Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think switching off landlines is crazy?

301 replies

humanassy · 13/11/2026 18:48

Old school telephone landlines are being switched off in January 2027 as we’ve all been told to go digital. In the light of the last 2 days with the Microsoft ‘outage’, AIBU to think this is lunacy?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
JustAMiddleAgedDirtBagBaby · 14/11/2026 07:28

18 years ago when we brought DD home from hospital to wait for the cardiac surgery she needed, we were strictly told to make sure that we had a back up phone to plug into the landline in a power cut as our cordless one wouldn't work - cordless phones need power for the handset to communicate with the base. This was so we could reliably call 999 if the power and mobile signals went.

I wonder what they are telling people with similarly sick children now.

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/11/2026 07:31

Umm use a mobile? The vast majority of 999 calls are made over mobile.

PersephoneParlormaid · 14/11/2026 07:32

Just because you’ve had no problem with your mobile for years doesn’t mean there couldn’t be a problem in the future. How are you going to ring 999 if the internet goes down?

tomorrowfollowstoday · 14/11/2026 07:33

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/11/2026 07:31

Umm use a mobile? The vast majority of 999 calls are made over mobile.

And in areas without mobile signal?
Or when the mobile network is down?

That's the whole point people are making!

HoppityBun · 14/11/2026 07:35

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/11/2026 07:31

Umm use a mobile? The vast majority of 999 calls are made over mobile.

Ummmmm I live in a town in the mobile reception my home, and generally in some areas , is crap. You don’t have to be living in the middle of nowhere to experience difficulties with mobile calls.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 14/11/2026 07:37

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/11/2026 07:24

So some people here seem to be under the impression that the old copper landlines are more resilient than broadband - they really really aren't.

It is anobselete platform at constant risk of unrecoverable failure. Also just like broadband it needs power to work, the difference is old fashioned landline are powered from the exchange rather than your house ( an accident of history rather than an in built resilience featire - when phones were first rolled out many homes did not have electricity, so in order to increase take up the private companies that ran the networks got the idea to provide power from tne exchange). But this only works now if you have an old fashioned hard wired phone, modern portable handsets also need power at the home, as do care alarms.

To focus the mind further, it seems the USA air traffic control failure over night was due to a overload and failure of the ageing system - that uses the same tech as copper landlines.

Copper landlines are not resilient, they never have been and they definitely aren't now.

Edited

Repeatedly setting out the problem with the existing copper infrastructure doesn't alter the fact that the network provider's proposed solution is inadequate as it leaves some areas unacceptably unprovided for.

Their solution is focused on profit maximisation, not national resilience.

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/11/2026 07:42

@PersephoneParlormaid "just because you haven't had a problem with your copper landline, doesn't mean you won't in the future, how will you call 999 if the landline breaks or has a fault" after the 1987 storm our billage had no landline for a month due to storm damage.

There are issues with the current transition but the idea that the copper landline network is or has ever been very resilient is laughable.

rwalker · 14/11/2026 08:14

I used to work in that industry the system is non longer viable there’s not enough subscribers to pay for it let alone invest in it
the whole network is on it’s knees it’s reached the end of its lifespan
the exchange equipment is obsolete nobody manufactures it
there salvaging old disused stuff to try and make it work
the exchange cards disintegrate when you touch them the racks they go into are brittle and collapse
you go into to the buildings there’s entire floors that were once rack after rack of live equipment there’s now a few live racks in the corner so little us the demand
there’s no way on earth people would pay per month what you’d have to charge to make it a viable network again

people need to educate themselves always quoting elderly people who don’t want broadband
you literally get what looks like a normal corded phone which has a built in hub and if see it exactly the same as a corded phone no different
you can get battery backup
life line and security alarms that have SIM cards in them
satellite mobiles
people need to campaign for better mobile coverage rather than think they can keep copper
the state of the copper network you’ve more chance of being off service due to the state of the copper network than you have from a power cut in fibre and you mobile not working

people really have no idea just how bad the copper network is and how much it would cost to bring it up t standard and how little people actually want to use copper

There normal corded phone’s that have a SIM card also if there is a power cut it switches to the cellular network

theres starlink broadband with battery backup life line again you’ll still have service in power cut

AIBU to think switching off landlines is crazy?
AIBU to think switching off landlines is crazy?
ShutterTyt · 14/11/2026 08:51

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 14/11/2026 05:11

Likewise.

Mumsnet never ceases to amaze me with the sheer number of users who are dead against any sort of technological change or progress. It's the same on the threads about cash. Presumably half of Mumsnet is still writing cheques, sending postal orders and telegrams, and pines for the simpler times where we lived in caves.

Reminds me of the banker who told Henry Ford's lawyer that the automobile was a novelty which would never replace the horse.

Smart meter-phobia. Another mumsnet obsession. Had a Smart meter in my flat for the past 7 years, works flawlessly, only time I ever need look at the thing is out of sheer curiosity, but no, they're the work of the devil if you listen to the nonsense on here.

Edited

What's the issue with smart meters? They easily record gas and electricity usage?

DoraSpenlow · 14/11/2026 09:07

Zanatdy · 14/11/2026 06:24

I haven’t had a landline for well over a decade now.

If there was a massive power outage how would you call the fire brigade if your house was on fire, or call an ambulance if a family member was taken ill?

ohtowinthelottery · 14/11/2026 09:14

My elderly partially sighted MIL, who lives alone, hasn't yet switched over to digital voice. But when she does (it's currently on the too difficult pile with her provider, I think) she will have no connectivity to the outside world during a power cut. Despite being in her late 90's, she uses a mobile phone but it only works on WiFi calling as the mobile signal is so poor where she lives. If her power goes off - which living in a rural area is not unlikely, she will have no phone use at all once switchover takes place and her emergency call alarm will also not work. As an MP raised at Westminster the other day (from Herefordshire I think) they should have concentrated on massively improving mobile phone signal/connectivity before turning off analogue landlines.

RaraRachael · 14/11/2026 09:17

Lots of old people don't have mobile phones or the Internet so what are they supposed to do.

Up until a couple of years ago I had terrible mobile signal so always gave people my landline number.

DoraSpenlow · 14/11/2026 09:17

ShutterTyt · 14/11/2026 08:51

What's the issue with smart meters? They easily record gas and electricity usage?

Not if you have an inconsistent broadband connection they don't. Probably ok if you live in a town but not all parts of the country have. My neighbours had one fitted but it kept losing connection so had to be replaced with an old fashioned meter because their usage wasn't being recorded properly.

Sharptonguedwoman · 14/11/2026 09:17

Rattymcratty · 13/11/2026 18:52

I’ve not heard this but makes sense. I can imagine they’re expensive to maintain and tbh who really uses them?

Bit like when the country switched to digital TV and that seemed like a big deal…

I live in an area with dodgy mobile signal. Personally, I think switching off the landlines is very bad news for vulnerable people, particularly the frail and elderly.

Sharptonguedwoman · 14/11/2026 09:22

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/11/2026 07:31

Umm use a mobile? The vast majority of 999 calls are made over mobile.

I don't live in a particularly remote area but one local friend has a house where mobiles simply don't work at the rear of the house or in the garden. It's not that simple.

Somersetbaker · 14/11/2026 09:37

DoraSpenlow · 14/11/2026 09:17

Not if you have an inconsistent broadband connection they don't. Probably ok if you live in a town but not all parts of the country have. My neighbours had one fitted but it kept losing connection so had to be replaced with an old fashioned meter because their usage wasn't being recorded properly.

Smart meters don't use broadband internet. They do send usage data over the mobile phone network, but if they can't get a connection they revert to being a "dumb" meter. Unless actually faulty, or have been tampered with, they always record usage data correctly, if they can never get a connection you just read and send in the reading like you used to do.

Suusue · 14/11/2026 09:38

Iv not had a landline in 12 years. No problems.

rainbowunicorn · 14/11/2026 09:45

CallMeDaphne · 13/11/2026 21:57

You agree with the OP that landlines should not be switched off, but you have not used yours for years.

That makes no sense.

Maybe because the person you are quoting has the intelligence to understand that even though it is not a problem in her circumstances, for others it could be.

ShutterTyt · 14/11/2026 09:58

DoraSpenlow · 14/11/2026 09:17

Not if you have an inconsistent broadband connection they don't. Probably ok if you live in a town but not all parts of the country have. My neighbours had one fitted but it kept losing connection so had to be replaced with an old fashioned meter because their usage wasn't being recorded properly.

Oh I thankfully don't live in the middle of nowhere and I have good WiFi

XenaSharples · 14/11/2026 10:03

A cyberattack on the "traditional" phone system (or a loss of power at the exchange) would have exactly the same effect as an attack on the digital phone system.

The exchanges are digital and the analogue signal is converted to/from digital on the way out/in. When you make a call it is routed through the digital network utility it leaves that final exchange.

The old copper network costs a lot to maintain, but no longer pays for itself.

Landlines aren't going away, but your landline might need a backup battery.

XenaSharples · 14/11/2026 10:05

DoraSpenlow · 14/11/2026 09:17

Not if you have an inconsistent broadband connection they don't. Probably ok if you live in a town but not all parts of the country have. My neighbours had one fitted but it kept losing connection so had to be replaced with an old fashioned meter because their usage wasn't being recorded properly.

Yes. It's necessary to ensure a reliable broadband connectivity for everyone. I do agree it's being switched off too soon in some places.

KnitOneSlipOneKnitOnePassSlippedStitchOver · 14/11/2026 10:08

My parents live in an otherwise well connected village 15 minutes from the M4, and have no mobile signal in the house on any network. Both have had to have ambulances in the past year. This has left them without any way to call for help if there’s no power - which happens in the winter as there are still above-ground cables in the immediate area and lots of trees. I wish a solution to this could have been offered before the switch over (which has already happened in our area) rather than trying to catch up with the people it’s made vulnerable afterwards.

CarlaH · 14/11/2026 10:28

Are the people who just keep parroting that they haven't had a landline for years and are doing just fine able to offer a solution to those who don't have a decent mobile signal or what people are supposed to do in the event of a power failure?

Just saying 'I haven't had any problems' really doesn't cut it.

Come on people offer up a proper solution for a lengthy power outage.

DoraSpenlow · 14/11/2026 10:34

Somersetbaker · 14/11/2026 09:37

Smart meters don't use broadband internet. They do send usage data over the mobile phone network, but if they can't get a connection they revert to being a "dumb" meter. Unless actually faulty, or have been tampered with, they always record usage data correctly, if they can never get a connection you just read and send in the reading like you used to do.

Ok, I stand corrected it must have been the mobile signal not the broadband, it was a while ago. I was just going by what the engineer who was replacing the smart meter told me when I let him in for my neighbours who were at work.

humanassy · 14/11/2026 10:35

XenaSharples · 14/11/2026 10:03

A cyberattack on the "traditional" phone system (or a loss of power at the exchange) would have exactly the same effect as an attack on the digital phone system.

The exchanges are digital and the analogue signal is converted to/from digital on the way out/in. When you make a call it is routed through the digital network utility it leaves that final exchange.

The old copper network costs a lot to maintain, but no longer pays for itself.

Landlines aren't going away, but your landline might need a backup battery.

That is interesting - did not realise the exchanges are digital

OP posts: