Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help with cultural capital

322 replies

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 14/11/2026 14:47

Because I genuinely need help navigating this and building my own.
after a childhood in and out of care I have, by a combination of finding good mentors, a voracious reading habit (and ignoring the many, many times this was mocked in various placements) and being in top sets through sheer hard work rather than natural intelligence I have a well respected, aspirational job that I love.
Thanks in no small part to MN I ‘mask’/fit in with the upper middle class around me in clothes, grooming and so forth. I’m not looking to imitate them if that makes sense but instead to navigate my way through what I missed as a child. I know nothing about classical music, opera or art. I am educating myself about philosophy at the moment after an interesting conversation I was part of (well, I didn’t have much to contribute tbh but you get the idea).
I feel like I have a lot of gaps that I want to plug, not because I don’t feel as good as other people more that I want to get behind the curtain and see what’s there.
if anyone has any suggestions about where to start as an adult - for example I have only found kids books describing the ballet for those who don’t know anything about it - navigating any aspect of this, 🙏
I’m happy to watch docs, read, listen. Don’t have limitless time and money but am happy to commit both realistically. The only thing I don’t need help with are our ‘classsics’ on the book world, EH, NT, skiing and horseriding (waaay to much open air).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
godmum56 · Yesterday 09:35

I just looked up the formal definition of cultural capital and it pretty well means what I thought it did, which does not seem to be what the OP wants and which may explain the divergence of the answers on this thread.
www.simplypsychology.org/cultural-capital-theory-of-pierre-bourdieu.html

Key Takeaways

  • Definition: Cultural capital refers to the non-financial social assets – like knowledge, skills, education, and cultural tastes—that influence a person’s status and opportunities in society.
  • Forms: It exists in three forms: embodied (personal traits and knowledge), objectified (cultural goods like books or art), and institutionalized (qualifications or credentials).
  • Impact: These assets can shape how individuals are perceived, how well they navigate social institutions, and their ability to succeed in education or the workplace.
  • Examples: Speaking in an “educated” way, owning classic literature, or holding a university degree are all forms of cultural capital that can open doors in certain social settings.
  • Contrast: Unlike economic capital (money) or social capital (networks), cultural capital is about what you know and how that aligns with what society values.
Floweressences · Yesterday 09:41

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 10:29

FatCatSkinnyRat · Yesterday 06:55

Dear OP, I have enjoyed this thread, thank you, and I think your efforts mirror mine in a way I have never really stopped to look back on until now. I also grew up devoid of any culture in a foreign country and, through my own interests, am now very well read in literature and have had a passion for the theatre for over 30 years. They bring me such joy I wanted to explore more but did not know where to start. I had tried roaming a bit around art galleries but a picture on its own can only do so much.

A few years ago - when my daughter was studying for her A levels - she recommended AnkiDroid Flash Cards as an app as a way to learn (just the names and artists) of important artworks, including Eastern art and also sculpture. I came from a place of zero knowledge. I agree that in itself it this is just trivia, really.

However what doing 50 of these flash cards per day provided me was an indication of my taste and preferences that then allowed me to explore more outside of the flash cards. I moved to YouTube lectures (such as Great Art Explained) that went in deep to the historical background and context at the time, including symbolism and more about the artist. This is where my knowledge really started to develop!

It is now a passion of mine that I share with my husband by travelling widely to visit exhibitions all over the world. Before each exhibition I am into the deep dive in preparation, reading artist biographies, attending lectures, listening to podcasts etc (am currently preparing for Van Eyck at the National next week!). I love it so much and have developed a passion and an eye and can now look at artworks and make a very good guess as to who the artist is. I am no expert really but art has changed and improved my life immeasurably and I hope you get some ideas from this thread that brings you to this place as well.

Wishing you the best of luck.

Edited

To be honest, there are such huge gaps in our learning and education now that the majority of people, even those who are privileged and educated etc will be lacking historical references, knowledge, etc. It's only as you start to look into it as an adult you realise just how little you know.

As pps have said, a reluctance to learn what was considered 'boring' or out of date meant that for a good long time people don't learn much about the arc of history. As an adult you generally have to do the research yourself.

ayesirasponge · Yesterday 10:41

I've enjoyed this thread OP, thank you.

I've been trying to do similar. I'd be considered well educated and have deep knowledge in areas like Science and UK Industry. But I pretty much never learned History. I grew up in an area where most kids would end up in agriculture or practical jobs. We were taught a lot about the lives of ordinary people and farmers in the past, but not the big facts that help anchor and organise an understanding of history.

I'm consciously trying to plug my gaps and have got so much pleasure from doing so. It makes my world richer. I love finding out how everyday sayings or words came into use, and getting to the point where I know enough to make links between books/music/people etc that help me understand more about a period of time and the influences on the people then.

I've found helpful:

  • Classical Education curricula - essentially what you would have learned as a boy at an English boarding school 100 years ago. I find these a great way to find potentially interesting areas to go at, and help organise how to do it.
  • Going down rabbit holes of interest, making links and seeing where it leads rather than trying to do everything at once.
  • Detailed posters of timelines of UK and World history.
  • Making my own timeline list of books I read, composers I listen to etc. so I'm not just enjoying the work but also thinking about what else was happening at the same time, what were they influenced by, who did they influence, who was paying for it.
  • My kids are primary age so I use the topics they are doing as jumping off points for things for me to find out more about. If I then talk to them about them it means I have to really understand them, so I can explain them simply.
  • I've started learning Latin using a primary curriculum (Maximus).
  • DC has started learning an instrument at school which I've also started learning (self taught so all free!). I'm currently learning pieces by Purcell and Bach which has been a great launchpad to find out more about the Baroque period.
  • The Rest is History podcast does a great job of giving an overview of a particular event in history or personality. I enjoy listening to episodes that tie in with whatever area of interest I'm thinking about.
  • Having a bible to hand, and understanding more about the history of the bible. I find now I'm looking things up all the time in it. I'm not religious myself, but so much of our culture is influenced by Christianity.

Thanks also to those who have linked to info on Ambleside Online and Hillsdale curricula. Really interesting despite an American slant (I'm more interested in British/European classical education). I smiled at the instruction to wives in the AO one to defer to your husband in if doubt of what to teach your children!
It's a shame some posters aren't able to see past the religious or political slants of these institutions (real or perceived). Every source has its viewpoint, and will have reasons for providing resources for free. Part of the richness of learning for me is understanding that, putting it in its context, absorbing the knowledge and making my own mind up about it.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 11:37

Yes, I expect a good education woudl start with critical thinking and consideration of sources, bias, and attempting a broad overview. The trouble with blindspots is we aren't aware of them!

AlexandraCarrington · Yesterday 13:20

To be honest, there are such huge gaps in our learning and education....

It's not just learning and education, it's the decline of reading for pleasure, or reading the type of fiction from which we learn stuff, even if some of the books themselves wouldn't be classed as great fiction. Where did many of us first learn about the Anschluss in 1938 Austria, for example. Or the difference between a stalactite and stalagmite. Or how charcoal burners work.

RikthePoet · Yesterday 13:45

Dinnerontheterrace · Yesterday 08:12

No, not like that.

Please link to where they have racist content. I am shocked.

Guess what? They don't have a course called "Why Whites have higher IQs."

They're clearly MAGA from the subjects they cover and the people they feature.

I've given you plenty of examples already. The all white, all male faculty pictured. The far-right talking points. All the talk of the fragility of Western Civilization and how woke values are taking over.

You've been very clear that you're able to spot bias and read between the lines. It's not rocket science! (They don't do rocket science...)

RikthePoet · Yesterday 13:49

AlexandraCarrington · Yesterday 13:20

To be honest, there are such huge gaps in our learning and education....

It's not just learning and education, it's the decline of reading for pleasure, or reading the type of fiction from which we learn stuff, even if some of the books themselves wouldn't be classed as great fiction. Where did many of us first learn about the Anschluss in 1938 Austria, for example. Or the difference between a stalactite and stalagmite. Or how charcoal burners work.

The Anchluss - a French comic book which had reprints of Spider-Man in the front and a European strip called Photonik in the back.

The difference between a stalactite and stalagmite - Five On A Treasure Island.

I don't know how charcoal burners work, or even what they are.

What's your point?

LeedsLoiner · Yesterday 13:52

There's a massive amount of stuff around art, music, and culture on the BBC I Player, go to your local galleries, go to concerts, and always be willing to listen and learn.
And don't worry if you don't like something, everyone has different tastes and tolerances. I personally can't get on with Mahler for example, it just doesn't connect for me, however having put that out there I can expect a few "Mahler is a genius, it's something wrong with you, not him" comments.... 😀

LeedsLoiner · Yesterday 13:59

AlexandraCarrington · Yesterday 13:20

To be honest, there are such huge gaps in our learning and education....

It's not just learning and education, it's the decline of reading for pleasure, or reading the type of fiction from which we learn stuff, even if some of the books themselves wouldn't be classed as great fiction. Where did many of us first learn about the Anschluss in 1938 Austria, for example. Or the difference between a stalactite and stalagmite. Or how charcoal burners work.

Mites go up, tights come down...

Doyouthinkthat · Yesterday 14:28

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Doyouthinkthat · Yesterday 14:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 14:31

AlexandraCarrington · Yesterday 13:20

To be honest, there are such huge gaps in our learning and education....

It's not just learning and education, it's the decline of reading for pleasure, or reading the type of fiction from which we learn stuff, even if some of the books themselves wouldn't be classed as great fiction. Where did many of us first learn about the Anschluss in 1938 Austria, for example. Or the difference between a stalactite and stalagmite. Or how charcoal burners work.

Here's some depressing reading.

https://jmarriott.substack.com/p/the-dawn-of-the-post-literate-society-aa1

The dawn of the post-literate society

And the end of civilisation

https://jmarriott.substack.com/p/the-dawn-of-the-post-literate-society-aa1

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 14:32

LeedsLoiner · Yesterday 13:52

There's a massive amount of stuff around art, music, and culture on the BBC I Player, go to your local galleries, go to concerts, and always be willing to listen and learn.
And don't worry if you don't like something, everyone has different tastes and tolerances. I personally can't get on with Mahler for example, it just doesn't connect for me, however having put that out there I can expect a few "Mahler is a genius, it's something wrong with you, not him" comments.... 😀

No, I'm with you on Mahler, can't fucking stand it.

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · Yesterday 14:50

ArabellaScott · Yesterday 14:32

No, I'm with you on Mahler, can't fucking stand it.

I was mildly amused that someone upthread suggested watching the whole of Wagner’s Ring cycle as an introduction to opera. It’s fair to say that wouldn’t work for everyone. But then it may for OP , who knows?!

ayesirasponge · Yesterday 15:08

AlexandraCarrington · Yesterday 13:20

To be honest, there are such huge gaps in our learning and education....

It's not just learning and education, it's the decline of reading for pleasure, or reading the type of fiction from which we learn stuff, even if some of the books themselves wouldn't be classed as great fiction. Where did many of us first learn about the Anschluss in 1938 Austria, for example. Or the difference between a stalactite and stalagmite. Or how charcoal burners work.

Charcoal burners! Usually called Billy, have an adder in their Teepee. Useful when your brother sprains his ankle...

MellersSmellers · Yesterday 16:41

iPlayer and Spotify podcasts are rich sources of knowledge, as are R4, R3 etc. The Proms are good value for money and museums are free.

But I think you may have an exaggerated view of how much "culture" your typical middle class nuclear family kid is exposed to!
Expand your knowledge if you love learning and exploring, not to just "fit in". Be your authentic self.

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · Yesterday 18:27

I was mildly amused that someone upthread suggested watching the whole of Wagner’s Ring cycle as an introduction to opera. It’s fair to say that wouldn’t work for everyone. But then it may for OP , who knows?!
well it took me a few goes through they video summary and it’s mildly alarming that the ENO is taking 5 years to go through it BUT who knows, it may be fabulous 😬
The ENO sound really welcoming from their blurb for anyone who is joining me in this kind of journey.

OP posts:
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · Yesterday 19:02

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · Yesterday 18:27

I was mildly amused that someone upthread suggested watching the whole of Wagner’s Ring cycle as an introduction to opera. It’s fair to say that wouldn’t work for everyone. But then it may for OP , who knows?!
well it took me a few goes through they video summary and it’s mildly alarming that the ENO is taking 5 years to go through it BUT who knows, it may be fabulous 😬
The ENO sound really welcoming from their blurb for anyone who is joining me in this kind of journey.

If you like it it will be fabulous.
If you don’t, well, the famous quote about Wagner is that he has great moments….and awful half hours.
Deciding what you like and what you don’t will be half the fun of this journey 🙂

FennelSnack · Yesterday 19:48

Opera fans of MN- there is a free stream of the Met's new Lincoln in the Bardo here available until 5am Thursday. I love the novel so really intrigued.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RqtQ162dIqg

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · Today 00:02

ayesirasponge · Yesterday 10:41

I've enjoyed this thread OP, thank you.

I've been trying to do similar. I'd be considered well educated and have deep knowledge in areas like Science and UK Industry. But I pretty much never learned History. I grew up in an area where most kids would end up in agriculture or practical jobs. We were taught a lot about the lives of ordinary people and farmers in the past, but not the big facts that help anchor and organise an understanding of history.

I'm consciously trying to plug my gaps and have got so much pleasure from doing so. It makes my world richer. I love finding out how everyday sayings or words came into use, and getting to the point where I know enough to make links between books/music/people etc that help me understand more about a period of time and the influences on the people then.

I've found helpful:

  • Classical Education curricula - essentially what you would have learned as a boy at an English boarding school 100 years ago. I find these a great way to find potentially interesting areas to go at, and help organise how to do it.
  • Going down rabbit holes of interest, making links and seeing where it leads rather than trying to do everything at once.
  • Detailed posters of timelines of UK and World history.
  • Making my own timeline list of books I read, composers I listen to etc. so I'm not just enjoying the work but also thinking about what else was happening at the same time, what were they influenced by, who did they influence, who was paying for it.
  • My kids are primary age so I use the topics they are doing as jumping off points for things for me to find out more about. If I then talk to them about them it means I have to really understand them, so I can explain them simply.
  • I've started learning Latin using a primary curriculum (Maximus).
  • DC has started learning an instrument at school which I've also started learning (self taught so all free!). I'm currently learning pieces by Purcell and Bach which has been a great launchpad to find out more about the Baroque period.
  • The Rest is History podcast does a great job of giving an overview of a particular event in history or personality. I enjoy listening to episodes that tie in with whatever area of interest I'm thinking about.
  • Having a bible to hand, and understanding more about the history of the bible. I find now I'm looking things up all the time in it. I'm not religious myself, but so much of our culture is influenced by Christianity.

Thanks also to those who have linked to info on Ambleside Online and Hillsdale curricula. Really interesting despite an American slant (I'm more interested in British/European classical education). I smiled at the instruction to wives in the AO one to defer to your husband in if doubt of what to teach your children!
It's a shame some posters aren't able to see past the religious or political slants of these institutions (real or perceived). Every source has its viewpoint, and will have reasons for providing resources for free. Part of the richness of learning for me is understanding that, putting it in its context, absorbing the knowledge and making my own mind up about it.

Alongside the Bible, try Robin Lane Fox's The Unauthorised Version. It examines the historical and archaeological sources that do - or don't - back up the bible stories, and the events going on in the areas at the relevant times. It also looks at the bible as a book - when and where chapters were written and amended, how the canon texts were selected, which were rejected etc. Lots of excellent historical rabbit holes to go down

New posts on this thread. Refresh page