@rwalker the information you shared was interesting. However
”people need to educate themselves always quoting elderly people who don’t want broadband
you literally get what looks like a normal corded phone which has a built in hub and if see it exactly the same as a corded phone no different
you can get battery backup
life line and security alarms that have SIM cards in them
satellite mobiles”
Many on this thread ARE educated on the issue we are discussing and, furthermore, have actual experience of living through extended power cuts. Maybe we are elderly, maybe not, this isn’t the point really. Perhaps you might also read our specific comments and reasons for the concern we raise.
Do you know that the battery backup only lasts about 12 hours? Not really good comms backup is it, when the old plug in would just come out of the cupboard are WORK during a power cut. like I did for over a week during the first severe storm around 2021 or 2 can’t remember as there was one when we were without in November for about 9 or 10 days. The alternative isn’t sufficient for swathes of the country who do not live in urban or even near urban areas. It’s not comparable.
Posters accusing those who are pointing out the resilience failings are not against progress. I can almost hear the ahhh the elderly, unwilling or unable to change, always better in ye olden days. But no. This is an unwillingness to actually read what many of us have described on here. Perhaps read what we are actually saying.
I am not elderly as it happens, not that that makes any difference. I do understand hazard, risk, mitigation, control, customer service and satisfaction, and, yes, as a management systems practitioner including quality, environment, and health and safety, I fully understand the need for continual improvement for a business. But it is users, customers, who are the judge of whether improvements are working for them. It is perfectly proper to raise risk of losing ALL forms of communication. It should have been properly considered and factored in. Not this 24 hour battery back up nonsense.
Actually, another thing I bring from my professional life is that if you have incidents, you learn from them. I and many others have been without power for days on end. But hey we don’t matter as it’s progress! Till it isn’t.
I am also convinced that resilience to storms is less than it was. It now seems what are no more than high winds cause damage. So I wonder, what joined up planning and risk identification has taken place between, say, the phones the power the energency services etc to consider effective- property effectiveness of back up communication - in severe situations? I gave an example earlier that during the longest outage (so no mobile, internet, etc) but i would phone on my plug in land line for updates. Ha! Things like “for full information where you can find locations for boiling up water or whatever, go to www.etc etc.
Totally understand the need if the old system is on its last legs but given that the service is to provide communication, you would think that would be top of the list to ensure customers actually continue to be provided with at the time they may most need it. It’s undeniably flawed.