Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

M&S calling security because a child was queuing to buy bread.

337 replies

Tinogirl · Yesterday 09:30

Reading another thread prompted me to post this.

Our M&S just a food one, is small with one entrance and a carpark obviously with pedestrian crossings between carpark and shop.

A few weeks ago around 4ish in the afternoon when it was still light I was queuing to pay behind a late primary school girl who was in school uniform. She had three batons of bread.

The cashier asked me if we were together without serving the child. The cashier asked her if she was alone and the child said her mother was in the car in the car park.

The cashier refused to serve her and called security who with a female member of staff took her back to the carpark .

WTF? I and everyone in the queues could not believe it.

When I pushed my trolley out the mother of the. Hold was arguing with the female member of staff. There were two other children in the car. The female staff member offered to stay with the car while the mother bought the bread but the mother just shouted she would never shop in there again.

I don’t think the mother did anything wrong.

I used to send my daughter into a small CoOp and a Tesco Metro while I waited outside to give her independence.

What do people think?

OP posts:
sheisforrealatiger · Yesterday 18:45

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 18:38

Many retail parks have a no unaccompanied minors around school leaving time policy because of thieving and vandalism.

But FGS - it was you saying the cashier didn’t want to make her life harder, but this child was just queuing to buy bread. So instead of being a jobsworth she clearly could have just served the girl.

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · Yesterday 18:45

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 18:37

If you bother to read my last post, it might enlighten you rather than thinking the shop worker just kicked off for fun.

Um, I have never mentioned the shop worker "kicking off for fun".

But your post proves nothing, as that message probably applies to 99% of retail establishments. My nearest town has a couple of schools and an M&S but there are always plenty of kids in there and I've never seen any of them kicked out. Maybe the OPs M&S just has a jobsworthy manager who doesn't want any minors in there, but it seems unlikely.

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · Yesterday 18:48

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 18:38

Many retail parks have a no unaccompanied minors around school leaving time policy because of thieving and vandalism.

Oh, so this child is a thief and a vandal now too. And there we were thinking they wanted to buy some bread.

AnAlpacaForChristmasPleaseSanta · Yesterday 18:49

CatCobain · Yesterday 18:32

Only on mumsnet would people think that children are no longer allowed to buy bread

Today bread, tomorrow hard drugs.
Its a thin line.

PineappleOnAStick · Yesterday 18:51

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 18:38

Many retail parks have a no unaccompanied minors around school leaving time policy because of thieving and vandalism.

I’ve never once seen a marks and Spencer’s where unaccompanied children are not allowed.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 18:56

sheisforrealatiger · Yesterday 17:58

Unaccompanied minors? There is no good reason.

So why do so many shops do it then?

Of course there is.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 18:59

Emilesgran · Yesterday 18:08

That’s for alcohol and cigarettes. Not bread.

Where do you guys live?

LOTS of shops and some entire shopping centres ban unaccompanied children.

Natsku · Yesterday 18:59

Ridiculous of M&S, hope the incident doesn't put the poor girl off doing things independently.
My children have been going to the shop down the road for me since they were 6, done wonders for their confidence, but I live in a country that isn't ridiculous about this kind of thing and doesn't treat children as incapable.

sheisforrealatiger · Yesterday 18:59

Imdunfer · Yesterday 18:56

So why do so many shops do it then?

Of course there is.

I have literally never heard of this so I wouldn’t know. A Pp has suggested it could be because of thieves and vandals (9-11 year old ones) but obviously since the girl wasn’t doing either of these things I still can’t think of a good reason why this particular girl was refused service and her mother told to come in and pay in her place. What a load of unnecessary faff.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:00

sheisforrealatiger · Yesterday 18:45

But FGS - it was you saying the cashier didn’t want to make her life harder, but this child was just queuing to buy bread. So instead of being a jobsworth she clearly could have just served the girl.

Why should she risk her job? From the response is clearly a shop policy.

sheisforrealatiger · Yesterday 19:01

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:00

Why should she risk her job? From the response is clearly a shop policy.

Yes, it would be more than her job’s worth…

Swissmeringue · Yesterday 19:02

Imdunfer · Yesterday 10:10

The outrage on this thread is completely pointless until we know whether the child had cash or was attempting to pay with a card.

Why? My 8 year old has her own card and has done for 2 years. Kids can have cards.

Lindy2 · Yesterday 19:06

Good grief. How are today's children ever supposed to grow up if we keep treating them as infants.

The poor girl was probably quite proud of herself helping her mum and being mature. Now she's probably embarrassed and has had her confidence knocked when she did nothing wrong. The mother also did nothing wrong.

The shop staff however, have made an error in judgement and have overstepped their role in trying to interfere in perfectly ok parenting decisions. I would be making a complaint to the store and wanting an explanation as to where they publicly advertise what age you have to be to buy something.

caringcarer · Yesterday 19:09

vickylou78 · Yesterday 09:51

We're they trying to use a card to pay perhaps? But if they had cash surely it's fine! Why are children not allowed to go in and pay for things in a shop?

OP said the DC never even got to payment stage.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:09

Swissmeringue · Yesterday 19:02

Why? My 8 year old has her own card and has done for 2 years. Kids can have cards.

You send them out to buy family food on them, do you?

We were clearly talking about using a card that didn't have her name on it.

But regardless, the shop has a policy of not allowing unaccompanied minors and there will only be one reason for that - problems caused by unaccompanied minors.

The woman on the till would have risked her job to serve her.

sheisforrealatiger · Yesterday 19:15

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:09

You send them out to buy family food on them, do you?

We were clearly talking about using a card that didn't have her name on it.

But regardless, the shop has a policy of not allowing unaccompanied minors and there will only be one reason for that - problems caused by unaccompanied minors.

The woman on the till would have risked her job to serve her.

This is one assumption after another based on nothing the OP has said.

ToadRage · Yesterday 19:28

I used to work in M&S and unless the item was age restricted I would not have thought twice about serving her. I did have a problem once when a mum didn't realise that Christmas crackers are age restricted and she sent her 10 year to go and buy some, I explained that i couldn't legally sell them to him and she looked at me like I was mad.

Emilesgran · Yesterday 19:44

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:09

You send them out to buy family food on them, do you?

We were clearly talking about using a card that didn't have her name on it.

But regardless, the shop has a policy of not allowing unaccompanied minors and there will only be one reason for that - problems caused by unaccompanied minors.

The woman on the till would have risked her job to serve her.

Didn’t have her name on it? How would she know the child’s name, and if it was her name, how would the child prove it anyway?

(You asked above where posters are - Im not in England so maybe that's why I’ve never come across a food hall that wouldn’t serve a child - except for alcohol, obviously. I have seen a sweetshop that’s just beside a school here that has a sign up saying they won’t let more than one pupil in at time. But that’s one tiny little shop that I presume was being overwhelmed with kids all arriving at break time. I haven’t seen it at a supermarket that sells actual food.)

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:45

sheisforrealatiger · Yesterday 19:15

This is one assumption after another based on nothing the OP has said.

So you think a miserable cow at a till called security because she was in a bad mood today and security came and took the child out to her mother for the fun of it?

Or is it just more likely that the shop, like many shops, has a policy where they've told the people on the tills not to serve unaccompanied children?

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:47

Emilesgran · Yesterday 19:44

Didn’t have her name on it? How would she know the child’s name, and if it was her name, how would the child prove it anyway?

(You asked above where posters are - Im not in England so maybe that's why I’ve never come across a food hall that wouldn’t serve a child - except for alcohol, obviously. I have seen a sweetshop that’s just beside a school here that has a sign up saying they won’t let more than one pupil in at time. But that’s one tiny little shop that I presume was being overwhelmed with kids all arriving at break time. I haven’t seen it at a supermarket that sells actual food.)

It's common in the UK, there are even whole shipping centres that do it, because of the antisocial behaviour they've experienced.

This shop isn't doing it to be nasty to children or frazzled mothers.

Emilesgran · Yesterday 19:49

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:45

So you think a miserable cow at a till called security because she was in a bad mood today and security came and took the child out to her mother for the fun of it?

Or is it just more likely that the shop, like many shops, has a policy where they've told the people on the tills not to serve unaccompanied children?

I think you’re missing the point. It’s unacceptable whether it’s shop policy or a single cashier. It wasn’t clearly marked anywhere, so if it was policy, nobody even knew to complain.

I think it’s sad how children are being excluded more and more from normal society. No wonder they can’t then deal with everyday life if they can’t even go to the shop on their own From The Car Park, without being singled out as though they were plague bearers.

Emilesgran · Yesterday 19:50

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:47

It's common in the UK, there are even whole shipping centres that do it, because of the antisocial behaviour they've experienced.

This shop isn't doing it to be nasty to children or frazzled mothers.

LOL England is not the UK, you do know that, right?

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:51

Emilesgran · Yesterday 19:49

I think you’re missing the point. It’s unacceptable whether it’s shop policy or a single cashier. It wasn’t clearly marked anywhere, so if it was policy, nobody even knew to complain.

I think it’s sad how children are being excluded more and more from normal society. No wonder they can’t then deal with everyday life if they can’t even go to the shop on their own From The Car Park, without being singled out as though they were plague bearers.

I expect there's a sign somewhere.

If other parents controlled their feral children it wouldn't be necessary.

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:53

Emilesgran · Yesterday 19:50

LOL England is not the UK, you do know that, right?

You think there are no Scots, Welsh or Irish shops with this policy. Sure.

Emilesgran · Yesterday 20:00

Imdunfer · Yesterday 19:53

You think there are no Scots, Welsh or Irish shops with this policy. Sure.

I don’t know - you asked where everyone was that we hadn’t all seen these signs, so since most people appear not to have, maybe it’s specific to where you are?

But you're the one making the claim that it’s commonplace (IME it’s not) - and when I said maybe that’s because I'm not in England you said that it’s commonplace in the Uk. Doing that English thing of assuming that England IS the UK 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread