Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

M&S calling security because a child was queuing to buy bread.

337 replies

Tinogirl · Yesterday 09:30

Reading another thread prompted me to post this.

Our M&S just a food one, is small with one entrance and a carpark obviously with pedestrian crossings between carpark and shop.

A few weeks ago around 4ish in the afternoon when it was still light I was queuing to pay behind a late primary school girl who was in school uniform. She had three batons of bread.

The cashier asked me if we were together without serving the child. The cashier asked her if she was alone and the child said her mother was in the car in the car park.

The cashier refused to serve her and called security who with a female member of staff took her back to the carpark .

WTF? I and everyone in the queues could not believe it.

When I pushed my trolley out the mother of the. Hold was arguing with the female member of staff. There were two other children in the car. The female staff member offered to stay with the car while the mother bought the bread but the mother just shouted she would never shop in there again.

I don’t think the mother did anything wrong.

I used to send my daughter into a small CoOp and a Tesco Metro while I waited outside to give her independence.

What do people think?

OP posts:
RowsOfFlowers · Yesterday 09:31

Completely over the top!!!

Wasywasydoodah · Yesterday 09:32

Wow - I’d worry about a 5 year old, but late primary school should be fine

Soreenmaltloaf23 · Yesterday 09:32

Ridiculous. How can we raise children this way.

LaughingArmadillo · Yesterday 09:32

That's mad. I'm of an age that I would have been shopping on my own at that age. It's ridiculous how we infantilize our children

HiCandles · Yesterday 09:33

Ridiculous. I think at our school, year 5 and 6 are allowed to walk home alone with parental permission, so could easily be going into shops (though buying sweets, not bread, I expect!).

Hagr1d · Yesterday 09:34

So weird. I sometimes wait with the toddler in the car, right outside a shop whilst my Y6 child goes in to buy bread.

Surely that's a normal and healthy way to build independence? He learns how to interact with staff, how to handle cash, how to find the item in the first place etc?

Blondeshavemorefun · Yesterday 09:34

Late primary so yr 5 start to help /teach children be more independent so walking home from school - starting to help make meals - putting washing on and yes going to the shop

M&S were way over the top with their response esp once they knew mum was outside

DeutscheBahnTicket · Yesterday 09:35

How utterly stupid. What is wrong with that cashier?

Sally2791 · Yesterday 09:35

Bonkers

WitchesBritches · Yesterday 09:35

Absolutely bat shit.

I would have emailed or phoned the management of the store and Head Office.

I hope the child wasn't too upset by the whole performance & that the Mum had the sense to get her back on the horse using a different shop.

VioletsTale · Yesterday 09:35

HiCandles · Yesterday 09:33

Ridiculous. I think at our school, year 5 and 6 are allowed to walk home alone with parental permission, so could easily be going into shops (though buying sweets, not bread, I expect!).

This. Especially y6 when it’s prime time for them to start going out in the local area by themselves in preparation for secondary school.

GardenAnarchist · Yesterday 09:35

YANBU, unless there is some sort of amazing backstory, that sounds absolutely bonkers!

I've been sending my DC to make basic purchases of this sort since they were in primary. I always thought it was a good thing, building their confidence and independence and learning how to interact with the wider world.

HoraceCope · Yesterday 09:36

that is appalling.

Createausername1970 · Yesterday 09:36

Does seem a bit of an over reaction.

My DS was ND so I needed to oversee him more than a typical child of the same age, but by the age OP describes I was encouraging him to go into the shop on his own to buy something basic, like bread, and I would wait outside.

How are kids going to learn practical skills?

itstoolateforsnacks · Yesterday 09:36

That’s terrible. You should write to them and tell them as an observer how inappropriate that was. As pp says, if the child was small, this might alert to other issues so it’s good if everyone in society is looking out for kids. But for a 10/11yr old to enter a shop alone is completely normal.

muggart · Yesterday 09:36

awful. how are we supposed to teach our children independence with this sort of ridiculous society.

Im relieved to see that everyone else thinks so too!

NewYearEveryYear · Yesterday 09:37

Was it because the child was using her parent’s card rather than cash? I can see how using someone else’s card could (rightly or wrongly) flag them to refuse the sale.

Bettysbutter · Yesterday 09:37

Ridiculous. How else is a child going to learn basic life skills like shopping if this happens?

Soontobe60 · Yesterday 09:38

What an odd thing!
What’s a baton of bread - is it a French stick? Was the child trying to pay with her mother’s card?

WitchesBritches · Yesterday 09:39

NewYearEveryYear · Yesterday 09:37

Was it because the child was using her parent’s card rather than cash? I can see how using someone else’s card could (rightly or wrongly) flag them to refuse the sale.

Edited

The child hadn't even been served so the checkout operator wouldn't have known how she intended to pay

DarkForces · Yesterday 09:39

Bloody hell. If she was buying gin and fags I might understand it but a few loaves of bread while mum is outside that's a huge overreaction. I used to get dd to pop into shops while I was outside with the dog as they felt a safe option. She could only go in and out one way and I could see it!

DiNozzoComingBack · Yesterday 09:39

Shops deciding how parents can and shpuld behave is a constant problem. They once wouldnt sell me an energy drink because I was with 13byear old ds. And while it never happened to me, I have heard of multiple.situations where pregnant women aren't allowed to buy alcohol - both in shops and in restaurants/pubs.

Similarly, my 20 year old niece had to produce id in a restaurant before they would give her a glass of wine even though she was with multiple older adults, including her parents.

Ridiculous.

And its why
so many people are hesitant to give their children independence. They worry about how they will be perceived or judged.

DanaScullysLegoHair · Yesterday 09:40

Er, that is absolutely crazy and can quite imagine the poor girl being more upset by this than anyone else. As a PP said, I really hope they went to another shop afterwards.

I hope the mum complains. You know your child best and know what is age appropriate for them to do. I can't believe the shop assistant thought this was remotely acceptable. The mind boggles.

MrsMoastyToasty · Yesterday 09:41

Jeez, I'm old enough to remember going to the shop to get my dad's cigarettes.

CurlewKate · Yesterday 09:42

There must be more to this, surely? I know some shops no longer allow children in school uniform at some times of day-was that it?