Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help with cultural capital

322 replies

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 14/11/2026 14:47

Because I genuinely need help navigating this and building my own.
after a childhood in and out of care I have, by a combination of finding good mentors, a voracious reading habit (and ignoring the many, many times this was mocked in various placements) and being in top sets through sheer hard work rather than natural intelligence I have a well respected, aspirational job that I love.
Thanks in no small part to MN I ‘mask’/fit in with the upper middle class around me in clothes, grooming and so forth. I’m not looking to imitate them if that makes sense but instead to navigate my way through what I missed as a child. I know nothing about classical music, opera or art. I am educating myself about philosophy at the moment after an interesting conversation I was part of (well, I didn’t have much to contribute tbh but you get the idea).
I feel like I have a lot of gaps that I want to plug, not because I don’t feel as good as other people more that I want to get behind the curtain and see what’s there.
if anyone has any suggestions about where to start as an adult - for example I have only found kids books describing the ballet for those who don’t know anything about it - navigating any aspect of this, 🙏
I’m happy to watch docs, read, listen. Don’t have limitless time and money but am happy to commit both realistically. The only thing I don’t need help with are our ‘classsics’ on the book world, EH, NT, skiing and horseriding (waaay to much open air).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
MoralOrLegal · 15/11/2026 11:23

CatesandAle · 15/11/2026 11:22

OP I’m sorry you are having to repeat yourself so many times about your totally reasonable and valid reasons for posting this thread!

It's almost as if posters don't read updates from the OP! Cultural Capital means spotting the Shakespeare reference in your username, for instance. Very virtuous of you.

Abitofalark · 15/11/2026 11:39

Ska, ah...one of my all time favourite records is Knock on Wood. Eddie Floyd. I never tire of listening to it. Also found a recording by the Sweet Inspirations. Love listening to different versions of a song or finding out the history of it. I think of it as blue beat, not sure of the different genres: ska, blue beat, easy beat but that rhythm catches you from the opening chord and is irresistible.

ColinISabirthdaycake · 15/11/2026 11:53

SuddenDaredJelly · 15/11/2026 11:15

Cultural capital doesn't have to mean traditionally "elitist" pursuits like opera & equestrian sports. It just means having some breadth of knowledge & hobbies that make you more interesting as a person. It just needs to be hobbies/interests that require slightly more effort as opposed to things you just "passively consume" like watching tv or listening to pop music.

Eg. It doesnt need to be opera or classical music. It could be singing in a choir, playing in a jazz band, being part of a steel drums group. My great uncle was part of a works brass band.

It doesnt have to be ballet. It could be modern dance like mark morris, or the matthew bourne edwards scissorhands production, or an adult tap or contemporary class.

It doesnt have to be high brow theatre, it could be comedy shows.

There are watercolour or oil painting or pottery classes, book clubs.

It might be taking your kids to a hockey club & volunteering. Its sticking with something long enough to build a bit more knowledge and skill

Yes. I was thinking about this thread again and I think you actually stand out more if you do something different to the norm and which isn't cliched.

An example might be going to Kent or Warwickshire on holiday, instead of Cornwall. Lots to see and do, but not the middle class cliche.

It's about having something different to talk about, if asked.

Soontobe60 · 15/11/2026 11:54

MoralOrLegal · 15/11/2026 09:46

If OP had asked about football, would you have asked why not opera?

My comment was about why the op only asked about highbrow things as if other things are beneath her.

ColinISabirthdaycake · 15/11/2026 11:58

Soontobe60 · 15/11/2026 11:54

My comment was about why the op only asked about highbrow things as if other things are beneath her.

In my first comment I said that the "low" brow things like football can be more expensive to go to than the "high" brow things.

I saw someone had mentioned concerts in churches - that's such a good idea - they are often free or very low priced and can be really good. I sadly don't live somewhere where I can easily get to one. Someone said on the retirement thread that it's easier to do things in a city or large town and it's true - I don't live that far from London but trains home at night are an issue. A lunchtime concert at a lovely Baroque church is a great way to get some culture! I'll have to go when I am in London for work.

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 15/11/2026 11:59

MoralOrLegal · 15/11/2026 11:23

It's almost as if posters don't read updates from the OP! Cultural Capital means spotting the Shakespeare reference in your username, for instance. Very virtuous of you.

I didn’t get this when I read your post and wondered if you were being…off but it didn’t fit with what you were saying. Now I’ve looked it up and understood you weren’t mocking in your use of the word virtuous I understand your joke and that of the pp. I’m actively building my cultural capital on MN on a Sunday morning 🙏

edited for awful typos

OP posts:
MoralOrLegal · 15/11/2026 12:09

Soontobe60 · 15/11/2026 11:54

My comment was about why the op only asked about highbrow things as if other things are beneath her.

I'm reminded of the dispute between two forms of Utilitarianism. Jeremy Bentham maintained that anything that gives pleasure is good, and indeed that's what "good" means. A generation later, JS Mill disagreed, ranking pleasures by intellectual content (he called them "higher and lower pleasures"); otherwise, he thundered, "push-pin were as good as poetry." (He also claimed that it was better to be Socrates and unhappy, than a pig and happy.) Mill's extended essay, "Utilitarianism," is a good place to start an investigation of moral philosophy, as it happens.

I tend to agree with you, and with Bentham, to be honest! Whatever floats your boat. But the OP already knows about the things you suggested, and was asking for specific help. If I'd posted asking how to get into football, I'd be annoyed by folk telling me that I shouldn't dismiss singing because of preconceptions.

RikthePoet · 15/11/2026 12:25

Dinnerontheterrace · 15/11/2026 10:32

Why do you think it is “extreme right wing views”? Please explain this to me?

I think you are being silky and making sweeping assumptions here. But it could be you are basing this on something that I am not aware of.

The language on that site is not just the language of pompous American academia, it's the language of MAGA authoritarianism, heavily conservative, regressive, racist, sexist etc.

Take this:

Our courses are created for every American who wishes to embark upon a life-changing education in the greatest ideas and texts of Western Civilization. The only requirements are a desire for truth and a love of liberty.

Anyone capitalising "Western Civilization" is specifically positioning their institution against Islam, communism, Maoism...

They have a line of internal publications where they publish the thoughts of far-right "intellectuals" on subjects including immigration (against), democratic socialism (against), Europe (against), vaccination (uncommitted).

shop.hillsdale.edu/en-gb/products/are-we-subjects-or-citizens-birthright-citizenship-and-the-constitution

They eulogise the late white Christian ethno-nationslist Charlie Kirk, with abhorrent views on race, religion, women etc (He said a ten year old girl who had been raped and got pregnant should carry the baby to term, and that he wouldn't want to fly in a plane with a black pilot.)

online.hillsdale.edu/paths/promo/the-charlie-kirk-path

They name a dozen tutors on their course page. All men. There are pictures of 8/9 of them. All white men.

Watch the trailer for their course American Citizenship and its Decline, which begins with the words: "When you have these woke revolutions, it requires all of us to say "No. Not gonna do this.""

This is not an unbiased education in civics, this is neo-con right-wing conspiracy theory.

The guest speaker at their conference on Sovereignty and the Nation State? Introduced with "Our speaker tonight is a very remarkable human being..." Nigel Farage!

This is not some great resource of unbiased historical truth. It is a deeply partisan white Christian nationalist institution, on the side of power, the patriarchy and guns.

SaySomethingMan · 15/11/2026 12:28

Nobody’s success is only down to hard work when it comes to academics, there’s always an element of natural ability.
e.g if there’s a learning difficulty in there, “sheer hard word” won’t cut it.

Dinnerontheterrace · 15/11/2026 12:37

Ah, gotcha @RikthePoet m

I did say ignore the US stuff. I really think the classics and ancient history is absolutely fine.

I also think intelligent adults can entertain ideas and be exposed to to ideas without accepting them.

Charlie Kirk was not my cup of tea, but I think it was horrific that he was shot. I do believe in free speech and open debate.

Effectively, I think cultural capital is knowing all sides of the argument, the historical evolution of attitudes, and not just approved narratives.

Abitofalark · 15/11/2026 13:00

The philosopher Bertrand Russell was one of the most interesting people for the life that he had and the many was in which he changed throughout. His early life was lonely and difficult to say the least as he suffered from the loss of parents.

He was a lucid writer, unlike some philosophers (no shortage to pick from), probably because he was originally a mathematician. Some few people are gifted at both mathematics and literary arts. Lord Denning was another of those, a child of humble country origin, originally graduating in maths and then law on which he wrote books with a characteristic lightness of touch.

One summer I took Russell's tome A History of Western Philosophy on holiday to France. I also read books of his essays: On Marriage and Morals was one I remember. They were never less than interesting. (I am still trying to read Karl Popper's The Open Society and its Enemies. Will I ever manage it?) He was a radical and activist campaigner on the left and established a sort of revolutionary school which was run on principles of freedom rather than traditional rigid rules and discipline.

RikthePoet · 15/11/2026 13:03

Dinnerontheterrace · 15/11/2026 12:37

Ah, gotcha @RikthePoet m

I did say ignore the US stuff. I really think the classics and ancient history is absolutely fine.

I also think intelligent adults can entertain ideas and be exposed to to ideas without accepting them.

Charlie Kirk was not my cup of tea, but I think it was horrific that he was shot. I do believe in free speech and open debate.

Effectively, I think cultural capital is knowing all sides of the argument, the historical evolution of attitudes, and not just approved narratives.

Well, I don't know exactly how their work on, say, Ancient Greek myth is framed, but I can imagine it mediated through right-wing ideas of empire, the rights of kings, religion, strong man narratives etc.

Yes, it's good to develop the cultural capital to be able to see all sides of the argument, what makes a source biased etc. But I don't think the best way to develop that is to learn the history of western thought from a hardline conservative/MAGA agenda.

(And I also don't believe we should go around shooting political opponents. That doesn't make Charlie Kirk's views any less abhorrent.)

MoralOrLegal · 15/11/2026 13:04

Abitofalark · 15/11/2026 13:00

The philosopher Bertrand Russell was one of the most interesting people for the life that he had and the many was in which he changed throughout. His early life was lonely and difficult to say the least as he suffered from the loss of parents.

He was a lucid writer, unlike some philosophers (no shortage to pick from), probably because he was originally a mathematician. Some few people are gifted at both mathematics and literary arts. Lord Denning was another of those, a child of humble country origin, originally graduating in maths and then law on which he wrote books with a characteristic lightness of touch.

One summer I took Russell's tome A History of Western Philosophy on holiday to France. I also read books of his essays: On Marriage and Morals was one I remember. They were never less than interesting. (I am still trying to read Karl Popper's The Open Society and its Enemies. Will I ever manage it?) He was a radical and activist campaigner on the left and established a sort of revolutionary school which was run on principles of freedom rather than traditional rigid rules and discipline.

Edited

He was also JS Mill's godson!

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 15/11/2026 13:22

I think find something that genuinely interests you, having 50 shallow interests is not really that useful.
For me it became theatre, but I also don't think I need to pretend I know the history of theatre in detail to know what I enjoy. I make sure I watch a range of plays, from ones I know I will love to some that I know I may not or which will be challenging. I read around subjects of some of the plays, I watch a few theatre reviewers, chat with people online, looking at recommendations of things to come.

bourdieusucks · 15/11/2026 13:32

I’m sorry you feel the need to even attempt to fit in with a class for which you were not prescribed. I understand why, being a working class academic and occasionally feeling out of place but it’s still quite sad.

Oh god I couldn't disagree more... 'a class for which you were not prescribed'?!

We get to choose how we develop our interests! I know more about some genres than others but know enough about heavy metal to know that the best is really great - I don't think there are objective cultural hierarchies.

But there are some forms that are just harder work to get into and enjoy, and - that's okay. They're not for everyone. I've never got into soccer, and also think that's okay, though am able to say something intelligent when needed. It's not compulsory to like it!

It's great to have breadth, it's great to be open, but it's also a great thing to have special interests if that's the kind of stimulation your brain needs.

And whoever described classical music/opera as 'upper class' should look at what upper class people actually do in their spare time.

We're never going to know everything that it's valuable to know, and we're always works-in-progress.

But there's a capacity called 'integrative complexity' which we should all strive for. The short version is that we can develop the capacity to go anywhere, try everything, and appreciate people and cultures on their own terms, while still being ourselves.

Usernamen · 15/11/2026 13:48

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 15/11/2026 11:59

I didn’t get this when I read your post and wondered if you were being…off but it didn’t fit with what you were saying. Now I’ve looked it up and understood you weren’t mocking in your use of the word virtuous I understand your joke and that of the pp. I’m actively building my cultural capital on MN on a Sunday morning 🙏

edited for awful typos

Edited

Nothing better than building your cultural capital on a Sunday!

I’m going to a documentary screening later today with Q&A with the documentary makers. It’s a bit pricey at £16pp for what is essentially a cinema ticket, but it looks very interesting. I’ll report back!

Great thread btw.

Pollyanna87 · 15/11/2026 15:12

There are good quality YouTube videos that explain the basics of opera, other art forms, historical periods etc. You might find that you simply don’t like some things you feel you’re ‘meant’ to like, and that’s perfectly fine.

Pollyanna87 · 15/11/2026 15:15

Might sound like a bit of an odd suggestion in 2026, but reading broadsheets (with the supplements) is a goldmine for cultural capital. I used to read the broadsheets every day in the school library and I feel like they taught me an immeasurable amount.

Pansykavalier · 15/11/2026 16:09

Dinnerontheterrace · 15/11/2026 12:37

Ah, gotcha @RikthePoet m

I did say ignore the US stuff. I really think the classics and ancient history is absolutely fine.

I also think intelligent adults can entertain ideas and be exposed to to ideas without accepting them.

Charlie Kirk was not my cup of tea, but I think it was horrific that he was shot. I do believe in free speech and open debate.

Effectively, I think cultural capital is knowing all sides of the argument, the historical evolution of attitudes, and not just approved narratives.

But why would you want to give traffic to such a right-wing website when there are so many more objective sources to choose from.

Papyrophile · 15/11/2026 17:56

Opera is wonderful, especially well sung, but it is a marvellous treat in sight and sound, even badly done.

Papyrophile · 15/11/2026 18:00

Pansykavalier · 15/11/2026 16:09

But why would you want to give traffic to such a right-wing website when there are so many more objective sources to choose from.

I would not personally choose a left leaning site either. For me, objectivity is everything.

bababamama · 15/11/2026 18:02

With classical music, start by listening to it on the radio then look for concerts locally, amateur is fine, work out what you enjoy - I love most of it but choral is my real passion. Once you’ve acquainted yourself go to a prom or two in the summer (mid July to early September) at the Albert hall, it’s an amazing experience. If you can afford it, a second tier loggia box is my favourite spot, and you can order food to be brought to your box. It’s an all comers festival though, no dress code, and tickets start at £8

Papyrophile · 15/11/2026 18:11

@Pansykavalier I don't want to presume I understand your political views, but I would tend to assume that you are fairly young (under 35?) and that you feel home ownership and all the etc is unlikely to happen.

If you want that you can go for it.

Coldcoffemorning · 15/11/2026 18:19

Re art, look at gallery websites such as Tate, Moma, met museum. Tate especially have sections that describe different art movements in history, technical terms and pieces on individual artists. Books I would recommend are "the story of art" by E.H.Gombrich for art history and a book called "art and visual perception" to understand the visual aspects of what you are looking at (it describes how fo see and understand line, tone, form, colour etc). Also a book called "art speak" might be good.

Just to say I completely understand what you are after. I am in a similar situation in life but I have areas of culture that I don't understand like theatre for example. Good luck and happy reading!

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 15/11/2026 18:36

Another good option for ballet is the programmes with several 1-act ballets rather than a single long one. Likely to give you a variety of styles and composers, as well as simpler plots.

Where to start with opera will depend on your wider taste in music. I'm personally very fond of Bizet - particularly the Pearl Fishers, which is unusual in having a tenor duet. Probably a reasonable starting point for most.

I also rather like baroque opera, but only with the right performer. It was written for a quite different singing style, and some modern singers rather overpower it. If you can find one with the original instruments (Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment or similar) then give Dido and Aeneas a go. But if you're not keen on baroque music in general then the operas are unlikely to be to your taste.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/i-v-DZjZ9iY?si=zPgzsNr3IP2d3WgS

Swipe left for the next trending thread