Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think that this man's family member/carer shouldn't have been allowing him to hug children at the park?

110 replies

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 17:44

Name changed for this, but I am a regular user, not a disability hate troll.

At the park with my 2 year old dd yesterday and there was a young man, who was very clearly mentally disabled, playing on the equipment. He was with his family, rather than a paid carer. I'm assuming this as the people he was with looked like they were having a birthday gathering at one of picnic tables.

Anyway, he came over and chatted with me, while I was helping my dd on the slide. Told me his name and that he was 20, and then gave me a hug. I was uncomfortable with this because I don't like hugging strangers but I let it happen because I didn't want to upset him.

He then tried to hug my dd, who ran away. I said something like "sorry, she doesn't want to hug right now. She's busy playing". He climbed up on the little climbing frame she was on and tried to hug her again. I quickly lifted her down because she was looking frightened at him coming towards her again.

He walked away after this, but tried to hug a couple more of the kids on the playground. They also looked uncomfortable with it.

Aibu to think that his family/carer should have been watching him a bit better?

OP posts:
WearyAuldWumman · 15/11/2026 19:56

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 19:46

I think you're missing my point. We have spent generations trying to avoid adults with profound learning difficulties being segregated and treated as though they should be hidden away.

This thread makes it sound as though there are young adults with learning disabilities waiting to pounce on unsuspecting members of the public in every local playground. That is simply not true. The adults with this young person should have been supervising him more closely, that's obvious.

I agree that the only issue here is that the young man was lacking proper supervision. However, I think that someone upthread suggested that proper supervision wouldn't necessarily be possible?

IMO, it should be.

I recall that there were issues when I was a child with a teenage girl with autism who used to chase after us younger children (presumably just wanting to play). The problem was that she looked like a full-grown adult to us and was much, much bigger than us, so we were frightened of her. She also seemed to be non-verbal, though she could make noises.

I was only about 7 the time she ran after me and slapped me full across the face when I tried to run off. She came back later and when she went for me again, a 12 yr old girl who was with me jumped up and slapped her in the face, causing her to run off crying.

I feel so sorry for the girl when I look back. I'm assuming that her parents had hoped to get a break and were thus allowing her out to play. We never saw her again after that, however.

I've cared for older adults, but I can't imagine what it's like to care for children with an intellectual disability. Nevertheless, for their safety and the safety of others, it's really not possible to allow someone so profoundly affected to be out and about on their own.

Twoshoesnewshoes · 15/11/2026 19:58

Play parks are for children.
i feel for the family and carers and understand that the adult may not understand these boundaries but that doesn’t mean we all just ignore them.

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 20:06

They were with their family, who are the ones to be blamed here, rather than a whole community.

Most families are very aware of age, height and weight limits, which is why the rare playgrounds with inclusive equipment are a godsend.

It is ceaseless, isolating & exhausting to care for a YP who may have been awake since the crack of dawn and wants to play until late into the evening. There is negligible external support if the YP has parents, maybe one or two days at a day centre, which might be cancelled due to ratios, sickness etc. Walks, trips to a park, visits to a beach etc offer both the YP and their family a change of scene and perhaps the chance to engage with other people outside of the home. Just a brief spark of normality.

Pearlstillsinging · 15/11/2026 20:06

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 17:50

No, I shouldn't of. But there was no warning before he tried to hug me so I couldn't have stopped him without pushing him away which I didn't want to do.

Most people with LD are taught to shake hands rather than hugging non-family members. I think the family should have been more vigilant and he was being naughty. In that position if you thrust out your hand to shake, that usually reminds anyone who is trying to hug you, of their manners.

vjg13 · 15/11/2026 20:10

Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 15/11/2026 18:39

It might be worth ringing Adult Social Care about it. Perhaps they could set up certain times when 'adult children' can use the facilities without the risk to young children. It's not good for them (or you) to be hugged unexpectedly by a stranger, especially one who can't understand social norms.
Well done though, you were very kind.

Yes, I’m absolutely sure adult social care will welcome this call and act on it! 🤯 And please stop saying “adult children” when describing someone with learning difficulties.

Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 15/11/2026 20:15

I wasn't going to post on here again, but I have a very close relative with a large, 23 year old body who, in terms of social and intellectual functioning, is developmentally a child. It is very difficult to find another term, other than 'adult children's which allows others to understand their developmental issues.

Blaming the family won't help either. Social care do offer support in these situations, thankfully, but I am wasting my time trying to make this point.

likelysuspect · 15/11/2026 20:30

vjg13 · 15/11/2026 20:10

Yes, I’m absolutely sure adult social care will welcome this call and act on it! 🤯 And please stop saying “adult children” when describing someone with learning difficulties.

What?

likelysuspect · 15/11/2026 20:32

Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 15/11/2026 20:15

I wasn't going to post on here again, but I have a very close relative with a large, 23 year old body who, in terms of social and intellectual functioning, is developmentally a child. It is very difficult to find another term, other than 'adult children's which allows others to understand their developmental issues.

Blaming the family won't help either. Social care do offer support in these situations, thankfully, but I am wasting my time trying to make this point.

Edited

Well, there is that, which as you say is factually correct

But presumably he is also someones child, who is also an adult?

This is what we call our adult children. Adult children.

What else are they called?

Offspring? Descendants? Progeny?

Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 15/11/2026 20:36

I was trying to make the point that however old the child becomes, he will remain intellectually and socially a child. I don't have a problem with the term 'adult children', and the quotation marks are to indicate that there is a different issue to simply being progeny or offspring.

likelysuspect · 15/11/2026 20:38

Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 15/11/2026 20:36

I was trying to make the point that however old the child becomes, he will remain intellectually and socially a child. I don't have a problem with the term 'adult children', and the quotation marks are to indicate that there is a different issue to simply being progeny or offspring.

I know, I agree with you. Im more aghast at the poster who seems to think adult children shouldnt be called adult children.

Jollyjapesuntiltheystopped · 15/11/2026 20:43

I am going to make this my absolute last post on this thread, as it is veering away from the initial issue.

The parks and playgrounds are brilliant resources in our communities. If we can get to the moon and speak to others thousands of miles away, as though they were sat next to us, we can find ways for different members of society to use our facilities safely.

I really do appreciate how kindly some people treat those with extra or different needs, as I am sure others with family members with these issues do too.

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 15/11/2026 20:44

I have a 12 year old son who has autism and likes to hug people. He has to be supervised everywhere he goes because he doesn't understand he can't hug people he doesn't know and also some people he does know don't want to be hugged either.

He is now in the middle of puberty and many people now see him as an adult. He isn't considered to have learning disabilities because he is academically able, especially in maths. But emotionally he is like a 3 year old. He has a 1-1 helper in mainstream school but there is no respite outside of school, it's just me and his dad. He struggles with sleep so I haven't slept properly since he was born. I will follow him around when out in public but I understand some parents can't because they are struggling with their own problems or are just exhausted.

I am finding it increasingly difficult to find places where we are welcome. Some people are absolutely lovely to him but some think he shouldn't be at the park or other activities which are aimed at younger children. Places that allow older children and adults to participate in climbing, swinging etc tend to be trampoline parks and theme parks that cost a ridiculous amount of money. He's not interested in most things for his age group although he quite likes bowling. He can't go to youth groups or scouts etc unless I stay with him which I can't do as I have other children as well. Recently we used inheritance money to buy a climbing frame and swing that cost £1.5k. Something similar for a younger child would have been around £250. And a younger child would also be able to use the park. If I want to take him to a place where he can play outside I have to drive for over an hour.

I do understand that my son makes strangers feel uncomfortable but they only have to experience it for a short time. I am looking after him all the time unless he is with his dad or at school. When he leaves education, that's it. No carers, no respite. Just me and his Dad. Until we die. Then goodness only knows. Hopefully the world will be more understanding by then.

DontBuyAnotherBook · 15/11/2026 20:57

They should be stopping him. Reminds me of Lenny out of "Of mice and men".

user1471538275 · 15/11/2026 21:26

An adult is an adult whether they have Learning disabilties or not.

They should not be at a children's playground. They are not a child and as demonstrated they may not be socially appropriate or safe around children.

Children's safety is paramount and it comes before adults comfort.

If their family was caring for him, then part of this care is not taking him to inappropriate places and preventing him from causing harm or distress to others.

They did not do this - they neglected his need to be in an appropriate place and to be supervised.

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 15/11/2026 21:33

user1471538275 · 15/11/2026 21:26

An adult is an adult whether they have Learning disabilties or not.

They should not be at a children's playground. They are not a child and as demonstrated they may not be socially appropriate or safe around children.

Children's safety is paramount and it comes before adults comfort.

If their family was caring for him, then part of this care is not taking him to inappropriate places and preventing him from causing harm or distress to others.

They did not do this - they neglected his need to be in an appropriate place and to be supervised.

Edited

But what is an appropriate place for these people to play in?

TheWonderhorse · 15/11/2026 22:05

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 15/11/2026 20:44

I have a 12 year old son who has autism and likes to hug people. He has to be supervised everywhere he goes because he doesn't understand he can't hug people he doesn't know and also some people he does know don't want to be hugged either.

He is now in the middle of puberty and many people now see him as an adult. He isn't considered to have learning disabilities because he is academically able, especially in maths. But emotionally he is like a 3 year old. He has a 1-1 helper in mainstream school but there is no respite outside of school, it's just me and his dad. He struggles with sleep so I haven't slept properly since he was born. I will follow him around when out in public but I understand some parents can't because they are struggling with their own problems or are just exhausted.

I am finding it increasingly difficult to find places where we are welcome. Some people are absolutely lovely to him but some think he shouldn't be at the park or other activities which are aimed at younger children. Places that allow older children and adults to participate in climbing, swinging etc tend to be trampoline parks and theme parks that cost a ridiculous amount of money. He's not interested in most things for his age group although he quite likes bowling. He can't go to youth groups or scouts etc unless I stay with him which I can't do as I have other children as well. Recently we used inheritance money to buy a climbing frame and swing that cost £1.5k. Something similar for a younger child would have been around £250. And a younger child would also be able to use the park. If I want to take him to a place where he can play outside I have to drive for over an hour.

I do understand that my son makes strangers feel uncomfortable but they only have to experience it for a short time. I am looking after him all the time unless he is with his dad or at school. When he leaves education, that's it. No carers, no respite. Just me and his Dad. Until we die. Then goodness only knows. Hopefully the world will be more understanding by then.

Oh I'm so sorry.

I would absolutely have hugged OP. I would have tried to include and teach my children that while they didn't need to hug if they didn't want to, they did need to be patient and kind.

There is no universe where I'm banning young adults from play areas, disabled or not. I think I've been on every swing and slide within a 3 mile radius of my house and I encourage others to do the same.

The people in my community with disabilities deserve to be there, and that's true even if they want to give my kid a hug. I'm willing to handle that as best I can and allow my children the value of meeting people who behave, appear and perhaps think a little differently to them. We can do that, can't we? It's not a big deal if we're giving a positive situation the care it deserves for five minutes while an exhausted family queue at the coffee shop.

plasticplate · 15/11/2026 22:24

user1471538275 · 15/11/2026 21:26

An adult is an adult whether they have Learning disabilties or not.

They should not be at a children's playground. They are not a child and as demonstrated they may not be socially appropriate or safe around children.

Children's safety is paramount and it comes before adults comfort.

If their family was caring for him, then part of this care is not taking him to inappropriate places and preventing him from causing harm or distress to others.

They did not do this - they neglected his need to be in an appropriate place and to be supervised.

Edited

My adult son uses playgrounds. He wouldn't want to use a piece of equipment with a child on it and has no interest in interacting with them. He doesn't need locking out of playgrounds.

There are plenty of adults without a learning disability who are not safe around children including many with children.

Valeriekat · 16/11/2026 10:57

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 18:48

Firstly, I'm sorry that you were made to feel uncomfortable. I'm sure his family didn't intend that. They should have been keeping a closer eye on him.

Those saying that the young person should have carers for outings, that's a lovely idea, but have you heard of the issues in adult social care? A family may receive 1 or 2 days in a day centre each week (typically 6 hours per day) and their family must provide care for every other hour of the week.

Segregated time for 'adult children' or removing them when others are in a playground. I'm speechless.

Edited

A mentally ill man threw a child off the roof restaurant at the Tate. I would choose my own child's safety over other people's feelings.

takealettermsjones · 16/11/2026 11:42

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 15/11/2026 20:44

I have a 12 year old son who has autism and likes to hug people. He has to be supervised everywhere he goes because he doesn't understand he can't hug people he doesn't know and also some people he does know don't want to be hugged either.

He is now in the middle of puberty and many people now see him as an adult. He isn't considered to have learning disabilities because he is academically able, especially in maths. But emotionally he is like a 3 year old. He has a 1-1 helper in mainstream school but there is no respite outside of school, it's just me and his dad. He struggles with sleep so I haven't slept properly since he was born. I will follow him around when out in public but I understand some parents can't because they are struggling with their own problems or are just exhausted.

I am finding it increasingly difficult to find places where we are welcome. Some people are absolutely lovely to him but some think he shouldn't be at the park or other activities which are aimed at younger children. Places that allow older children and adults to participate in climbing, swinging etc tend to be trampoline parks and theme parks that cost a ridiculous amount of money. He's not interested in most things for his age group although he quite likes bowling. He can't go to youth groups or scouts etc unless I stay with him which I can't do as I have other children as well. Recently we used inheritance money to buy a climbing frame and swing that cost £1.5k. Something similar for a younger child would have been around £250. And a younger child would also be able to use the park. If I want to take him to a place where he can play outside I have to drive for over an hour.

I do understand that my son makes strangers feel uncomfortable but they only have to experience it for a short time. I am looking after him all the time unless he is with his dad or at school. When he leaves education, that's it. No carers, no respite. Just me and his Dad. Until we die. Then goodness only knows. Hopefully the world will be more understanding by then.

I do understand that my son makes strangers feel uncomfortable but they only have to experience it for a short time.

If you're talking about this in a generic sense then I understand, and it sounds so difficult. But if you meant this in response to OP's situation - i.e. that the little child should put up with being hugged because it's only for a short time - that will never be okay.

plasticplate · 16/11/2026 12:43

Valeriekat · 16/11/2026 10:57

A mentally ill man threw a child off the roof restaurant at the Tate. I would choose my own child's safety over other people's feelings.

Plenty of 'ordinary' men are unsafe around children. Perhaps we should ban all men from places where children go

Twoshoesnewshoes · 16/11/2026 12:44

I don’t want to experience physical contact with an unknown male even for a short time.
do I also have to make concessions to my personal space if someone is sad, lonely, drunk etc?
we all have the same bill of rights, kindness and respect go both ways. And that’s a really important lesson for children to learn and see.

likelysuspect · 16/11/2026 13:16

plasticplate · 16/11/2026 12:43

Plenty of 'ordinary' men are unsafe around children. Perhaps we should ban all men from places where children go

Well children's play grounds are usually limited to use by children so that is already in effect.

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 16/11/2026 16:28

takealettermsjones · 16/11/2026 11:42

I do understand that my son makes strangers feel uncomfortable but they only have to experience it for a short time.

If you're talking about this in a generic sense then I understand, and it sounds so difficult. But if you meant this in response to OP's situation - i.e. that the little child should put up with being hugged because it's only for a short time - that will never be okay.

I didn't mean hugging, I don't let him do that with strangers. I mean things like being pleasant to him when he shouts hello and waves enthusiastically at them. Not complaining when he is playing in the park etc.

Happyindevon · 16/11/2026 16:49

YANBU. Similar happened to my sister, his ‘carer’ watched on as he actually kissed her and made her really uncomfortable. It’s sexual assault regardless of the motive; she was a bit shaken up.

MyOtherCarIsASatsuma · 16/11/2026 16:54

I think you are right that he should have been better supervised but none of us are perfect all the time. Maybe they were having an "everyone fed, no one dead" level day. I certainly had those when mine were toddlers. I can imagine I would be struggling to bring my A game every single hour of every single day after another 18 years of it.

Basically yes, it shouldn't have happened, but you haven't walked in their shoes so I wouldn't waste my time sitting in judgement on them from a position of knowing very little of their lives.

Swipe left for the next trending thread