Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think that this man's family member/carer shouldn't have been allowing him to hug children at the park?

110 replies

Yellowwellyboots · 15/11/2026 17:44

Name changed for this, but I am a regular user, not a disability hate troll.

At the park with my 2 year old dd yesterday and there was a young man, who was very clearly mentally disabled, playing on the equipment. He was with his family, rather than a paid carer. I'm assuming this as the people he was with looked like they were having a birthday gathering at one of picnic tables.

Anyway, he came over and chatted with me, while I was helping my dd on the slide. Told me his name and that he was 20, and then gave me a hug. I was uncomfortable with this because I don't like hugging strangers but I let it happen because I didn't want to upset him.

He then tried to hug my dd, who ran away. I said something like "sorry, she doesn't want to hug right now. She's busy playing". He climbed up on the little climbing frame she was on and tried to hug her again. I quickly lifted her down because she was looking frightened at him coming towards her again.

He walked away after this, but tried to hug a couple more of the kids on the playground. They also looked uncomfortable with it.

Aibu to think that his family/carer should have been watching him a bit better?

OP posts:
Velumental · 17/11/2026 03:06

likelysuspect · 15/11/2026 18:42

Well, watching him? And then what, physically move him away? Tell him off? Tell him not to?

I think its really hard, I think its more likey that if it was a family member they're more likely to be quite blunt about it, social and physical boundaries are often quite a bit focus for people with LD who could be inappropriate without meaning to or understanding.

Yes, stopping him or moving him away, of course that's what should happen.

Velumental · 17/11/2026 03:10

hestilllovesthattrombelese · 16/11/2026 22:12

You've been running around after your little one for what, 6 or 7 months now? That man's family have been minding him for 18 years longer than you have been minding your DD. You have absolutely no idea how exhausted they would be. And no idea the level of care he needs at home. Can you even imagine handling a grown man who might be still prone to tantrums or 5am waking or leaping with excitement at watching Ms Rachel or needing help in the shower and the toilet. I know it's not your problem but have some empathy. I think you are being massively unreasonable. You hugged him. You modelled to your DD that it's ok, and now you are here saying someone else shouldn't allow it happen and should have intervened. Even if they were watching they wouldn't have intervened when they say you consenting to the hug. Just thank your lucky stars that that's the biggest problem you have today

This is such an odd take. I absolutely know how hard it is dealing with a child with additional needs, however you cannot just accept that a grown man is following a little girl up a climbing frame to hug her against her will. That's nuts.

Anarchy99 · 17/11/2026 17:34

hestilllovesthattrombelese · 16/11/2026 22:12

You've been running around after your little one for what, 6 or 7 months now? That man's family have been minding him for 18 years longer than you have been minding your DD. You have absolutely no idea how exhausted they would be. And no idea the level of care he needs at home. Can you even imagine handling a grown man who might be still prone to tantrums or 5am waking or leaping with excitement at watching Ms Rachel or needing help in the shower and the toilet. I know it's not your problem but have some empathy. I think you are being massively unreasonable. You hugged him. You modelled to your DD that it's ok, and now you are here saying someone else shouldn't allow it happen and should have intervened. Even if they were watching they wouldn't have intervened when they say you consenting to the hug. Just thank your lucky stars that that's the biggest problem you have today

Genuine question - the OP allowed him to hug her because she was being polite but should she then let him try to hug her child, who was uncomfortable about it?

I know it’s probably a question with no easy answer and I am empathetic to your situation.

What should people do when they are faced with this situation? Is it really that unreasonable for the carers to stop him, considering very few people would welcome this?

The carers didn’t know how the OP would react and luckily for them she did what we women learn to do - she reluctantly went along with it.

I would not have been able to do this - I am AUDHD and can’t deal with hugs - actually any bodily contact. if caught off guard I would be likely to cause a scene by having a meltdown.

Presumably that would make things worse for the disabled person, who can’t help it but is relying on their carers to keep them safe.

Yellowwellyboots · 17/11/2026 18:44

@Anarchy99 thank you for your posts. I totally agree with you.

I don't think I lacked empathy. I was as kind as possible to this man, while also protecting my daughter. I just think it's a serious safeguarding issue for both parties that he was allowed to follow a two year old girl up a climbing frame to try and hug her after already being told no.

I did really struggle with the hug too. I didn't include this in the op because I didn't want to look like I was being cruel about this young man, but he also had visibly bad hygiene and smelt very strongly.

OP posts:
Anarchy99 · 17/11/2026 19:12

Yellowwellyboots · 17/11/2026 18:44

@Anarchy99 thank you for your posts. I totally agree with you.

I don't think I lacked empathy. I was as kind as possible to this man, while also protecting my daughter. I just think it's a serious safeguarding issue for both parties that he was allowed to follow a two year old girl up a climbing frame to try and hug her after already being told no.

I did really struggle with the hug too. I didn't include this in the op because I didn't want to look like I was being cruel about this young man, but he also had visibly bad hygiene and smelt very strongly.

You were very kind to him and supported your little girl (and we all know one of the biggest gifts you can give a child (particularly a girl) is the knowledge she has bodily autonomy).

Nobody is blaming the man of course, his carers are letting him down. (Especially as it sounds like they weren’t taking care of his personal hygiene).

It presumably hasn’t occurred to them that plenty of people would have reacted badly in the moment and that would be awful for the man and the person he tried to hug. Or they don’t care.

Namechangerage · 17/11/2026 23:53

plasticplate · 16/11/2026 23:57

All the adults that I know with a severe learning disability don't go around hugging random children.

A 'ban' would unenforceable anyway.

But that’s what the post is about? Nobody is saying a ban is needed but the carers should have been more closely involved to intervene if he tried to hug children in the park.

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 00:10

Namechangerage · 17/11/2026 23:53

But that’s what the post is about? Nobody is saying a ban is needed but the carers should have been more closely involved to intervene if he tried to hug children in the park.

Or in fact tried to hug anyone.

An adult may well react in what he would feel is a scary way. If he chases a small child who is there with their father, it could kick off

Ladamesansmerci · Yesterday 00:25

I actually just don't think adults, learning disabilities or not, should not be using a place designated for small children. Obviously it's a free world and anyone can enjoy a park, but not everyone should be clinbing on the equipment.

It is absolutely not this gent's fault though, and yes they should have been watching him more closely.

On another note, people with learning disablities still have adult bodies, and some have adult needs but do not have any understanding of boundaries/consent, which in my opinion is another reason park equipment should be for children in a specific age range.

Parks should be a space for all children, including disabled children. They should not be a place for adults. Just as women should be entitled to single sex spaces, children should be entitled to child only spaces.

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 00:27

Ladamesansmerci · Yesterday 00:25

I actually just don't think adults, learning disabilities or not, should not be using a place designated for small children. Obviously it's a free world and anyone can enjoy a park, but not everyone should be clinbing on the equipment.

It is absolutely not this gent's fault though, and yes they should have been watching him more closely.

On another note, people with learning disablities still have adult bodies, and some have adult needs but do not have any understanding of boundaries/consent, which in my opinion is another reason park equipment should be for children in a specific age range.

Parks should be a space for all children, including disabled children. They should not be a place for adults. Just as women should be entitled to single sex spaces, children should be entitled to child only spaces.

Except there is no such thing because they have to be accompanied.

Ladamesansmerci · Yesterday 00:32

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 00:27

Except there is no such thing because they have to be accompanied.

Yes but a parent helping a kid use equipment isn't the same as a childless adult using the play equipment. I'm pretty sure you wouldn't want want to see grown men with no child climbing through the soft play, or hanging out on the swings.

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 00:37

But I was picking up on your use of the phrase ‘child only spaces’ which is impossible.

takealettermsjones · Yesterday 09:45

Ladamesansmerci · Yesterday 00:25

I actually just don't think adults, learning disabilities or not, should not be using a place designated for small children. Obviously it's a free world and anyone can enjoy a park, but not everyone should be clinbing on the equipment.

It is absolutely not this gent's fault though, and yes they should have been watching him more closely.

On another note, people with learning disablities still have adult bodies, and some have adult needs but do not have any understanding of boundaries/consent, which in my opinion is another reason park equipment should be for children in a specific age range.

Parks should be a space for all children, including disabled children. They should not be a place for adults. Just as women should be entitled to single sex spaces, children should be entitled to child only spaces.

I agree with you. I think there could be designated times for adults, or different sections, if there was a demand for it and the equipment was robust enough (which I'm assuming it is, given safety margins etc). But I would remove my children from play equipment if there was an adult actively playing on it because I would be concerned about them getting hurt accidentally. I actually have experience of having to remove my kids from an activity (designed for everyone, not just kids) when an adult was behaving incredibly dangerously, but nobody said or did anything. I'm not putting my kids in danger to avoid upsetting anyone.

fatphalange · Yesterday 10:13

I’m fed up of the attitude in my local community, where unaccompanied people (I don’t know official diagnoses…learning disabled I would guess) are excused for making young women feel uncomfortable because they ‘don’t mean’ to cause harm. What fucking difference does it make when the outcome is still the same? There are two I know of who spend a lot of time on buses attempting to chat up much younger girls, cross physical boundaries and follow them. They need to be supervised for their own safety if nothing else because someone’s dad recently hit the roof over one incident.
I’ve been in so many frankly distressing situations myself when younger as I was conditioned to not be rude to someone less fortunate but I wouldn’t have it any more.

5128gap · Yesterday 11:45

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 19:46

I think you're missing my point. We have spent generations trying to avoid adults with profound learning difficulties being segregated and treated as though they should be hidden away.

This thread makes it sound as though there are young adults with learning disabilities waiting to pounce on unsuspecting members of the public in every local playground. That is simply not true. The adults with this young person should have been supervising him more closely, that's obvious.

Adults with learning disabilities shouldn't be segregated from situations intended for adults. However, no adult belongs at a children's play park, using the equipment and playing with unknown children. So the obvious resolve here would be to ban all adults who weren't accompanying a child.
However this would mean some adults with learning disabilities would miss out on something pleasurable for them, so the suggestion is to introduce designated times when they can use the park. Its an extra accommodation not available to non disabled adults, not treating disabled adults detrimentally to non disabled adults, which would be discriminatory.

plasticplate · Yesterday 12:05

Ladamesansmerci · Yesterday 00:32

Yes but a parent helping a kid use equipment isn't the same as a childless adult using the play equipment. I'm pretty sure you wouldn't want want to see grown men with no child climbing through the soft play, or hanging out on the swings.

The parent is more likely to be 'dodgy'.

plasticplate · Yesterday 12:08

fatphalange · Yesterday 10:13

I’m fed up of the attitude in my local community, where unaccompanied people (I don’t know official diagnoses…learning disabled I would guess) are excused for making young women feel uncomfortable because they ‘don’t mean’ to cause harm. What fucking difference does it make when the outcome is still the same? There are two I know of who spend a lot of time on buses attempting to chat up much younger girls, cross physical boundaries and follow them. They need to be supervised for their own safety if nothing else because someone’s dad recently hit the roof over one incident.
I’ve been in so many frankly distressing situations myself when younger as I was conditioned to not be rude to someone less fortunate but I wouldn’t have it any more.

These adults aren't adults with a severe learning disability.

Hoppinggreen · Yesterday 12:10

HewasH2O · 15/11/2026 19:22

I'm speechless because it is illegal to discriminate on the grounds of disability.

Which time of day do you propose someone with a learning disability should be allowed to use the public space? What if little Daphne or Rowen wanted to use the playground at the same time? Do you tell them they can't, because there's a scary person with learning disabilities in there?

Don't be so silly
Nobody suggested that
If someone is not capable of understanding that physical contact with strangers is only with permission then they should be more carefully watched thats all
If they are capable but just don't care then thats a different issue
This is to protect everyone

fatphalange · Yesterday 12:30

plasticplate · Yesterday 12:08

These adults aren't adults with a severe learning disability.

I don’t follow?

GeorgeandTimmy21 · Yesterday 12:34

People keep saying disabled adults shouldn't be at the park but nobody seems to have an answer about where are adults with disabilities supposed to play if they want to.

fatphalange · Yesterday 12:41

GeorgeandTimmy21 · Yesterday 12:34

People keep saying disabled adults shouldn't be at the park but nobody seems to have an answer about where are adults with disabilities supposed to play if they want to.

Theres no easy answer because these adults have been infantilised for so long by society, due to unhelpful language such as ‘he’s mentally 6 years old’ (for example)- an odd concept- that people seem to have taken the comparison on board and think they actually are children, but they are not.

Monkeytennis97 · Yesterday 13:04

@fatphalange my DS has a lower cognitive age (6 would be a dream!), he is not infantalised. It is who he is.

plasticplate · Yesterday 13:23

fatphalange · Yesterday 12:30

I don’t follow?

They are not adults who want to use playground equipment. It is annoying to have those with a severe learning disability lumped in with every man who causes problems.

fatphalange · Yesterday 13:25

Monkeytennis97 · Yesterday 13:04

@fatphalange my DS has a lower cognitive age (6 would be a dream!), he is not infantalised. It is who he is.

There has been an infantilisation by society in general which has led to some viewing cognitive age as actual age, we’ve seen on the thread that some posters think certain adults are entitled to children’s play equipment, for example.

fatphalange · Yesterday 13:29

plasticplate · Yesterday 13:23

They are not adults who want to use playground equipment. It is annoying to have those with a severe learning disability lumped in with every man who causes problems.

Who are they? The people I posted about? I don’t know what else they do. Maybe they hang around playgrounds as well? I wouldn’t know because my kids are too old for play parks now so I haven’t seen anything like that myself as I haven’t been near any for a while.
I was giving one example in my post to demonstrate my point which was about unsupervised adults who should be supervised.

plasticplate · Yesterday 13:37

fatphalange · Yesterday 13:25

There has been an infantilisation by society in general which has led to some viewing cognitive age as actual age, we’ve seen on the thread that some posters think certain adults are entitled to children’s play equipment, for example.

Some adults like playing on that equipment. They also like playing with toys that are aimed at young children. There is nothing wrong with that. It appears you cannot cope with idea of difference.