Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help with cultural capital

322 replies

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 14/11/2026 14:47

Because I genuinely need help navigating this and building my own.
after a childhood in and out of care I have, by a combination of finding good mentors, a voracious reading habit (and ignoring the many, many times this was mocked in various placements) and being in top sets through sheer hard work rather than natural intelligence I have a well respected, aspirational job that I love.
Thanks in no small part to MN I ‘mask’/fit in with the upper middle class around me in clothes, grooming and so forth. I’m not looking to imitate them if that makes sense but instead to navigate my way through what I missed as a child. I know nothing about classical music, opera or art. I am educating myself about philosophy at the moment after an interesting conversation I was part of (well, I didn’t have much to contribute tbh but you get the idea).
I feel like I have a lot of gaps that I want to plug, not because I don’t feel as good as other people more that I want to get behind the curtain and see what’s there.
if anyone has any suggestions about where to start as an adult - for example I have only found kids books describing the ballet for those who don’t know anything about it - navigating any aspect of this, 🙏
I’m happy to watch docs, read, listen. Don’t have limitless time and money but am happy to commit both realistically. The only thing I don’t need help with are our ‘classsics’ on the book world, EH, NT, skiing and horseriding (waaay to much open air).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Inspectorshar · 16/11/2026 08:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

hppywkndvwhdjjf · 16/11/2026 08:55

LynneEast · 16/11/2026 01:20

When you insultingly say, "pale, male, stale" are you including people like these:

Shakespeare; Joyce; Yeats; Dickens; Keats; Heaney; Wordsworth; Hardy

Chopin; Beethoven; Cage; Debussy; Ravel; Mozart; Schubert; Elgar

Rossetti; Lowry; Monet; Picasso; da Vinci; Rembrandt; Turner; Raphael

I have randomly named 8 each in the categories of Literature, Music and Art; I could easily have named 80!

You insultingly refer to Christianity (American) but anyone who doesn't have a working knowledge of the bible will struggle when it comes to interpretating much of western culture.

So, we have great cause to be be very, very, very grateful to "pale, male and stale" artists who have contributed much to western civilization and, sadly for you, that is just a fact, no matter how much you may search for slim pickings elsewhere.

The fact that you employ some sloppy teenage rhyme to describe them suggests that you neither know, respect or appreciate culture.

How embarrassing for you to have shown your arse in this way, unless of course you are 17 and a half and then, I won't judge you as harshly as you have a long way to go.

Just want to second this.

ArabellaScott · 16/11/2026 09:15

Usernamen · 16/11/2026 03:24

Totally agree with this. Teaching hard knowledge is really out of fashion - everything has to be viewed through the lens of whatever social ills we’re trying to correct in the present. You have to self-educate on the actual facts.

Yes, and has been so for quite some time.

OP would do well to both study historical arcs as much as possible while also reading up on recent/contemporary aspects while bearing in mind the latter is theory, and just what is currently fashionable, despite being presented as the culmination and The Right Side of history.

Self study will probably give you a better education than current institutions, tbh. Although it can be hard to get an overview, at least one starts from the position of knowing one doesn't know much, rather than the assumptions that are apparently baked into so many institutions.

Nettie1964 · 16/11/2026 10:39

I wouldnt advise you to pretend an interest, I know lots of UC people who are absulute philistines. I love opera but the Ballet i find boring and have no interest in. Classical music is fantastic but sometimes I prefer Robbie Williams. Just because you think someone upper class is somehow better than you is sad. Love the things you love admit when you dont know have belief in yourself.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 16/11/2026 10:48

The bible is indeed one of the foundations of western culture - particularly 2nd millennium culture - but it also has strong roots in Greco-Roman history, politics and myths. And back to the Egyptians, Babylonians, and the earliest days of the Fertile Crescent. You leave a massive hole in Shakespeare if you take out the Romams, or in the bible if you remove the Epic of Gilgamesh and the religious reforms of Akenaten. Rameses II gave us Shelley's vast and trunkless legs of stone, and Chuna's Yuan Dynasty provided Coleridge with his vast and stately pleasure dome.

So you need to know about the bible and Christianity to understand Western culture. But you don't need to learn it through a Christian lens. Evangelist and explicitly Christocentric sources often ignore or diminish those other contributions.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 16/11/2026 10:50

Nettie1964 · 16/11/2026 10:39

I wouldnt advise you to pretend an interest, I know lots of UC people who are absulute philistines. I love opera but the Ballet i find boring and have no interest in. Classical music is fantastic but sometimes I prefer Robbie Williams. Just because you think someone upper class is somehow better than you is sad. Love the things you love admit when you dont know have belief in yourself.

You've completely misunderstood the OP.

PotolKimchi · 16/11/2026 11:05

People have given lots of ballet specific advice. I had a pretty MC childhood. I still don't 'get' art. But classical music I now get as both my kids play an instrument so I can tell when something is good.

Go to TwoSet Violin and watch some of their old videos. They demystify some of the stuff around classical music. Make a note of some of the pieces and listen to them. When you are familiar with some music, look to see if there is a concert where you can go and listen to that. It is always easier to sit through a 30 min concerto when you know the piece well.

I love ballet, and there is a wonderful documentary on the making of the Nutcracker somewhere. It will give you an insight into what goes on behind the scenes. It will help you appreciate the craft more.

Also remember you don't just have to enjoy what other people do. There is constantly new stuff happening in ballet, opera or classical music. Chineke! for instance do some interesting programming. Go listen to the National Youth Orchestra maybe?

Another good thing to do is sign up for some guided tours of galleries? You can then figure out what you enjoy and you don't. I like sculpture and installations- traditional art not so much. I like classical music, but not opera. I love watching the ballet. Do you like watching plays? You can watch the National Theatre online at home, and they often have good stuff.

NorWouldTilly · 16/11/2026 11:38

There’s an element of people conflating a passing knowledge of (Western) culture with cultural capital. As in something consciously invested in which can be spent or deployed to further your purposes.

I probably know more about one of the ‘high’ arts this thread has focused on than 99% of the population; fuck all use to me standing in a prep school vestibule waiting for a child whilst all the parents around me discussed, at length, their horses and their last three sailing trips …

WhiteCat13 · 16/11/2026 16:58

Where do you live? I knew nothing about ballet and opera until my husband left to live with his longterm girlfriend (just after lockdowns) and I suddenly found I had spare cash. I have been to the National Ballet and Opera House in Covent Garden quite a few times since, and seen operas where I knew nowt about them. The words are on a screen to read, and the voices are phenomenal. The costs for the cheap seats, where I sit vary from £20 to £30, and while you may not have the best view, you can still experience the opera. I have seen ballet there, but would recommend Sadler's Wells for the ballet. Again, costs are usually around £20 and there isn't a bad seat at Sadler's Wells in my
opinion. Just go to see if you like it. I much prefer plays, operas and ballet, to my ex-husband! But it's not compulsory....

CatesandAle · 16/11/2026 17:51

LynneEast · 16/11/2026 01:20

When you insultingly say, "pale, male, stale" are you including people like these:

Shakespeare; Joyce; Yeats; Dickens; Keats; Heaney; Wordsworth; Hardy

Chopin; Beethoven; Cage; Debussy; Ravel; Mozart; Schubert; Elgar

Rossetti; Lowry; Monet; Picasso; da Vinci; Rembrandt; Turner; Raphael

I have randomly named 8 each in the categories of Literature, Music and Art; I could easily have named 80!

You insultingly refer to Christianity (American) but anyone who doesn't have a working knowledge of the bible will struggle when it comes to interpretating much of western culture.

So, we have great cause to be be very, very, very grateful to "pale, male and stale" artists who have contributed much to western civilization and, sadly for you, that is just a fact, no matter how much you may search for slim pickings elsewhere.

The fact that you employ some sloppy teenage rhyme to describe them suggests that you neither know, respect or appreciate culture.

How embarrassing for you to have shown your arse in this way, unless of course you are 17 and a half and then, I won't judge you as harshly as you have a long way to go.

What is the point of this post? Are you expecting the poster you are responding to to be stunned, shamed and silenced by the breaking news that Shakespeare is a dead white man?

LynneEast · 16/11/2026 18:16

CatesandAle · 16/11/2026 17:51

What is the point of this post? Are you expecting the poster you are responding to to be stunned, shamed and silenced by the breaking news that Shakespeare is a dead white man?

Yes, I am.

I am also expecting her to reflect on why she adopts such a dismissive attitude to dead white men, who were responsible for much of Western culture.

It does rather seem as if it will be breaking news to her or maybe she is trying to imply that a painted boomerang is just as important to Western culture as the works of da Vinci...it's not.

I hope that helps you with your confusion, which is not really disguised by what you clearly think is a witty post...it's not.

HappyHedgehog247 · 16/11/2026 19:01

Radio 4 for current affairs
The Marginalian newsletter for philosophical and literary ideas
Radio 3 for classical music
A broadsheet newspaper every Sunday eg Sunday Times for food and holiday fashions
maybe ask AI what areas of contemporary society you'd like to learn about.
Join your local theatre as a member for a year and see a wide diversity of arts shows
Well done on all you have achieved.

RikthePoet · 16/11/2026 19:27

LynneEast · 16/11/2026 01:20

When you insultingly say, "pale, male, stale" are you including people like these:

Shakespeare; Joyce; Yeats; Dickens; Keats; Heaney; Wordsworth; Hardy

Chopin; Beethoven; Cage; Debussy; Ravel; Mozart; Schubert; Elgar

Rossetti; Lowry; Monet; Picasso; da Vinci; Rembrandt; Turner; Raphael

I have randomly named 8 each in the categories of Literature, Music and Art; I could easily have named 80!

You insultingly refer to Christianity (American) but anyone who doesn't have a working knowledge of the bible will struggle when it comes to interpretating much of western culture.

So, we have great cause to be be very, very, very grateful to "pale, male and stale" artists who have contributed much to western civilization and, sadly for you, that is just a fact, no matter how much you may search for slim pickings elsewhere.

The fact that you employ some sloppy teenage rhyme to describe them suggests that you neither know, respect or appreciate culture.

How embarrassing for you to have shown your arse in this way, unless of course you are 17 and a half and then, I won't judge you as harshly as you have a long way to go.

When you insultingly say, "pale, male, stale" are you including people like these..?

No, I'm not. Those guys are great artists of the past. I referred, very specifically, to the living pale, male, stale faculty of this particular college.

And I specifically referred, not to Christianity (American) but to a specific "American Christian nationalist institution". "American Christian nationalist" is the point - the particular racist, regressive political ideology.

How embarrassing for you to have shown your, as you put it, arse in this way.

RikthePoet · 16/11/2026 19:33

Dinnerontheterrace · 15/11/2026 23:20

Because at the moment, I don’t know of a left-wing site with the same content which is free and so accessible.

Quit clutching your pearls. Hillsdale is fusty, but it’s not MAGA.

”Cultural capital” is context specific. When a person lives in London, the subtext is frankly understanding what used to be called “Western Civilisation.” Just attended opera or ballet is nice but superficial. You need to understand enough of the history, as it was understood until recently, to understand what is going on in the play, or the opera, or the painting, etc.

If a person isn’t lucky enough to learn it over the dinner table, or at a “public school” there are very few places to find it. Declaring the few places left where it can be found is gatekeeping. Shaming people from having the knowledge they need to access the fruits of the culture and society in which they live.

Hillsdale is absolutely MAGA.

Read their series of political pamphlets. All Fox News-style hard right talking points with a veneer of mahogany panelled respectability.

Dinnerontheterrace · 16/11/2026 20:11

I don’t think it is.

It will have Maga people there, so will the University of Texas, or even Harvard.

You seem really worried about people getting information and using their own judgment about whether it has a bias. Most adults are capable of doing this.

You make it seem a lot more subversive and sexy than it is. It’s just old-fashioned.

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 16/11/2026 20:19

“Just because you think someone upper class is somehow better than you is sad”

I don’t

”Love the things you love admit when you dont know have belief in yourself.”

I am confident and do have belief in myself.

I don’t know much about wine and don’t drink enough of it to develop a broad understanding and a very happy discussing with a sommelier their recommendations and those of friends and colleagues.

What I am looking for here is the best ‘how to’ for other aspects of things that I’m finding harder to navigate.

OP posts:
Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 16/11/2026 20:29

“fuck all use to me standing in a prep school vestibule”

presumably a little more use though in other contexts, in decoding the multitude of times and uses in micro parts not in h t e least MN names

OP posts:
RikthePoet · 16/11/2026 20:33

Dinnerontheterrace · 16/11/2026 20:11

I don’t think it is.

It will have Maga people there, so will the University of Texas, or even Harvard.

You seem really worried about people getting information and using their own judgment about whether it has a bias. Most adults are capable of doing this.

You make it seem a lot more subversive and sexy than it is. It’s just old-fashioned.

Yeah, like Jim Crow is just old-fashioned.

Abitofalark · Yesterday 00:20

The phrase is 'male, pale, stale'.

Abitofalark · Yesterday 00:23

I suddenly remembered yesterday that mumsnet has a sub forum called Culture Vultures. It's something I only discovered here very recently and I don't frequent it but it might be a useful source.

shiningcuckoo · Yesterday 01:27

I recommend the book Year of Wonder by Clemency Burton-Hill. I takes you on a classical music journey and there is a Spotify list to accompany the text.

FatCatSkinnyRat · Yesterday 06:55

Dear OP, I have enjoyed this thread, thank you, and I think your efforts mirror mine in a way I have never really stopped to look back on until now. I also grew up devoid of any culture in a foreign country and, through my own interests, am now very well read in literature and have had a passion for the theatre for over 30 years. They bring me such joy I wanted to explore more but did not know where to start. I had tried roaming a bit around art galleries but a picture on its own can only do so much.

A few years ago - when my daughter was studying for her A levels - she recommended AnkiDroid Flash Cards as an app as a way to learn (just the names and artists) of important artworks, including Eastern art and also sculpture. I came from a place of zero knowledge. I agree that in itself it this is just trivia, really.

However what doing 50 of these flash cards per day provided me was an indication of my taste and preferences that then allowed me to explore more outside of the flash cards. I moved to YouTube lectures (such as Great Art Explained) that went in deep to the historical background and context at the time, including symbolism and more about the artist. This is where my knowledge really started to develop!

It is now a passion of mine that I share with my husband by travelling widely to visit exhibitions all over the world. Before each exhibition I am into the deep dive in preparation, reading artist biographies, attending lectures, listening to podcasts etc (am currently preparing for Van Eyck at the National next week!). I love it so much and have developed a passion and an eye and can now look at artworks and make a very good guess as to who the artist is. I am no expert really but art has changed and improved my life immeasurably and I hope you get some ideas from this thread that brings you to this place as well.

Wishing you the best of luck.

ItsOkItsDarkChocolate · Yesterday 07:05

@Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow

The fact that you’re aware of culture capital and making an effort to learn, you have a thirst for knowledge, that’s the main thing.

For me, culture capital is about experiencing a range of things, keeping an open mind, and trying to keep a growth mindset and be curious.

Traveling, and actually experiencing some of the local culture when doing so, their food, their language, trying to imagine what life is life to actually live there.

I’d just like to say though, I feel you may be experiencing a massive dose of FOMO!

Don’t put too much pressure on yourself, life is all about the learning, growth, and there is so much available to us now, we just can’t do it all.

We all have ‘gaps’ and many will never get ‘filled’, that’s what makes us all unique and different, and life interesting.

This seems to be an insecurity about what you feel you are ‘missing’ and don’t ‘understand’ about life. I’d suggest getting more comfortable with that, it just makes you human, not necessarily lacking as a person, regardless of your childhood experience.

And if it’s snobby comments from the higher middle class people that you’re blending in with that’s driving this, then that says more about them than you. My learning observing people in my life is that sometimes the higher up the classes you get, they less compassion and empathy they have. Not all, but certainly for some.

And likewise, had I have read the info about Swanlake before I went to see it, it’d have made more sense! 😂 But there we go.

ItsOkItsDarkChocolate · Yesterday 07:28

@Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow

I’m also now just realising that I’ve maybe not properly understood what the term Culture Capital means either! 😂

I’d only heard the term in my early 30’s, now mid 40’s.

Being cultured can mean different things to different people, I guess that’s the beauty of it.

I think you’re referring to understanding the subtext at times in communication, jokes, or whatever? This may just be about the people you hang about with, but I guess you get a little internal warmth, or sense of satisfaction from it. The danger there is it can create a bit of a those who know and those who don’t attitude. Watch out for that.

I may be thinking of it more in terms of deepening an appreciation for the things I am interested in. For example, I okay the clarinet, not particularly well, but I do. When I hear a piece of music I have also played, I have a deeper connection and appreciation for it than when I haven’t. Just learning an instrument has given me an appreciation for it in general, same for learning another language. It’s not to a particularly good standard and very rusty, but good to do nonetheless.

FOMO is often still not what it’s cracked up to be! 😂

Dinnerontheterrace · Yesterday 08:12

RikthePoet · 16/11/2026 20:33

Yeah, like Jim Crow is just old-fashioned.

No, not like that.

Please link to where they have racist content. I am shocked.

Swipe left for the next trending thread