Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help with cultural capital

322 replies

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 14/11/2026 14:47

Because I genuinely need help navigating this and building my own.
after a childhood in and out of care I have, by a combination of finding good mentors, a voracious reading habit (and ignoring the many, many times this was mocked in various placements) and being in top sets through sheer hard work rather than natural intelligence I have a well respected, aspirational job that I love.
Thanks in no small part to MN I ‘mask’/fit in with the upper middle class around me in clothes, grooming and so forth. I’m not looking to imitate them if that makes sense but instead to navigate my way through what I missed as a child. I know nothing about classical music, opera or art. I am educating myself about philosophy at the moment after an interesting conversation I was part of (well, I didn’t have much to contribute tbh but you get the idea).
I feel like I have a lot of gaps that I want to plug, not because I don’t feel as good as other people more that I want to get behind the curtain and see what’s there.
if anyone has any suggestions about where to start as an adult - for example I have only found kids books describing the ballet for those who don’t know anything about it - navigating any aspect of this, 🙏
I’m happy to watch docs, read, listen. Don’t have limitless time and money but am happy to commit both realistically. The only thing I don’t need help with are our ‘classsics’ on the book world, EH, NT, skiing and horseriding (waaay to much open air).

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 15/11/2026 18:43

Incidentall trivia: the Puritans played a part in popularising opera in Britain. Cromwell banned plays, but not concerts, so 'sung-through' plays could be performed while other drama was shut down.

WarmCat · 15/11/2026 19:40

I agree with listening to Radio 3. Mornings are good for hearing single movements and shorter pieces so there's more variety and you can get an idea of what you like. Ballets are lovely both to watch and listen to, especially the Tchaikovsky ones or Coppelia or Giselle. There are plot summaries on Wikipedia. Art galleries are good and there are a lot of art documentaries on BBCiplayer.

EBearhug · 15/11/2026 19:53

Papyrophile · 15/11/2026 18:00

I would not personally choose a left leaning site either. For me, objectivity is everything.

How much objectivity do you really think there can be? Every writer will have their biases. If you know it's a right or left wing site, just read more sources and come to your own conclusion. That is the basis of critical thinking.

AlexandraCarrington · 15/11/2026 19:54

Ballets are lovely both to watch and listen to, especially the Tchaikovsky ones or Coppelia or Giselle. There are plot summaries on Wikipedia

Thinking back, one of the comics we used to have - Bunty or Judy, probably - had a series on Stories from the Ballet, told in strip cartoon form. So I grew up familiar with Coppelia, The Nutcracker and others. And there were all the stories about aspiring dancers, beginning with Ballet Shoes.

Someone mentioned Nessun Dorma. The Three Tenors concert in Rome, the evening before the 1990 World Cup Final, is worth watching. Lots of popular songs from opera and other music.

Bunny65 · 15/11/2026 20:03

If you want to know about ballet, join an adult ballet class. Go and see an opera, go to the theatre. You won’t like everything and there’s nothing wrong with that. Find out what you like and enjoy it, visit art galleries. No one is an expert on everything.

Plexie · 15/11/2026 20:04

Bumper crop of programmes on BBC4 tonight.

7pm People's Palaces: The Golden Age of Civic Architecture

Two part series about Victorian civic architecture in northern English cities, including Leeds Town Hall. Part 1 is neo-Classical and Part 2 is neo-Gothic.

8pm The Medici: Makers of Modern Art

The Medici family who bankrolled the Italian Renaissance in Florence.

9pm Britain's Most Fragile Treasure

York Minster's Great East Window's medieval stained glass.

10pm Gilbert & Sullivan's The Gondoliers

TwinklySquid · 15/11/2026 21:15

If you know what topics you want (fairly specific), you can ask ChatGTP to make you a weekly course. I recently asked it to help me with an area I feel I could work on (academic) and it made me a 12 week course with assignments, reading list etc. I was quite surprised

LoserWinner · 15/11/2026 21:58

FWIW, I buy cheap tickets to the theatre through Central Tickets. There are two advantages to that: first, I can go to a lot more things, and second, if I’m not enjoying the play, I don’t feel bad about leaving early. There may be options like that local to the OP.

Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow · 15/11/2026 21:59

good to know it was useful for you, I wasn’t sure how much it would hallucinate witHoyt me realising

OP posts:
GreenSalon26 · 15/11/2026 22:12

@Whatifthemurderisjustonecrow I didn’t have your early life challenges but grew up with not much money (free school meals) and no exposure to arts and culture. Also a voracious reader which helped me hugely, allowed me to go to university.
Following a very circuitous route I work in a very senior level in the cultural sector and have skilled myself up along the way as I didn’t have an arts background. I was and am competing with people who grew up with cultural capital.

FWIW, my advice is that I understand that you want to more broadly educate yourself but I concur with a point someone else made earlier about the classic arts not necessarily having to be your main focus. So much of contemporary performing arts is often way more interesting, relevant and accessible. I also include film and television in this where brilliantly made, well written series for example are as good as classic theatre IMO.

If you are Leeds area, as you probably know, Leeds Playhouse has an excellent cross art form programme and would recommend a few visits if you haven’t gone already. For example contemporary poets like Holly McNish are a great way in to being confident about exploring more classic poets in time for example as her work is easy to “get” but no less intelligent for it (sadly sold out in Leeds). Apologies if you know all of this but Northern Ballet in Leeds also good and Yorkshire Sculpture Park as also mentioned is excellent and the temporary gallery there is great. Opera North also good and do special ticket prices for people new to opera. Seeing their full orchestra perform the live soundtrack to the Home Alone film can be more accessible and just as enjoyable as seeing their versions of the classic opera. Accessible isn’t about dumbing down, just easier to jump in mostly.

MedusasHead · 15/11/2026 22:18

Op, if you’re interested to know more about art there’s a brilliant and very short book called Ways of Seeing by John Berger, also an amazing series made for BBC in 1970s. It’s v accessible and really explains different ways of looking at visual art.

cheeseomelette · 15/11/2026 22:23

Great thread. I’m fairly well read, well travelled, enjoy learning languages, like the theatre,
gigs and art but have zero interest in ballet or opera.

I’d also feel comfortable freely admitting that in any social setting, including amongst our Board at work, who are insanely bright and include more than one titled person.

I think confidence is probably the trick here. I know I can hold a conversation over dinner with any of them and am therefore not that worried about what they think of me. We generally talk about travel the most, other than about the food, setting or work related things. Nobody has ever asked me about the arts!

nomadmaident · 15/11/2026 23:02

I'd join your local Arts Society. There is one in Leeds. Monthly illustrated lectures from experts on diverse topics. Also day-trips and longer journeys. Social aspect if you want it, but not necessary.

Try Open University. They do entry-level courses in Arts & Humanities. Would help you get your bearings and map out the landscape.
Just go after everything you enjoy and push your boundaries outwards from your starting point. It's so easy now to pre-prepare, e.g. going to an opera? - read up on Wikipedia to fill yourself in on the plot and the background to the writing of the opera / careers of the composer & librettist.
ENO is moving to Manchester. They're about to put on Philip Glass's "Einstein On The Beach", should be worth having a look at that.
I'm 80. Left school with measly 5 'O' levels. Managed to get a professional qual aged 25 & worked my way up throughout a long career. Now I'm pursuing the classical education that, when I was a "know-nuffink" kid, I didn't know I thirsted after. It's never too late. Go for it!

Dinnerontheterrace · 15/11/2026 23:20

Pansykavalier · 15/11/2026 16:09

But why would you want to give traffic to such a right-wing website when there are so many more objective sources to choose from.

Because at the moment, I don’t know of a left-wing site with the same content which is free and so accessible.

Quit clutching your pearls. Hillsdale is fusty, but it’s not MAGA.

”Cultural capital” is context specific. When a person lives in London, the subtext is frankly understanding what used to be called “Western Civilisation.” Just attended opera or ballet is nice but superficial. You need to understand enough of the history, as it was understood until recently, to understand what is going on in the play, or the opera, or the painting, etc.

If a person isn’t lucky enough to learn it over the dinner table, or at a “public school” there are very few places to find it. Declaring the few places left where it can be found is gatekeeping. Shaming people from having the knowledge they need to access the fruits of the culture and society in which they live.

hppywkndvwhdjjf · 15/11/2026 23:50

RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 14:52

Listen to BBC Radio 3. See if you like the music.

In 2026, you don't need to have to a vast knowledge of classical music to be culturally literate.

I think it's a huge waste of your time to try and develop an interest in something you don't like.

Same with philosophy. I never heard middle to upper middle class friends at uni and later on discussing philosophy (except for those who did PPE degrees, but even then not often).

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 16/11/2026 00:57

Several people have suggested adult ballet classes. That would certainly give you an appreciation of the physical effort involved, and the names of the steps, but won't teach you about the art form - the music, the history, the stories, the mime aren't part of what's essentially an exercise class (a tough one, that will do wonders for your posture).

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 16/11/2026 01:04

TwinklySquid · 15/11/2026 21:15

If you know what topics you want (fairly specific), you can ask ChatGTP to make you a weekly course. I recently asked it to help me with an area I feel I could work on (academic) and it made me a 12 week course with assignments, reading list etc. I was quite surprised

Please don't do this. And you don't need to rely on the conservative Christian right either.

Search for 'MOOC' and the topic you're interested in and there are heaps of free or very cheap courses from reputable, major universities. Taught by actual human experts, not data scrapers that regurgitate whatever rubbish is on the Internet.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 16/11/2026 01:18

hppywkndvwhdjjf · 15/11/2026 23:50

Same with philosophy. I never heard middle to upper middle class friends at uni and later on discussing philosophy (except for those who did PPE degrees, but even then not often).

It's not necessarily about sitting down for a dedicated 2-hour dissection of Socrates vs Kant. It's whether you understand what someone means if they call an idea 'Benthamite' or make a human/Humean pun. Cultural capital works on shared references and understanding that can underpin any conversation.

And the OP isn't trying to force herself to learn about things she doesn't like. She's trying to find more things she might actually enjoy but hasn't been previously exposed to.

LynneEast · 16/11/2026 01:20

RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 18:52

Good grief!

So your solution to avoid "Marxist spin" is to go a heavily conservatively-biased, pale, male, stale, American Christian nationalist institution for your baseline history?

When you insultingly say, "pale, male, stale" are you including people like these:

Shakespeare; Joyce; Yeats; Dickens; Keats; Heaney; Wordsworth; Hardy

Chopin; Beethoven; Cage; Debussy; Ravel; Mozart; Schubert; Elgar

Rossetti; Lowry; Monet; Picasso; da Vinci; Rembrandt; Turner; Raphael

I have randomly named 8 each in the categories of Literature, Music and Art; I could easily have named 80!

You insultingly refer to Christianity (American) but anyone who doesn't have a working knowledge of the bible will struggle when it comes to interpretating much of western culture.

So, we have great cause to be be very, very, very grateful to "pale, male and stale" artists who have contributed much to western civilization and, sadly for you, that is just a fact, no matter how much you may search for slim pickings elsewhere.

The fact that you employ some sloppy teenage rhyme to describe them suggests that you neither know, respect or appreciate culture.

How embarrassing for you to have shown your arse in this way, unless of course you are 17 and a half and then, I won't judge you as harshly as you have a long way to go.

wand3rer · 16/11/2026 01:22

@TheKindnessProject

I totally agree, but couldn't have articulated it nearly as brilliantly. Very perceptive 😊

Usernamen · 16/11/2026 03:24

Dinnerontheterrace · 14/11/2026 15:36

I think a lot of “cultural capital” now is knowing the western tradition. This isn’t taught in a straight forward way in state schools or universities anymore, but somehow posh people know it. Perhaps it’s through family or private schools who go outside the curriculum. What really marks people out is knowing the straight facts about Roman History, or what Kant said, or the sequence of WWII, etc. without Marxists spin or current social justice theory. Real sophistication is knowing the classic position and understanding the current fashionable, political overlay.

I am not a conservative Christian, but a good place to find free online courses that are very entertaining is here:

https://online.hillsdale.edu

Just skip all the US history. I personally think the bible stuff is useful from a cultural point of view because our traditions rest on it. It’s foundational to so much western art and literature. But you can skip it too, there is plenty to trawl though. I listened to the Odyssey series after the film came out, and I found it interesting and enjoyable.

Totally agree with this. Teaching hard knowledge is really out of fashion - everything has to be viewed through the lens of whatever social ills we’re trying to correct in the present. You have to self-educate on the actual facts.

MoralOrLegal · 16/11/2026 06:07

Oh, just one more idea! As you might have guessed, I taught philosophy for many years. The A-level curriculum is actually a very very good introduction to most of the key areas in the western tradition, and there are some excellent textbooks (with reading lists) for it. I thoroughly recommend Michael Lacewing's books. Also, I second the Open University. (I took a few Art History courses, and they were amazing at putting art in its socioeconomic context. You could probably get hold of their textbooks even if you don't want to sign up for a full course!)

ChocolateCinderToffee · 16/11/2026 06:49

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 14/11/2026 14:54

Do you have a cinema near you that does live link ups with opera, ballet and theatre? These are a great way to expose yourself to a range of things at a reasonable price and they often include an interval talk or mini documentary about the piece.

This. I go and see them in my local Vue where a ticket is about £20. Any time I’m in London overnight, I’ll buy a ticket for whatever is on at Covent Garden (Royal Opera House) but it’s too expensive to stay in London overnight unless I have another reason to be there. If you live within a couple of hours of London, go to a matinee.

TwinklySquid · 16/11/2026 07:50

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 16/11/2026 01:04

Please don't do this. And you don't need to rely on the conservative Christian right either.

Search for 'MOOC' and the topic you're interested in and there are heaps of free or very cheap courses from reputable, major universities. Taught by actual human experts, not data scrapers that regurgitate whatever rubbish is on the Internet.

You may not like AI, but it’s uses are brilliant.

I’ve spent weeks trying to find information on the topic I needed help with. I have dyslexia and trying to work out what is useful and isn’t can be a challenge for me. ChatGTP filtered the information for me, condensed it and applied it to the specific area I needed help with. I got links to websites and a reading list to further expand my knowledge too.

OP: If you want something like I did above I would say: “ I would like to improve my cultural capital. I need you to create a ( I would ask for a course that covers one topic per week ie 3 week ) course with examples, quizzes, book recommendations, as well as website and YouTube examples to further my knowledge. I would like an overview of each topic with key phrases and topics so I could have a basic knowledge. The topics I would like you to cover are (x,y,z). “

You will get a starting point. I find that learning about a new topic can be harder because you don’t actually know what you need to know - like key words - to search. An Ai course will give you a jumping point to start.

ArabellaScott · 16/11/2026 07:53

Hey OP.

For visual arts, I absolutely loved John Canaday's 'What is art'. Fluent and clear writing, on both the historical development of art and deeper philosophical aspects without getting lost in arcane theory.

I have read a LOT on art and this book was a joy. It was written in 1979, so you could update /augment with more.recent texts. Maybe John Berger - Ways of Seeing is seminal.