Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think switching off landlines is crazy?

301 replies

humanassy · 13/11/2026 18:48

Old school telephone landlines are being switched off in January 2027 as we’ve all been told to go digital. In the light of the last 2 days with the Microsoft ‘outage’, AIBU to think this is lunacy?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Mountainpika · 14/11/2026 10:39

We use a landline phone to make phone calls. Have mobile phones but rarely use them. Laptop for emails, internet etc..

Barranca · 14/11/2026 10:40

@rwalker the information you shared was interesting. However

”people need to educate themselves always quoting elderly people who don’t want broadband
you literally get what looks like a normal corded phone which has a built in hub and if see it exactly the same as a corded phone no different
you can get battery backup
life line and security alarms that have SIM cards in them
satellite mobiles”

Many on this thread ARE educated on the issue we are discussing and, furthermore, have actual experience of living through extended power cuts. Maybe we are elderly, maybe not, this isn’t the point really. Perhaps you might also read our specific comments and reasons for the concern we raise.

Do you know that the battery backup only lasts about 12 hours? Not really good comms backup is it, when the old plug in would just come out of the cupboard are WORK during a power cut. like I did for over a week during the first severe storm around 2021 or 2 can’t remember as there was one when we were without in November for about 9 or 10 days. The alternative isn’t sufficient for swathes of the country who do not live in urban or even near urban areas. It’s not comparable.

Posters accusing those who are pointing out the resilience failings are not against progress. I can almost hear the ahhh the elderly, unwilling or unable to change, always better in ye olden days. But no. This is an unwillingness to actually read what many of us have described on here. Perhaps read what we are actually saying.

I am not elderly as it happens, not that that makes any difference. I do understand hazard, risk, mitigation, control, customer service and satisfaction, and, yes, as a management systems practitioner including quality, environment, and health and safety, I fully understand the need for continual improvement for a business. But it is users, customers, who are the judge of whether improvements are working for them. It is perfectly proper to raise risk of losing ALL forms of communication. It should have been properly considered and factored in. Not this 24 hour battery back up nonsense.

Actually, another thing I bring from my professional life is that if you have incidents, you learn from them. I and many others have been without power for days on end. But hey we don’t matter as it’s progress! Till it isn’t.

I am also convinced that resilience to storms is less than it was. It now seems what are no more than high winds cause damage. So I wonder, what joined up planning and risk identification has taken place between, say, the phones the power the energency services etc to consider effective- property effectiveness of back up communication - in severe situations? I gave an example earlier that during the longest outage (so no mobile, internet, etc) but i would phone on my plug in land line for updates. Ha! Things like “for full information where you can find locations for boiling up water or whatever, go to www.etc etc.

Totally understand the need if the old system is on its last legs but given that the service is to provide communication, you would think that would be top of the list to ensure customers actually continue to be provided with at the time they may most need it. It’s undeniably flawed.

Barranca · 14/11/2026 10:42

Suusue · 14/11/2026 09:38

Iv not had a landline in 12 years. No problems.

What’s the longest power cut you’ve ever had, and how far do you live to your nearest “community”?

Barranca · 14/11/2026 10:44

CarlaH · 14/11/2026 10:28

Are the people who just keep parroting that they haven't had a landline for years and are doing just fine able to offer a solution to those who don't have a decent mobile signal or what people are supposed to do in the event of a power failure?

Just saying 'I haven't had any problems' really doesn't cut it.

Come on people offer up a proper solution for a lengthy power outage.

I am also keen to hear the solutions! Ones that actually would work for long power cuts.

Barranca · 14/11/2026 10:45

Mountainpika · 14/11/2026 10:39

We use a landline phone to make phone calls. Have mobile phones but rarely use them. Laptop for emails, internet etc..

How would you manage if you didn’t have ANY power for days and days? Or if you had no broadband etc?

brownbootsandhats · 14/11/2026 10:54

You need to push for back up generators at mobile masts. That would be OFCOM and governments choice. There are some but not enough I suspect

you need to make a stink about lack of mobile overage - be reassured it’s actually very rare that you wouldn’t get a 999 call through even if you can’t get YouTube . It goes over any network at high priority

again that’s OFCOM you need to be talking too if your mobile provider doesn’t have service at your home. But also - ask friends and families - we have great mobile at home where other providers are not providing any service so you may need to switch

keeping the telephone network running isn’t possible.

DoraSpenlow · 14/11/2026 10:55

I'm going back a few years now but do any older Mumsnetters remember Norman Collier's broken microphone gag? Examples on Youtube. That's just how it sounds when my cousin calls me on her mobile from home rather than her landline!

rwalker · 14/11/2026 11:02

For all those saying keep copper who’s going to pay for it

Puzzledandpissedoff · 14/11/2026 11:16

I think it’s very short sighted to get rid of analogue services when we are under constant threat of cyber outages

Another crucial point, Zov, along with the many others you've made

You'd think the sort who run tech for a living would have given this proper consideration, but no; all it needs is someone with a presentation about how terribly clever it all is and the exclusionary ideas come rolling out, and to hell with anyone who asks the difficult questions

gingercat02 · 14/11/2026 11:25

We have had a digital "landline" for years, we never use it, but DH uncle phones every few months and rings on it, even though he has DH mobile number!
We probably should get rid, but its bundled in with our broadband package.

Somersetbaker · 14/11/2026 11:42

humanassy · 14/11/2026 10:35

That is interesting - did not realise the exchanges are digital

Edited

System-X which BT (though probably still the Post Office then) started to install in the mid 1980's is digital internally, analogue calls are converted to PCM data streams, it replaced TXE analogue exchanges, the first of which was installed in 1968. The analogue phone network works during power outages, because the exchanges are powered by enormous 50V batteries, on continuous charge with generator back up, in case of grid failure.

ShutterTyt · 14/11/2026 12:16

I asked chatgpt and it said the economics means it's not cost worthy to run landlines anymore. So I guess we should get rid of it

Shinyhappyapple · 14/11/2026 12:23

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 14/11/2026 05:11

Likewise.

Mumsnet never ceases to amaze me with the sheer number of users who are dead against any sort of technological change or progress. It's the same on the threads about cash. Presumably half of Mumsnet is still writing cheques, sending postal orders and telegrams, and pines for the simpler times where we lived in caves.

Reminds me of the banker who told Henry Ford's lawyer that the automobile was a novelty which would never replace the horse.

Smart meter-phobia. Another mumsnet obsession. Had a Smart meter in my flat for the past 7 years, works flawlessly, only time I ever need look at the thing is out of sheer curiosity, but no, they're the work of the devil if you listen to the nonsense on here.

Edited

You are missing the point. It’s about resilience in terms of the increasing possibility of infrastructure going down due to hacking or whatever other reason. A few years back I would have agreed with you. However it’s more and more apparent that although we all need to get on board with any new technology, it’s wise to have back ups in case it’s suddenly no longer there. As individuals, it’s sensible, as a country it’s vital.

Mrsgreen44 · 14/11/2026 15:42

I think it’s crazy because when the Internet goes down or at worsethe electrics go off, the phone signals also lose power so we can’t call other mobile phones we lose our network and have no way of contacting anyone if there is an issue. Yes, I haven’t had a landline for years via the copper wires however with the talk of an electric blackout, we wouldn’t have any communication whatsoever.
But I suppose we’ve just got a roll with it

Trottersup · 14/11/2026 15:47

Most people completely missing the point that in a power outage, you lose your phone and the internet.

ScholesPanda · 14/11/2026 15:49

YABU. We've not had a landline in years.

It's too expensive to keep an emergency network going to the tens of millions of houses in this country on the off-chance that we have a storm that knocks out the electric and blows mobile towers down but inexplicably doesn't affect the landline wires or pylons.

I bet the vote would be very different if people were told it could be kept for £5 a month on everyone's household broadband bill.

Zov · 14/11/2026 15:55

Trottersup · 14/11/2026 15:47

Most people completely missing the point that in a power outage, you lose your phone and the internet.

I know right. I repeated this over and over earlier in the thread, but still, a few people have failed to grasp it. 'But it's still a landline..... landlines are changing but it's still a landline......' No it isn't. It's a telephone handset and the internet. It will not work when there is a power cut.

Proper original traditional landlines never stopped working when there was a power cut. Ever. It's nothing to do with dismissing or shunning new technology, it's about the fact that VoiP home phones are NOT equal to proper landline phones. They. Are. Not. The. Same.

Some proper daft comments on here from a few people. 🙄

ColinISabirthdaycake · 14/11/2026 15:57

humanassy · 14/11/2026 10:35

That is interesting - did not realise the exchanges are digital

Edited

Yes those who are older like me (born in the 70s) will remember the old dialling tone which changed when we changed to digital. I think it was also the reason we don't use the old dials anymore and have push buttons on landline phones - the dials were analogue.

KnitOneSlipOneKnitOnePassSlippedStitchOver · 14/11/2026 16:02

ScholesPanda · 14/11/2026 15:49

YABU. We've not had a landline in years.

It's too expensive to keep an emergency network going to the tens of millions of houses in this country on the off-chance that we have a storm that knocks out the electric and blows mobile towers down but inexplicably doesn't affect the landline wires or pylons.

I bet the vote would be very different if people were told it could be kept for £5 a month on everyone's household broadband bill.

Storms knock out the electricity in rural areas primarily because badly maintained trees fall and take out above-ground electricity cables. Those storms don’t blow mobile masts over, but mobile masts need electricity to work, so if the power goes out over the area which includes your local mobile mast, so does the mobile signal. This is a common occurrence in rural areas, where millions of people live in the UK. The majority of landline infrastructure even in my rural county is underground, so in my lifetime (over half a century) when we have had significant power cuts every winter, we never lost the landline phone signal, so always had a way to contact the vulnerable and get emergency help when needed.

You make it sound as though the possibility of losing broadband and mobile signal at the same time is so remote as to be negligible, but people will tell you that it’s just not the case, and our experience shows otherwise, and that there needs to be a solid backup plan for at least vulnerable people who haven’t had a choice in this change.

RVectensian · 14/11/2026 16:03

We thought the same. Where we are is in an absolute network black spot. We get next to no mobile reception on any network, so the only way our mobiles work is through Wi-Fi calling. If the Wi-Fi goes down or the power goes off, we have no way of contacting the outside world. A landline with an old fashioned curly cord that drew its power from the wall was in our power cut supply kit...which obviously doesn't work anymore.

Barranca · 14/11/2026 16:07

@zov it’s so frustrating that some posters are ignoring actual facts and experiences and just telling us we are anti change.

PennGarnet · 14/11/2026 16:31

I'm not happy about losing landlines: my family live on the border in Northern Ireland where there are few UK network mobile phone masts so for most people in that area the only mobile signal available is from the Republic of Ireland. This means the phones with a UK network are constantly roaming internationally on an ROI signal.

A lot of people get around this by having either two mobiles or two sim cards (one UK, One ROI) but it's a crap workaround and would make it hard to rely on a mobile over having a landline for emergencies. If you dial 999 on a roaming NI mobile you stand a very good change of getting put through to ROI emergency services.

The border area doesn't have fantastic broadband infrastructure either so VOiP isn't always the answer to lack of mobile signal or landline.

ErrolTheDragon · 14/11/2026 16:37

ScholesPanda · 14/11/2026 15:49

YABU. We've not had a landline in years.

It's too expensive to keep an emergency network going to the tens of millions of houses in this country on the off-chance that we have a storm that knocks out the electric and blows mobile towers down but inexplicably doesn't affect the landline wires or pylons.

I bet the vote would be very different if people were told it could be kept for £5 a month on everyone's household broadband bill.

A lot of the copper network was buried, not on poles. Very robust.

CarlaH · 14/11/2026 16:43

I would be more than happy to pay £5 a month to keep my landline. A genuine one I mean not one that relies on having power.

Palmtreesinthegarden · 14/11/2026 16:44

I havnt had a landline phone for over 10 years!