Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think switching off landlines is crazy?

301 replies

humanassy · 13/11/2026 18:48

Old school telephone landlines are being switched off in January 2027 as we’ve all been told to go digital. In the light of the last 2 days with the Microsoft ‘outage’, AIBU to think this is lunacy?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Hermyknee · 16/11/2026 09:27

We are vulnerable and have medical equipment. We can’t get fibre to our house because national grid won’t allow bt/openreach to use the poles leading up to our house. We have been sent a battery back up and by said they would be in touch.

Does anyone know how the battery works? They said in only lasts 30 mins. Does it mean I can use the phone for an ambulance for the 30 min period into a powercut then it cuts out too? The woman couldn’t tell me.

Ginmonkeyagain · 16/11/2026 10:55

@Hermyknee it's a battery, that works like any battery - the more you use it the less time it lasts.

Love how people think copper landlines don't need electricity to work - they absolutely do just not from your house (unless you are one of the 80% or so of landline users who have a DECT or cordless phone then you absolutely need power at your house for it to work) In an emergency long term power outage situation power supply at exchanges would also fail at some point. Storms that take down overhead power lines also often also take down overhead telephone cables.

Ultimately most of this is not a comms issue but a power resilience issue - any money people think would be a good idea to use to keep copper landlines going would be better pumped in to areas with poor power resilience.

Oh and if you live rurally stop opposing any new phone masts.

BusyGreySnail · 16/11/2026 10:57

we've not had one for 10 years, and don't miss it at all.

BUT that said, modern technology is not great for resilience as we have seen from recent cuber attacks etc.

Barranca · 16/11/2026 11:05

Ginmonkeyagain · 16/11/2026 10:55

@Hermyknee it's a battery, that works like any battery - the more you use it the less time it lasts.

Love how people think copper landlines don't need electricity to work - they absolutely do just not from your house (unless you are one of the 80% or so of landline users who have a DECT or cordless phone then you absolutely need power at your house for it to work) In an emergency long term power outage situation power supply at exchanges would also fail at some point. Storms that take down overhead power lines also often also take down overhead telephone cables.

Ultimately most of this is not a comms issue but a power resilience issue - any money people think would be a good idea to use to keep copper landlines going would be better pumped in to areas with poor power resilience.

Oh and if you live rurally stop opposing any new phone masts.

How come then my old corded landline worked for the full 10 DAYS power cut I’ve had? It was the ONLY means of communication from my house.

Ginmonkeyagain · 16/11/2026 11:24

Depends on your exchange location and the power running from it. Some have batteries or generators, some have nothing.

A lot of variables really, including whether your telephone wires are over head and if they survived a storm.

Copper landlines not uniquely power resilient, it is just an accident of history (and physics) that they are powered from the exchange rather than your house.

You can't power fibre from the exchange as glass does not conduct electricity.

Barranca · 16/11/2026 11:31

Ginmonkeyagain · 16/11/2026 11:24

Depends on your exchange location and the power running from it. Some have batteries or generators, some have nothing.

A lot of variables really, including whether your telephone wires are over head and if they survived a storm.

Copper landlines not uniquely power resilient, it is just an accident of history (and physics) that they are powered from the exchange rather than your house.

You can't power fibre from the exchange as glass does not conduct electricity.

Whatever, over 30+ years of occasional power cuts, the plug in landline NEVER failed, ie it provided important communication resilience.

As I said elsewhere on this thread, the most severe loss I’ve had was 2021 November storms and 10 days no power but could communicate (as mobile signal also gone). I don’t care how it is fixed, but it’s unacceptable to leave thousands of people vulnerable to no communication when they likely most need it. I appreciate it’s not a single vital utility in isolation but that joined up foresight should have happened before now.

Hermyknee · 16/11/2026 12:28

Ginmonkeyagain · 16/11/2026 10:55

@Hermyknee it's a battery, that works like any battery - the more you use it the less time it lasts.

Love how people think copper landlines don't need electricity to work - they absolutely do just not from your house (unless you are one of the 80% or so of landline users who have a DECT or cordless phone then you absolutely need power at your house for it to work) In an emergency long term power outage situation power supply at exchanges would also fail at some point. Storms that take down overhead power lines also often also take down overhead telephone cables.

Ultimately most of this is not a comms issue but a power resilience issue - any money people think would be a good idea to use to keep copper landlines going would be better pumped in to areas with poor power resilience.

Oh and if you live rurally stop opposing any new phone masts.

Ok I am confused but you seem to know what you are talking about!

I’d be really grateful if you could explain this to me:

What I understand so far: BT are saying is we’ll have fibre up to the national grid poles then the information will be going through the old copper wires as it is now. But the phone won’t work as it’s a new digital signal. We won’t have to have any work done, in will just ‘happen’.

So in a power cut the thing stopping our BT hub working and the landline would be power from our end? Doesn’t it require power from their end?

Would the battery just power the phone or the broadband?

The monitor attached to my body and my sugar levels displayed on my phone I think connect through Bluetooth so as long as I have a way of charging my phone (solar panel?) I should be ok for days. The seizealarm system connects my Apple Watch via the landline to an American company so not sure on that. Any thoughts on how to future proof this? If the limiting factor is the power at our end only, would solar panels charging up a large battery in the garage work?

Hermyknee · 16/11/2026 12:29

Barranca · 16/11/2026 11:31

Whatever, over 30+ years of occasional power cuts, the plug in landline NEVER failed, ie it provided important communication resilience.

As I said elsewhere on this thread, the most severe loss I’ve had was 2021 November storms and 10 days no power but could communicate (as mobile signal also gone). I don’t care how it is fixed, but it’s unacceptable to leave thousands of people vulnerable to no communication when they likely most need it. I appreciate it’s not a single vital utility in isolation but that joined up foresight should have happened before now.

Our neighbour, a doctor, came over to us to phone his hospital to check on a patient to see if he needed to go in. We had a working landline, but no mobile or power.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/11/2026 12:30

We are vulnerable and have medical equipment. We can’t get fibre to our house because national grid won’t allow bt/openreach to use the poles leading up to our house

And right there you've got another example of the inadequacy of planning, @Hermyknee

These things would be much easier to resolve with a little cooperation, but instead too many focus on what "can't be done", which is why in a disaster they'd no doubt be sitting in committee meetings while all around them goes to hell

Askingforafriendtoday · 16/11/2026 13:10

https://youtube.com/shorts/t42RuUA4tWA?si=9KknRcwtnqgq5URD

Copper wire swich off caused flight chaos

This might have already been.posted on here

Before you continue to YouTube

https://youtube.com/shorts/t42RuUA4tWA?si=9KknRcwtnqgq5URD

Askingforafriendtoday · 16/11/2026 13:12

Sunday Times yesterday

AIBU to think switching off landlines is crazy?
CasperGutman · 16/11/2026 13:21

We still have a home phone, although it's VOIP based and not an actual landline. For purely practical reasons we quite often want to speak to someone who's home rather than a specific individual who might be at work/school/an activity/visiting friends etc.

Tequilamockinbird · 16/11/2026 13:34

If people are using cordless phones on their copper/analogue landline now, they will also not work in a power cut. How many people still have old landline phones plugged into the socket?

Vulnerable people should register as such with their providers, and battery back ups should be provided for them. You can also buy battery back ups if you aren’t vulnerable but are worried.

The old copper telephone network is aging, knackered, and VERY expensive to upkeep. The switch to digital has been in progress, and publicized for a long time.

Elbowpatch · 16/11/2026 13:36

CasperGutman · 16/11/2026 13:21

We still have a home phone, although it's VOIP based and not an actual landline. For purely practical reasons we quite often want to speak to someone who's home rather than a specific individual who might be at work/school/an activity/visiting friends etc.

We have the same. It’s also very useful for putting on forms that ask for but don’t really need a phone number.

Barranca · 16/11/2026 14:12

Tequilamockinbird · 16/11/2026 13:34

If people are using cordless phones on their copper/analogue landline now, they will also not work in a power cut. How many people still have old landline phones plugged into the socket?

Vulnerable people should register as such with their providers, and battery back ups should be provided for them. You can also buy battery back ups if you aren’t vulnerable but are worried.

The old copper telephone network is aging, knackered, and VERY expensive to upkeep. The switch to digital has been in progress, and publicized for a long time.

Many people who would not be categorised as vulnerable are made vulnerable without communication. Battery pack backups are insufficient where power and all forms of communication are out for more than the 12 hour or so reported estimated time the pack will work for.

oh and before the switchover, yes I plugged in my corded phone which (at the risk of becoming a parrot) worked for the full 10 days of a power cut when no other method of communication worked. A battery pack way hay would have covered maybe 1 day, what about the other 10?

DoraSpenlow · 16/11/2026 14:22

Tequilamockinbird · 16/11/2026 13:34

If people are using cordless phones on their copper/analogue landline now, they will also not work in a power cut. How many people still have old landline phones plugged into the socket?

Vulnerable people should register as such with their providers, and battery back ups should be provided for them. You can also buy battery back ups if you aren’t vulnerable but are worried.

The old copper telephone network is aging, knackered, and VERY expensive to upkeep. The switch to digital has been in progress, and publicized for a long time.

We did keep an old plug in handset purely for this purpose. We have had to switch over now so we binned it.

The longest we have been without power is 6 days but frequently get outages of a few hours.

CarlaH · 16/11/2026 14:23

Tequilamockinbird · 16/11/2026 13:34

If people are using cordless phones on their copper/analogue landline now, they will also not work in a power cut. How many people still have old landline phones plugged into the socket?

Vulnerable people should register as such with their providers, and battery back ups should be provided for them. You can also buy battery back ups if you aren’t vulnerable but are worried.

The old copper telephone network is aging, knackered, and VERY expensive to upkeep. The switch to digital has been in progress, and publicized for a long time.

I bought a cheap handset which I would have been able to plug into the wall socket. Obviously that won't help me now.

Ginmonkeyagain · 16/11/2026 16:58

@Hermyknee So currently old fashioned landlines are from a copper line that is powered remotely from the exchange - so that will work in a powercut (IF any overhead lines have survived a storm) but often other devices such as telecare alarm often need a mains power supply at the home.

New VoIP landlines work over broadband via your router which needs a power supply at the home. A battery back up simply powers that router if the mains power is cut. Regulations say this has to last for at LEAST one hour but it is just a battery, and as you know from your mobile, batteries last longer the less you use them - it won't just cut out after an hour.

As you have medical equipment I would make sure you register as vulnerable with both your telecoms and energy providers.

TBH many medical alarms and devices these days do not operate over the old fashioned phone line but use a combination of broadband with an internal back up battery and universal roaming mobile SIM - I would check this with your device manufacturer and may be get some power banks that charge mobile phone via a usb port (you can also charge a mobile off you car or laptop)

HiEarthlings · 16/11/2026 17:04

My landline is now digital. Swapped when I changed broadband providers a while back. Doesn't bother me in the slightest. I can count on the finger (singular) of one...well, finger, the number of times I've used the 'landline' in the past 5 years. My partner doesn't even have a landline telephone and hasn't had for about 10 years (and she lives in the middle of nowhere).

Yes, there are occasional network outages, but then, I remember landlines dying from time to time, back in the day, so it's no different as far as I'm concerned. I'm not one to get worked up over supposed "imminent terror attacks" and everything else people seem to get themselves into a lather about. If something happens, it happens, if it doesn't (far more likely), it doesn't. Much more important things to worry about IMO....

CherryBakewellParent · 17/11/2026 14:30

People shouldn’t be left with no way to contact the emergency services in a power cut

123dayslater · 17/11/2026 14:51

One option is Starlink mobile phone & broadband

Barranca · 17/11/2026 15:37

123dayslater · 17/11/2026 14:51

One option is Starlink mobile phone & broadband

So does that not need electricity? Will work in a power cut especially an extended one?

bananasplitsallround · 17/11/2026 19:14

You are not being unreasonable at all! But like many things, we are powerless to do anything about it. Many people probably don’t realise they are on a digital line already or at least have not thought about the consequences of power/ network outages. We only keep ours so the kids always know where a phone is if there was ever an emergency.

Minglingpringle · 17/11/2026 21:33

We were switched to digital a while back. The line became glitchy. It stopped working a couple of times and we only found out when my husband phoned the house, thought no one was there AND mentioned it to me. Rang customer services (from my mobile…) and they said, to fix it I had to turn the router off and then on again. It worked. But it really undermined my confidence in it.

MrsJeanLuc · Yesterday 15:38

Barranca · 15/11/2026 12:11

Sorry but a few hours 🤣
A few days more like needs to be considered, as many on here have described.

When there were severe storms many were also without water. As pumps etc are electric I believe (I’m not so familiar with the set up as I’m on private water supply). To be without water and power at the same time, for days on end, in cold weather, would be horrendous.

Sorry but a few hours 🤣
A few days more like needs to be considered, as many on here have described.

Yes, of course. But you wouldn't use those hours continuously. You'd switch it on for a few minutes, do whatever research/communication you wanted to, then turn it off again to preserve the power.

And, yes, indeed, it would be horrendous.

Oh, this will make you laugh .. when I said to my husband that perhaps we should get a few (maybe 8) litres of water he said not to bother because we have plenty of beer in!

Swipe left for the next trending thread