Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

M&S calling security because a child was queuing to buy bread.

337 replies

Tinogirl · Yesterday 09:30

Reading another thread prompted me to post this.

Our M&S just a food one, is small with one entrance and a carpark obviously with pedestrian crossings between carpark and shop.

A few weeks ago around 4ish in the afternoon when it was still light I was queuing to pay behind a late primary school girl who was in school uniform. She had three batons of bread.

The cashier asked me if we were together without serving the child. The cashier asked her if she was alone and the child said her mother was in the car in the car park.

The cashier refused to serve her and called security who with a female member of staff took her back to the carpark .

WTF? I and everyone in the queues could not believe it.

When I pushed my trolley out the mother of the. Hold was arguing with the female member of staff. There were two other children in the car. The female staff member offered to stay with the car while the mother bought the bread but the mother just shouted she would never shop in there again.

I don’t think the mother did anything wrong.

I used to send my daughter into a small CoOp and a Tesco Metro while I waited outside to give her independence.

What do people think?

OP posts:
JoderTia · Yesterday 10:24

Insane. I used to do the full food shop for the family at that age with a shopping trolley.

dodgercity · Yesterday 10:25

Imdunfer · Yesterday 10:10

The outrage on this thread is completely pointless until we know whether the child had cash or was attempting to pay with a card.

The OP said she thinks she had a £20 note

Tinogirl · Yesterday 10:25

Imdunfer · Yesterday 10:10

The outrage on this thread is completely pointless until we know whether the child had cash or was attempting to pay with a card.

I think she had a £20 note in her hand. I definitely think I would have seen a card.

OP posts:
EndorsingPRActice · Yesterday 10:27

Completey agree with all PPs, it's good for older kids to shop alone. Mine did, I did, where is the harm?

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · Yesterday 10:27

dodgercity · Yesterday 10:25

The OP said she thinks she had a £20 note

And if she hadn't yet paid, the cashier couldn't be pulling her up for using an adults bank card anyway.

NCembarassed · Yesterday 10:28

This is completely mad of the staff. I deliberately encouraged my children (from a similar age) to do this stuff. I believe it's an important life skill, and I want them to be confident & competent by the time they get to do their own shopping.

By getting groceries, it also gets them in the habit of thinking of what we buy and when eg we need bread & milk for breakfast, or onions to make dinner. By involving them in the day to day stuff of running a home, they're better set up for independence when it happens.

Mine were involved in laundry from age 3 (obviously with appropriate help), but that was largely as I left home at 18 having never been allowed to use the washing machine. I managed, but wanted mine to know how to use it, and what cycles to use (not obvious on Uni industrial washers).

WimbyAce · Yesterday 10:29

Wow that's crazy! Late primary is our start of middle school where the children are encouraged to become more independent. A lot of them walk home on their own and may pop in a shop on the way.

PuggyPuggyPuggy · Yesterday 10:31

So the older child was somehow not safe to go into a shop full of people and buy some bread while the mother waited in the car park, but the children would be safe left alone with a random stranger who works in M&S while the mother went in to buy bread? That's... an interesting take 🤔

FishPie2 · Yesterday 10:31

Lots of pupils from the school across from M&S where I live do their lunch time food shopping in there without a problem. They spend a fortune on sandwiches and yogurts etc and don't see Marks having a problem with them.

SwanRivers · Yesterday 10:31

School kids are banned from my local Morrisons during the morning, lunchtime and after school due to the outrageous amount of shoplifting.

So basically if they're in school uniform, they're not allowed in.

Could be something like that.

GardenAnarchist · Yesterday 10:31

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · Yesterday 10:27

And if she hadn't yet paid, the cashier couldn't be pulling her up for using an adults bank card anyway.

Exactly, going by the OP's timeline, the child never even got to the point of being served - therefore the cashier (unless she was blessed with precognition) couldn't have known what method of payment was coming. So the question of "whose bank card?" is a massive red herring.

GooseCreekandtheRiver · Yesterday 10:31

What difference would it make whether she was paying by cash or card?

Kids bank accounts also have cards.

BCBird · Yesterday 10:32

MrsMoastyToasty · Yesterday 09:41

Jeez, I'm old enough to remember going to the shop to get my dad's cigarettes.

I was just thinking that. I also think, though I will stand corrected, that teachers used to send kids to the shop!!! I also remember doing community service ss part of school curriculum. It involved visiting elderly people in the community. How times have changed.

Kelticgold · Yesterday 10:33

When I was around 10, my grandad once sent me to the local bar to buy him a packet of cigarettes. No one batted an eyelid. Surely, there must be a middle ground? 😅

Toodarktooearly · Yesterday 10:33

NineteenSeventyThree · Yesterday 10:07

OK, so if you dropped your credit card in town, and some child picked it up and started using it in various shops, you'd be completely happy that no-one thought to challenge a 10 year old using a Mastercard in the name of 'Mrs RumPidgeon' or whatever?

You'd be fine with the hassle of having to go through the process of getting refunds for unauthorised transactions?

And the staff would get a reprimand and possibly loose their job. Mand S have had awful problems with shoplifting and stolen cards so this is a probably a blanket policy. Shame on the posters calling the staff member names and suggesting OP complains about them

forgivingfiggy · Yesterday 10:33

The expectation nowadays seems to be to give children absolutely no freedom or responsibility in the real world, while giving them absolute freedom and responsibility on the internet.

Macinae · Yesterday 10:34

Completely OTT. I used to walk home from school myself at this age and often pop into the local newsagents on the way home for sweets. No one asked where my parents were!

CandidLurker · Yesterday 10:34

ThisChirpyPinkBear · Yesterday 09:52

Even if it was a card there shouldn't have been an issue if they were just buying bread and explained it was their mums card if asked, really

They’d be in breach of their merchant service agreement with the Bank if they knowingly permitted this.

SwanRivers · Yesterday 10:35

Everyone seems to be getting hung up on the card or 'safety'.

I bet if the OP emails the store to check, she'll be told there's a schoolchildren ban due to shoplifting and anti-social behaviour 🤷‍♂️

LakieLady · Yesterday 10:35

Onefairfish · Yesterday 09:43

When I was a child I used to go to the shop to buy cigarettes for my mother. No, I wasn’t abused or neglected, it was the 60s, and this was quite normal. Times have changed for the better in this regard, but fussing over a child buying bread is utterly ridiculous.

Same here.

I was nearly 10 when my brother was born, and for a couple of weeks afterwards I did a fair bit of shopping. There was no paternity leave in those days (mid 60s) and shops shut at 5.30 or 6pm, so too late for my father to go after work.

Sometimes I'd just go to the local shops, a 5 minute walk, but sometimes we'd need stuff from Sainsburys, which was about 15 minutes away. I used to double up sometimes by giving the dog a walk at the same time, and leaving her tied up outside the supermarket. No-one batted an eyelid at a 10YO walking back from town with a bag of shopping and a German Shepherd.

I also used to go to the off licence for my parents, which seems really shocking now. The lady who ran it knew me, and was happy to sell me a couple of bottles of beer and a packet of fags, and always gave me a bar of chocolate, so I was more than happy!

C8H10N4O2 · Yesterday 10:36

Imdunfer · Yesterday 10:10

The outrage on this thread is completely pointless until we know whether the child had cash or was attempting to pay with a card.

The child was in the queue not at the till. The OP has already stated this and that she looked to have cash in her hand.

Its ridiculous overreach and if its M&S policy that children quietly standing and waiting to payare not welcome in their stores I'm sure their customer base will take that under advisement along with their custom.

Wordsmithery · Yesterday 10:37

It's outrageous.
It's important to give your children opportunities to be independent and to increase their confidence in a safe environment and that sounds like a perfect moment.
I can't imagine the reasons the woman refused to serve her.

C8H10N4O2 · Yesterday 10:38

Toodarktooearly · Yesterday 10:33

And the staff would get a reprimand and possibly loose their job. Mand S have had awful problems with shoplifting and stolen cards so this is a probably a blanket policy. Shame on the posters calling the staff member names and suggesting OP complains about them

In which case the store should have a clear sign and policy saying "no children". Of course their core customer base is women with children...

Most shoplifting is carried out by adults, not children in school uniform standing in a queue holding bread. Perhaps they should ban all adults as well.

Bedlingtonwarrior · Yesterday 10:39

Probably not allowed now but I was getting the bus to and from school at the age of six !!!!
Different times as I am now 75 years of age.
Children then were very much taught early independence.
Modern parents would fall down in shock at this nowadays !!!!!!

drspouse · Yesterday 10:42

My DD is 12 and walks to and from the bus to school popping in various shops on the way. From a much younger age both DCs were shopping for ingredients for dinner. I did have to institute recently a 50p bonus for only buying the things on the list and no extra sweets or biscuits!

Swipe left for the next trending thread