Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think switching off landlines is crazy?

301 replies

humanassy · 13/11/2026 18:48

Old school telephone landlines are being switched off in January 2027 as we’ve all been told to go digital. In the light of the last 2 days with the Microsoft ‘outage’, AIBU to think this is lunacy?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Lancrelady80 · 14/11/2026 00:30

Dm in 90s, v poor mobility, now registered as blind rather than "just" impaired, hard of hearing, lives alone with telecare system. It's been a nightmare of people not turning up or turning up and doing half a job, resulting in her being left with no way of contacting anyone including her careline for 3 days, during which time she fell. Fortunately able to get herself up. Four months down the line it's almost sorted. She got a letter telling her to inform her telecare company so they could check that equipment would work - it wouldn't, so they came and set up a new telecare system. The phone company needed to be informed she was vulnerable and has telecare equipment. Long story short, they eventually sorted and set up a new router and also left her with a backup phone for powercuts. It is a standard handset (but huge buttons etc for accessibility) but plugs into any electrical socket, no router needed. It needs plugging in so it holds charge in case power goes - several hours of use once fully charged. Despite the handset, it is effectively a mobile phone and has its own 07 etc number. There is a sim card inside with a limited number of prepaid minutes and it runs on 4g. There seems to be a reasonable signal despite it being dodgy signalwise near her.

ErrolTheDragon · 14/11/2026 00:39

Puzzledandpissedoff · 13/11/2026 21:54

Just as an aside, I spend a lot of time in Florida - the land of hurricanes - and there, when they know power cuts are coming, they enable access to satellites which effectively turns communication devices into sat phones

Admittedly that's no good with unexpected power cuts, but at least it's something ... though try suggesting it in the UK and it'll be the blank stare again

Newer Apple phones have some sort of emergency number only satellite capability if there’s no mobile signal, so that’s something.

Tcateh · 14/11/2026 00:43

Openreach is phasing out copper in my area as it's now fully fibre capable. Small Devon town.
If you have FTTC you're being forced to go FTTH.
They're really pushing people to go over to digital voice, and apparently here copper deadline is January 31st 2027.

I must have been living under a rock. I got a letter through in the summer.

123dayslater · 14/11/2026 00:56

Landlines are changing to VOIP

Care lines too

ShutterTyt · 14/11/2026 00:59

We cut ours years ago. Our mobiles still worked

ShattonerfDaParp · 14/11/2026 03:50

Fucking smart meters. Useless as shite. They wanted everyone to have one by 2020. LOL, some use that is when most of them malfunction. Hell will freeze over before I have one.

Ooh careful. When I said on here that I wasn't bothered about getting a smart meter and would just ignore all the shite trying to coerce me into getting one, I was told all sorts of blood-curdling stories of the supposed dangers of not having one, only just stopping short of 'old electricity meters attract meteorites'.

Re landlines it does seem like another example of doing away with resilience/fall-back/redundancy just for the sake of money. The sort of thing that screwed the world over so badly during covid. I haven't used the defibrillator in the village in 15 years - fuck it get rid of it then.

Canape · 14/11/2026 05:10

ErrolTheDragon · 14/11/2026 00:39

Newer Apple phones have some sort of emergency number only satellite capability if there’s no mobile signal, so that’s something.

Yes, and isn't it alarming just how often that little satellite pops up in some places.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 14/11/2026 05:11

Slightyamusedandsilly · 13/11/2026 19:12

Not had a landline for 25 years. Not had a problem with that once.

Likewise.

Mumsnet never ceases to amaze me with the sheer number of users who are dead against any sort of technological change or progress. It's the same on the threads about cash. Presumably half of Mumsnet is still writing cheques, sending postal orders and telegrams, and pines for the simpler times where we lived in caves.

Reminds me of the banker who told Henry Ford's lawyer that the automobile was a novelty which would never replace the horse.

Smart meter-phobia. Another mumsnet obsession. Had a Smart meter in my flat for the past 7 years, works flawlessly, only time I ever need look at the thing is out of sheer curiosity, but no, they're the work of the devil if you listen to the nonsense on here.

Canape · 14/11/2026 05:20

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 14/11/2026 05:11

Likewise.

Mumsnet never ceases to amaze me with the sheer number of users who are dead against any sort of technological change or progress. It's the same on the threads about cash. Presumably half of Mumsnet is still writing cheques, sending postal orders and telegrams, and pines for the simpler times where we lived in caves.

Reminds me of the banker who told Henry Ford's lawyer that the automobile was a novelty which would never replace the horse.

Smart meter-phobia. Another mumsnet obsession. Had a Smart meter in my flat for the past 7 years, works flawlessly, only time I ever need look at the thing is out of sheer curiosity, but no, they're the work of the devil if you listen to the nonsense on here.

Edited

It's not all about you

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 14/11/2026 05:30

Canape · 14/11/2026 05:20

It's not all about you

I never implied it was. I just don't accept the view that nothing should ever change or progress because some people will be left behind or struggle to adapt when the overwhelming bulk cope just fine or actually benefit from the change.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 14/11/2026 05:38

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 14/11/2026 05:30

I never implied it was. I just don't accept the view that nothing should ever change or progress because some people will be left behind or struggle to adapt when the overwhelming bulk cope just fine or actually benefit from the change.

If it was your relative at risk because they would be unable to call for help you might have some understanding of the concerns.

This change isn't about progress for the user. It's about profit for the privatised provider.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 14/11/2026 05:43

tomorrowfollowstoday · 14/11/2026 05:38

If it was your relative at risk because they would be unable to call for help you might have some understanding of the concerns.

This change isn't about progress for the user. It's about profit for the privatised provider.

Mobile telephony has been available to the public for 40 years at least, 30 since it became widespread, cheap, and accessible. How long were you expecting them to persist with hopelessly outdated copper wire tech precisely? Why on earth would they devote resources to the upkeep of a tech which more and more people are abandoning and is rapidly going the way of the dodo? It isn't about profit, it's about abandoning redundant, archaic technology in the same way we've always done when it becomes outdated and supersceded.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 14/11/2026 05:46

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 14/11/2026 05:43

Mobile telephony has been available to the public for 40 years at least, 30 since it became widespread, cheap, and accessible. How long were you expecting them to persist with hopelessly outdated copper wire tech precisely? Why on earth would they devote resources to the upkeep of a tech which more and more people are abandoning and is rapidly going the way of the dodo? It isn't about profit, it's about abandoning redundant, archaic technology in the same way we've always done when it becomes outdated and supersceded.

Mobile telephony Hmm is not universally available.

You're naive if you think the primary motivation for pretty much every decision made by private companies isn't profit.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 14/11/2026 05:53

tomorrowfollowstoday · 14/11/2026 05:46

Mobile telephony Hmm is not universally available.

You're naive if you think the primary motivation for pretty much every decision made by private companies isn't profit.

Then if you have a coverage shortage that's something that needs taken up with the providers and your local authorities until it's put right. They're not going to continue to maintain copper wire tech just because you'd prefer it.

Of course companies are motivated by profit. Innovation provides opportunities, opportunities provide profit, it's kinda cart before horse to imply it's the profit driving the change, it's not.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 14/11/2026 06:01

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 14/11/2026 05:53

Then if you have a coverage shortage that's something that needs taken up with the providers and your local authorities until it's put right. They're not going to continue to maintain copper wire tech just because you'd prefer it.

Of course companies are motivated by profit. Innovation provides opportunities, opportunities provide profit, it's kinda cart before horse to imply it's the profit driving the change, it's not.

I don't have any issues personally. I'm just able to understand the providers are not behaving in the national interest.

Yes, profit has driven the decisions. Those in rural areas are being inappropriately disregarded.

WhitegreeNcandle · 14/11/2026 06:15

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 14/11/2026 05:11

Likewise.

Mumsnet never ceases to amaze me with the sheer number of users who are dead against any sort of technological change or progress. It's the same on the threads about cash. Presumably half of Mumsnet is still writing cheques, sending postal orders and telegrams, and pines for the simpler times where we lived in caves.

Reminds me of the banker who told Henry Ford's lawyer that the automobile was a novelty which would never replace the horse.

Smart meter-phobia. Another mumsnet obsession. Had a Smart meter in my flat for the past 7 years, works flawlessly, only time I ever need look at the thing is out of sheer curiosity, but no, they're the work of the devil if you listen to the nonsense on here.

Edited

It’s not dead against technology. It’s that since 1949 when the copper cable was put into this farm we could always ring 999 and the people we sell our goods now.

since 2023 when BT switched off our copper we had to move to our phones running over the internet. We don’t have fttp as it’s far too expensive for anyone to fit. So it can be slow and unreliable and drop out. That’s before power cuts (which like another poster suspected are most definitely increasing.) If we can’t speak to our suppliers and customers your supermarkets will be short of food in a matter of days. Possibly even hours.

Let alone elderly people who live rurallly with no mobile signal

WhitegreeNcandle · 14/11/2026 06:19

Oh, and there are whole swathes of the countryside that don’t have mobile signal!

Also not convinced how expensive a copper line it to maintain. Ours ran up a mile and half long farm drive. Don’t remember it ever being changed.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 14/11/2026 06:20

WhitegreeNcandle · 14/11/2026 06:15

It’s not dead against technology. It’s that since 1949 when the copper cable was put into this farm we could always ring 999 and the people we sell our goods now.

since 2023 when BT switched off our copper we had to move to our phones running over the internet. We don’t have fttp as it’s far too expensive for anyone to fit. So it can be slow and unreliable and drop out. That’s before power cuts (which like another poster suspected are most definitely increasing.) If we can’t speak to our suppliers and customers your supermarkets will be short of food in a matter of days. Possibly even hours.

Let alone elderly people who live rurallly with no mobile signal

Yes this is the point - what is happening isn't progress for all.

What is happening will make the country less resilient overall.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 14/11/2026 06:23

WhitegreeNcandle · 14/11/2026 06:19

Oh, and there are whole swathes of the countryside that don’t have mobile signal!

Also not convinced how expensive a copper line it to maintain. Ours ran up a mile and half long farm drive. Don’t remember it ever being changed.

Overall copper is expensive - but it shouldn't be acceptable to leave people without secure phone connections.

There should be a hybrid solution.

Zanatdy · 14/11/2026 06:24

I haven’t had a landline for well over a decade now.

AitkenDrum1970 · 14/11/2026 06:25

NewNewForest · 13/11/2026 19:43

“turning off landlines” is not a knee jerk task - it’s been 25 years in the planning - inventing an alternative, scaling it up, getting the regulations updated, funding, rolling out… it’s not happened overnight!

The old network is on its knees, BT are the primary operator and rumour has it, have to buy their spares on eBay!

There will be a few lift alarms, gates, traffic lights that get forgotten but the industry have been pushing incredibly hard to get users moved over. You’ve never seen resistance from the public like it though 🫣

You can still have a phone in your house if you want one.

Old tech: copper line with phone service and internet delivered over it.
New tech: internet line with a phone service delivered on it if you want it.

But they still haven’t considered places where we get regular power cuts (the last major one lasting 5 days) and where the mobile signal is poor to non-existent (deep valley). Lots of our elderly neighbours have the emergency call alarms which rely on a landline connection. These are not going to work in a power cut and they wouldn’t be able to get anywhere to find a mobile signal. They have been offered a battery back-up but these only last for a couple of hours at most. They are being put in a very dangerous situation and we are actively campaigning through our local MP but a solution doesn’t seem to be forthcoming.

tomorrowfollowstoday · 14/11/2026 06:29

NewNewForest · 13/11/2026 19:43

“turning off landlines” is not a knee jerk task - it’s been 25 years in the planning - inventing an alternative, scaling it up, getting the regulations updated, funding, rolling out… it’s not happened overnight!

The old network is on its knees, BT are the primary operator and rumour has it, have to buy their spares on eBay!

There will be a few lift alarms, gates, traffic lights that get forgotten but the industry have been pushing incredibly hard to get users moved over. You’ve never seen resistance from the public like it though 🫣

You can still have a phone in your house if you want one.

Old tech: copper line with phone service and internet delivered over it.
New tech: internet line with a phone service delivered on it if you want it.

If they've been planning 25 years, they've done a really shit job given they haven't considered the needs of all areas.

Whatabouterry · 14/11/2026 06:36

I completely agree OP. In terms of resilience planning as a country I think it leaves us with another level of vulnerability. Digital doesn’t exactly seem like a failsafe solution right now.

muddyford · 14/11/2026 06:38

We get regular power cuts and have no mobile signal. I keep my plug in telephone to use then as there's no other way of contacting anyone. If this has been planned for 25 years they're making a crap job of it.

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/11/2026 07:24

So some people here seem to be under the impression that the old copper landlines are more resilient than broadband - they really really aren't.

It is anobselete platform at constant risk of unrecoverable failure. Also just like broadband it needs power to work, the difference is old fashioned landline are powered from the exchange rather than your house ( an accident of history rather than an in built resilience featire - when phones were first rolled out many homes did not have electricity, so in order to increase take up the private companies that ran the networks got the idea to provide power from tne exchange). But this only works now if you have an old fashioned hard wired phone, modern portable handsets also need power at the home, as do care alarms.

To focus the mind further, it seems the USA air traffic control failure over night was due to a overload and failure of the ageing system - that uses the same tech as copper landlines.

Copper landlines are not resilient, they never have been and they definitely aren't now.