

He walked away after this, but tried to hug a couple more of the kids on the playground. They also looked uncomfortable with it.

Aibu to think that his family/carer should have been watching him a bit better?

Well, watching him? And then what, physically move him away? Tell him off? Tell him not to?

I think its really hard, I think its more likey that if it was a family member they're more likely to be quite blunt about it, social and physical boundaries are often quite a bit focus for people with LD who could be inappropriate without meaning to or understanding.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 15/11/2026 18:45

20 year old young man would be quite physically strong too and possibly unaware of his own strength compared to yours and a childs .

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 18:48

Firstly, I'm sorry that you were made to feel uncomfortable. I'm sure his family didn't intend that. They should have been keeping a closer eye on him.

Those saying that the young person should have carers for outings, that's a lovely idea, but have you heard of the issues in adult social care? A family may receive 1 or 2 days in a day centre each week (typically 6 hours per day) and their family must provide care for every other hour of the week.

Segregated time for 'adult children' or removing them when others are in a playground. I'm speechless.

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 18:49

likelysuspect · 15/11/2026 18:42

Well, watching him? And then what, physically move him away? Tell him off? Tell him not to?

I think its really hard, I think its more likey that if it was a family member they're more likely to be quite blunt about it, social and physical boundaries are often quite a bit focus for people with LD who could be inappropriate without meaning to or understanding.

Maybe distract him, remind him not to hug strangers, or to ask first. I'm not sure. It is really hard.

OP posts:
BillieWiper · 15/11/2026 18:53

I'd have said 'you shouldn't be hugging little kids'. And if he was still trying to I'd maybe speak to his family. I guess it depends a lot on a few different factors though. It might have felt like it was being dealt with by the other kids parents.

likelysuspect · 15/11/2026 18:54

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 18:49

Maybe distract him, remind him not to hug strangers, or to ask first. I'm not sure. It is really hard.

I would hope that is a message he does have, however I forgot to mention that there are a large number of people with extra needs or LD whose family also have low intelligence (not LD specifically) but are lower functioning, or have other conditions perhaps ND or MH, and so although they might technically be the identified carer for their relative, they're not really socially or emotionally astute enough to do the work with him or identify risks in the community from or to him. We see this a lot at work. We're working with someone extremely vulnerable and that person is a carer for their relative and the relative is a carer for them and both are just muddling through, theres no way they'd be able to teach new strategies or manage the other person better in the community.

likelysuspect · 15/11/2026 18:56

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 18:48

Firstly, I'm sorry that you were made to feel uncomfortable. I'm sure his family didn't intend that. They should have been keeping a closer eye on him.

Those saying that the young person should have carers for outings, that's a lovely idea, but have you heard of the issues in adult social care? A family may receive 1 or 2 days in a day centre each week (typically 6 hours per day) and their family must provide care for every other hour of the week.

Segregated time for 'adult children' or removing them when others are in a playground. I'm speechless.

Edited

Why are you speechless?

Many children's playgrounds specify they're for children only anyway, so it wouldnt be expected for adults who are cognitively impaired to use it. It would be a positive to have a mixed use for that reason so that adults with LD could come along and use it without it needing to be a problem if they do struggle to behave in socially appropriate ways around children.

WhatNoRaisins · 15/11/2026 18:57

It sounds like he didn't mean any harm but I agree that he needs closer supervision. He might try to hug a child whose family will react badly to it.

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 19:06

likelysuspect · 15/11/2026 18:54

I would hope that is a message he does have, however I forgot to mention that there are a large number of people with extra needs or LD whose family also have low intelligence (not LD specifically) but are lower functioning, or have other conditions perhaps ND or MH, and so although they might technically be the identified carer for their relative, they're not really socially or emotionally astute enough to do the work with him or identify risks in the community from or to him. We see this a lot at work. We're working with someone extremely vulnerable and that person is a carer for their relative and the relative is a carer for them and both are just muddling through, theres no way they'd be able to teach new strategies or manage the other person better in the community.

Thanks, that is something I hadn't considered.

OP posts:
HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 19:22

I'm speechless because it is illegal to discriminate on the grounds of disability.

Which time of day do you propose someone with a learning disability should be allowed to use the public space? What if little Daphne or Rowen wanted to use the playground at the same time? Do you tell them they can't, because there's a scary person with learning disabilities in there?

likelysuspect · 15/11/2026 19:28

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 19:22

I'm speechless because it is illegal to discriminate on the grounds of disability.

Which time of day do you propose someone with a learning disability should be allowed to use the public space? What if little Daphne or Rowen wanted to use the playground at the same time? Do you tell them they can't, because there's a scary person with learning disabilities in there?

What discrimination?

Age discimination?

The play grounds are for children

Adults being allowed to use them would be for a specific reason like this.

Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 15/11/2026 19:30

I'm not trying to suggest segregation, more that it would be good to make sure that everyone is safe.

I won't spell it out, but I am very close to a young person with very similar issues to the one in the OP. I am fully aware of the issues in social care and if they can go round to check on the person for a fully funded hour, three times a day, they could support them in community activities at appropriate times.

People react emotively to these things because they are in their lives!

I'm going to name change, incase someone close to the person involved sees this and recognises me. Unfortunately, where I intended to widen participation, some have chosen to see it as segregation.

I am speechless that people would split hairs about the attempts of others to improve things.

Nonetheless, well done OP.

WearyAuldWumman · 15/11/2026 19:40

likelysuspect · 15/11/2026 19:28

What discrimination?

Age discimination?

The play grounds are for children

Adults being allowed to use them would be for a specific reason like this.

Yup. When I was a child, the local playgrounds had signs stipulating that they were only for the use of those below the age of 14.

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 19:46

I think you're missing my point. We have spent generations trying to avoid adults with profound learning difficulties being segregated and treated as though they should be hidden away.

This thread makes it sound as though there are young adults with learning disabilities waiting to pounce on unsuspecting members of the public in every local playground. That is simply not true. The adults with this young person should have been supervising him more closely, that's obvious.

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 19:48

WearyAuldWumman · 15/11/2026 19:40

Yup. When I was a child, the local playgrounds had signs stipulating that they were only for the use of those below the age of 14.

This park has similar signs. The climbing frame my DD was on has a sign saying it was intended for 2-5 year olds. Then there's a larger climbing frame that says 5-12 years.

I don't personally mind adults with learning disabilities using them. Parents are up them all the time helping their kids too. But I do think the safety of the kids has to be put first in playgrounds and that can't really be called discrimination.

OP posts:
Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 15/11/2026 19:54

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 19:46

I think you're missing my point. We have spent generations trying to avoid adults with profound learning difficulties being segregated and treated as though they should be hidden away.

This thread makes it sound as though there are young adults with learning disabilities waiting to pounce on unsuspecting members of the public in every local playground. That is simply not true. The adults with this young person should have been supervising him more closely, that's obvious.

In the scenario above, we could include the 'adult children', which I referred to above, one of whom, as I said I am very close. They could be included by allowing them to use the equipment in a way which protects the actual children from any potential harm, while safeguarding the chronological adults from accusations or conflict.
We can include people without them sharing space. I have been in the position of both having an adult child in this kind of environment and also seen them struggle to understand turn taking and social etiquette, such as not hugging everyone when you're happy.
Lack of segregation can lead to lack of safeguarding. If the young person's parents or family couldn't stop him from doing inappropriate things, then there needs to be some social mechanisms in place to help, whether that's carers or specific times of use for play areas.