Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help with cultural capital

322 replies

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 14/11/2026 14:47

Because I genuinely need help navigating this and building my own.
after a childhood in and out of care I have, by a combination of finding good mentors, a voracious reading habit (and ignoring the many, many times this was mocked in various placements) and being in top sets through sheer hard work rather than natural intelligence I have a well respected, aspirational job that I love.
Thanks in no small part to MN I ‘mask’/fit in with the upper middle class around me in clothes, grooming and so forth. I’m not looking to imitate them if that makes sense but instead to navigate my way through what I missed as a child. I know nothing about classical music, opera or art. I am educating myself about philosophy at the moment after an interesting conversation I was part of (well, I didn’t have much to contribute tbh but you get the idea).
I feel like I have a lot of gaps that I want to plug, not because I don’t feel as good as other people more that I want to get behind the curtain and see what’s there.
if anyone has any suggestions about where to start as an adult - for example I have only found kids books describing the ballet for those who don’t know anything about it - navigating any aspect of this, 🙏
I’m happy to watch docs, read, listen. Don’t have limitless time and money but am happy to commit both realistically. The only thing I don’t need help with are our ‘classsics’ on the book world, EH, NT, skiing and horseriding (waaay to much open air).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
helpfulperson · 14/11/2026 18:27

I've just discovered the british museum have a youtube channel. I've loved finding out more detail about things I had vaguely heard of

NoSmilingNoWrinkles · 14/11/2026 18:34

We use this study programme with our children, it's a great way of learning about composers, artists, folk songs, hymns, Shakespeare and Plutarch. They're the riches that accompany our home education.
Edited to add link:
https://amblesideonline.org/artists

Blueseaurchin · 14/11/2026 18:35

I forgot to mention the Open University in my previous comment. They have a great selection of online, free short courses that would help you expend your cultural knowledge.

Taytocrisps · 14/11/2026 18:35

I'm not sure if you live near any art galleries or concert halls? If you're on Facebook and you like/follow them, you'll get updates if there are any new exhibitions or events on. Look up their calendar of events - do any of them give talks or lectures? I have a friend who is a member of a gallery and she gets invited to lots of events which aren't open to the general public. I've no idea how much it costs though.

I go to a Christmas concert every year with friends and family. We try out a different one every year. Some of them are mostly carols where everyone can sing along and others are a mix - classical pieces interspersed with carols. It's a nice way to discover composers and lots of the tunes are familiar.

Try out different things - a ballet, an art exhibition, a play, an opera etc. See what takes your fancy. You don't have to do them all in one go.

If you visit foreign cities, check out what culture is on offer there.

Dogssleeping · 14/11/2026 18:36

I was in this situation 3 years ago and it had been on my mind for 20 plus years. My background is different very academic (one STEM background) but very non supportive background and I was very out of place and bullied until I learnt within my birth family just to be silent.

Firstly / you are putting your natural intelligence vastly underestimated. Some people sound intelligent and just aren’t they are repeating what they have read or following a herd. If you don’t like it don’t do it.

Over the years I have done the following with great success:

  • I read ‘The Week’ once a week from cover to cover - even the sport pages! I do it in summer with a cup of tea or lemonade in the garden and in the winter with tea in front of the fire I find this helps me keep up to date with news and culture without rage! 😜
  • I have a life membership to the NT and we go often - like 3-4 places in half term and we learn the history of the place who lived there, how they made money etc we also do English heritage
  • We explore - travel (will come back to this)
  • I alternate between radio 2, radio 4 and classic fm and it is normally on the background
  • I have different interests now - so for example art, I went to a Van Gough guided tour, Picasso - I don’t have to like it but I learn about it and make my own mind up. If I know diddly squat I’m happy to say so and learn, go on a course or visit someone or somewhere.
  • I am very old school and listen to CDs such as Now that’s what I call classic music and learn what I like and then I might buy some more of that eg https://www.musicmagpie.co.uk/store/products/now-thats-what-i-call-classical/
  • Same with DVDs, and iplayer watch history time team, Mary Beard, Lucy Worsley, sister Wendy on painting, coast to coast etc on iplayer
  • some podcasts are just outstanding and some books I like Mary Beard and Natalie Haynes and I just absorb it
  • set a budget aside for Waterstones and just go in and browse and buy really nice interesting books
  • Join your local history society - I have learnt about my local village coal mining industry, local leader in education Hannah Moore, the Bristol Channel all sorts. Ours is £20 a year total bargain!!
  • Reading and podcasts - in the car as a passenger it’s one or the other. Or sittings waiting for someone book (carry one) or podcast
  • concerts and local / national things - we have just booked on a stained glass course for January, we regularly go to our local church for concerts, or to the Bristol Old vic for theatre and we don’t pay a fortune either / cheap seats with clear view and just enjoy.
  • we love learning via seeing and doing and also travel. So going to Malta and visiting a friend we went to some cathedrals, temples etc and we try to learn.
  • online course are great - eg my husband has just gone back to university to do a part time MA / I like future learn. My husband has a degree in economics but loved history so started doing an OU degree in history with different modules. Introduction to art or literature or something and you can do the same it doesn’t have to cost a lot or lead to a degree or qualification although his is
  • we both have little project books about things that interest us
Everyone has something they can teach you. You have something you can teach others. Having a like minded person to go with is great (my husband is mine although I have others friends who I ring and say guided tour of Salisbury cathedral do you fancy a day out and meet up? And they say yes or no.

Back to travel - I like lonely planet guides. I read up about where we are going on cruises or holiday eg Malta or Portugal and I try to learn. We have one for the Uk to and we use it and the NT guide.

And there is nothing wrong with looking at reference books in the children section of Waterstones - I got a great book which was an introduction to famous paintings for children - loved it! See attached. - photo below and then moved onto the adult ones.

I don’t know if you are SW of England - but if you are let me know - I’ve met up with several people from Mumsnet who were looking for someone to go to a gallery with. I’m near Bristol and my local museum is free, my husband or I or both of us walk round and potter and just enjoy.

Also you could do a new year resolution read a long on here, or something like Clemency Burton- Hill which I did one year called a Year of Wonder a piece of classic music each year and the history. I also like almanacs learn lots that way, or a year of poetry or something - I’ve done several of them. I’m dyslexic and I’ve given up on my spelling or feeling stupid and now I just read and enjoy / if I’m not enjoying it for me I try audio book or stop.

Local cinema live events are good as are national ballet etc

Ps when I took my teenagers we did a synopsis first before they went eg Macbeth so they knew the plot and had greater focus.

Enjoy I will never know everything but I love learning.

To ask for help with cultural capital
Sgtmajormummy · 14/11/2026 18:38

I’ve always known I liked classical music but other than Bach, Vivaldi and Mozart I couldn’t name the styles I enjoyed.

Then, during lockdown I got the book mentioned above (Year of Wonder) on Kindle and did about 6 months of its daily pieces. There’s a site on YouTube with the corresponding music but I tried to find them with my favourite musicians like Glenn Gould, Arthur Rubinstein, Itzhak Perlman etc. I must get back into it…

I also tune straight in to Classic FM on the car radio whenever I’m in the UK. It’s so accessible with a mix of well-known and more unusual music, all in maximum 20 minute slots. I remember stopping the car one holiday and not getting out until John Williams finished talking about his influences and career!

Now I can honestly say I prefer Beethoven, Handel, Chopin and Rachmaninov (!) and enjoy guessing the composer on Classic FM.
Not to impress anyone, just to widen my understanding of something I already instinctively loved.

FKAT · 14/11/2026 18:40

I'm from a similar background to you and now work in one of the art forms you mentioned.

Remember that classical music, ballet and opera are niche pursuits even among the wealthy and well-educated. Even among the north London well-heeled, professional middle class I'm seen as being a bit eccentric for going to opera rather than Oasis.

It's called capital because it grows and builds over time. You can't fake your way to it through YouTube or BBC Sounds or Wikipedia - particularly as the point of ballet / opera / theatre / concerts is that they are live experiences. It's an accumulation of knowledge and expertise. You are very well read for example but you would not get that same wisdom and literary knowledge by skimming synopses or watching an instagram about Jane Austen. It takes time.

Just choose a few things - galleries and classical music are the most accessible and cheapest - opera requires deep pockets. Then follow what you enjoy. And you're not passing a test - you don't have to 'know' classical music in and out. You can dip into ballet, pop to an exhibition, go to a concert...the point is it is to be enjoyed.

AlexandraCarrington · 14/11/2026 18:46

Someone a while back mentioned Western civilisation. Try Kenneth Clark's classic series Civilisation, which traces it from the fall of the Roman Empire to the Industrial Revolution. Available on BBC i-player.

(Back when BBC shows were fronted by experts, not presenters.)

EBearhug · 14/11/2026 18:50

I'm another who agreed with R3 and R4, especially In Our Time.

Most of the National museums and galleries are free, unless it's for a special exhibition, and we have some of the world's greatest collections. It's not just London, though - there are some wonderful museums and galleries all around the country. But you can start with your local library, which is bound to have a book on the history of art, or 100 greatest paintings or something.

Don't expect to like everything. I'm a big fan of the PreRaphaelites, but I have friends who aren't keen at all. I'm not actually that bothered about Turner, however important he might be to the history of British art, but I've seen enough to come to that conclusion. Likewise, you probably won't like all classical music, but you don't have to like everything. You might enjoy Puccini or Verdi but not Wagner. You might love most of Mozart, but not all his stuff. And knowing what you're not interested in is as important as knowing what you love.

Most people at work, I'd be better off talking about football or Marvel films if I wanted to fit in, but I'm not interested, just as they're not interested in Hokusai or Renoir. I've got other friends I can talk to about stuff like thst, so it doesn't really matter. I fit in with some people, just not everyone.

CrystalSingerFan · 14/11/2026 18:50

Lots of great suggestions on the thread. R3/4, etc. However, as an opera fan, I'm all in favour of a bit of visual stuff. Here's the best, accessible, brilliant, beautiful (short) extracts from Wagner's Ring Cycle from Valencia relatively recently. (As PP have said, always start with the highlights.)

X
Finale of Das Rheingold. STUNNING visuals.

2 Act 1 Finale of Die Walkure. (TW: incest)

3 (Ignore the fact that Brunhillde looks like a bag of spanners, and Siegfried looks like a badger.) Start about half way through.

4 (Stunning visuals again. Rhine maidens in tanks!)

I hope you enjoy it. (Personally I don't think you always have to know what's going on. Sometimes it's just enough to sit there going WTAF? Do I actually like this or not?)

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=PLz_kQKl1-OMA0vti1HLc8wSBOpPLY-_pX&v=BryfDHcjD9o

RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 18:52

Dinnerontheterrace · 14/11/2026 15:36

I think a lot of “cultural capital” now is knowing the western tradition. This isn’t taught in a straight forward way in state schools or universities anymore, but somehow posh people know it. Perhaps it’s through family or private schools who go outside the curriculum. What really marks people out is knowing the straight facts about Roman History, or what Kant said, or the sequence of WWII, etc. without Marxists spin or current social justice theory. Real sophistication is knowing the classic position and understanding the current fashionable, political overlay.

I am not a conservative Christian, but a good place to find free online courses that are very entertaining is here:

https://online.hillsdale.edu

Just skip all the US history. I personally think the bible stuff is useful from a cultural point of view because our traditions rest on it. It’s foundational to so much western art and literature. But you can skip it too, there is plenty to trawl though. I listened to the Odyssey series after the film came out, and I found it interesting and enjoyable.

Good grief!

So your solution to avoid "Marxist spin" is to go a heavily conservatively-biased, pale, male, stale, American Christian nationalist institution for your baseline history?

Pansykavalier · 14/11/2026 18:58

Some classic opera pieces to get your teeth into…

Mario expresses his love of life as he is about to be executed (Tosca):

Violetta (La Traviata) mourns the life she has lost, knowing her life is about to end:

Tatiana summons up the courage to write a love letter to Eugene Onegin:

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 14/11/2026 19:08

@LumberPainJackie not Classics but classics in books so Austen, Catch 22 and so on.
to the person who asked about philosophy I’ve been reading Western philosophers - Descartes, Epicurus, Kant and so on.

OP posts:
RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 19:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LumberPainJackie · 14/11/2026 19:11

RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 18:52

Good grief!

So your solution to avoid "Marxist spin" is to go a heavily conservatively-biased, pale, male, stale, American Christian nationalist institution for your baseline history?

I agree! I feel like I have sat on far too many tables with boring (usually men) who seem to be keen to wang on about these topics while boring everyone to tears. I certainly wouldn't think they were particularly unusual.

Pansykavalier · 14/11/2026 19:16

And some key ballet scenes…

The 32 fouetee from Swan Lake:

The bedroom pas des deux from Manon:

Giselle returns as a ghost:

And to cheer yourself up, the Sugar Plum Fairy and her prince:

MoralOrLegal · 14/11/2026 19:21

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 14/11/2026 19:08

@LumberPainJackie not Classics but classics in books so Austen, Catch 22 and so on.
to the person who asked about philosophy I’ve been reading Western philosophers - Descartes, Epicurus, Kant and so on.

The thing about Western philosophy is that it seems utterly bizarre why people would write things unless you have some sort of timeline; the authors are normally responding to previous ideas in a very slow conversation. (Then there's a big split after Kant into two very different approaches, 'analytic' and 'continental'.) 20th century philosophy explodes in all sorts of different directions.

I find it a fascinating window into the concerns of society, as much as anything else.

MoralOrLegal · 14/11/2026 19:24

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 14/11/2026 19:08

@LumberPainJackie not Classics but classics in books so Austen, Catch 22 and so on.
to the person who asked about philosophy I’ve been reading Western philosophers - Descartes, Epicurus, Kant and so on.

And I take my hat off to you if you're making any sense at all of Kant! Except, maybe, for the Groundwork to the Metaphysics of Morals, he's pretty much unreadable, at least in my opinion. (Dig into Hume or Berkeley, who are actually quite funny.)

Scunnygal · 14/11/2026 19:25

CheesyWotzzit · 14/11/2026 15:13

Don't rush and look at it as a fun project.

Start with what actually interests you.
Do you like ballet, theatre, opera, visual art, music? What would be most interesting to you?

Visual art - most London art galleries are free. Just go in and have a wander round. Look for what catches your eye. Walk into a room, scan the walls and pick the picture that most appeals to you - don't think about it tooo much. Then go to that picture, read the label and who painted it, then stand and look at it carefully. Could you paint it or draw it? Could you try? Look at the brush strokes. look at the imagery and all the details or if no details what does it say to you.

Ballet - a lot of classical ballets are based on romantic tragedies or history. Start by looking out for a well known ballet like Swan Lake, Sleeping Beauty, Giselle, The Nutcracker (often on at this time of year) (google for the stories and see if any interest you). Then go to watch one. Many of these are filmed so you may find them online but there's nothing like being there. Then slowly tick them off your list.

Opera - this is more challenging as it can be expensive to go. Search for the top classical famous operas, have a look at the stories and again see if anything grabs you. Go and see one. English National Opera, Opera North, smaller companies will be cheaper than the Royal Opera House. Opera (IMO) really doesn't translate well to film you need to be in the room.

Theatre - divides into old classic staples (Shakespeare, Marlowe) more modern classics (Oscar Wilde, Pinter) and new plays. Shakespeare introduction is usually better with a comedy like A Midsummer Nights Dream or Twelfth Night but Macbeth is short and engaging (a bit bloody, lots of murder). Read the plot before you go.

Straightforward exposure to art and opera doesn’t give you actual cultural capital. Looking at a Caravaggio and asking yourself if you could draw it doesn’t teach you anything about the political impact of the art, who his sponsors were and why, how his work was received and why, helping you understand connecting references to certain famous paintings across history and literature.
I completely agree that people (especially) children should be exposed to wide cultural capital from an early age. Not because it’s good to like classical music or appreciate ballet but because there are so many cultural references, jokes, nods to assumed knowledge in communication across your life. You’re missing out on so much depth if you don’t get what people are referring to.

Malbecfan · 14/11/2026 19:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

People like you drive me mad. If you met me, I’m so far from your pathetic evaluation of me, you wouldn’t recognise me.

i suggest you get off your high horse and go and annoy someone else. My post was meant to be encouraging and supportive.

i loathe snobbery about classical music. FFS, my grandmother was in service. My parents educated themselves. But crack on with your narrow-minded beliefs.

i used the term “serious music” to distinguish between classical music, which is that composed between around 1750 and 1820 and romantic, baroque etc. if you knew anything about music, you would understand.

Your 2nd point is bullshit. I never want to change what people enjoy. I just want them to expand their listening. If you have never heard something before, how can you know whether or not you like it?

Your 3rd point is simply pathetic. BBC 10
Piecrs is designed for school children so has a particular presenting style. I wanted to warn the OP, nothing more.

Point 4: I have played a lot of different music. Some is great, a lot is not so good in my opinion. My point is that it is fine to dislike something but again, you have read something into my comment that was not meant.

Point 5: my point is that your tastes change over time. Again, your insistence on my “snobbery” is wildly misplaced.

Point 6: I was trying to encourage the OP. Obviously that was the wrong thing to do.

Your comments are rude and completely wide of the mark. Go and listen to some decent music and get a life.

NoSmilingNoWrinkles · 14/11/2026 19:33

Dogssleeping · 14/11/2026 18:36

I was in this situation 3 years ago and it had been on my mind for 20 plus years. My background is different very academic (one STEM background) but very non supportive background and I was very out of place and bullied until I learnt within my birth family just to be silent.

Firstly / you are putting your natural intelligence vastly underestimated. Some people sound intelligent and just aren’t they are repeating what they have read or following a herd. If you don’t like it don’t do it.

Over the years I have done the following with great success:

  • I read ‘The Week’ once a week from cover to cover - even the sport pages! I do it in summer with a cup of tea or lemonade in the garden and in the winter with tea in front of the fire I find this helps me keep up to date with news and culture without rage! 😜
  • I have a life membership to the NT and we go often - like 3-4 places in half term and we learn the history of the place who lived there, how they made money etc we also do English heritage
  • We explore - travel (will come back to this)
  • I alternate between radio 2, radio 4 and classic fm and it is normally on the background
  • I have different interests now - so for example art, I went to a Van Gough guided tour, Picasso - I don’t have to like it but I learn about it and make my own mind up. If I know diddly squat I’m happy to say so and learn, go on a course or visit someone or somewhere.
  • I am very old school and listen to CDs such as Now that’s what I call classic music and learn what I like and then I might buy some more of that eg https://www.musicmagpie.co.uk/store/products/now-thats-what-i-call-classical/
  • Same with DVDs, and iplayer watch history time team, Mary Beard, Lucy Worsley, sister Wendy on painting, coast to coast etc on iplayer
  • some podcasts are just outstanding and some books I like Mary Beard and Natalie Haynes and I just absorb it
  • set a budget aside for Waterstones and just go in and browse and buy really nice interesting books
  • Join your local history society - I have learnt about my local village coal mining industry, local leader in education Hannah Moore, the Bristol Channel all sorts. Ours is £20 a year total bargain!!
  • Reading and podcasts - in the car as a passenger it’s one or the other. Or sittings waiting for someone book (carry one) or podcast
  • concerts and local / national things - we have just booked on a stained glass course for January, we regularly go to our local church for concerts, or to the Bristol Old vic for theatre and we don’t pay a fortune either / cheap seats with clear view and just enjoy.
  • we love learning via seeing and doing and also travel. So going to Malta and visiting a friend we went to some cathedrals, temples etc and we try to learn.
  • online course are great - eg my husband has just gone back to university to do a part time MA / I like future learn. My husband has a degree in economics but loved history so started doing an OU degree in history with different modules. Introduction to art or literature or something and you can do the same it doesn’t have to cost a lot or lead to a degree or qualification although his is
  • we both have little project books about things that interest us
Everyone has something they can teach you. You have something you can teach others. Having a like minded person to go with is great (my husband is mine although I have others friends who I ring and say guided tour of Salisbury cathedral do you fancy a day out and meet up? And they say yes or no.

Back to travel - I like lonely planet guides. I read up about where we are going on cruises or holiday eg Malta or Portugal and I try to learn. We have one for the Uk to and we use it and the NT guide.

And there is nothing wrong with looking at reference books in the children section of Waterstones - I got a great book which was an introduction to famous paintings for children - loved it! See attached. - photo below and then moved onto the adult ones.

I don’t know if you are SW of England - but if you are let me know - I’ve met up with several people from Mumsnet who were looking for someone to go to a gallery with. I’m near Bristol and my local museum is free, my husband or I or both of us walk round and potter and just enjoy.

Also you could do a new year resolution read a long on here, or something like Clemency Burton- Hill which I did one year called a Year of Wonder a piece of classic music each year and the history. I also like almanacs learn lots that way, or a year of poetry or something - I’ve done several of them. I’m dyslexic and I’ve given up on my spelling or feeling stupid and now I just read and enjoy / if I’m not enjoying it for me I try audio book or stop.

Local cinema live events are good as are national ballet etc

Ps when I took my teenagers we did a synopsis first before they went eg Macbeth so they knew the plot and had greater focus.

Enjoy I will never know everything but I love learning.

Is that Hannah More the slavery abolitionist friend of William Wilberforce?

NoSmilingNoWrinkles · 14/11/2026 19:37

A good working knowledge of Greek and Roman mythology, plus Arthurian legend is really helpful for understanding cultural references too.

MoralOrLegal · 14/11/2026 19:43

Malbecfan · 14/11/2026 19:27

People like you drive me mad. If you met me, I’m so far from your pathetic evaluation of me, you wouldn’t recognise me.

i suggest you get off your high horse and go and annoy someone else. My post was meant to be encouraging and supportive.

i loathe snobbery about classical music. FFS, my grandmother was in service. My parents educated themselves. But crack on with your narrow-minded beliefs.

i used the term “serious music” to distinguish between classical music, which is that composed between around 1750 and 1820 and romantic, baroque etc. if you knew anything about music, you would understand.

Your 2nd point is bullshit. I never want to change what people enjoy. I just want them to expand their listening. If you have never heard something before, how can you know whether or not you like it?

Your 3rd point is simply pathetic. BBC 10
Piecrs is designed for school children so has a particular presenting style. I wanted to warn the OP, nothing more.

Point 4: I have played a lot of different music. Some is great, a lot is not so good in my opinion. My point is that it is fine to dislike something but again, you have read something into my comment that was not meant.

Point 5: my point is that your tastes change over time. Again, your insistence on my “snobbery” is wildly misplaced.

Point 6: I was trying to encourage the OP. Obviously that was the wrong thing to do.

Your comments are rude and completely wide of the mark. Go and listen to some decent music and get a life.

For what it's worth, I read @Malbecfan's post as helpful, reassuring, and enthusiastic. I'm certain she's a great music teacher.

bitterbuddhist · 14/11/2026 19:45

Learn an instrument, OP. Be it piano, or violin. There's a lot of classical music written around various instruments, and a lot of history around them too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread