Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

M&S calling security because a child was queuing to buy bread.

337 replies

Tinogirl · Yesterday 09:30

Reading another thread prompted me to post this.

Our M&S just a food one, is small with one entrance and a carpark obviously with pedestrian crossings between carpark and shop.

A few weeks ago around 4ish in the afternoon when it was still light I was queuing to pay behind a late primary school girl who was in school uniform. She had three batons of bread.

The cashier asked me if we were together without serving the child. The cashier asked her if she was alone and the child said her mother was in the car in the car park.

The cashier refused to serve her and called security who with a female member of staff took her back to the carpark .

WTF? I and everyone in the queues could not believe it.

When I pushed my trolley out the mother of the. Hold was arguing with the female member of staff. There were two other children in the car. The female staff member offered to stay with the car while the mother bought the bread but the mother just shouted she would never shop in there again.

I don’t think the mother did anything wrong.

I used to send my daughter into a small CoOp and a Tesco Metro while I waited outside to give her independence.

What do people think?

OP posts:
SwanRivers · Yesterday 11:08

Schoolstressed · Yesterday 11:07

….

Edited

Click the link below and start your own thread in Chat.

Good luck 💐

www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat

Toodarktooearly · Yesterday 11:09

Moonlightdust · Yesterday 11:01

She could have been buying for herself and siblings? The point I’m making is, if it genuinely was a kid that was hungry buying food - how nice of M&S to chuck them out all because no adult is accompanying them! Hardly like she was buying a bottle of vodka!

Edited

Idiocy level 100 achieved we can all go home. I can see the headline now Starving child denied bread by callous shop staff. While her car bound mother remained trapped in the carpark. Bring the pitchforks we ride tonight!

99victoria · Yesterday 11:09

Toodarktooearly · Yesterday 10:33

And the staff would get a reprimand and possibly loose their job. Mand S have had awful problems with shoplifting and stolen cards so this is a probably a blanket policy. Shame on the posters calling the staff member names and suggesting OP complains about them

😂
'Shame'

LuciferOverLancashire · Yesterday 11:11

i think, like the BBC, M&S regard themselves as a beloved National Treasure who can throw their weight about with impunity.

Globules · Yesterday 11:11

The thing I find even worse is that the mother was expected to leave her 2 younger children with a complete stranger to complete the purchase in store with the elderly

That is not a solution!

SaySomethingMan · Yesterday 11:12

What are you considering at late primary?
I wouldn’t be quick to judge; there could be a history you’re unaware of.

Isobel201 · Yesterday 11:12

Imdunfer · Yesterday 10:06

You're right I'm great fun at parties.

A child can't legally use a payment card that belongs to an adult.

You sound a bit naive. There are adult thieves who would send a child into a shop with a stolen card because they can't be prosecuted under the age of 10. You can't expect shop staff to distinguish between a child thief and a nice girl whose busy mum is in the car park. There will probably be a blanket rule that no unaccompanied child is to pay with anything but cash.

as long as its used with the permission of the adult there is no problem. But if a card was genuinely lost or stolen it would be immediately flagged as such and frozen for future purchases anyway.

MushMonster · Yesterday 11:13

This is just plain ridiculous. And if they wanted to be careful, they could have served the girl and the security accompany her to the car. With the bread.
All done, safely. Over the top, but safely.
Why refusing to sell bread to an older primary child? That is so so so so stupid!

CatSquirrelDuck · Yesterday 11:14

M&S employee was completely out of line. Completely.

THese are the same people who will also be complaining that children haven't been taught to do anything for themselves someday...

FancyLilacHare · Yesterday 11:14

Age discrimination?

Mention that in any complaint letter.

Kottorando · Yesterday 11:15

Mapletree1985 · Yesterday 10:18

In Japan they make charming TV shows about 5 year olds going to the shop on their own for the first time.

Society is loosing its collective mind.

It's called Old Enough, so cute 🤗

MushMonster · Yesterday 11:15

Globules · Yesterday 11:11

The thing I find even worse is that the mother was expected to leave her 2 younger children with a complete stranger to complete the purchase in store with the elderly

That is not a solution!

Exactly! Just sell the bread to the 10 year old and scort her to her car if you want to be 100% sure she crosses safely and she is accompanied by an adult.

SwanRivers · Yesterday 11:16

MushMonster · Yesterday 11:13

This is just plain ridiculous. And if they wanted to be careful, they could have served the girl and the security accompany her to the car. With the bread.
All done, safely. Over the top, but safely.
Why refusing to sell bread to an older primary child? That is so so so so stupid!

No it's not if they have a terrible problem with shoplifting for example.

They have to blanket ban schoolchildren because the staff have to stick to the policy and can't be picking and choosing.

No kids in uniform means no kids in uniform (if this is indeed the case).

MyGirlJ · Yesterday 11:17

WitchesBritches · Yesterday 09:35

Absolutely bat shit.

I would have emailed or phoned the management of the store and Head Office.

I hope the child wasn't too upset by the whole performance & that the Mum had the sense to get her back on the horse using a different shop.

This could really affect the child's confidence (with things like this) going forward. Children need to learn how to exist in the world.

AffableApple · Yesterday 11:17

What do young carers do? Starve?

FairKoala · Yesterday 11:18

Dd is only in her mid 20s and I waved goodbye to her in the morning in year 5 and she travelled across London independently to school. Navigating tube rail and the dreaded bus replacement services.

I don’t use M&S food as I am always followed around there by staff members. They are so busy watching me who has never stolen a thing in my life that they missed the guy stuffing goods down his trousers.

Mind you I was once told I couldn’t buy a scratch card because I couldn’t prove I was over 25

I was 55 and probably looked around 65
The whole queue was laughing at the cashier Challenge 25 was lost on them as they thought it meant you had to prove you were 25 to buy a lottery ticket

SwanRivers · Yesterday 11:19

FancyLilacHare · Yesterday 11:14

Age discrimination?

Mention that in any complaint letter.

Kids are not protected here.

  • Equality Act 2010: Under UK law, the age discrimination protections in the Equality Act 2010 only apply to adults (aged 18 and over) when it comes to the provision of goods, facilities, and services. 1, 2]
  • Under-18s Excluded: Because the law does not protect minors from age discrimination in commercial services, shops, and supermarkets, they are legally allowed to ban, restrict, or place conditions on children and young people (such as requiring an adult after a certain hour or limiting how many can enter at once). 1, 2, 3]

https://www.google.com/goto?url=CAESpQEBxCJF1_UlO6cL7P1JLrA2MrrUf0dK6pkrxcajqejMw7kNC7fKTCvrilZZCWFg1jCwIjZ8rincf1aVZS6twM0RwyobLZiOCqp-g_4lBvu5ZcX6xLrI92QiQSn0rM1qSJD_8d15DIAzz87DDPk6FoN0LiGQe0ynQSHC4dWM2sgzOpdcmjl-KpdyFK-O_kKwBLlwSrf8O92eorysVvIxaRUcxraqXM8

Purplebunnie · Yesterday 11:20

Why would a mother leave her 3 children in the care of a total stranger whilst she goes and buys some bread? She'd have to lock her children in the car to do that because no way would I let that woman in a car with my children. This is so fucked up I can't honestly believe the store asked her to do this.

MargaretThursday · Yesterday 11:21

Moonlightdust · Yesterday 10:56

Ridiculous. What if that poor child was starving and she had only scrimped enough to buy herself some bread!

In which case it's a good thing that they took her out to the car park, then they can assess the situation and call for help.

Ionlymakejokestodistractmyself · Yesterday 11:22

I hope the mum complains. This was ridiculous. A single schoolchild queueing patiently is clearly not shoplifting.

It's actually really important we allow kids age appropriate freedoms like this.

See Jonathan Haidt for more.

Ladybird69 · Yesterday 11:22

Sorry I’ve not read all posts. When I was 12 my mother became disabled, so I would do the full weekly shop! (Ran whole household) I also went to the BT shop and organised having the telephone connected to our house! Just handed over a letter from my mum and paid the bill! M&S not allowing a 15 year old to buy a loaf of bread! How absolutely ridiculous

MushMonster · Yesterday 11:24

SwanRivers · Yesterday 11:16

No it's not if they have a terrible problem with shoplifting for example.

They have to blanket ban schoolchildren because the staff have to stick to the policy and can't be picking and choosing.

No kids in uniform means no kids in uniform (if this is indeed the case).

That is ridiculous. This girl was not shoplifting. She was queueing to pay!
But nevermind. I stopped shopping in Tesco because they considered banning children in their shops during covid.... I mean... really, think a little!
M&S is much easier for me to never shop in again, as I do not have any that close.

Have we completely lost our sense of community?
At the age of 11 children are expected to catch buses, go to secondary on their own, walk there, get back home, buy their lunch and so on. But 9-10 year olds are not allowed to practice some independance by buying some bread?
Let's have a little think about it.

FOJN · Yesterday 11:27

OP says the cashier asked her if she was with the child before attempting to serve the child, the problem occured before any payment had been offered so it was unlikely to be a card issue.

The wildest part of this story is that they refused to serve an unaccompanied child but thought it was OK for mum to leave a complete random, in an M&S uniform, to supervise her children whilst she went into the shop. Do M&S uniforms provide evidence of childcare competency and substitute for DBS checks now?

ColinISabirthdaycake · Yesterday 11:29

That is completely ridiculous. My mum used to send me to our local shop when I was about 8, it was a 5 minute walk from home. I know times have changed, but not to the extent that someone isn't allowed to buy something in a shop.

The uniform thing might be an issue with secondary school kids - but that's more about not letting more than a couple in at a time (presumably they're worried about them shoplifting) but not a younger child?

SwanRivers · Yesterday 11:29

MushMonster · Yesterday 11:24

That is ridiculous. This girl was not shoplifting. She was queueing to pay!
But nevermind. I stopped shopping in Tesco because they considered banning children in their shops during covid.... I mean... really, think a little!
M&S is much easier for me to never shop in again, as I do not have any that close.

Have we completely lost our sense of community?
At the age of 11 children are expected to catch buses, go to secondary on their own, walk there, get back home, buy their lunch and so on. But 9-10 year olds are not allowed to practice some independance by buying some bread?
Let's have a little think about it.

That is ridiculous. This girl was not shoplifting. She was queueing to pay!

Do you understand what a 'blanket ban' means?

The staff in my local Morrisons have been left absolutely terrified after gangs of school kids have steamed into the store en masse to shoplift.

They don't make these rules lightly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread