Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think that this man's family member/carer shouldn't have been allowing him to hug children at the park?

110 replies

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 17:44

Name changed for this, but I am a regular user, not a disability hate troll.

At the park with my 2 year old dd yesterday and there was a young man, who was very clearly mentally disabled, playing on the equipment. He was with his family, rather than a paid carer. I'm assuming this as the people he was with looked like they were having a birthday gathering at one of picnic tables.

Anyway, he came over and chatted with me, while I was helping my dd on the slide. Told me his name and that he was 20, and then gave me a hug. I was uncomfortable with this because I don't like hugging strangers but I let it happen because I didn't want to upset him.

He then tried to hug my dd, who ran away. I said something like "sorry, she doesn't want to hug right now. She's busy playing". He climbed up on the little climbing frame she was on and tried to hug her again. I quickly lifted her down because she was looking frightened at him coming towards her again.

He walked away after this, but tried to hug a couple more of the kids on the playground. They also looked uncomfortable with it.

Aibu to think that his family/carer should have been watching him a bit better?

OP posts:
Doubtingdebs · 16/11/2026 17:11

Jesus. OP you did well on the situation.
The poster referencing the mentally ill man throwing a child from the Tate Modern versus a man with intellectual disabilities asking if trying to hug people.. ouch!
I have a child - a 9 year old girl - who is nonverbal and needs to use a wheelchair. She is severely intellectually disabled.. apparently.
What she does now is expect she will be doing for life.
sure a man is more frightening than a woman .. usually.
But not always.
And certainly not to all the perfect children who stare at my child or the parents who pull their children closer in case it’s catching I suppose, or that one little angel who said “look mummy it’s the scary girl”, and lovely mummy mouthed sorry to me instead of telling her child that sometimes people are born differently and vocalise differently.
Maybe one day she’ll be scaring people on a larger scale. it won’t be because I didn’t care for her properly that’s for fucking sure!

OP - it’s extraordinarily difficult to constantly- every fucking second of the day - manage the child’s needs when they are profoundly disabled. That was the point if your thread I assume as you phrased it. Yes maybe they should have tried harder to stop him from in any way touching you or your child. Probably they know he’s “harmless” and won’t be throwing them off buildings or sexually assaulting them but YOU don’t know that. I think it’s perfectly understandable that you were concerned and .. I’ve been around an intellectualy disabled 12 year old who held my child who was 5 at the time and kissed her. His mum explained he’d seen some films with kissing and had decided on a course of reenactment. I was just about tolerant.

But I’ll tell you something.. I’d rather be unnerved by an intellectually disabled person trying to hug me in complete innocence than abused or harmed by a fully “normal” man. And I’ll bet some dads sitting in that park do exactly that to their partners or even strangers. In an ideal world we’d all have perfect consent and no fear but .. it’s far from perfect and for what it’s worth.. sometimes you CANNOT teach someone who is disabled intellectually what you could teach some other disabled person. Not all one bucket of .. this worked for x, so itll work for y.

plasticplate · 16/11/2026 18:22

likelysuspect · 16/11/2026 13:16

Well children's play grounds are usually limited to use by children so that is already in effect.

So you agree with no dads taking their kids to the playground.

likelysuspect · 16/11/2026 18:23

plasticplate · 16/11/2026 18:22

So you agree with no dads taking their kids to the playground.

I think its fairly obvious and doesnt need to be pointed out as its so obvious that parents accompanying their children to said playground have to be there for that, its a given. There isnt a way to avoid that. We're talking about unaccompanied adults (unaccompanied by children)

plasticplate · 16/11/2026 21:57

likelysuspect · 16/11/2026 18:23

I think its fairly obvious and doesnt need to be pointed out as its so obvious that parents accompanying their children to said playground have to be there for that, its a given. There isnt a way to avoid that. We're talking about unaccompanied adults (unaccompanied by children)

The dads are more likely to be unsafe with children than an adult with a severe learning disability.

likelysuspect · 16/11/2026 22:07

plasticplate · 16/11/2026 21:57

The dads are more likely to be unsafe with children than an adult with a severe learning disability.

Im not sure what the stats are on that, all men pose a much higher risk to children than women but given its a childresn playground there will be dads there, theres no way round that, they will be there for their kids

An unaccompanied single adult, male or female, doestn need to be there, so there is a way round that.

hestilllovesthattrombelese · 16/11/2026 22:12

You've been running around after your little one for what, 6 or 7 months now? That man's family have been minding him for 18 years longer than you have been minding your DD. You have absolutely no idea how exhausted they would be. And no idea the level of care he needs at home. Can you even imagine handling a grown man who might be still prone to tantrums or 5am waking or leaping with excitement at watching Ms Rachel or needing help in the shower and the toilet. I know it's not your problem but have some empathy. I think you are being massively unreasonable. You hugged him. You modelled to your DD that it's ok, and now you are here saying someone else shouldn't allow it happen and should have intervened. Even if they were watching they wouldn't have intervened when they say you consenting to the hug. Just thank your lucky stars that that's the biggest problem you have today

Yellowwellyboots · 16/11/2026 22:32

hestilllovesthattrombelese · 16/11/2026 22:12

You've been running around after your little one for what, 6 or 7 months now? That man's family have been minding him for 18 years longer than you have been minding your DD. You have absolutely no idea how exhausted they would be. And no idea the level of care he needs at home. Can you even imagine handling a grown man who might be still prone to tantrums or 5am waking or leaping with excitement at watching Ms Rachel or needing help in the shower and the toilet. I know it's not your problem but have some empathy. I think you are being massively unreasonable. You hugged him. You modelled to your DD that it's ok, and now you are here saying someone else shouldn't allow it happen and should have intervened. Even if they were watching they wouldn't have intervened when they say you consenting to the hug. Just thank your lucky stars that that's the biggest problem you have today

I did not hug him. He hugged me and I didn't push him off like I wanted too. If I'd had more warning I would have stepped away or said no thanks.

My DD did not want a hug and he followed her up onto a climbing frame and tried again. I think that's a problem.

OP posts:
WitchesBritches · 16/11/2026 22:40

user1471538275 · 15/11/2026 21:26

An adult is an adult whether they have Learning disabilties or not.

They should not be at a children's playground. They are not a child and as demonstrated they may not be socially appropriate or safe around children.

Children's safety is paramount and it comes before adults comfort.

If their family was caring for him, then part of this care is not taking him to inappropriate places and preventing him from causing harm or distress to others.

They did not do this - they neglected his need to be in an appropriate place and to be supervised.

Edited

What a horrible attitude.

You clearly have absolutely no experience with young people with learning disorders.

I hope for the sake you'll never in a position to be caring for someone with these extra needs.

Blueeyedmale · 16/11/2026 22:40

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 19:22

I'm speechless because it is illegal to discriminate on the grounds of disability.

Which time of day do you propose someone with a learning disability should be allowed to use the public space? What if little Daphne or Rowen wanted to use the playground at the same time? Do you tell them they can't, because there's a scary person with learning disabilities in there?

It's not disability discrimination to be worried about the safety of women and children,and the op is not blaming his disability or discriminating,she said she felt uncomfortable and it made her DD feel uncomfortable.

There are plenty of activities for the career to take this disabled adult I don't think a children's play area is the right place for this.

Just beacuse someone has a disability it shouldn't come before the safety of women and children.

WearyAuldWumman · 16/11/2026 23:04

hestilllovesthattrombelese · 16/11/2026 22:12

You've been running around after your little one for what, 6 or 7 months now? That man's family have been minding him for 18 years longer than you have been minding your DD. You have absolutely no idea how exhausted they would be. And no idea the level of care he needs at home. Can you even imagine handling a grown man who might be still prone to tantrums or 5am waking or leaping with excitement at watching Ms Rachel or needing help in the shower and the toilet. I know it's not your problem but have some empathy. I think you are being massively unreasonable. You hugged him. You modelled to your DD that it's ok, and now you are here saying someone else shouldn't allow it happen and should have intervened. Even if they were watching they wouldn't have intervened when they say you consenting to the hug. Just thank your lucky stars that that's the biggest problem you have today

I somehow didn't press the "Post" button when I first wrote this out.

It's hardly fair to blame the OP for consenting to the hug. Consent from one person doesn't mean that the young man had consent to hug the daughter or the other children.

There's no doubt that parents of intellectually disabled adults have an exceptionally difficult life; I don't see that the OP is lacking in empathy, however: she has specifically said that she didn't want to upset the young man.

Gabbycat245 · 16/11/2026 23:15

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 19:22

I'm speechless because it is illegal to discriminate on the grounds of disability.

Which time of day do you propose someone with a learning disability should be allowed to use the public space? What if little Daphne or Rowen wanted to use the playground at the same time? Do you tell them they can't, because there's a scary person with learning disabilities in there?

Age discrimination can be objectively justified if it is a proportionate mean of achieving a legitimate aim. Like protecting the health and safety of children from adults clambering around on play equipment that wasn't built with them in mind. It's not discriminatory to ban adults because they're adults.

PuddleDuckling5 · 16/11/2026 23:25

hestilllovesthattrombelese · 16/11/2026 22:12

You've been running around after your little one for what, 6 or 7 months now? That man's family have been minding him for 18 years longer than you have been minding your DD. You have absolutely no idea how exhausted they would be. And no idea the level of care he needs at home. Can you even imagine handling a grown man who might be still prone to tantrums or 5am waking or leaping with excitement at watching Ms Rachel or needing help in the shower and the toilet. I know it's not your problem but have some empathy. I think you are being massively unreasonable. You hugged him. You modelled to your DD that it's ok, and now you are here saying someone else shouldn't allow it happen and should have intervened. Even if they were watching they wouldn't have intervened when they say you consenting to the hug. Just thank your lucky stars that that's the biggest problem you have today

Thank you and the handful of other posters who have made thoughtful, kind and empathetic posts on this deeply distressing thread that has brought me to tears.

I have a 5 year old son who will one day be like the man in the OP’s post. You have no idea OP. You just have no idea.

Yellowwellyboots · 16/11/2026 23:32

PuddleDuckling5 · 16/11/2026 23:25

Thank you and the handful of other posters who have made thoughtful, kind and empathetic posts on this deeply distressing thread that has brought me to tears.

I have a 5 year old son who will one day be like the man in the OP’s post. You have no idea OP. You just have no idea.

I'm sorry my thread was distressing for you. That's not how I intended it. I just didn't know how to handle this situation any better. My DD was genuinely scared when he approached her again and would've been hacked into a corner, if I hadn't lifted her down.

OP posts:
Yellowwellyboots · 16/11/2026 23:39

That should say 'backed into a corner', sorry.

OP posts:
Blueeyedmale · 16/11/2026 23:42

Yellowwellyboots · 16/11/2026 23:39

That should say 'backed into a corner', sorry.

Op please don't apologise like I said in a previous post you were not knocking his disability you genuinely felt uncomfortable and were worried for the safety of your daughter,dont let others guilt trip you for just looking out for your DD.

Namechangerage · 16/11/2026 23:48

plasticplate · 16/11/2026 21:57

The dads are more likely to be unsafe with children than an adult with a severe learning disability.

No one is suggesting any malice but what happens about a child being scared due to unwanted hugs from an adult-sized person? I don’t see many dads going around hugging children they don’t know?

Namechangerage · 16/11/2026 23:49

Yellowwellyboots · 16/11/2026 23:32

I'm sorry my thread was distressing for you. That's not how I intended it. I just didn't know how to handle this situation any better. My DD was genuinely scared when he approached her again and would've been hacked into a corner, if I hadn't lifted her down.

It’s so hard. Not saying they shouldn’t be allowed in the playground at all but a carer or family member should have intervened with any physical contact towards strangers.

Monkeytennis97 · 16/11/2026 23:55

GeorgeandTimmy21 · 15/11/2026 20:44

I have a 12 year old son who has autism and likes to hug people. He has to be supervised everywhere he goes because he doesn't understand he can't hug people he doesn't know and also some people he does know don't want to be hugged either.

He is now in the middle of puberty and many people now see him as an adult. He isn't considered to have learning disabilities because he is academically able, especially in maths. But emotionally he is like a 3 year old. He has a 1-1 helper in mainstream school but there is no respite outside of school, it's just me and his dad. He struggles with sleep so I haven't slept properly since he was born. I will follow him around when out in public but I understand some parents can't because they are struggling with their own problems or are just exhausted.

I am finding it increasingly difficult to find places where we are welcome. Some people are absolutely lovely to him but some think he shouldn't be at the park or other activities which are aimed at younger children. Places that allow older children and adults to participate in climbing, swinging etc tend to be trampoline parks and theme parks that cost a ridiculous amount of money. He's not interested in most things for his age group although he quite likes bowling. He can't go to youth groups or scouts etc unless I stay with him which I can't do as I have other children as well. Recently we used inheritance money to buy a climbing frame and swing that cost £1.5k. Something similar for a younger child would have been around £250. And a younger child would also be able to use the park. If I want to take him to a place where he can play outside I have to drive for over an hour.

I do understand that my son makes strangers feel uncomfortable but they only have to experience it for a short time. I am looking after him all the time unless he is with his dad or at school. When he leaves education, that's it. No carers, no respite. Just me and his Dad. Until we die. Then goodness only knows. Hopefully the world will be more understanding by then.

As a mother of an adult son with SLD and autism I totally agree. We have to still go to play parks with our adult children who are mentally around toddler age. It is mentally developmentally appropriate for them if not physically and to be frank I often wish more of the NT world would teach their children about developmental disabilities and so we might get less gawping when out and about.

plasticplate · 16/11/2026 23:57

Namechangerage · 16/11/2026 23:48

No one is suggesting any malice but what happens about a child being scared due to unwanted hugs from an adult-sized person? I don’t see many dads going around hugging children they don’t know?

All the adults that I know with a severe learning disability don't go around hugging random children.

A 'ban' would unenforceable anyway.

PollyBell · 17/11/2026 00:08

There is no reason for a parent of this person to allow them to hug children, children may agree to the hug doeant mean they are comfortable in doing so

No i do not think the person was intentionally doing anything wrong but their needs should not go above what ia appropriate foe younger children and it is up to their parents or carers to navigate this not the parents of the younger children

vanillaalmondlatte · 17/11/2026 00:09

YANBU at all. You were much nicer than I would have been. I bet he never tries to hug a random man…

Chickadee26 · 17/11/2026 00:19

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 19:46

I think you're missing my point. We have spent generations trying to avoid adults with profound learning difficulties being segregated and treated as though they should be hidden away.

This thread makes it sound as though there are young adults with learning disabilities waiting to pounce on unsuspecting members of the public in every local playground. That is simply not true. The adults with this young person should have been supervising him more closely, that's obvious.

No her OP doesn't give that impression, not to me.
I would have quickly stepped away and told his carers what he is doing.

Anarchy99 · 17/11/2026 00:28

Yellowwellyboots · 16/11/2026 22:32

I did not hug him. He hugged me and I didn't push him off like I wanted too. If I'd had more warning I would have stepped away or said no thanks.

My DD did not want a hug and he followed her up onto a climbing frame and tried again. I think that's a problem.

I can’t believe you are getting a hard time!

Well done for standing up for your daughter. Of course it’s not the man’s fault but the carers need to ensure he isn’t in that position where he has the opportunity to hug strangers, particularly children. With the emphasis on bodily autonomy, children have as much right not to be hugged as adults.

I am AUDHD and loathe being touched and hugged, I tend to react quite instinctively and push people away or tell them loudly not to touch me (last time I did it, it was started by someone putting their hand on my arm). I would have struggled in your position

Hollyhobbi · 17/11/2026 01:35

WearyAuldWumman · 16/11/2026 23:04

I somehow didn't press the "Post" button when I first wrote this out.

It's hardly fair to blame the OP for consenting to the hug. Consent from one person doesn't mean that the young man had consent to hug the daughter or the other children.

There's no doubt that parents of intellectually disabled adults have an exceptionally difficult life; I don't see that the OP is lacking in empathy, however: she has specifically said that she didn't want to upset the young man.

But the op did not consent to be hugged?

WearyAuldWumman · 17/11/2026 02:58

Hollyhobbi · 17/11/2026 01:35

But the op did not consent to be hugged?

As I said: "Consent from one person doesn't mean that the young man had consent to hug the daughter or the other children."

[ETA Apologies. I misread your post so I'm adding this edit to make sense of my post now that I've re-read yours.]

Moreover, if you've read all of the OP's posts she made it clear that she was trying to avoid upsetting him and goes on to say: "He hugged me and I didn't push him off like I wanted too. If I'd had more warning I would have stepped away or said no thanks."

The OP only tolerated the hug because she didn't have time to get away from him and the alternative would have been to shove him away.

[Further edit. So no - it wasn't consent. She tolerated it. Even if the young man mistook it for consent, it didn't give the young man or his carers permission to see that as being consent for her child to be hugged. A pp claimed that she'd 'modelled' consent. Even if that had happened, it's not consent for others.]