Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help with cultural capital

321 replies

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 14/11/2026 14:47

Because I genuinely need help navigating this and building my own.
after a childhood in and out of care I have, by a combination of finding good mentors, a voracious reading habit (and ignoring the many, many times this was mocked in various placements) and being in top sets through sheer hard work rather than natural intelligence I have a well respected, aspirational job that I love.
Thanks in no small part to MN I ‘mask’/fit in with the upper middle class around me in clothes, grooming and so forth. I’m not looking to imitate them if that makes sense but instead to navigate my way through what I missed as a child. I know nothing about classical music, opera or art. I am educating myself about philosophy at the moment after an interesting conversation I was part of (well, I didn’t have much to contribute tbh but you get the idea).
I feel like I have a lot of gaps that I want to plug, not because I don’t feel as good as other people more that I want to get behind the curtain and see what’s there.
if anyone has any suggestions about where to start as an adult - for example I have only found kids books describing the ballet for those who don’t know anything about it - navigating any aspect of this, 🙏
I’m happy to watch docs, read, listen. Don’t have limitless time and money but am happy to commit both realistically. The only thing I don’t need help with are our ‘classsics’ on the book world, EH, NT, skiing and horseriding (waaay to much open air).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Keepingongoing · 14/11/2026 16:53

Igneococcus · 14/11/2026 16:00

Someone else mentioned Radio 3 already. Radio 3 is a fantastic resource. There is a series ongoing at the moment called Key Changes: Radio 3's Essential History of Classical Music (new episode every Saturday 1pm, but all previous ones available on BBC Sounds), it's excellent and gives a lot of historical context to new developments in music.
Also on Saturdays is Building a library where some expert talks through their favourite recording of a piece of classical music. I've learned more about music from listening to this regularly than from any other source.

I was coming on to say much the same thing. Radio 3 is probably unique in the world and it’s totally free. In addition to the programs mentioned, I absolutely loved The Listening Service with Tom Service who’s a classical music broadcaster. It’s a discussion of themes in classical music and is very wide ranging. I say ‘loved’ because The Listening Service isn’t being made any more, but you can find all the past episodes on BBC Sounds. Tom Service now does a 3 hours of music and discussion on Saturday mornings and it’s a nice introduction. Programmes like BBC Young musician of the year can also be very approachable and informative.

One other thing - the Open University does short courses, totally free, and some probably cover arty subjects. Look for OpenLearn.

It’s a lovely project to have OP, I hope you will enjoy it. I took some people to a classical concert once, they were newcomers to classical music and it was great fun.

LumberPainJackie · 14/11/2026 16:53

How did you go about learning Classics OP? I ask because usually that is a course not offered in State schools, so if you had the momentum to self learn that, the depth and volume being what it is, I would say you already have a fair amount of cultural capital. I did well at GCSE and A level Classical Civilisation and still don't feel I know the topic as well as others. I say this to more emphasise the point that there is no end to these subjects and you will always find someone willing to show you up or out quote you, or generally try to make you feel inadequate in some way. I think it is often more important to recognise that in others as a personality defect and step away from them, rather than to try to know more than everyone else about everything. Don't set yourself up to fail if there is a person you are trying to impress who delights in making you feel bad. I had a parent like this and a lifetime of achievements has done nothing to make them less disappointed.

If you live in London all of the suggestions above are worthwhile. I would also add the V&A for variations and the wonderful Netflix show Secrets of The Museum for some fun watching and appreciation of the little things that aren't always centre stage but really give you a feel for a time period.

Octavia64 · 14/11/2026 16:54

Some classical concerts do talks before about the music.

there’s also concerts aimed at children and families which are a mix of talking about the music and playing it.

https://lpo.org.uk/project/funharmonics/

we took our kids to loads of these when they were young.

opera and ballet are much more of a specialist taste. You can get fairly cheap seats at some opera venues and there are touring operas as well. Opera like theatre largely splits into tragedy and comedy.

you’ll never follow the plot of either but it doesn’t really matter. I personally have seen and liked Aida and Madame butterfly (same story as Miss Saigon) and La boheme (same story as rent the musical).

lots of operas are also plays - Macbeth, etc etc. if not sure of the opera look at the play.

i personally avoid ballet like the plague. My dd loved it as a child and I find it incredibly boring.

if you do want to try to see some then the royal opera house have a smaller stage where they do some shorter (less tedious) pieces that are often more modern.

TheBlueKoala · 14/11/2026 16:57

@Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow I would say listen to some Mozart, Chopin, Beethoven on youtube and see if you like it first. Then you can move forward. Same with art; go to a museum and see if something moves you. Look up some contemporary art on Internet. See if something strikes a chord. Same for ballet/dance/theater.

Honestly, if nothing above moves you then it's fine. I was brought up in a high cultural capital (not wealthy) thanks to my mum who worked with and was passionate about it. But I am not like her at all. Most art leaves me numb. Strongly dislike ballet and opera and I'm very picky about theatre and films.

All the highbrow things you are supposed to like are mostly performatively adorsed by aspirational, insecure people who really don't give a shit. And then we got some like my mother but they are a minority. Just like you I love litterature ; reading has shaped the person I am and it's my go to place where I feel safe. You must be very passionate about reading since you stuck with it besides being put down for liking it so why don't you just embrace that? Also you get many cultural references from litterature so why don't yoy start looking those up every time you stumble on them? That way you broaden your horizon while doing something you love. X

MrsMitford3 · 14/11/2026 16:57

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 14/11/2026 15:29

I would just ask a friend if they fancy a trip to the ballet but I wouldn’t go out of my way to try to read up about stuff just to fit in
not being snarky but it’s not about fitting in, it’s about wanting to know what I don’t. I went to see Swam Lake and enjoyed it but without the lady behind me explaining it to her little one I wouldn’t have got as much out of it as I did for example. That seemed to me to be a good example of the difference between being able to appreciate it be a you know about it and watching what was objectively beautiful but a little confusing.

DH and I love the theatre and have seen a lot-I love musicals as well as straight plays.

I have seen a lot of Shakespeare and really enjoy it but even if I know the play I read up on it before hand-I find it helps me immerse myself and follow along better in the moment as there are so many interpretations etc

There are also lots of podcasts that you can experiment with as you find areas that you are enjoying-

And lots of ppl blag and exaggerate their knowledge so don't always assume everyone else knows more than you!!

Puffykins · 14/11/2026 16:59

There was an important break in art with the Impressionists and the Post-Impressionists (so from the end of the 19th century onwards) when the narrative of a painting became less important than the colours and shapes and general composition - and the leading art critics of the day encouraged people to just stand in front of them and see how you felt - and I honestly think that’s all you need to do. You’ll start noticing the names of the artists you like - and you can read up about their lives if you want to - and then you can, if you’re interested, work backwards to what came before, and then before that etc. I don’t know where you are based, but the National Gallery has a really good (free) collection of Impressionism and Post-Impressionism. And ballet - well, it’s really just if you like watching it or not. I could watch Manon/ Giselle/ the Nutcracker/ Swan Lake forever, but I wouldn’t say that I know lots. The Royal Opera House, where the Royal Ballet performs, has some very cheap seats…

Octavia64 · 14/11/2026 17:01

Some cinemas also show films of current or past ballets or shows.

royal ballet are screening Alice in wonderland in Feb
https://www.rbo.org.uk/production/alices-adventures-in-wonderland-christopher-wheeldon?mode=cinema

and the national theatre regularly do this I saw Andrew Scott’s amazing one man Chekhov last year.

if you are looking at going in person Wednesday matinees have the cheapest tickets and January and Feb is usually not so busy.

Alice's Adventures in Wonderland

Find out about Alice's Adventures in Wonderland at the Royal Ballet and Opera.

https://www.rbo.org.uk/production/alices-adventures-in-wonderland-christopher-wheeldon?mode=cinema

Legolasses · 14/11/2026 17:02

@HedgerowD people don’t feel self conscious around real friends.

accidentalmillionaire · 14/11/2026 17:07

Listen to Radio 3 and 4. But also don’t worry. You’ve obviously done brilliantly and are super bright.
my DH went to a crap comp (the same as mine in fact!), got a first at Oxford and a PhD. And knows nothing about classical music etc . But he is curious and asks questions and can dissect an argument better than most opera buffs!
jist keep doing what you’re doing. You sound like my kind of person!

MoralOrLegal · 14/11/2026 17:07

There has been some great advice on this thread, and the OP might decide that these art-forms aren't for her... but she won't know until she tries, right? I sometimes feel completely at sea if conversations turn to pop culture, celebrities, or sport... so I've dipped my toe in and found some things I enjoy in those alien realms. It's much the same thing, I think!

Ponderingwindow · 14/11/2026 17:07

This may be my implicit capital, but I don’t believe these areas have that much importance in society anymore. They are niche interests. I would not discourage you from exploring the arts, but a better understanding of opera or ballet is not going to help you fit in.

I believe the easiest way to “plug the gap” would be following a course on the history of western civilization. If you have spent time surveying philosophy you have already begun this path. A western civilization course will also give you a summary of religions, politics, and major world events taught specifically from the perspective of how those things influence the society we live in today. There is bias in saying that western civilization is more important and that has become a bit controversial. However, we are speaking about the most direct impact on the society you are operating within on a day to day basis, so I think focusing on western civilization is fair.

Malbecfan · 14/11/2026 17:08

Good for you OP!

I've spent the last 32 years teaching Music in mostly secondary schools. Lots of kids have come in with preconceptions that "classical music is not for me". But with careful choices of music, I have invariably won the vast majority of them round to liking some serious music.

I second the suggestions of BBC Radio 3 and 4. The breakfast show on R3 tends to have a variety of shorter pieces, so if you don't like something, it won't last for long! Similarly with Classic FM, although the adverts and lack of knowledge of some of the presenters can be really annoying.

Something not mentioned upthread is on the BBC education website: 10 Pieces https://www.bbc.co.uk/teach/ten-pieces
It is into its next incarnation, but all the previous pieces are there. Don't be put off by the enthusiastic presenters; they explain parts of the piece to grab the attention of their young listeners then have a decent performance of the whole work or section. I taught a 6 week unit in a very mixed primary school based on the Ravi Shankar piece on there. The kids absolutely loved it and I got brownie points for tying my work in with their topic work.

Even as a decent musician, there are composers and pieces that I really don't like. It's fine to dislike something. When I was younger, I thought Mozart was too simplistic. Now I love how pared back everything is and for me, he's probably the most challenging composer to play well as there is simply nowhere to hide. Even in my late 50s I am still making discoveries.

Finally, lots of amateur groups are coming up to their end of term concerts. They might not be as high quality as professional gigs but will probably be cheaper and you will be supporting local groups. The orchestra I play in has excellent programme notes about each piece so you can follow along. Traditionally you don't applaud between sections/movements of the same piece, but I don't mind if people do - it shows they are really enjoying the music. Have fun and let us know what you discover.

Logo for Teach

BBC Ten Pieces

BBC Ten Pieces opens up the world of classical music to 7-14 year olds. Explore our exciting films, lesson plans and instrumental arrangements.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/teach/ten-pieces

TheKindnessProject · 14/11/2026 17:08

This is really interesting and resonated with me. I didn't grow up in care, but I did have an adverse childhood, and although I had access to education, I had very little social or cultural capital. When I entered a middle-class profession, I became increasingly aware of this and spent much of my twenties consciously broadening my knowledge of literature, philosophy, classical music, and history.

It's taken me years to recognise that my understanding of cultural capital was largely modelled on the knowledge and interests of a particular social class, and that I had sl8ghtly unconsciously positioned as somehow superior to my own background. I don't regret any of that learning but I've become more interested in examining why I privileged certain forms of knowledge over others, and how much of that was driven by a desire to position myself as 'better' than I had been.

I still want to develop my cultural capital, but I'm increasingly interested in questioning who gets to define it, and in pursuing knowledge for its intellectual value rather than its social currency.

I'm not making any assumptions about your motivations or suggesting that your thinking mirrors mine, and there's certainly no judgement intended. I just thought I'd share my own experience in case it's of interest.

idontknowhowtodreamyourdreams · 14/11/2026 17:09

RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 14:52

Listen to BBC Radio 3. See if you like the music.

In 2026, you don't need to have to a vast knowledge of classical music to be culturally literate.

I think it's a huge waste of your time to try and develop an interest in something you don't like.

This. Focus on the things you actually like. If you don’t like classical music, don’t bother just for the sake of it! Life is way too short.

Maybe you prefer theatre/the “literary canon”/art?

Namechangefordaughterevasion · 14/11/2026 17:12

I think you are underestimating yourself. No one knows everything about every field of art. And not everyone will enjoy every sort of art.

You say you read a lot so you probably know more about literature/popular fiction than a lot of people. You do a lot of sports and very middle class sports too so that's cementing your place in the circles you move in. You are probably absolutely enough just as you are.

My working class parents loved ballet, jazz and art so I was exposed to a lot of all three but as I grew up I realised I didn't share their passions. My tastes are for straight plays, heavy rock and reading. Perhaps not as highbrow as my aspirational parents preferences but they make me happy and I'm confident of my opinions in those areas.

when conversation moves to anything I don't know about I'm happy to admit my ignorance and equally, when it moves to something I do know about I join in enthusiastically.

Like you, despite my background, I'm well educated and for also some reason very well spoken so people assume I'm posher than I am. It's sometimes fun to confound them by letting them know where I grew up/went to school etc.

HedgerowD · 14/11/2026 17:13

Legolasses · 14/11/2026 17:02

@HedgerowD people don’t feel self conscious around real friends.

That isn't true. Plenty of people feel self conscious around good friends. Its different to worrying about being judged.

I remember attending drinks after work and someone made a joke comparing something to Jackson Pollocks artwork. Everyone laughed so I just joined in and felt really thick. No one there would have judged me.

There are so many references to classic literature, art etc all around us. And for a significant amount of people its just general knowledge. They aren't being pretentious, its just assumed that everyone knows.

Cycleaway · 14/11/2026 17:13

There is a programme on r4 called Add to Playlist, where four musicians have to choose pieces of music that have some kind of link to the previous piece. The tracks they pick are really diverse, and the musicians explain the technical elements of the music in really interesting and understandable ways. There are loads of series available to listen to on BBC sounds. I think this would be a really good starting point to learn a lot about about lots of genres of music

MyCatPrefersPeaches · 14/11/2026 17:16

AveragePotato · 14/11/2026 15:16

Set yourself a challenge to do something completely new to you every month. Not just opera and ballet, but the theatre, a wine tasting night, foreign cinema, try out ballroom dancing, line dancing, an art class.

The more you expose yourself to, the more interesting you are to others, and the more likely you are to hit on something you really love.

If you have money and time, the first year of the OU's general arts degree is really interesting (albeit a lot more expensive than it was before uni fees increased). Or, the OU and maybe a local uni also, offer free lectures on all sorts of interesting subjects.

I really love this as a suggestion. For ballet and opera, you can often watch the Royal Opera House performances at local cinemas if the real thing is too far.

For classical music, I learned an awful lot through piano lessons with a teacher who was truly passionate about educating children and had little stories about all the composers. I also really enjoy Desert Island Discs and a lot of the interviewees select classical pieces.

To explore it in an educational sense, as well as radio selections, you could pick a composer from each century or musical period (eg Baroque/Romantic) and listen to a few different pieces of theirs. Or you could pick a few different composers from particular countries (appreciating borders have changed and people moved around). For example, if you listen to piano sonatas and so on by Mozart (18th century) and Clementi (similar time period), and then move on to someone like Liszt or Rachmaninov (19th century), or Chopin, you’ll hear a big difference in the music.

Or you could pick a book set in a historical era and try to find the music those characters would have listened to (the 1996 TV version of Pride and Prejudice would be a good one for this as it has both music that people would have danced to, and piano music that ladies would have performed as entertainment) and do a bit of research around it.

I appreciate that the above are quite random ideas but I think it’s more fun to follow your interests than to just pick up a book!

Puffykins · 14/11/2026 17:16

Sorry - I just saw that you’ve seen Swan Lake and enjoyed it, but also enjoyed hearing more about the story etc. I always google the story first - and then I’ve realised that I will have seen ballets with the same composer (so Tchaikovsky also did Sleeping Beauty and Nutcracker) - or, for instance choreographer - I love Kenneth Macmillan’s ballets which are emotionally intense and often have extraordinary pas de deux - his Romeo & Juliet, Manon and Mayerling are all still performed by the Royal Ballet. I also follow a whole host of Royal Ballet soloists on Instagram - I still don’t know much, I just love it.

And it sort of ties into my job (I’m an art historian) as quite a few artists have designed sets and costumes for ballet, which is another angle you could take as a direction of finding out more.

RowanWi · 14/11/2026 17:19

For classical music generally this is a lovely book https://www.amazon.co.uk/YEAR-WONDER-Classical-Music-Every/dp/1472252306/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2IJBVIK8N520W&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.svFSjh53NGErIpS-3p58slv6XxZRCCGNSZk1yK5W0UQ7LKjiAbTjdMQCHTHzSUld0rHMZCOSuygLhSqKZAbKGeB207CFRTesjCp3S3Koj8pMX7anT3B8iXIRBkufQZdx6vPhbkT_ABSMog_Gx1eFAwPSViS2qPEJYDHW2umoSv4kcOPOMk48MLhriv852Kmx-hPSIZ4A_VlmTjvLVTNJtvmMHpCtJsoxN5gplY-9XT0.WOnXnetQt23IfMoZuZDRb3WPuCztE7XLkAcDgjf_FSc&dib_tag=se&keywords=classical+music+everyday&qid=1794675848&sprefix=classical+music+everyday%2Caps%2C122&sr=8-1

Something to listen to every day with a good explanation- it will help you dip your toe into all sorts of classical music and see what you might like. You can also do this just by sticking Radio 3 on in the morning and note it down if you hear something you like. Classical music is a huge and varied thing- you probably won't like it all but equally you probably will like some of it, and that can lead you onto other things.

Opera/ballet- the cinema relays are a good way to dip a toe in without breaking the bank. https://www.rbo.org.uk/tickets-and-events?venue=cinema-broadcasts&page=1

For ballet, there will be Nutcracker screenings next month- a nice easy festive way in. You don't need to know anything about it to enjoy it. In fact anything here (ballet or opera) would be good to see (with the exception of Götterdämmerung which is the last part of a four part work so you'll be a bit lost- also musically not the easiest). The Tosca production is excellent- I saw it last year (or was it this year?) with Netrebko- would definitely recommend. For a complete contrast you could try Cosi Fan Tutte as well. Nothing beats going in the flesh but it's not always easy depending on where you live and can be expensive.

I wouldn't think in terms of plugging gaps/cultural capital but instead just exploring to see what you like and letting it grow organically.

Amazon

Amazon

https://www.amazon.co.uk/YEAR-WONDER-Classical-Music-Every/dp/1472252306/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2IJBVIK8N520W&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.svFSjh53NGErIpS-3p58slv6XxZRCCGNSZk1yK5W0UQ7LKjiAbTjdMQCHTHzSUld0rHMZCOSuygLhSqKZAbKGeB207CFRTesjCp3S3Koj8pMX7anT3B8iXIRBkufQZdx6vPhbkT_ABSMog_Gx1eFAwPSViS2qPEJYDHW2umoSv4kcOPOMk48MLhriv852Kmx-hPSIZ4A_VlmTjvLVTNJtvmMHpCtJsoxN5gplY-9XT0.WOnXnetQt23IfMoZuZDRb3WPuCztE7XLkAcDgjf_FSc&dib_tag=se&keywords=classical%20music%20everyday&qid=1794675848&sprefix=classical%20music%20everyday%2Caps%2C122&sr=8-1&tag=mumsnet&ascsubtag=mnforum-am-i-being-unreasonable-5599624-to-ask-for-help-with-cultural-capital

Abitofalark · 14/11/2026 17:20

OP, I don't understand your final sentence.
That aside I am happy to mention some music I like and would suggest an immediate starter on opera with the Radio 3 broadcast of Mozart's Don Giovanni this evening from 6 o'clock. I love love love Mozart and Don G is great. There are other composers I love as well and have many favourite arias from opera.

Radio 3 broadcasts live or recorded opera performances every Saturday evening so tune in and see what you like. It's not every opera I like and nor will you. I can offer more suggestions for operas or arias or singers I like, if you want. I'm no kind of expert and not even very knowledgeable but just love music, and not only classical either. You have the world of music at your fingertips with youtube and I take full advantage of that.

napody · 14/11/2026 17:22

Dinnerontheterrace · 14/11/2026 15:36

I think a lot of “cultural capital” now is knowing the western tradition. This isn’t taught in a straight forward way in state schools or universities anymore, but somehow posh people know it. Perhaps it’s through family or private schools who go outside the curriculum. What really marks people out is knowing the straight facts about Roman History, or what Kant said, or the sequence of WWII, etc. without Marxists spin or current social justice theory. Real sophistication is knowing the classic position and understanding the current fashionable, political overlay.

I am not a conservative Christian, but a good place to find free online courses that are very entertaining is here:

https://online.hillsdale.edu

Just skip all the US history. I personally think the bible stuff is useful from a cultural point of view because our traditions rest on it. It’s foundational to so much western art and literature. But you can skip it too, there is plenty to trawl though. I listened to the Odyssey series after the film came out, and I found it interesting and enjoyable.

I totally agree with this.
I'd add things like fairy tales and the bible stories that used to be told at school. So much art and modern literature nods to these cultural references. It's not really about buying tickets to things. Bbc podcasts and documentaries are great. Even the likes of horrible histories is a way in!

Solasum · 14/11/2026 17:22

@RowanWi I was just about to recommend the same book. OP, it is a really easy way to hear new things. I used to listen while cleaning my teeth. There will be some pieces you like and others that are meh. Mark the ones you like and then later you can listen to more of that composer or style.

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · 14/11/2026 17:24

There is no need for you to develop an interest in the arts with a capital 'A' if you you're not already interested in them. If you are, then fine.

B0D · 14/11/2026 17:26

“In our time” Radio 4. Loads of fascinating topics and very accessible

Swipe left for the next trending thread